Summary
Lucy finds her footing as a teacher by learning to work with, rather than against, her students' nature. The Labassecourienne girls won't be forced to learn, but they respond to humor and strategic sarcasm. Lucy discovers that effective leadership means adapting your approach to your audience, not demanding they change for you. Meanwhile, her relationship with fellow English student Ginevra Fanshawe reveals troubling patterns. Ginevra casually accepts expensive gifts from her admirer 'Isidore' while having no intention of returning his feelings. She sees nothing wrong with taking jewelry, gloves, and bouquets from a man she considers beneath her socially, justifying it as his 'pleasure and honor' to give them. Lucy recognizes this as fundamentally dishonest—that accepting gifts creates expectations and obligations, even if unspoken. Ginevra's attitude reveals her character: she wants the benefits of being desired without any of the responsibility that comes with it. She's attracted to shallow, fashionable men but allows the devoted Isidore to finance her social life. Lucy's growing frustration with Ginevra's selfishness shows her own moral clarity. The chapter explores how we establish boundaries in relationships and work, and the importance of recognizing when someone is taking advantage of another's generosity. It also demonstrates that successful teaching—like successful living—requires reading people accurately and responding strategically rather than rigidly.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
A mysterious Dr. John enters the story, bringing with him questions about identity and the masks people wear. Lucy's world is about to become more complicated as past and present collide in unexpected ways.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
SIDORE. My time was now well and profitably filled up. What with teaching others and studying closely myself, I had hardly a spare moment. It was pleasant. I felt I was getting on; not lying the stagnant prey of mould and rust, but polishing my faculties and whetting them to a keen edge with constant use. Experience of a certain kind lay before me, on no narrow scale. Villette is a cosmopolitan city, and in this school were girls of almost every European nation, and likewise of very varied rank in life. Equality is much practised in Labassecour; though not republican in form, it is nearly so in substance, and at the desks of Madame Beck’s establishment the young countess and the young bourgeoise sat side by side. Nor could you always by outward indications decide which was noble and which plebeian; except that, indeed, the latter had often franker and more courteous manners, while the former bore away the bell for a delicately-balanced combination of insolence and deceit. In the former there was often quick French blood mixed with the marsh-phlegm: I regret to say that the effect of this vivacious fluid chiefly appeared in the oilier glibness with which flattery and fiction ran from the tongue, and in a manner lighter and livelier, but quite heartless and insincere. To do all parties justice, the honest aboriginal Labassecouriennes had an hypocrisy of their own, too; but it was of a coarse order, such as could deceive few. Whenever a lie was necessary for their occasions, they brought it out with a careless ease and breadth altogether untroubled by the rebuke of conscience. Not a soul in Madame Beck’s house, from the scullion to the directress herself, but was above being ashamed of a lie; they thought nothing of it: to invent might not be precisely a virtue, but it was the most venial of faults. “J’ai menti plusieurs fois,” formed an item of every girl’s and woman’s monthly confession: the priest heard unshocked, and absolved unreluctant. If they had missed going to mass, or read a chapter of a novel, that was another thing: these were crimes whereof rebuke and penance were the unfailing weed. While yet but half-conscious of this state of things, and unlearned in its results, I got on in my new sphere very well. After the first few difficult lessons, given amidst peril and on the edge of a moral volcano that rumbled under my feet and sent sparks and hot fumes into my eyes, the eruptive spirit seemed to subside, as far as I was concerned. My mind was a good deal bent on success: I could not bear the thought of being baffled by mere undisciplined disaffection and wanton indocility, in this first attempt to get on in life. Many hours of the night I used to lie awake, thinking what plan I had best adopt to get a reliable hold on these mutineers, to bring this stiff-necked tribe under permanent influence. In...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Taker's Playbook - How People Justify Using Others
People who habitually exploit others always have elaborate moral justifications for why their taking is actually generous.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone habitually takes from others while reframing exploitation as kindness.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone consistently accepts help, money, or favors but always has elaborate explanations for why it's actually good for the giver.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Cosmopolitan
A city with people from many different countries and backgrounds living together. In Lucy's time, this was unusual - most places were much more homogeneous. Villette's international mix creates both opportunities and tensions.
Modern Usage:
We see this in major cities today where immigrants, expats, and locals create diverse communities with complex social dynamics.
Republican in substance
A society where people are treated as equals in practice, even if there's still technically a class system. The school mixes countesses with middle-class girls at the same desks, which was radical for the 1850s.
Modern Usage:
Like workplaces today that claim to be 'flat organizations' where everyone's equal, but subtle hierarchies still exist.
Plebeian
Common people, not nobility. Originally from ancient Rome, it meant anyone who wasn't from the aristocratic class. Lucy uses it to distinguish between titled students and regular middle-class ones.
Modern Usage:
We still use this to describe working-class or ordinary people, often in contrast to elites or celebrities.
Aboriginal Labassecouriennes
The native-born locals of this fictional Belgian city, as opposed to the international students. Lucy observes that even the locals have their own forms of dishonesty and manipulation.
Modern Usage:
Like how every workplace or community has its own unspoken rules and ways of being fake that outsiders have to learn.
Vivacious fluid
Lucy's sarcastic way of describing the 'lively French blood' that supposedly makes people charming but insincere. She's mocking the stereotype that French people are naturally more animated and socially skilled.
Modern Usage:
Like when we stereotype certain cultures as being 'naturally' good at sales, socializing, or performing - often missing the manipulation underneath.
