An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 3169 words)
. PAUL KEEPS HIS PROMISE.
On the first of May, we had all—i.e. the twenty boarders and the four
teachers—notice to rise at five o’clock of the morning, to be dressed
and ready by six, to put ourselves under the command of M. le
Professeur Emanuel, who was to head our march forth from Villette, for
it was on this day he proposed to fulfil his promise of taking us to
breakfast in the country. I, indeed, as the reader may perhaps
remember, had not had the honour of an invitation when this excursion
was first projected—rather the contrary; but on my now making allusion
to this fact, and wishing to know how it was to be, my ear received a
pull, of which I did not venture to challenge the repetition by
raising, further difficulties.
“Je vous conseille de vous faire prier,” said M. Emanuel, imperially
menacing the other ear. One Napoleonic compliment, however, was enough,
so I made up my mind to be of the party.
The morning broke calm as summer, with singing of birds in the garden,
and a light dew-mist that promised heat. We all said it would be warm,
and we all felt pleasure in folding away heavy garments, and in
assuming the attire suiting a sunny season. The clean fresh print
dress, and the light straw bonnet, each made and trimmed as the French
workwoman alone can make and trim, so as to unite the utterly
unpretending with the perfectly becoming, was the rule of costume.
Nobody flaunted in faded silk; nobody wore a second-hand best article.
At six the bell rang merrily, and we poured down the staircase, through
the carré, along the corridor, into the vestibule. There stood our
Professor, wearing, not his savage-looking paletôt and severe
bonnet-grec, but a young-looking belted blouse and cheerful straw hat.
He had for us all the kindest good-morrow, and most of us for him had a
thanksgiving smile. We were marshalled in order and soon started.
The streets were yet quiet, and the boulevards were fresh and peaceful
as fields. I believe we were very happy as we walked along. This chief
of ours had the secret of giving a certain impetus to happiness when he
would; just as, in an opposite mood, he could give a thrill to fear.
He did not lead nor follow us, but walked along the line, giving a word
to every one, talking much to his favourites, and not wholly neglecting
even those he disliked. It was rather my wish, for a reason I had, to
keep slightly aloof from notice, and being paired with Ginevra
Fanshawe, bearing on my arm the dear pressure of that angel’s not
unsubstantial limb—(she continued in excellent case, and I can assure
the reader it was no trifling business to bear the burden of her
loveliness; many a time in the course of that warm day I wished to
goodness there had been less of the charming commodity)—however, having
her, as I said, I tried to make her useful by interposing her always
between myself and M. Paul, shifting my place, according as I heard him
coming up to the right hand or the left. My private motive for this
manœuvre might be traced to the circumstance of the new print dress I
wore, being pink in colour—a fact which, under our present convoy, made
me feel something as I have felt, when, clad in a shawl with a red
border, necessitated to traverse a meadow where pastured a bull.
For awhile, the shifting system, together with some modifications in
the arrangement of a black silk scarf, answered my purpose; but,
by-and-by, he found out, that whether he came to this side or to that,
Miss Fanshawe was still his neighbour. The course of acquaintance
between Ginevra and him had never run so smooth that his temper did not
undergo a certain crisping process whenever he heard her English
accent: nothing in their dispositions fitted; they jarred if they came
in contact; he held her empty and affected; she deemed him bearish,
meddling, repellent.
At last, when he had changed his place for about the sixth time,
finding still the same untoward result to the experiment—he thrust his
head forward, settled his eyes on mine, and demanded with impatience,
“Qu’est-ce que c’est? Vous me jouez des tours?”
The words were hardly out of his mouth, however, ere, with his
customary quickness, he seized the root of this proceeding: in vain I
shook out the long fringe, and spread forth the broad end of my scarf.
“A-h-h! c’est la robe rose!” broke from his lips, affecting me very
much like the sudden and irate low of some lord of the meadow.
“It is only cotton,” I alleged, hurriedly; “and cheaper, and washes
better than any other colour.”
