Summary
At the annual shearing supper, Bathsheba orchestrates a complex social dance that reveals her growing awareness of her own power. She seats Gabriel at the head table, then publicly demotes him when Boldwood arrives, showing how easily she manipulates the men around her. The evening unfolds with traditional songs and camaraderie among the workers, but underneath runs a current of tension and desire. When Bathsheba sings 'The Banks of Allan Water' with Gabriel accompanying on flute and Boldwood providing bass harmony, the scene becomes a metaphor for the triangle consuming all three characters. After the workers leave, Boldwood makes his second, more desperate proposal. This time, Bathsheba doesn't reject him outright. Instead, she agrees to consider marriage after harvest—a conditional acceptance that traps them both. Her response comes not from love but from guilt over the valentine that started his obsession, mixed with a dangerous thrill at her power over this respected man. The chapter exposes how Bathsheba's impulsive actions create consequences she struggles to control, while showing Boldwood's transformation from dignified farmer to lovesick supplicant. Hardy reveals the intoxicating but destructive nature of power in relationships, and how good intentions can lead to emotional manipulation.
Coming Up in Chapter 24
That same night, in the darkness of the fir plantation, another crucial conversation unfolds—one that will shift the balance of power once again and force Bathsheba to confront truths she's been avoiding.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
EVENTIDE—A SECOND DECLARATION For the shearing-supper a long table was placed on the grass-plot beside the house, the end of the table being thrust over the sill of the wide parlour window and a foot or two into the room. Miss Everdene sat inside the window, facing down the table. She was thus at the head without mingling with the men. This evening Bathsheba was unusually excited, her red cheeks and lips contrasting lustrously with the mazy skeins of her shadowy hair. She seemed to expect assistance, and the seat at the bottom of the table was at her request left vacant until after they had begun the meal. She then asked Gabriel to take the place and the duties appertaining to that end, which he did with great readiness. At this moment Mr. Boldwood came in at the gate, and crossed the green to Bathsheba at the window. He apologized for his lateness: his arrival was evidently by arrangement. “Gabriel,” said she, “will you move again, please, and let Mr. Boldwood come there?” Oak moved in silence back to his original seat. The gentleman-farmer was dressed in cheerful style, in a new coat and white waistcoat, quite contrasting with his usual sober suits of grey. Inwardy, too, he was blithe, and consequently chatty to an exceptional degree. So also was Bathsheba now that he had come, though the uninvited presence of Pennyways, the bailiff who had been dismissed for theft, disturbed her equanimity for a while. Supper being ended, Coggan began on his own private account, without reference to listeners:— I’ve lost my love, and I care not, I’ve lost my love, and I care not; I shall soon have another That’s better than t’other; I’ve lost my love, and I care not. This lyric, when concluded, was received with a silently appreciative gaze at the table, implying that the performance, like a work by those established authors who are independent of notices in the papers, was a well-known delight which required no applause. “Now, Master Poorgrass, your song!” said Coggan. “I be all but in liquor, and the gift is wanting in me,” said Joseph, diminishing himself. “Nonsense; wou’st never be so ungrateful, Joseph—never!” said Coggan, expressing hurt feelings by an inflection of voice. “And mistress is looking hard at ye, as much as to say, ‘Sing at once, Joseph Poorgrass.’” “Faith, so she is; well, I must suffer it!... Just eye my features, and see if the tell-tale blood overheats me much, neighbours?” “No, yer blushes be quite reasonable,” said Coggan. “I always tries to keep my colours from rising when a beauty’s eyes get fixed on me,” said Joseph, differently; “but if so be ’tis willed they do, they must.” “Now, Joseph, your song, please,” said Bathsheba, from the window. “Well, really, ma’am,” he replied, in a yielding tone, “I don’t know what to say. It would be a poor plain ballet of my own composure.” “Hear, hear!” said the supper-party. Poorgrass, thus assured, trilled forth...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Borrowed Power - When Guilt Becomes Currency
When someone leverages your guilt over past actions to control your future decisions, turning your conscience into their bargaining chip.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone weaponizes your conscience against your autonomy.
