Summary
Sue returns to her former husband Phillotson, driven by overwhelming guilt over her children's deaths and a twisted sense of religious duty. She arrives pale and shaken, declaring her children's deaths were punishment for her 'sinful' relationship with Jude and that remarrying Phillotson is her path to purification. Despite her obvious revulsion—she physically recoils when Phillotson kisses her—she insists on rushing into the marriage ceremony the next morning. In a powerful symbolic act, Sue tears apart a beautiful nightgown she once bought to please Jude, burning it as 'adulterous' while sobbing. Mrs. Edlin, the local widow helping Sue, sees through the facade and begs Phillotson not to go through with the wedding, recognizing that Sue is forcing herself into something that violates her deepest nature. But Phillotson, motivated by his own desires and social rehabilitation, ignores the warning. The morning wedding proceeds in fog and gloom, with Sue looking like a ghost of herself. Even Phillotson feels qualms about his actions, sensing he's betraying the humane instinct that once led him to free her. The chapter exposes how trauma can warp judgment, leading people to punish themselves in ways that seem righteous but are actually self-destructive. Sue's extreme religious guilt has convinced her that denying her true feelings is moral, when it's actually a form of emotional suicide.
Coming Up in Chapter 48
Meanwhile, Jude remains in Christminster, unaware of Sue's remarriage. A mysterious woman in shabby black appears at his door in the rain, bringing news that will shatter what remains of his world.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
The next afternoon the familiar Christminster fog still hung over all things. Sue’s slim shape was only just discernible going towards the station. Jude had no heart to go to his work that day. Neither could he go anywhere in the direction by which she would be likely to pass. He went in an opposite one, to a dreary, strange, flat scene, where boughs dripped, and coughs and consumption lurked, and where he had never been before. “Sue’s gone from me—gone!” he murmured miserably. She in the meantime had left by the train, and reached Alfredston Road, where she entered the steam-tram and was conveyed into the town. It had been her request to Phillotson that he should not meet her. She wished, she said, to come to him voluntarily, to his very house and hearthstone. It was Friday evening, which had been chosen because the schoolmaster was disengaged at four o’clock that day till the Monday morning following. The little car she hired at the Bear to drive her to Marygreen set her down at the end of the lane, half a mile from the village, by her desire, and preceded her to the schoolhouse with such portion of her luggage as she had brought. On its return she encountered it, and asked the driver if he had found the master’s house open. The man informed her that he had, and that her things had been taken in by the schoolmaster himself. She could now enter Marygreen without exciting much observation. She crossed by the well and under the trees to the pretty new school on the other side, and lifted the latch of the dwelling without knocking. Phillotson stood in the middle of the room, awaiting her, as requested. “I’ve come, Richard,” said she, looking pale and shaken, and sinking into a chair. “I cannot believe—you forgive your—wife!” “Everything, darling Susanna,” said Phillotson. She started at the endearment, though it had been spoken advisedly without fervour. Then she nerved herself again. “My children—are dead—and it is right that they should be! I am glad—almost. They were sin-begotten. They were sacrificed to teach me how to live! Their death was the first stage of my purification. That’s why they have not died in vain! … You will take me back?” He was so stirred by her pitiful words and tone that he did more than he had meant to do. He bent and kissed her cheek. Sue imperceptibly shrank away, her flesh quivering under the touch of his lips. Phillotson’s heart sank, for desire was renascent in him. “You still have an aversion to me!” “Oh no, dear—I have been driving through the damp, and I was chilly!” she said, with a hurried smile of apprehension. “When are we going to have the marriage? Soon?” “To-morrow morning, early, I thought—if you really wish. I am sending round to the vicar to let him know you are come. I have told him all, and he highly approves—he says it will...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Trauma-Driven Self-Punishment
The destructive belief that suffering and self-denial are moral responses to tragedy or guilt.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when overwhelming guilt is masquerading as moral clarity, leading to self-destructive choices disguised as virtue.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel compelled to choose the most painful option because it 'feels right'—pause and ask whether this choice helps you heal or just makes you hurt more.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Religious guilt
The overwhelming shame and self-punishment that comes from believing you've sinned against God or moral law. In Victorian times, this was especially intense around sexuality and marriage. Sue believes her children died as divine punishment for her 'immoral' relationship with Jude.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who punish themselves for perfectly normal desires because of strict religious upbringing or trauma.
Self-mortification
Deliberately causing yourself physical or emotional pain as a form of penance or purification. Sue tears up her beautiful nightgown and forces herself into a marriage that disgusts her, believing suffering will cleanse her soul.
Modern Usage:
This shows up today in people who stay in toxic relationships or situations because they think they 'deserve' the pain.
Social rehabilitation
Restoring your reputation and place in society after scandal or disgrace. Phillotson sees remarrying Sue as his chance to regain respectability after their divorce caused him professional and social ruin.
Modern Usage:
Like when politicians or celebrities try to rebuild their image after a scandal by making 'respectable' choices.
Trauma response
How people react to overwhelming emotional damage, often in ways that seem logical but are actually harmful. Sue's children's deaths broke her psychologically, leading her to make decisions that destroy her further.
Modern Usage:
We recognize now that trauma can make people sabotage their own happiness or make choices that seem crazy to outsiders.