“Et Mademoiselle Lucy est coquette comme dix Parisiennes,” he answered.
“A-t-on jamais vu une Anglaise pareille. Regardez plutôt son chapeau,
et ses gants, et ses brodequins!” These articles of dress were just
like what my companions wore; certainly not one whit smarter—perhaps
rather plainer than most—but Monsieur had now got hold of his text, and
I began to chafe under the expected sermon. It went off, however, as
mildly as the menace of a storm sometimes passes on a summer day. I got
but one flash of sheet lightning in the shape of a single bantering
smile from his eyes; and then he said, “Courage!—à vrai dire je ne suis
pas fâché, peut-être même suis je content qu’on s’est fait si belle
pour ma petite fête.”
“Mais ma robe n’est pas belle, Monsieur—elle n’est que propre.”
“J’aime la propreté,” said he. In short, he was not to be dissatisfied;
the sun of good humour was to triumph on this auspicious morning; it
consumed scudding clouds ere they sullied its disk.
And now we were in the country, amongst what they called “les bois et
les petits sentiers.” These woods and lanes a month later would offer
but a dusty and doubtful seclusion: now, however, in their May
greenness and morning repose, they looked very pleasant.
We reached a certain well, planted round, in the taste of Labassecour,
with an orderly circle of lime-trees: here a halt was called; on the
green swell of ground surrounding this well, we were ordered to be
seated, Monsieur taking his place in our midst, and suffering us to
gather in a knot round him. Those who liked him more than they feared,
came close, and these were chiefly little ones; those who feared more
than they liked, kept somewhat aloof; those in whom much affection had
given, even to what remained of fear, a pleasurable zest, observed the
greatest distance.
He began to tell us a story. Well could he narrate: in such a diction
as children love, and learned men emulate; a diction simple in its
strength, and strong in its simplicity. There were beautiful touches in
that little tale; sweet glimpses of feeling and hues of description
that, while I listened, sunk into my mind, and since have never faded.
He tinted a twilight scene—I hold it in memory still—such a picture I
have never looked on from artist’s pencil.
I have said, that, for myself, I had no impromptu faculty; and perhaps
that very deficiency made me marvel the more at one who possessed it in
perfection. M. Emanuel was not a man to write books; but I have heard
him lavish, with careless, unconscious prodigality, such mental wealth
as books seldom boast; his mind was indeed my library, and whenever it
was opened to me, I entered bliss. Intellectually imperfect as I was, I
could read little; there were few bound and printed volumes that did
not weary me—whose perusal did not fag and blind—but his tomes of
thought were collyrium to the spirit’s eyes; over their contents,
inward sight grew clear and strong. I used to think what a delight it
would be for one who loved him better than he loved himself, to gather
and store up those handfuls of gold-dust, so recklessly flung to
heaven’s reckless winds.
His story done, he approached the little knoll where I and Ginevra sat
apart. In his usual mode of demanding an opinion (he had not reticence
to wait till it was voluntarily offered) he asked, “Were you
interested?”
According to my wonted undemonstrative fashion, I simply
answered—“Yes.”
“Was it good?”
“Very good.”
“Yet I could not write that down,” said he.
“Why not, Monsieur?”
“I hate the mechanical labour; I hate to stoop and sit still. I could
dictate it, though, with pleasure, to an amanuensis who suited me.
Would Mademoiselle Lucy write for me if I asked her?”
“Monsieur would be too quick; he would urge me, and be angry if my pen
did not keep pace with his lips.”
“Try some day; let us see the monster I can make of myself under the
circumstances. But just now, there is no question of dictation; I mean
to make you useful in another office. Do you see yonder farm-house?”
“Surrounded with trees? Yes.”
“There we are to breakfast; and while the good fermière makes the café
au lait in a caldron, you and five others, whom I shall select, will
spread with butter half a hundred rolls.”
Having formed his troop into line once more, he marched us straight on
the farm, which, on seeing our force, surrendered without capitulation.