Practice This Today
Next time someone argues you 'owe them' something based on their emotional response to your past actions, pause and ask: Am I responsible for their feelings, or just for my own behavior?
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Shearing supper
A traditional harvest celebration where the farm owner provided a feast for workers after completing sheep shearing. These events mixed business with pleasure, creating temporary social equality while maintaining clear hierarchies. The master sat with workers but still controlled the evening's flow.
Modern Usage:
Like company holiday parties where the boss tries to be 'one of the gang' but everyone knows who really holds the power.
Gentleman-farmer
A landowner who farmed for profit but maintained social status above working farmers. They had education, money, and respectability that separated them from laborers. Boldwood represents this class - he works the land but doesn't get his hands dirty.
Modern Usage:
Think successful small business owners who still do some hands-on work but clearly aren't regular employees.
Social positioning
The deliberate arrangement of people to show status and relationships. Bathsheba's seating choices communicate power - who sits where, when they're moved, and how publicly it happens. Every placement sends a message to everyone watching.
Modern Usage:
Like choosing who sits at the head table at a wedding or who gets invited to the important meeting.
Conditional acceptance
Agreeing to something with strings attached, creating obligation without commitment. Bathsheba doesn't say yes or no to Boldwood's proposal - she says 'maybe after harvest,' keeping him hoping while avoiding decision. It's manipulation disguised as consideration.
Modern Usage:
When someone says 'We'll see' or 'Ask me later' to avoid giving a real answer but keep you hanging on.
Public humiliation
Deliberately embarrassing someone in front of others to show dominance. Bathsheba demotes Gabriel from head of table to his original seat when Boldwood arrives, making her preference clear to everyone present. The public nature amplifies the insult.
Modern Usage:
Like being publicly reassigned at work or having your responsibilities given to someone else in front of colleagues.
Emotional manipulation
Using someone's feelings to control their behavior without direct confrontation. Bathsheba plays on Boldwood's obsession and Gabriel's loyalty, getting what she wants while appearing innocent. She creates situations where others feel compelled to please her.
Modern Usage:
When someone uses guilt, hope, or attraction to get their way instead of being direct about what they want.
Characters in This Chapter
Bathsheba Everdene
Protagonist
She orchestrates the evening's social dynamics, publicly demoting Gabriel to elevate Boldwood, then gives a conditional acceptance to Boldwood's marriage proposal. Her actions reveal growing awareness of her power over men but also her dangerous tendency to manipulate rather than make clear decisions.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who keeps multiple romantic interests on the hook while avoiding commitment
Gabriel Oak
Loyal friend/unrequited lover
He accepts his public demotion from head table without protest, then accompanies Bathsheba's song on flute. His silence and compliance show both his deep love and his understanding of his place in her hierarchy of affections.
Modern Equivalent:
The reliable friend who gets treated poorly but keeps coming back because they're in love
Mr. Boldwood
Obsessed suitor
He arrives by arrangement in unusually cheerful dress and mood, makes his second marriage proposal, and receives Bathsheba's conditional acceptance. His transformation from dignified farmer to desperate suitor shows how obsession changes a person's character.
Modern Equivalent:
The successful person who becomes completely obsessed with someone who doesn't really want them
Pennyways
Disruptive presence
The dismissed bailiff's uninvited presence disturbs Bathsheba's carefully orchestrated evening, representing the consequences of past decisions that can't be controlled. His theft and dismissal create ongoing tension that intrudes on the celebration.
Modern Equivalent:
The fired employee who still shows up to company events and makes everyone uncomfortable
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Gabriel, will you move again, please, and let Mr. Boldwood come there?"
Context: She publicly demotes Gabriel from the head of the table when Boldwood arrives
This seemingly polite request is actually a power play performed in front of all the workers. Bathsheba shows everyone her romantic preferences while forcing Gabriel to accept public humiliation. The word 'please' makes it sound courteous while the action is cruel.
