An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1620 words)
ARMERS—A RULE—AN EXCEPTION
The first public evidence of Bathsheba’s decision to be a farmer in her
own person and by proxy no more was her appearance the following
market-day in the cornmarket at Casterbridge.
The low though extensive hall, supported by beams and pillars, and
latterly dignified by the name of Corn Exchange, was thronged with hot
men who talked among each other in twos and threes, the speaker of the
minute looking sideways into his auditor’s face and concentrating his
argument by a contraction of one eyelid during delivery. The greater
number carried in their hands ground-ash saplings, using them partly as
walking-sticks and partly for poking up pigs, sheep, neighbours with
their backs turned, and restful things in general, which seemed to
require such treatment in the course of their peregrinations. During
conversations each subjected his sapling to great varieties of
usage—bending it round his back, forming an arch of it between his two
hands, overweighting it on the ground till it reached nearly a
semicircle; or perhaps it was hastily tucked under the arm whilst the
sample-bag was pulled forth and a handful of corn poured into the palm,
which, after criticism, was flung upon the floor, an issue of events
perfectly well known to half-a-dozen acute town-bred fowls which had as
usual crept into the building unobserved, and waited the fulfilment of
their anticipations with a high-stretched neck and oblique eye.
Among these heavy yeomen a feminine figure glided, the single one of
her sex that the room contained. She was prettily and even daintily
dressed. She moved between them as a chaise between carts, was heard
after them as a romance after sermons, was felt among them like a
breeze among furnaces. It had required a little determination—far more
than she had at first imagined—to take up a position here, for at her
first entry the lumbering dialogues had ceased, nearly every face had
been turned towards her, and those that were already turned rigidly
fixed there.
Two or three only of the farmers were personally known to Bathsheba,
and to these she had made her way. But if she was to be the practical
woman she had intended to show herself, business must be carried on,
introductions or none, and she ultimately acquired confidence enough to
speak and reply boldly to men merely known to her by hearsay. Bathsheba
too had her sample-bags, and by degrees adopted the professional pour
into the hand—holding up the grains in her narrow palm for inspection,
in perfect Casterbridge manner.
Something in the exact arch of her upper unbroken row of teeth, and in
the keenly pointed corners of her red mouth when, with parted lips, she
somewhat defiantly turned up her face to argue a point with a tall man,
suggested that there was potentiality enough in that lithe slip of
humanity for alarming exploits of sex, and daring enough to carry them
out. But her eyes had a softness—invariably a softness—which, had they
not been dark, would have seemed mistiness; as they were, it lowered an
expression that might have been piercing to simple clearness.
Strange to say of a woman in full bloom and vigor, she always allowed
her interlocutors to finish their statements before rejoining with
hers. In arguing on prices, she held to her own firmly, as was natural
in a dealer, and reduced theirs persistently, as was inevitable in a
woman. But there was an elasticity in her firmness which removed it
from obstinacy, as there was a naïveté in her cheapening which saved
it from meanness.
Those of the farmers with whom she had no dealings (by far the greater
part) were continually asking each other, “Who is she?” The reply would
be—
“Farmer Everdene’s niece; took on Weatherbury Upper Farm; turned away
the baily, and swears she’ll do everything herself.”
The other man would then shake his head.
“Yes, ’tis a pity she’s so headstrong,” the first would say. “But we
ought to be proud of her here—she lightens up the old place. ’Tis such
a shapely maid, however, that she’ll soon get picked up.”
It would be ungallant to suggest that the novelty of her engagement in
such an occupation had almost as much to do with the magnetism as had
the beauty of her face and movements. However, the interest was
general, and this Saturday’s début in the forum, whatever it may have
been to Bathsheba as the buying and selling farmer, was unquestionably
a triumph to her as the maiden. Indeed, the sensation was so pronounced
that her instinct on two or three occasions was merely to walk as a
queen among these gods of the fallow, like a little sister of a little
Jove, and to neglect closing prices altogether.
The numerous evidences of her power to attract were only thrown into
greater relief by a marked exception. Women seem to have eyes in their
ribbons for such matters as these. Bathsheba, without looking within a
right angle of him, was conscious of a black sheep among the flock.