Clean knives and plates, and fresh butter being provided, half-a-dozen
of us, chosen by our Professor, set to work under his directions, to
prepare for breakfast a huge basket of rolls, with which the baker had
been ordered to provision the farm, in anticipation of our coming.
Coffee and chocolate were already made hot; cream and new-laid eggs
were added to the treat, and M. Emanuel, always generous, would have
given a large order for “jambon” and “confitures” in addition, but that
some of us, who presumed perhaps upon our influence, insisted that it
would be a most reckless waste of victual. He railed at us for our
pains, terming us “des ménagères avares;” but we let him talk, and
managed the economy of the repast our own way.
With what a pleasant countenance he stood on the farm-kitchen hearth
looking on! He was a man whom it made happy to see others happy; he
liked to have movement, animation, abundance and enjoyment round him.
We asked where he would sit. He told us, we knew well he was our slave,
and we his tyrants, and that he dared not so much as choose a chair
without our leave; so we set him the farmer’s great chair at the head
of the long table, and put him into it.
Well might we like him, with all his passions and hurricanes, when he
could be so benignant and docile at times, as he was just now. Indeed,
at the worst, it was only his nerves that were irritable, not his
temper that was radically bad; soothe, comprehend, comfort him, and he
was a lamb; he would not harm a fly. Only to the very stupid, perverse,
or unsympathizing, was he in the slightest degree dangerous.
Mindful always of his religion, he made the youngest of the party say a
little prayer before we began breakfast, crossing himself as devotedly
as a woman. I had never seen him pray before, or make that pious sign;
he did it so simply, with such child-like faith, I could not help
smiling pleasurably as I watched; his eyes met my smile; he just
stretched out his kind hand, saying, “Donnez-moi la main! I see we
worship the same God, in the same spirit, though by different rites.”
Most of M. Emanuel’s brother Professors were emancipated free-thinkers,
infidels, atheists; and many of them men whose lives would not bear
scrutiny; he was more like a knight of old, religious in his way, and
of spotless fame. Innocent childhood, beautiful youth were safe at his
side. He had vivid passions, keen feelings, but his pure honour and his
artless piety were the strong charm that kept the lions couchant.
That breakfast was a merry meal, and the merriment was not mere vacant
clatter: M. Paul originated, led, controlled and heightened it; his
social, lively temper played unfettered and unclouded; surrounded only
by women and children there was nothing to cross and thwart him; he had
his own way, and a pleasant way it was.
The meal over, the party were free to run and play in the meadows; a
few stayed to help the farmer’s wife to put away her earthenware. M.
Paul called me from among these to come out and sit near him under a
tree—whence he could view the troop gambolling, over a wide pasture—and
read to him whilst he took his cigar. He sat on a rustic bench, and I
at the tree-root. While I read (a pocket-classic—a Corneille—I did not
like it, but he did, finding therein beauties I never could be brought
to perceive), he listened with a sweetness of calm the more impressive
from the impetuosity of his general nature; the deepest happiness
filled his blue eye and smoothed his broad forehead. I, too, was
happy—happy with the bright day, happier with his presence, happiest
with his kindness.
He asked, by-and-by, if I would not rather run to my companions than
sit there? I said, no; I felt content to be where he was. He asked
whether, if I were his sister, I should always be content to stay with
a brother such as he. I said, I believed I should; and I felt it.
Again, he inquired whether, if he were to leave Villette, and go far
away, I should be sorry; and I dropped Corneille, and made no reply.
“Petite sœur,” said he; “how long could you remember me if we were
separated?”
“That, Monsieur, I can never tell, because I do not know how long it
will be before I shall cease to remember everything earthly.”
“If I were to go beyond seas for two—three—five years, should you
welcome me on my return?”
“Monsieur, how could I live in the interval?”
“Pourtant j’ai été pour vous bien dur, bien exigeant.”