In Today's Words:
Move over - the important person just showed up.
"Oak moved in silence back to his original seat."
Context: Gabriel's response to being publicly demoted at the dinner table
Gabriel's silent compliance reveals both his deep love for Bathsheba and his painful understanding of where he stands. He doesn't protest or show anger because he knows it would only make things worse. His dignity comes from accepting humiliation gracefully.
In Today's Words:
He took the hint and didn't make a scene, even though it hurt.
"I will try to love you. Yes, I will!"
Context: Her response to Boldwood's desperate second marriage proposal
This conditional acceptance reveals Bathsheba's fatal flaw - she can't make clean decisions. Instead of honest rejection, she offers hope based on guilt and obligation. The phrase 'try to love' shows she doesn't love him now but feels she should, which will doom them both.
In Today's Words:
I'll give it a shot, I guess - maybe I can learn to feel something for you.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Bathsheba discovers the intoxicating nature of having respected men compete for her attention, but this power becomes a prison when guilt forces her into unwanted commitments
Development
Evolved from her initial naive enjoyment of male attention to understanding its dangerous consequences
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you realize your approval or attention has more impact on others than you expected, creating obligations you never intended.
Guilt
In This Chapter
Bathsheba's remorse over the valentine becomes Boldwood's primary tool for securing her conditional acceptance of marriage
Development
Introduced here as the driving force behind major life decisions
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone uses your past mistakes or their hurt feelings to pressure you into current commitments.
Class
In This Chapter
The shearing supper reveals how social hierarchies can be manipulated—Bathsheba elevates Gabriel then demotes him based on who's watching
Development
Continues the exploration of how class boundaries are both rigid and surprisingly fluid
In Your Life:
You might see this in how you adjust your behavior or associations based on who's present in professional or social settings.
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Both Bathsheba and Boldwood manipulate each other—she through guilt-driven concessions, he through emotional pressure disguised as reasonable requests
Development
Growing more sophisticated as characters learn to use each other's weaknesses
In Your Life:
You might notice this when someone frames their demands as your moral obligation or when you find yourself agreeing to things you don't want to avoid conflict.
Consequences
In This Chapter
The valentine's aftermath shows how impulsive actions create cascading obligations that become harder to escape over time
Development
Building from earlier impulsive decisions to show how consequences compound
In Your Life:
You might experience this when a small decision or joke spirals into major life complications that feel impossible to untangle.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Bathsheba seat Gabriel at the head table, then move him when Boldwood arrives? What does this reveal about how she handles social situations?
analysis • surface - 2
Boldwood doesn't argue that Bathsheba loves him or that he's the best choice. Instead, he focuses on the valentine and says 'You gave me reason to hope.' Why is this approach more effective than romantic declarations?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about times when someone has made you feel responsible for their emotional reaction to something you did. How did that change your behavior toward them?
application • medium - 4
Bathsheba agrees to 'consider' marriage after harvest, not because she wants to, but because she feels guilty. When have you made decisions based on guilt rather than what you actually wanted? How did it turn out?
application • deep - 5
Hardy shows us that feeling powerful (controlling Boldwood's emotions) can actually trap us (obligating us to consider his proposal). What does this suggest about the difference between real power and the illusion of control?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Rewrite the Guilt Script
Think of a situation where someone used your past actions to pressure you into a current decision (like Boldwood using the valentine). Write out what they said, then rewrite how you could have responded differently. Focus on acknowledging impact without accepting ownership of their feelings.
Consider:
- •Separate your actions from their emotional response - you can own one without owning the other
- •Notice the difference between 'I understand this hurt you' and 'I am responsible for fixing your hurt'
- •Consider what you actually owe someone versus what guilt makes you think you owe
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt trapped by someone else's expectations based on something you did in the past. How might you handle a similar situation differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 24: Tangled in the Dark
Moving forward, we'll examine chance encounters can shift life's direction in unexpected ways, and understand compliments matter more than we admit in relationships. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.