Summary
Charles Darnay has built a respectable life in London as a French tutor, proving that success comes from honest work and perseverance, not privilege. After a year of loving Lucie Manette in silence, he finally gathers courage to speak with her father about his feelings. The conversation reveals the delicate psychology of trauma survivors—Dr. Manette becomes visibly distressed when Darnay mentions his own past love, showing how old wounds can suddenly reopen. Darnay handles this masterfully, demonstrating emotional intelligence by recognizing the unique bond between father and daughter. He doesn't ask Dr. Manette to influence Lucie, only to speak truthfully if she ever asks about him. Most importantly, he promises never to separate them, understanding that their relationship was forged through shared suffering. Dr. Manette agrees to support Darnay if Lucie chooses him freely, but demands one condition: Darnay must not reveal his true identity until their wedding day, if it comes to that. After Darnay leaves, Dr. Manette suffers what appears to be a psychological episode, returning to his old prison habit of making shoes—a sign that discussing the past has triggered his trauma. This chapter shows how love requires not just passion, but wisdom, patience, and deep understanding of the people involved.
Coming Up in Chapter 17
The focus shifts to another character's perspective on love and relationships, revealing different approaches to pursuing the same goal. We'll see how others handle matters of the heart with far less sensitivity and wisdom.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Two Promises More months, to the number of twelve, had come and gone, and Mr. Charles Darnay was established in England as a higher teacher of the French language who was conversant with French literature. In this age, he would have been a Professor; in that age, he was a Tutor. He read with young men who could find any leisure and interest for the study of a living tongue spoken all over the world, and he cultivated a taste for its stores of knowledge and fancy. He could write of them, besides, in sound English, and render them into sound English. Such masters were not at that time easily found; Princes that had been, and Kings that were to be, were not yet of the Teacher class, and no ruined nobility had dropped out of Tellson’s ledgers, to turn cooks and carpenters. As a tutor, whose attainments made the student’s way unusually pleasant and profitable, and as an elegant translator who brought something to his work besides mere dictionary knowledge, young Mr. Darnay soon became known and encouraged. He was well acquainted, more-over, with the circumstances of his country, and those were of ever-growing interest. So, with great perseverance and untiring industry, he prospered. In London, he had expected neither to walk on pavements of gold, nor to lie on beds of roses; if he had had any such exalted expectation, he would not have prospered. He had expected labour, and he found it, and did it and made the best of it. In this, his prosperity consisted. A certain portion of his time was passed at Cambridge, where he read with undergraduates as a sort of tolerated smuggler who drove a contraband trade in European languages, instead of conveying Greek and Latin through the Custom-house. The rest of his time he passed in London. Now, from the days when it was always summer in Eden, to these days when it is mostly winter in fallen latitudes, the world of a man has invariably gone one way--Charles Darnay’s way--the way of the love of a woman. He had loved Lucie Manette from the hour of his danger. He had never heard a sound so sweet and dear as the sound of her compassionate voice; he had never seen a face so tenderly beautiful, as hers when it was confronted with his own on the edge of the grave that had been dug for him. But, he had not yet spoken to her on the subject; the assassination at the deserted chateau far away beyond the heaving water and the long, long, dusty roads--the solid stone chateau which had itself become the mere mist of a dream--had been done a year, and he had never yet, by so much as a single spoken word, disclosed to her the state of his heart. That he had his reasons for this, he knew full well. It was again a summer day when, lately arrived in London from his college occupation, he turned...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Earned Trust
Authentic relationships and influence come through consistent demonstration of character over time, not through demands or credentials.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone's 'no' isn't about you—it's about protecting someone they love from past hurt.
Practice This Today
Next time someone seems unreasonably suspicious of your good intentions, look for who they're protecting and what past experiences taught them to be careful.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Tutor
A private teacher who works one-on-one with students, usually from wealthy families. In Dickens' time, this was respectable work for educated men without inherited wealth. Tutors lived by their skills and reputation, not family connections.
Modern Usage:
Like freelance consultants or private coaches today who build their business through word-of-mouth and proven results.
Attainments
Skills and knowledge you've actually earned through study and practice. Dickens emphasizes that Darnay succeeds because of what he knows and can do, not who his family is. It's merit-based achievement.
Modern Usage:
Your LinkedIn skills section or professional certifications - what you can actually deliver, not just your degree.
Conversant
Being familiar with and able to discuss something intelligently. Darnay doesn't just speak French - he understands French culture and literature deeply enough to teach it effectively.
Modern Usage:
Like being fluent in workplace culture or knowing your industry inside and out, not just the basics.
Perseverance
Continuing to work steadily toward a goal despite obstacles or slow progress. Darnay builds his reputation gradually through consistent effort, not expecting instant success or shortcuts.
Modern Usage:
The grind mentality - showing up every day and putting in the work even when results aren't immediate.
Pavements of gold
An old saying about unrealistic expectations of easy wealth, especially in big cities. Darnay understood London wouldn't hand him success just for showing up - he'd have to earn it.
