Summary
Spiritual Hoarding and Sacred Clutter
Dark Night of the Soul by Saint John of the Cross
Picture someone who owns every self-help book ever written but hasn't changed a single habit. These seekers develop an insatiable appetite for more—more books, more advice, more religious objects, more spiritual experiences. They're like people who think buying workout equipment will make them fit, or collecting cookbooks will make them great chefs. John watches beginners accumulate rosaries, crosses, and religious trinkets, constantly switching between different spiritual practices and teachers, always hunting for the next thing that will give them the feelings they crave. But this accumulation becomes its own addiction. Instead of doing the hard work of inner transformation—what John calls 'mortification and perfecting of inward poverty of spirit'—they stay busy consuming spiritual content. They want the consolation and comfort that spirituality can bring, but they resist the difficult parts that actually change you. John sees this as spiritual avarice, a form of greed dressed up in holy clothes. The real problem isn't owning religious objects or reading spiritual books—it's the attachment, the possessiveness, the belief that having more spiritual stuff equals being more spiritual. This chapter reveals how even our desire for spiritual growth can become corrupted by the very human tendency to seek security through accumulation. John is pointing toward something deeper: true spiritual poverty means letting go of our need to control and possess our spiritual experience.
Coming Up in Chapter 4
John continues examining how beginners stumble on their spiritual path, turning next to anger—and how spiritual people can become surprisingly hostile when their religious feelings are threatened.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 212 words)
Of some imperfections which some of these souls are apt to have, with respect to the second capital sin, which is avarice, in the spiritual sense. Many of these beginners have also at times great spiritual avarice. They will be found to be discontented with the spirituality which God gives them; they are very disconsolate and querulous because they find not in spiritual things the consolation that they would desire. Many can never have enough of listening to counsels and learning spiritual precepts, and of possessing and reading many books which treat of this matter, and they spend their time on these things rather than on works of mortification and the perfecting of the inward poverty of spirit which should be theirs. Furthermore, they burden themselves with images and rosaries which are very curious; now they put down one, now take up another; now they change about, now change back again; now they want this kind of thing, now that, preferring one kind of cross to another, because it is more curious. And others you will see adorned with agnus deis and relics and tokens, like children with trinkets. Here I condemn the attachment of the heart, and the possessiveness, which regards these things, for this is contrary to poverty of spirit.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Spiritual Hoarding - When More Becomes Less
Mistaking the collection of tools, information, or experiences for actual progress or transformation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when busy activity disguises lack of real advancement.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you're researching solutions to problems you could start solving today with what you already know.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
spiritual avarice
The greedy accumulation of spiritual practices, objects, and experiences. It's when someone treats spirituality like a shopping spree, always wanting more books, more advice, more religious items to make them feel holy.
Modern Usage:
We see this in people who buy every self-help book but never apply the advice, or collect meditation apps but never actually meditate consistently.
mortification
The practice of deliberately denying yourself comfort or pleasure to build spiritual discipline. It's like spiritual strength training - doing hard things to grow stronger on the inside.
Modern Usage:
Similar to people who do cold showers, strict diets, or digital detoxes to build willpower and break bad habits.
poverty of spirit
Being spiritually humble and unattached to things, even spiritual things. It means not needing to own or control your spiritual experience to feel secure.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who can be happy without constantly checking social media for validation or buying things to feel better about themselves.
consolation
The good feelings and comfort that come from spiritual practices - peace, joy, feeling close to God. John warns against becoming addicted to these feelings.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how people can become addicted to the endorphin high from exercise or the dopamine hit from social media likes.
agnus dei
Small wax medallions blessed by the Pope, worn as religious tokens. John uses these as examples of how people collect spiritual objects thinking they'll make them more holy.
Modern Usage:
Like people who think wearing expensive workout clothes will make them fitter, or buying organic food will automatically make them healthy.
attachment of the heart
When your emotional security depends on having or controlling something. John says this possessiveness ruins the spiritual benefit of religious practices.
