Summary
The March family hovers anxiously around their returned father, but everyone senses something unresolved hanging in the air. When John Brooke arrives to retrieve his umbrella, Meg has prepared a perfectly dignified rejection speech. But the moment he calls her 'Margaret' and speaks of love, all her careful words vanish. She becomes flustered and tells him to go away, enjoying her newfound power over him. Enter Aunt March at the worst possible moment. The meddling aunt threatens to cut off Meg's inheritance if she marries 'this Cook' and lectures her about marrying for money and position. This proves to be a spectacular miscalculation. Aunt March's opposition instantly clarifies Meg's feelings - she finds herself passionately defending John and declaring she'll marry whom she pleases. When the old woman storms off in defeat, John emerges from hiding, having overheard Meg's spirited defense. Instead of the dignified rejection she planned, Meg whispers 'Yes, John' and hides her face against his waistcoat. Jo discovers them in this compromising position and dramatically announces the 'awful news' to the family. But the parents approve, and even Jo begins to soften when she sees how happy the couple is. The chapter ends with the family gathered around the newly engaged pair, marking the end of childhood and the beginning of change. Sometimes the very opposition meant to destroy something only makes it stronger.
Coming Up in Chapter 24
Three years pass in a blink, and it's time for Meg's wedding. But married life brings new challenges no one prepared her for, and the March sisters must navigate their first major separation.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE AUNT MARCH SETTLES THE QUESTION Like bees swarming after their queen, mother and daughters hovered about Mr. March the next day, neglecting everything to look at, wait upon, and listen to the new invalid, who was in a fair way to be killed by kindness. As he sat propped up in a big chair by Beth’s sofa, with the other three close by, and Hannah popping in her head now and then ‘to peek at the dear man’, nothing seemed needed to complete their happiness. But something was needed, and the elder ones felt it, though none confessed the fact. Mr. and Mrs. March looked at one another with an anxious expression, as their eyes followed Meg. Jo had sudden fits of sobriety, and was seen to shake her fist at Mr. Brooke’s umbrella, which had been left in the hall. Meg was absent-minded, shy, and silent, started when the bell rang, and colored when John’s name was mentioned. Amy said, “Everyone seemed waiting for something, and couldn’t settle down, which was queer, since Father was safe at home,” and Beth innocently wondered why their neighbors didn’t run over as usual. Laurie went by in the afternoon, and seeing Meg at the window, seemed suddenly possessed with a melodramatic fit, for he fell down on one knee in the snow, beat his breast, tore his hair, and clasped his hands imploringly, as if begging some boon. And when Meg told him to behave himself and go away, he wrung imaginary tears out of his handkerchief, and staggered round the corner as if in utter despair. “What does the goose mean?” said Meg, laughing and trying to look unconscious. “He’s showing you how your John will go on by-and-by. Touching, isn’t it?” answered Jo scornfully. “Don’t say my John, it isn’t proper or true,” but Meg’s voice lingered over the words as if they sounded pleasant to her. “Please don’t plague me, Jo, I’ve told you I don’t care much about him, and there isn’t to be anything said, but we are all to be friendly, and go on as before.” “We can’t, for something has been said, and Laurie’s mischief has spoiled you for me. I see it, and so does Mother. You are not like your old self a bit, and seem ever so far away from me. I don’t mean to plague you and will bear it like a man, but I do wish it was all settled. I hate to wait, so if you mean ever to do it, make haste and have it over quickly,” said Jo pettishly. “I can’t say anything till he speaks, and he won’t, because Father said I was too young,” began Meg, bending over her work with a queer little smile, which suggested that she did not quite agree with her father on that point. “If he did speak, you wouldn’t know what to say, but would cry or blush, or let him have his own way, instead of...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Reverse Psychology - When Opposition Creates What It Fears
Heavy-handed attempts to control or forbid something often create the exact outcome they're trying to prevent.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone's heavy-handed attempts to control your choices are actually revealing their own agenda rather than protecting your interests.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's objections to your choices seem more about their control than your wellbeing - pause and ask yourself what you actually want versus what you're being told to want.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Propriety
The Victorian rules about proper behavior, especially for women. This meant being modest, obedient, and never showing strong emotions in public. Women were expected to be guided by male relatives in major decisions.
Modern Usage:
We still see this in families that expect daughters to be 'good girls' who don't cause trouble or speak up too boldly.
Inheritance leverage
Using money or property you plan to leave someone as a weapon to control their choices. Wealthy relatives would threaten to 'cut someone off' to force obedience.
Modern Usage:
Today it's parents threatening to stop paying for college or grandparents threatening to change their will if you don't follow their wishes.
Social climbing
Marrying someone to move up in society's ranks. In Alcott's time, a woman's social status came entirely from her husband's position and wealth.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who only date others with certain jobs, cars, or bank accounts to improve their own status.
Reverse psychology
When trying to stop someone from doing something actually makes them want to do it more. Aunt March's opposition to John makes Meg realize she loves him.