I hid my face with the book, for it was covered with tears. I asked him
why he talked so; and he said he would talk so no more, and cheered me
again with the kindest encouragement. Still, the gentleness with which
he treated me during the rest of the day, went somehow to my heart. It
was too tender. It was mournful. I would rather he had been abrupt,
whimsical, and irate as was his wont.
When hot noon arrived—for the day turned out as we had anticipated,
glowing as June—our shepherd collected his sheep from the pasture, and
proceeded to lead us all softly home. But we had a whole league to
walk, thus far from Villette was the farm where he had breakfasted; the
children, especially, were tired with their play; the spirits of most
flagged at the prospect of this mid-day walk over chaussées flinty,
glaring, and dusty. This state of things had been foreseen and provided
for. Just beyond the boundary of the farm we met two spacious vehicles
coming to fetch us—such conveyances as are hired out purposely for the
accommodation of school-parties; here, with good management, room was
found for all, and in another hour M. Paul made safe consignment of his
charge at the Rue Fossette. It had been a pleasant day: it would have
been perfect, but for the breathing of melancholy which had dimmed its
sunshine a moment.
That tarnish was renewed the same evening.
Just about sunset, I saw M. Emanuel come out of the front-door,
accompanied by Madame Beck. They paced the centre-alley for nearly an
hour, talking earnestly: he—looking grave, yet restless; she—wearing an
amazed, expostulatory, dissuasive air.
I wondered what was under discussion; and when Madame Beck re-entered
the house as it darkened, leaving her kinsman Paul yet lingering in the
garden, I said to myself—“He called me ‘petite sœur’ this morning. If
he were really my brother, how I should like to go to him just now, and
ask what it is that presses on his mind. See how he leans against that
tree, with his arms crossed and his brow bent. He wants consolation, I
know: Madame does not console: she only remonstrates. What now——?”
Starting from quiescence to action, M. Paul came striding erect and
quick down the garden. The carré doors were yet open: I thought he was
probably going to water the orange-trees in the tubs, after his
occasional custom; on reaching the court, however, he took an abrupt
turn and made for the berceau and the first-classe glass door. There,
in that first classe I was, thence I had been watching him; but there I
could not find courage to await his approach. He had turned so
suddenly, he strode so fast, he looked so strange; the coward within me
grew pale, shrank and—not waiting to listen to reason, and hearing the
shrubs crush and the gravel crunch to his advance—she was gone on the
wings of panic.
Nor did I pause till I had taken sanctuary in the oratory, now empty.
Listening there with beating pulses, and an unaccountable, undefined
apprehension, I heard him pass through all the schoolrooms, clashing
the doors impatiently as he went; I heard him invade the refectory
which the “lecture pieuse” was now holding under hallowed constraint; I
heard him pronounce these words—“Où est Mademoiselle Lucie?”
And just as, summoning my courage, I was preparing to go down and do
what, after all, I most wished to do in the world—viz., meet him—the
wiry voice of St. Pierre replied glibly and falsely, “Elle est au lit.”
And he passed, with the stamp of vexation, into the corridor. There
Madame Beck met, captured, chid, convoyed to the street-door, and
finally dismissed him.
As that street-door closed, a sudden amazement at my own perverse
proceeding struck like a blow upon me. I felt from the first it was me
he wanted—me he was seeking—and had not I wanted him too? What, then,
had carried me away? What had rapt me beyond his reach? He had
something to tell: he was going to tell me that something: my ear
strained its nerve to hear it, and I had made the confidence
impossible. Yearning to listen and console, while I thought audience
and solace beyond hope’s reach—no sooner did opportunity suddenly and
fully arrive, than I evaded it as I would have evaded the levelled
shaft of mortality.
Well, my insane inconsistency had its reward. Instead of the comfort,
the certain satisfaction, I might have won—could I but have put choking
panic down, and stood firm two minutes—here was dead blank, dark doubt,
and drear suspense.
