Summary
Chapter 5
A Room with a View by E.M. Forster
The morning after witnessing murder in the Piazza, Lucy wakes expecting judgment but finds Charlotte surprisingly pleasant about "her adventure" - though notably, none of their friends know she was there or that George carried her to safety. This isolation forces Lucy to process the experience alone, without the usual social chorus confirming or denying her reactions. Desperate to avoid George and any reminder of yesterday's intensity, she chooses shopping with Charlotte over a hill walk where the Emersons will be present. But Florence won't let her forget. Charlotte insists on stopping at exactly the spot on the embankment where George threw away Lucy's blood-stained photographs. Then they return to the Piazza Signoria itself, where the murder occurred, and Lucy understands "the nature of ghosts" - places can haunt us with what happened in them. Miss Lavish is already there, gleefully collecting material to turn the tragedy into a novel. Her ghoulish excitement contrasts sharply with George's strange purity about the event. Then Mr. Eager, the chaplain, joins them and darkly hints that Mr. Emerson "murdered his wife" - metaphorically, he claims, but the accusation hangs in the air. Lucy surprises herself by defending the Emersons, her first real moment of rebellion. The chapter brilliantly captures how society processes tragedy - Miss Lavish turns it into entertainment, Mr. Eager into moral ammunition, Charlotte into an etiquette problem. Only George and Lucy, who actually experienced it, understand that "something tremendous has happened." Lucy tries desperately to return to normal tourist activities, but the Piazza has changed meaning for her. She can't unknow what real experience feels like. By chapter's end, she's begging Charlotte to flee to Rome, to escape Florence and everything it's forcing her to confront about authentic versus performed life.
Coming Up in Chapter 6
Back in England, Lucy tries to bury what happened in Italy, but the past has a way of catching up. When familiar faces from Florence unexpectedly appear in her quiet Surrey village, her carefully rebuilt world begins to crumble again.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
T was a family saying that “you never knew which way Charlotte Bartlett would turn.” She was perfectly pleasant and sensible over Lucy’s adventure, found the abridged account of it quite adequate, and paid suitable tribute to the courtesy of Mr. George Emerson. She and Miss Lavish had had an adventure also. They had been stopped at the Dazio coming back, and the young officials there, who seemed impudent and _désœuvré_, had tried to search their reticules for provisions. It might have been most unpleasant. Fortunately Miss Lavish was a match for any one. For good or for evil, Lucy was left to face her problem alone. None of her friends had seen her, either in the Piazza or, later on, by the embankment. Mr. Beebe, indeed, noticing her startled eyes at dinner-time, had again passed to himself the remark of “Too much Beethoven.” But he only supposed that she was ready for an adventure, not that she had encountered it. This solitude oppressed her; she was accustomed to have her thoughts confirmed by others or, at all events, contradicted; it was too dreadful not to know whether she was thinking right or wrong. At breakfast next morning she took decisive action. There were two plans between which she had to choose. Mr. Beebe was walking up to the Torre del Gallo with the Emersons and some American ladies. Would Miss Bartlett and Miss Honeychurch join the party? Charlotte declined for herself; she had been there in the rain the previous afternoon. But she thought it an admirable idea for Lucy, who hated shopping, changing money, fetching letters, and other irksome duties—all of which Miss Bartlett must accomplish this morning and could easily accomplish alone. “No, Charlotte!” cried the girl, with real warmth. “It’s very kind of Mr. Beebe, but I am certainly coming with you. I had much rather.” “Very well, dear,” said Miss Bartlett, with a faint flush of pleasure that called forth a deep flush of shame on the cheeks of Lucy. How abominably she behaved to Charlotte, now as always! But now she should alter. All morning she would be really nice to her. She slipped her arm into her cousin’s, and they started off along the Lung’ Arno. The river was a lion that morning in strength, voice, and colour. Miss Bartlett insisted on leaning over the parapet to look at it. She then made her usual remark, which was “How I do wish Freddy and your mother could see this, too!” Lucy fidgeted; it was tiresome of Charlotte to have stopped exactly where she did. “Look, Lucia! Oh, you are watching for the Torre del Gallo party. I feared you would repent you of your choice.” Serious as the choice had been, Lucy did not repent. Yesterday had been a muddle—queer and odd, the kind of thing one could not write down easily on paper—but she had a feeling that Charlotte and her shopping were preferable to George Emerson and the summit of the...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Authentic Disruption
Genuine feelings or desires break through constructed identities, forcing a choice between programmed responses and authentic self-expression.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when genuine emotions are breaking through social conditioning and learned expectations.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you immediately dismiss a feeling or desire because it doesn't fit who you're 'supposed' to be—pause and ask what that authentic impulse might be telling you.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Chaperone
An older woman whose job was to supervise young unmarried women in public to protect their reputation. In 1908, a young lady like Lucy couldn't go anywhere alone without risking scandal.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in helicopter parenting or workplace mentors who monitor new employees
Propriety
The social rules about what's considered proper behavior, especially for women. Breaking these rules could ruin a woman's chances of marriage and social standing.
Modern Usage:
Like unwritten workplace dress codes or social media etiquette - break them and face consequences
Spontaneous passion
Acting on genuine emotion without thinking about social consequences. In Lucy's world, this was dangerous for women because it could lead to scandal and social ruin.