Emotional coercion
Using someone's guilt, fear, or desperation to manipulate them into doing what you want. Phillotson accepts Sue back knowing she's mentally broken and not choosing freely, but it serves his purposes.
Modern Usage:
This happens when someone takes advantage of another person's vulnerability or crisis to get what they want.
Victorian marriage laws
Legal and social systems that made divorce nearly impossible and gave husbands complete control over wives. Once Sue remarries Phillotson, she becomes his legal property again with no easy escape.
Modern Usage:
While laws have changed, we still see people trapped in marriages by financial dependence, immigration status, or social pressure.
Characters in This Chapter
Sue
Tragic protagonist
Returns to Phillotson in a state of psychological breakdown, convinced that punishing herself through an unwanted marriage will atone for her children's deaths. Her self-destruction is heartbreaking to witness.
Modern Equivalent:
The trauma survivor who punishes herself for things that weren't her fault
Phillotson
Opportunistic husband
Takes advantage of Sue's mental breakdown to get her back, knowing she's not choosing freely but prioritizing his own desires for respectability and companionship over her wellbeing.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex who swoops in during your crisis because they know you're vulnerable
Mrs. Edlin
Voice of conscience
The local widow who helps Sue but sees through her facade, recognizing that Sue is forcing herself into something unnatural and begging Phillotson not to go through with the wedding.
Modern Equivalent:
The concerned friend or family member who tries to talk you out of a terrible decision
Jude
Absent but haunting presence
Though not physically present, his love for Sue permeates the chapter. Sue's destruction of the nightgown she bought to please him symbolizes her attempt to kill her true self.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex-partner whose memory you're trying to erase by making destructive choices
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She could now enter Marygreen without exciting curiosity, since she was ostensibly only a woman returning to her husband"
Context: As Sue arrives at Phillotson's village to remarry him
Shows how Sue is using marriage as a mask for respectability, hiding her true broken state behind social conventions. The word 'ostensibly' reveals the gap between appearance and reality.
In Today's Words:
Now she could walk into town without people gossiping, since she looked like just another wife coming back to her husband
"I have thought it over, and I see I was wrong. The children were taken from us to show us this"
Context: Explaining to Phillotson why she's returning to him
Reveals Sue's twisted logic that turns tragedy into divine punishment. She's rewriting her children's deaths to justify self-punishment, showing how trauma can warp thinking.
In Today's Words:
I've been thinking, and I was wrong before. The kids died to teach us a lesson
"It is adulterous! I will burn it up!"
Context: Tearing apart the beautiful nightgown she once bought to please Jude
This symbolic destruction of beauty and sensuality shows Sue's attempt to kill her true self. She's literally burning the evidence of her capacity for joy and physical love.
In Today's Words:
This is sinful! I'm going to destroy it!
Thematic Threads
Religious Guilt
In This Chapter
Sue twists religious doctrine into a weapon against herself, believing God demands her suffering
Development
Escalated from earlier spiritual searching to destructive self-flagellation
In Your Life:
You might use moral or religious beliefs to justify staying in situations that harm you
Social Rehabilitation
In This Chapter
Phillotson sees remarrying Sue as his path back to respectability and professional standing
Development
His earlier humanitarian gesture now corrupted by self-interest and social pressure
In Your Life:
You might prioritize how things look to others over what's actually right or healthy
Authentic Self
In This Chapter
Sue destroys symbols of her true desires, forcing herself to become someone she's not
Development
Complete reversal from her earlier fight for authenticity and freedom
In Your Life:
You might abandon your real values and desires when guilt or trauma overwhelm you
Bystander Awareness
In This Chapter
Mrs. Edlin clearly sees the destructiveness of this union but is powerless to stop it
Development
Introduced here as voice of practical wisdom ignored by those in crisis
In Your Life:
You might recognize when others are making self-destructive choices but feel helpless to intervene
Moral Confusion
In This Chapter
Both Sue and Phillotson convince themselves their harmful actions are virtuous
Development
Culmination of the book's exploration of how social pressure corrupts moral judgment
In Your Life:
You might rationalize harmful choices by telling yourself they're the 'right' thing to do
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific actions does Sue take to 'purify' herself, and what do these actions reveal about her mental state?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Sue believe that suffering through a marriage she finds repulsive will somehow honor her dead children?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today—people punishing themselves after tragedy, believing that suffering equals righteousness?
application • medium - 4
How can someone distinguish between healthy guilt that motivates positive change and toxic guilt that demands endless self-punishment?
application • deep - 5
What does Sue's story teach us about how trauma can hijack our moral compass and convince us that self-destruction is virtue?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Identify Your Self-Punishment Patterns
Think about a time when you felt overwhelming guilt or responsibility after something went wrong. Write down the 'solutions' your mind offered you—did they involve making yourself suffer, work harder, or deny yourself something good? Now identify which responses were actually helping you heal versus which were just making you hurt more.
Consider:
- •Notice if your brain equates suffering with being a 'good person'
- •Ask whether this choice helps you grow or just punishes you
- •Consider what someone who truly loved you would want for you
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you chose to punish yourself after a mistake or loss. Looking back, what would genuine healing have looked like instead of self-punishment?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 48: When Desperation Makes Dangerous Choices
What lies ahead teaches us vulnerability can be weaponized by those who know your weaknesses, and shows us grief and alcohol create perfect storms for poor decisions. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.