Oilier glibness
Smooth, slick talking that sounds impressive but is actually shallow and dishonest. The kind of charm that slides off the tongue too easily to be genuine.
Modern Usage:
Think of politicians, salespeople, or social media influencers who are too polished - their smoothness makes you suspicious.
Characters in This Chapter
Lucy Snowe
Protagonist and narrator
Lucy is finding her stride as a teacher by learning to adapt her methods to her students' personalities rather than forcing them to conform. She's becoming more strategic and less rigid in her approach to both work and relationships.
Modern Equivalent:
The new manager who learns to motivate different employees differently instead of using one-size-fits-all approaches
Ginevra Fanshawe
Shallow friend and moral foil
Ginevra casually accepts expensive gifts from her devoted admirer while having no romantic interest in him. She sees nothing wrong with taking advantage of his generosity and considers it his privilege to give to her.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who lets guys buy her drinks and dinner while leading them on, claiming she never promised anything
Isidore
Devoted but unseen admirer
Though he doesn't appear directly, his generous gifts to the uninterested Ginevra drive the chapter's moral tension. He represents someone whose kindness is being exploited by someone who sees his attention as her due.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who keeps spending money on someone who's clearly not interested but won't tell him directly
Madame Beck
School proprietress
Her school serves as the setting where Lucy observes the mixing of social classes and nationalities. The democratic seating arrangement at her establishment reflects broader social changes happening in Europe.
Modern Equivalent:
The progressive boss who implements policies about equality but still operates within existing power structures
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I felt I was getting on; not lying the stagnant prey of mould and rust, but polishing my faculties and whetting them to a keen edge with constant use."
Context: Lucy reflects on how her busy teaching schedule is developing her abilities
This shows Lucy's growth mindset and her relief at having purpose after a period of stagnation. She sees challenge as sharpening her skills rather than wearing her down, which reveals her resilience and ambition.
In Today's Words:
I felt like I was actually getting somewhere instead of just wasting away - like I was getting sharper and better at what I do.
"The honest aboriginal Labassecouriennes had an hypocrisy of their own, too; but it was of a coarse order, such as could deceive few."
Context: Lucy compares the local students' dishonesty to that of the more sophisticated international ones
Lucy recognizes that everyone has their own way of being fake, but she prefers obvious dishonesty to subtle manipulation. This shows her developing ability to read people and navigate social dynamics.
In Today's Words:
Even the local girls were fake in their own way, but at least their BS was obvious and didn't fool anybody.
"You always by outward indications decide which was noble and which plebeian; except that, indeed, the latter had often franker and more courteous manners."
Context: Lucy observes that you can't always tell social class by behavior at the school
This reveals Lucy's sharp social observation skills and her discovery that good manners don't correlate with high birth. She's learning that assumptions about class and character are often wrong.
In Today's Words:
You couldn't always tell who came from money just by looking, and actually the regular kids were often more genuine and polite.
Thematic Threads
Manipulation
In This Chapter
Ginevra uses moral justifications to take gifts from Isidore while feeling superior about it
Development
Introduced here as a major character dynamic
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in people who always have reasons why you should give more while they give less
Boundaries
In This Chapter
Lucy recognizes the dishonesty in accepting gifts without reciprocal feelings or intentions
Development
Building on Lucy's growing ability to read people and situations clearly
In Your Life:
You face this when deciding whether to accept help or gifts that might create unwanted obligations
Adaptation
In This Chapter
Lucy learns to teach effectively by working with her students' nature, not against it
Development
Continuation of Lucy's practical growth in navigating social situations
In Your Life:
You might need to adjust your approach with difficult coworkers or family members rather than demanding they change
Class
In This Chapter
Ginevra considers Isidore beneath her socially despite accepting his financial support
Development
Ongoing exploration of how class affects relationships and moral reasoning
In Your Life:
You might see this in how people treat service workers or anyone they consider 'below' them socially
Recognition
In This Chapter
Lucy clearly sees through Ginevra's self-serving justifications for her behavior
Development
Lucy's growing ability to read people's true motivations and character
In Your Life:
You develop this skill when you start noticing patterns in how people treat others versus how they treat you
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What strategy does Lucy discover for managing her difficult students, and why does it work better than trying to force them to behave?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Ginevra justify accepting expensive gifts from Isidore while having no romantic interest in him? What does this reveal about her character?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see Ginevra's pattern of 'justified taking' in modern relationships - romantic, workplace, or family situations?
application • medium - 4
If you were Lucy's friend, how would you advise her to handle Ginevra's behavior? What boundaries would you set with someone like this?
application • deep - 5
What does Lucy's success with her students teach us about the difference between demanding respect and earning it? How does this apply beyond teaching?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Spot the Justified Taker
Think of someone in your life who regularly takes more than they give but always has good reasons why it's okay. Write down their typical justifications, then rewrite each one as what it actually means. For example: 'I never asked for anything' becomes 'I created situations where you felt obligated to offer.'
Consider:
- •Focus on patterns of behavior, not isolated incidents
- •Notice how they reframe taking as actually doing you a favor
- •Pay attention to how they respond when you try to set boundaries
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you recognized you were being taken advantage of. What were the warning signs you initially ignored? How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 10: The Young Doctor's Arrival
In the next chapter, you'll discover emotional detachment can mask deeper motivations and needs, and learn some people are drawn to places and situations that seem beneath them. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.