Modern Usage:
Like expecting to get rich quick in crypto or thinking moving to a big city automatically means better opportunities.
Psychological episode
When past trauma suddenly resurfaces and overwhelms someone in the present. Dr. Manette's return to shoemaking shows how discussing painful memories can trigger old coping mechanisms.
Modern Usage:
Like having a panic attack or falling back into old habits when stressed - trauma responses that seem to come out of nowhere.
Characters in This Chapter
Charles Darnay
Protagonist seeking love and honest living
Proves his worth through hard work as a French tutor, building respect through skill rather than connections. Shows emotional maturity by approaching Dr. Manette respectfully about Lucie and promising never to separate father and daughter.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who works his way up from nothing and handles relationships with integrity
Dr. Manette
Trauma survivor and protective father
Struggles with his past when Darnay mentions love, showing how old wounds can suddenly reopen. Despite his distress, he agrees to support Darnay if Lucie chooses freely, but demands Darnay keep his identity secret until marriage.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who's been through hell and is fiercely protective of their child's happiness
Lucie Manette
Beloved daughter and object of affection
Though not directly present in the conversation, her wellbeing drives every decision. Both men understand that her choice must be completely free and that her bond with her father is sacred.
Modern Equivalent:
The person everyone wants to protect but who deserves to make her own choices
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He had expected labour, and he found it, and did it, and made the best of it."
Context: Describing how Darnay approached building his life in London
This shows Darnay's realistic mindset and work ethic. He didn't expect handouts or easy success - he came prepared to work hard and stayed committed when the work was exactly as difficult as expected.
In Today's Words:
He knew it would be tough, so when it was tough, he just kept grinding.
"If she should ever tell me that you are essential to her perfect happiness, I will give her to you."
Context: Agreeing to support Darnay's suit if Lucie chooses him freely
This reveals Dr. Manette's deep love for his daughter and his understanding that her happiness matters most. He won't influence her decision but will support whatever makes her truly happy.
In Today's Words:
If she tells me she can't be happy without you, then you have my blessing.
"I have looked at her from a distance, and I have looked at her when a distance of a few yards would not have been far enough."
Context: Confessing his love for Lucie to her father
This poetic way of saying he loves her both from afar and up close shows the depth and constancy of his feelings. It's not just infatuation - he's observed her in many situations and his love has grown.
In Today's Words:
I've loved her from across the room and I've loved her standing right next to her.
Thematic Threads
Emotional Intelligence
In This Chapter
Darnay reads Dr. Manette's distress and adjusts his approach, showing sophisticated understanding of trauma and relationships
Development
Building from earlier chapters where characters misread situations, now showing what emotional awareness looks like
In Your Life:
You might need this when approaching a sensitive conversation with someone who's been hurt before
Patience
In This Chapter
Darnay waits a full year before approaching Dr. Manette, proving his feelings through time and consistency
Development
Contrasts with the impulsive actions we've seen from other characters throughout the story
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you want to rush important decisions or relationships that need time to develop properly
Respect
In This Chapter
Darnay promises never to separate father and daughter, understanding their bond was forged through shared trauma
Development
Shows mature understanding of existing relationships, unlike characters who've tried to force their way in
In Your Life:
You might face this when entering a family or close-knit workplace where relationships have deep history
Identity
In This Chapter
Darnay must hide his true identity until the wedding day, showing how past can complicate present relationships
Development
Continues the theme of hidden identities and their consequences that runs throughout the novel
In Your Life:
You might struggle with when and how to reveal difficult parts of your past in new relationships
Trauma
In This Chapter
Dr. Manette's return to shoemaking shows how discussing the past can trigger old psychological wounds
Development
Deepens our understanding of how Dr. Manette's prison experience continues to affect him
In Your Life:
You might see this in yourself or others when certain topics or situations bring back painful memories unexpectedly
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Darnay wait a full year before speaking to Dr. Manette about his feelings for Lucie?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Darnay's approach to asking for Dr. Manette's blessing reveal about his understanding of trust and relationships?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'proving yourself through actions over time' in your own workplace or relationships?
application • medium - 4
If you wanted someone's trust or respect in your life right now, how would you apply Darnay's strategy of demonstration over declaration?
application • deep - 5
What does Dr. Manette's reaction to discussing the past teach us about how trauma survivors navigate new relationships?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Trust-Building Strategy
Think of someone whose trust or respect you want to earn - a supervisor, family member, or potential partner. Write down three specific actions you could take consistently over the next month to demonstrate your character, just like Darnay did. Focus on what you can DO, not what you can SAY.
Consider:
- •What does this person value most based on their actions and words?
- •What small, consistent behaviors would prove your reliability?
- •How can you respect their existing relationships while building your own connection?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone earned your trust through their actions rather than their words. What did they do that convinced you? How can you apply their approach to your current situation?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: When Friends Give Terrible Advice
The coming pages reveal some people use friendship as a platform for superiority, and teach us unsolicited advice often reveals more about the giver than receiver. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.