Modern Usage:
Like being so attached to your phone that losing it ruins your whole day, or needing your morning coffee ritual to function.
Characters in This Chapter
the beginners
spiritual seekers being critiqued
These are people just starting their spiritual journey who fall into the trap of collecting spiritual stuff instead of doing inner work. They represent a common mistake John wants to help people avoid.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who buys expensive gym equipment but never works out
Saint John of the Cross
spiritual mentor and observer
He's the wise teacher pointing out these patterns with compassion but firmness. He's seen this mistake so many times he can spot it immediately.
Modern Equivalent:
The experienced therapist who's heard every excuse and gently calls out self-defeating patterns
Key Quotes & Analysis
"They will be found to be discontented with the spirituality which God gives them; they are very disconsolate and querulous because they find not in spiritual things the consolation that they would desire."
Context: John is describing how spiritual beginners get frustrated when prayer or meditation doesn't make them feel good
This reveals how people often approach spirituality like a vending machine - put in the practice, expect good feelings to come out. When it doesn't work that way, they get cranky and demanding.
In Today's Words:
They're never happy with their spiritual experience and complain constantly because they're not getting the good vibes they think they deserve.
"Many can never have enough of listening to counsels and learning spiritual precepts, and of possessing and reading many books which treat of this matter, and they spend their time on these things rather than on works of mortification."
Context: John is pointing out how people become spiritual information addicts instead of doing the actual work
This exposes a classic avoidance pattern - staying busy with learning about change instead of actually changing. It feels productive but keeps you stuck in your comfort zone.
In Today's Words:
They're always reading about how to be spiritual instead of actually doing the hard work that makes you grow.
"Here I condemn the attachment of the heart, and the possessiveness, which regards these things, for this is contrary to poverty of spirit."
Context: John clarifies that owning religious objects isn't the problem - being emotionally dependent on them is
John makes a crucial distinction between having things and needing things. The problem isn't the stuff itself but how tightly we grip it for security.
In Today's Words:
The problem isn't having spiritual stuff - it's being emotionally attached to it like your life depends on it.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Spiritual seekers define themselves by what they own rather than who they're becoming
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself buying identity markers instead of doing the work to become that person
Class
In This Chapter
Spiritual materialism mirrors economic materialism - more stuff equals higher status
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might judge your progress by what you can afford to buy rather than what you've actually changed
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
True growth requires letting go of the need to control and possess the process
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might resist the uncertainty of real change by collecting guarantees and safety nets
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
People perform spirituality through visible accumulation to meet others' expectations
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might buy things to signal your commitment to others instead of doing private work
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors does John of the Cross identify in spiritual beginners that he considers problematic?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does John see the constant accumulation of spiritual books and objects as a form of greed rather than genuine devotion?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'collecting instead of practicing' in modern life - whether in fitness, relationships, career development, or personal growth?
application • medium - 4
How would you help someone recognize when they're using accumulation to avoid the actual work of change?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about why humans often choose the illusion of progress over the difficulty of real transformation?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Audit Your Accumulation Patterns
Choose one area of your life where you want to improve (health, relationships, finances, career, parenting). List everything you've accumulated in that area - books, apps, courses, equipment, advice. Then identify what you actually use consistently versus what just sits there. Finally, pick one thing you already own and commit to using it for the next 30 days before acquiring anything new.
Consider:
- •Notice the emotional pull to keep shopping for solutions rather than using what you have
- •Consider whether you're seeking the feeling of progress or actual results
- •Ask yourself what you're avoiding by staying in accumulation mode
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you bought something thinking it would change your life, but then never used it consistently. What were you really hoping that purchase would do for you?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 4: When Your Body Betrays Your Spirit
Moving forward, we'll examine to recognize when physical urges interfere with spiritual goals, and understand unwanted thoughts during meaningful moments don't define you. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.