I took my wages to my pillow, and passed the night counting them.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When fear of vulnerability causes us to destroy the very connections and opportunities we most desperately want.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify the moment when fear transforms opportunity into avoidance, helping us catch ourselves before we destroy what we want.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel the urge to cancel, avoid, or hide from something you actually want - then take one small step toward it instead of away.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Je vous conseille de vous faire prier"
Context: When Lucy mentions she wasn't originally invited on the excursion
M. Paul's playful threat shows his growing fondness for Lucy. Instead of formal politeness, he's teasing her like someone he's comfortable with, signaling their relationship is deepening.
In Today's Words:
Don't make me have to convince you to come along
"I made up my mind to be of the party"
Context: After M. Paul's gentle insistence that she join the excursion
Lucy's decision to join shows her beginning to overcome her tendency to exclude herself from good experiences. It's a small but significant step toward connection.
In Today's Words:
Fine, I decided I was going to go and actually enjoy myself for once
"Lucy! Lucy! Lucy!"
Context: Searching through the school for her in the evening
The repetition and urgency of his call shows how important it is that he speak with her. His use of her first name suggests intimacy and desperation to connect.
In Today's Words:
The way someone calls your name when they really need to tell you something important
Thematic Threads
Self-Sabotage
In This Chapter
Lucy hides when M. Paul seeks her out, destroying the private conversation she's been wanting
Development
Introduced here as Lucy's ultimate protective mechanism
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you avoid job interviews, end good relationships, or skip medical appointments you actually need
Vulnerability
In This Chapter
Lucy's tears during M. Paul's questions reveal her deep feelings, but this emotional honesty terrifies her
Development
Evolution from Lucy's earlier emotional numbness to genuine feeling that now frightens her
In Your Life:
You might feel this when someone gets too close and you suddenly want to push them away
Class Dynamics
In This Chapter
Lucy's anxiety about her pink dress making her too conspicuous, M. Paul's gentle response to her self-consciousness
Development
Continues Lucy's struggle with feeling she doesn't belong in refined society
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you feel out of place in professional or social settings due to your background
Authentic Connection
In This Chapter
The perfect day reveals M. Paul's true generous nature and Lucy's capacity for genuine happiness
Development
First time Lucy experiences uncomplicated joy with another person
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in moments when someone sees past your defenses and you feel truly understood
Regret
In This Chapter
Lucy's immediate recognition that she's destroyed exactly what she wanted most
Development
New theme showing Lucy gaining self-awareness of her destructive patterns
In Your Life:
You might feel this after avoiding opportunities or pushing away people who mattered to you
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Lucy do when M. Paul comes looking for her in the evening, and how does this contrast with her behavior during their perfect day together?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Lucy hide in the oratory when M. Paul is searching for her, especially after spending such a wonderful day with him?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of self-sabotage in modern life - people destroying opportunities they actually want because they're afraid of being vulnerable?
application • medium - 4
If you were Lucy's friend and noticed her hiding from M. Paul, what would you say to help her recognize what she was doing to herself?
application • deep - 5
What does Lucy's choice to hide reveal about how fear can make us become our own worst enemy, and why is the pain of 'what if' often worse than facing the actual risk?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Self-Sabotage Triggers
Think of a recent opportunity you avoided or a conversation you dodged when someone reached out to you. Write down what you were afraid might happen if you had stayed present instead of pulling away. Then write what actually happened because you avoided it. Compare the imagined fear to the real consequence.
Consider:
- •Notice if your imagined worst-case scenario was realistic or exaggerated
- •Consider whether avoiding the situation actually protected you or hurt you more
- •Think about patterns - do you tend to pull away when things get too good or too real?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you sabotaged something you wanted because you were afraid of being disappointed or rejected. What would you do differently now, knowing that hiding guarantees the loss you were trying to avoid?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 34: The Puppet Master's Strings
The mysterious conversation between M. Paul and Madame Beck bears fruit, and Lucy discovers that forces beyond her control are working to separate her from the one person who truly understands her. The chapter title 'Malevola' suggests malevolent influences are at work.