It perplexed her first. If there had been a respectable minority on
either side, the case would have been most natural. If nobody had
regarded her, she would have taken the matter indifferently—such cases
had occurred. If everybody, this man included, she would have taken it
as a matter of course—people had done so before. But the smallness of
the exception made the mystery.
She soon knew thus much of the recusant’s appearance. He was a
gentlemanly man, with full and distinctly outlined Roman features, the
prominences of which glowed in the sun with a bronze-like richness of
tone. He was erect in attitude, and quiet in demeanour. One
characteristic pre-eminently marked him—dignity.
Apparently he had some time ago reached that entrance to middle age at
which a man’s aspect naturally ceases to alter for the term of a dozen
years or so; and, artificially, a woman’s does likewise. Thirty-five
and fifty were his limits of variation—he might have been either, or
anywhere between the two.
It may be said that married men of forty are usually ready and generous
enough to fling passing glances at any specimen of moderate beauty they
may discern by the way. Probably, as with persons playing whist for
love, the consciousness of a certain immunity under any circumstances
from that worst possible ultimate, the having to pay, makes them unduly
speculative. Bathsheba was convinced that this unmoved person was not a
married man.
When marketing was over, she rushed off to Liddy, who was waiting for
her beside the yellow gig in which they had driven to town. The horse
was put in, and on they trotted—Bathsheba’s sugar, tea, and drapery
parcels being packed behind, and expressing in some indescribable
manner, by their colour, shape, and general lineaments, that they were
that young lady-farmer’s property, and the grocer’s and draper’s no
more.
“I’ve been through it, Liddy, and it is over. I shan’t mind it again,
for they will all have grown accustomed to seeing me there; but this
morning it was as bad as being married—eyes everywhere!”
“I knowed it would be,” Liddy said. “Men be such a terrible class of
society to look at a body.”
“But there was one man who had more sense than to waste his time upon
me.” The information was put in this form that Liddy might not for a
moment suppose her mistress was at all piqued. “A very good-looking
man,” she continued, “upright; about forty, I should think. Do you know
at all who he could be?”
Liddy couldn’t think.
“Can’t you guess at all?” said Bathsheba with some disappointment.
“I haven’t a notion; besides, ’tis no difference, since he took less
notice of you than any of the rest. Now, if he’d taken more, it would
have mattered a great deal.”
Bathsheba was suffering from the reverse feeling just then, and they
bowled along in silence. A low carriage, bowling along still more
rapidly behind a horse of unimpeachable breed, overtook and passed
them.
“Why, there he is!” she said.
Liddy looked. “That! That’s Farmer Boldwood—of course ’tis—the man you
couldn’t see the other day when he called.”
“Oh, Farmer Boldwood,” murmured Bathsheba, and looked at him as he
outstripped them. The farmer had never turned his head once, but with
eyes fixed on the most advanced point along the road, passed as
unconsciously and abstractedly as if Bathsheba and her charms were thin
air.
“He’s an interesting man—don’t you think so?” she remarked.
“O yes, very. Everybody owns it,” replied Liddy.
“I wonder why he is so wrapt up and indifferent, and seemingly so far
away from all he sees around him.”
“It is said—but not known for certain—that he met with some bitter
disappointment when he was a young man and merry. A woman jilted him,
they say.”
“People always say that—and we know very well women scarcely ever jilt
men; ’tis the men who jilt us. I expect it is simply his nature to be
so reserved.”
“Simply his nature—I expect so, miss—nothing else in the world.”
“Still, ’tis more romantic to think he has been served cruelly, poor
thing’! Perhaps, after all, he has!”
“Depend upon it he has. Oh yes, miss, he has! I feel he must have.”
“However, we are very apt to think extremes of people. I shouldn’t
wonder after all if it wasn’t a little of both—just between the
two—rather cruelly used and rather reserved.”
“Oh dear no, miss—I can’t think it between the two!”
“That’s most likely.”