Modern Usage:
Parents who forbid a relationship often push their kids closer together, or telling someone they 'can't handle' something makes them determined to prove you wrong.
Coming of age
The moment when childhood officially ends and adult responsibilities begin. For Victorian women, this usually meant engagement or marriage.
Modern Usage:
Today it might be graduating, getting your first real job, moving out, or making a major life commitment.
Emotional manipulation
Using guilt, fear, or threats to control someone's decisions. Aunt March tries to scare Meg with poverty and social shame.
Modern Usage:
We see this in toxic relationships where someone threatens to leave, hurt themselves, or punish you if you don't do what they want.
Characters in This Chapter
Meg
Protagonist in transition
She starts the chapter planning to reject John properly, but Aunt March's interference makes her realize her true feelings. She transforms from dutiful daughter to woman making her own choice.
Modern Equivalent:
The people-pleaser who finally stands up to family pressure about their life choices
John Brooke
Romantic lead
He arrives to collect his umbrella but stays to declare his love. His genuine emotion and patience win Meg over despite her initial resistance.
Modern Equivalent:
The decent guy who waits for the right moment and doesn't pressure you into anything
Aunt March
Antagonist/catalyst
Her attempt to control Meg through threats and snobbery backfires completely. She accidentally pushes Meg into John's arms by opposing the match so harshly.
Modern Equivalent:
The meddling relative who thinks their money gives them the right to run everyone's life
Jo
Comic relief/resistant observer
She discovers the engaged couple and dramatically announces it to the family. She's struggling with the change this represents in her relationship with Meg.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who's not ready for the group dynamic to change when someone gets serious about dating
Mr. and Mrs. March
Supportive parents
They approve of the engagement and welcome John into the family. They represent a more progressive approach to marriage based on love rather than money.
Modern Equivalent:
Parents who trust their adult children to make good choices and support them even when it's hard
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I shall marry whom I please, Aunt March, and you can leave your money to anyone you like!"
Context: When Aunt March threatens to disinherit her for considering John
This is Meg's declaration of independence. For the first time, she chooses love over money and stands up to family pressure. It's the moment she becomes an adult.
In Today's Words:
I'll date whoever I want, and you can keep your money if it comes with strings attached!
"Yes, John"
Context: Her whispered acceptance after John asks if she truly meant her defense of him
After all her careful planning to reject him properly, Meg's actual answer is simple and from the heart. Sometimes the biggest decisions require the fewest words.
In Today's Words:
Yes, I choose you.
"You ought to be ashamed of yourself! What would your poor mother say to such stuff?"
Context: Scolding Meg for considering marrying for love instead of money
Aunt March reveals her values - that practical advantage matters more than happiness. She can't understand why anyone would choose differently.
In Today's Words:
Your mother would be horrified that you're not gold-digging like a smart girl should!
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Aunt March's snobbery about John being 'just a tutor' reveals rigid class expectations
Development
Deepens from earlier hints about family's reduced circumstances and social position
In Your Life:
You might face judgment about your choices based on others' ideas of what's 'appropriate' for your background
Power
In This Chapter
Aunt March wields financial threats to control Meg's romantic choices
Development
Builds on earlier scenes of adult authority over the girls' decisions
In Your Life:
Someone in your life might use money, job security, or family pressure to control your personal decisions
Identity
In This Chapter
Meg discovers her true feelings only when forced to defend them against opposition
Development
Continues Meg's journey from dutiful daughter to independent woman
In Your Life:
You might not know what you really want until someone tries to take that choice away from you
Love
In This Chapter
John and Meg's relationship solidifies through external pressure rather than despite it
Development
First major romantic resolution in the story, showing love's power over social convention
In Your Life:
Your relationships might grow stronger when you have to defend them against outside criticism
Family
In This Chapter
The March parents' acceptance contrasts sharply with Aunt March's interference
Development
Shows the difference between supportive and controlling family dynamics
In Your Life:
You might need to choose between pleasing extended family and following your own path
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What was Meg's original plan when John arrived, and how did it completely fall apart?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did Aunt March's threats and lectures backfire so spectacularly - what psychological principle was at work?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern in your own life - someone's opposition making you more determined to do the opposite?
application • medium - 4
If you were John, would you have stayed hidden during Aunt March's lecture, or would you have intervened? What are the risks and benefits of each choice?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between making choices from authentic desire versus making them as rebellion against control?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Rewrite the Intervention
Imagine you're Aunt March, but you genuinely want what's best for Meg. Rewrite her conversation to express concerns without triggering rebellion. Then compare your approach to what actually happened in the chapter.
Consider:
- •How do you express concerns without sounding controlling or condescending?
- •What tone and word choices might have opened dialogue instead of shutting it down?
- •How could Aunt March have honored Meg's agency while still sharing her perspective?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's opposition made you more determined to do something. Looking back, were you choosing from authentic desire or just rebelling? How can you tell the difference in future situations?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 24: Family Updates and Wedding Preparations
Moving forward, we'll examine families adapt and grow through major life transitions, and understand the difference between material wealth and emotional richness in relationships. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.