Modern Usage:
Any time we act on authentic feelings instead of playing it safe - quitting a job impulsively, speaking up when we should stay quiet
Social conditioning
The way society trains us from childhood to behave in certain ways. Lucy has been taught that proper ladies don't have strong feelings or act on impulse.
Modern Usage:
How we're taught gender roles, career expectations, or family traditions that may not fit who we really are
Authentic emotion
Real feelings that come from within, not what we're supposed to feel. George represents this - he acts on what he genuinely feels rather than what society expects.
Modern Usage:
Being true to yourself instead of performing what others want to see
Class consciousness
Being constantly aware of social rank and acting accordingly. Lucy knows George is beneath her social class, which makes her attraction to him problematic.
Modern Usage:
Dating someone your family thinks isn't good enough, or feeling out of place in certain social or professional circles
Characters in This Chapter
Lucy Honeychurch
Protagonist
Experiences her first real kiss and authentic emotion, which forces her to question everything she's been taught about proper behavior. Her confusion and shame afterward show how deeply social conditioning runs.
Modern Equivalent:
The good girl who's always followed the rules suddenly questioning everything
George Emerson
Catalyst
Represents authentic passion and direct action. He kisses Lucy because he feels it's right, not because it's socially appropriate. His spontaneity threatens her carefully ordered world.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who says what everyone's thinking or the friend who lives by their own rules
Charlotte Bartlett
Enforcer of social rules
Discovers Lucy and George together, immediately understanding the scandal this could create. Her reaction reinforces all the social pressures Lucy feels.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who always asks when you're getting married or the boss who monitors your every move
Cecil Vyse
Socially acceptable option
Represents the safe, proper choice Lucy is expected to make. He's the kind of man her society approves of, making her attraction to George even more problematic.
Modern Equivalent:
The partner your parents love but who doesn't really get you
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Youth enwrapped them; the song of Phaethon announced passion requited, love attained."
Context: Describing the moment when George kisses Lucy in the violet field
This elevated language contrasts with Lucy's later shame, showing how the narrator sees this as natural and beautiful while society will see it as scandalous. The mythological reference suggests this is a timeless human experience.
In Today's Words:
They were young and in love, and for a moment everything felt perfect and right
"Something tremendous has happened."
Context: After kissing Lucy, recognizing the significance of the moment
George understands that this kiss has changed everything between them and for Lucy personally. He's not apologizing or minimizing it - he's acknowledging its power.
In Today's Words:
This changes everything between us
"How dare you! How dare you!"
Context: Her immediate reaction when Charlotte discovers them
Lucy's anger is really directed at herself for enjoying the kiss. She's trying to restore her proper image by rejecting what just happened, even though it felt right in the moment.
In Today's Words:
I can't believe I let that happen - and that I liked it
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Lucy experiences genuine passion with George, disrupting her carefully controlled emotional life
Development
Introduced here as the central conflict between genuine feeling and social programming
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when your gut reaction conflicts with what you think you should want or feel.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Lucy's immediate shame and denial after the kiss shows how deeply she's internalized proper behavior for young women
Development
Building from earlier chapters where social rules governed every interaction
In Your Life:
You see this when you automatically apologize for taking up space or having needs that don't fit others' expectations.
Class
In This Chapter
George represents everything Lucy's class background tells her to avoid—directness, passion, authenticity over propriety
Development
Evolving from earlier class tensions to show how class shapes emotional expression
In Your Life:
You might notice this in code-switching behavior or feeling ashamed of your background in certain settings.
Identity
In This Chapter
One kiss forces Lucy to question everything she thought she knew about herself and what she wants
Development
Building from her earlier confusion about her own desires and preferences
In Your Life:
You experience this when a single moment or conversation makes you question the story you've been telling yourself about who you are.
Choice
In This Chapter
Lucy must now choose between the safe, approved path (Cecil) and following her genuine feelings (George)
Development
Crystallizing from earlier hints about Lucy's passive acceptance of others' plans for her life
In Your Life:
You face this when you realize you can no longer avoid choosing between what's expected and what you actually want.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What exactly happens between Lucy and George in the field, and how does Lucy react immediately afterward?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Lucy feel so confused and ashamed after the kiss, even though she seemed to enjoy the moment?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today struggling between what they're 'supposed' to want and what they actually want?
application • medium - 4
If you were Lucy's friend, how would you help her process this moment without dismissing either her feelings or her concerns?
application • deep - 5
What does Lucy's immediate denial teach us about how we protect ourselves from authentic feelings that threaten our constructed identity?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Authentic Disruptions
Think of a recent moment when you felt pulled toward something that didn't fit your usual identity - maybe a career change, a relationship choice, or a way of expressing yourself. Write down what you felt in that moment versus what you told yourself you 'should' feel. Then identify what part of your authentic self was trying to emerge.
Consider:
- •Notice the difference between your immediate gut reaction and your second-guessing thoughts
- •Consider what fears or expectations made you dismiss the authentic feeling
- •Think about small ways you could honor that authentic impulse without dramatic life changes
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you chose safety over authenticity. What would you do differently now, and what small step could you take toward honoring your genuine feelings?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 6
As the story unfolds, you'll explore key events and character development in this chapter, while uncovering thematic elements and literary techniques. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.