“Well, yes, so it is. I am convinced it is most likely. You may take my
word, miss, that that’s what’s the matter with him.”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
We become most fascinated by those who show us the least interest, mistaking their indifference for superiority or hidden wisdom.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when indifference creates artificial attraction and how our brains mistake scarcity for value.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you find yourself most interested in someone who seems least interested in you—ask whether you're chasing validation or genuine connection.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She moved between them as a chaise between carts, was heard after them as a romance after sermons."
Context: Describing how Bathsheba stands out among the rough farmers at market
Hardy uses this elegant comparison to show how Bathsheba's refinement contrasts with the practical, earthy world of farming. She brings beauty and grace to a purely functional space, which both helps and complicates her business goals.
In Today's Words:
She was like a luxury car in a parking lot full of work trucks - obviously different class, impossible to ignore.
"It appears that ordinary men take wives because possession is not possible without marriage, and that ordinary women accept husbands because marriage is not possible without possession."
Context: Reflecting on typical marriage motivations in contrast to Bathsheba's independence
This cynical observation reveals Hardy's understanding of marriage as often transactional rather than romantic. It highlights why Bathsheba's financial independence makes her unusual - she doesn't need marriage for security.
In Today's Words:
Most people get married because they want something they can't get any other way - men want guaranteed companionship, women want financial security.
"Farmer Boldwood's eyes were fixed upon a point in the distance, and he passed by as if she had been a tree."
Context: When Boldwood walks past Bathsheba without acknowledging her presence
This moment is crucial because it's the first time Bathsheba encounters a man who doesn't react to her beauty. His indifference wounds her pride and sparks her curiosity more than any compliment could.
In Today's Words:
He looked right through her like she wasn't even there - didn't even register that she existed.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Bathsheba must balance being taken seriously as a farmer while navigating her feminine identity in a male-dominated space
Development
Building from her inheritance decision, now she's actively constructing her professional identity
In Your Life:
You might struggle to be authentic while fitting into professional or social expectations that don't quite match who you are
Class
In This Chapter
She moves through the market 'like a chaise between carts'—elegant and refined among working farmers
Development
Her elevated social position continues to set her apart and complicate her relationships
In Your Life:
You might feel caught between different social worlds, not quite fitting perfectly into any single group
Power
In This Chapter
Bathsheba wields both economic power as a landowner and social power through her beauty and presence
Development
She's learning to navigate and use her various forms of influence
In Your Life:
You might have different types of power or influence that you're still learning how to use effectively
Attention
In This Chapter
Universal male attention means nothing compared to one man's indifference
Development
Introduced here as a new dynamic that will drive future plot developments
In Your Life:
You might find yourself more affected by one person's disinterest than by many people's approval
Curiosity
In This Chapter
Boldwood's mystery—his past disappointment and current aloofness—creates irresistible intrigue
Development
Introduced here, showing how unknown stories about people can captivate us
In Your Life:
You might be drawn to people precisely because you can't figure them out or understand their motivations
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Bathsheba become fascinated by Boldwood when he's the only man who doesn't pay attention to her at the market?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Boldwood's indifference reveal about how we assign value to people's opinions and attention?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern in modern life - people becoming more interested in those who seem uninterested in them?
application • medium - 4
How can recognizing this 'indifference attraction' pattern help you make better decisions about where to invest your emotional energy?
application • deep - 5
What does Bathsheba's reaction teach us about the difference between wanting genuine connection and wanting to win someone over?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Attention Patterns
Think about your workplace, friend group, or family. Identify one person whose approval or attention you find yourself seeking more than others. Write down what makes their opinion feel more valuable than people who already show you support and interest.
Consider:
- •Is their indifference actually a sign of incompatibility rather than superiority?
- •What energy and opportunities might you be missing by focusing on the unresponsive person?
- •How might this person's aloofness be creating artificial attraction rather than reflecting genuine worth?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you chased someone's approval or attention who seemed uninterested. Looking back, what were you really seeking - their validation or proof of your own worth?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 13: The Valentine That Changed Everything
Bathsheba's curiosity about the mysterious Farmer Boldwood leads to an impulsive decision involving a valentine that will have far-reaching consequences. Sometimes a moment's whim can change everything.




