An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 4010 words)
SNEEZE OUT OF SEASON.
I had occasion to smile—nay, to laugh, at Madame again, within the
space of four and twenty hours after the little scene treated of in the
last chapter.
Villette owns a climate as variable, though not so humid, as that of
any English town. A night of high wind followed upon that soft sunset,
and all the next day was one of dry storm—dark, beclouded, yet
rainless,—the streets were dim with sand and dust, whirled from the
boulevards. I know not that even lovely weather would have tempted me
to spend the evening-time of study and recreation where I had spent it
yesterday. My alley, and, indeed, all the walks and shrubs in the
garden, had acquired a new, but not a pleasant interest; their
seclusion was now become precarious; their calm—insecure. That casement
which rained billets, had vulgarized the once dear nook it overlooked;
and elsewhere, the eyes of the flowers had gained vision, and the knots
in the tree-boles listened like secret ears. Some plants there were,
indeed, trodden down by Dr. John in his search, and his hasty and
heedless progress, which I wished to prop up, water, and revive; some
footmarks, too, he had left on the beds: but these, in spite of the
strong wind, I found a moment’s leisure to efface very early in the
morning, ere common eyes had discovered them. With a pensive sort of
content, I sat down to my desk and my German, while the pupils settled
to their evening lessons; and the other teachers took up their
needlework.
The scene of the “etude du soir” was always the refectory, a much
smaller apartment than any of the three classes or schoolrooms; for
here none, save the boarders, were ever admitted, and these numbered
only a score. Two lamps hung from the ceiling over the two tables;
these were lit at dusk, and their kindling was the signal for
school-books being set aside, a grave demeanour assumed, general
silence enforced, and then commenced “la lecture pieuse.” This said
“lecture pieuse” was, I soon found, mainly designed as a wholesome
mortification of the Intellect, a useful humiliation of the Reason; and
such a dose for Common Sense as she might digest at her leisure, and
thrive on as she best could.
The book brought out (it was never changed, but when finished,
recommenced) was a venerable volume, old as the hills—grey as the Hôtel
de Ville.
I would have given two francs for the chance of getting that book once
into my hands, turning over the sacred yellow leaves, ascertaining the
title, and perusing with my own eyes the enormous figments which, as an
unworthy heretic, it was only permitted me to drink in with my
bewildered ears. This book contained legends of the saints. Good God!
(I speak the words reverently) what legends they were. What gasconading
rascals those saints must have been, if they first boasted these
exploits or invented these miracles. These legends, however, were no
more than monkish extravagances, over which one laughed inwardly; there
were, besides, priestly matters, and the priestcraft of the book was
far worse than its monkery. The ears burned on each side of my head as
I listened, perforce, to tales of moral martyrdom inflicted by Rome;
the dread boasts of confessors, who had wickedly abused their office,
trampling to deep degradation high-born ladies, making of countesses
and princesses the most tormented slaves under the sun. Stories like
that of Conrad and Elizabeth of Hungary, recurred again and again, with
all its dreadful viciousness, sickening tyranny and black impiety:
tales that were nightmares of oppression, privation, and agony.
I sat out this “lecture pieuse” for some nights as well as I could, and
as quietly too; only once breaking off the points of my scissors by
involuntarily sticking them somewhat deep in the worm-eaten board of
the table before me. But, at last, it made me so burning hot, and my
temples, and my heart, and my wrist throbbed so fast, and my sleep
afterwards was so broken with excitement, that I could sit no longer.
Prudence recommended henceforward a swift clearance of my person from
the place, the moment that guilty old book was brought out. No Mause
Headrigg ever felt a stronger call to take up her testimony against
Sergeant Bothwell, than I—to speak my mind in this matter of the popish
“lecture pieuse.” However, I did manage somehow to curb and rein in;
and though always, as soon as Rosine came to light the lamps, I shot
from the room quickly, yet also I did it quietly; seizing that vantage
moment given by the little bustle before the dead silence, and
vanishing whilst the boarders put their books away.
When I vanished—it was into darkness; candles were not allowed to be
carried about, and the teacher who forsook the refectory, had only the
unlit hall, schoolroom, or bedroom, as a refuge. In winter I sought the
long classes, and paced them fast to keep myself warm—fortunate if the
moon shone, and if there were only stars, soon reconciled to their dim
gleam, or even to the total eclipse of their absence. In summer it was
never quite dark, and then I went up-stairs to my own quarter of the
long dormitory, opened my own casement (that chamber was lit by five
casements large as great doors), and leaning out, looked forth upon the
city beyond the garden, and listened to band-music from the park or the
palace-square, thinking meantime my own thoughts, living my own life,
in my own still, shadow-world.
This evening, fugitive as usual before the Pope and his works, I
mounted the staircase, approached the dormitory, and quietly opened the
door, which was always kept carefully shut, and which, like every other
door in this house, revolved noiselessly on well-oiled hinges. Before I
saw, I felt that life was in the great room, usually void: not that
there was either stir or breath, or rustle of sound, but Vacuum lacked,
Solitude was not at home. All the white beds—the “lits d’ange,” as they
were poetically termed—lay visible at a glance; all were empty: no
sleeper reposed therein. The sound of a drawer cautiously slid out
struck my ear; stepping a little to one side, my vision took a free
range, unimpeded by falling curtains. I now commanded my own bed and my
own toilet, with a locked work-box upon it, and locked drawers
underneath.
Very good. A dumpy, motherly little body, in decent shawl and the
cleanest of possible nightcaps, stood before this toilet, hard at work
apparently doing me the kindness of “tidying out” the “meuble.” Open
stood the lid of the work-box, open the top drawer; duly and
impartially was each succeeding drawer opened in turn: not an article
of their contents but was lifted and unfolded, not a paper but was
glanced over, not a little box but was unlidded; and beautiful was the
adroitness, exemplary the care with which the search was accomplished.
Madame wrought at it like a true star, “unhasting yet unresting.” I
will not deny that it was with a secret glee I watched her. Had I been
a gentleman I believe Madame would have found favour in my eyes, she
was so handy, neat, thorough in all she did: some people’s movements
provoke the soul by their loose awkwardness, hers—satisfied by their
trim compactness. I stood, in short, fascinated; but it was necessary
to make an effort to break this spell, a retreat must be beaten. The
searcher might have turned and caught me; there would have been nothing
for it then but a scene, and she and I would have had to come all at
once, with a sudden clash, to a thorough knowledge of each other: down
would have gone conventionalities, away swept disguises, and I should
have looked into her eyes, and she into mine—we should have known that
we could work together no more, and parted in this life for ever.
Where was the use of tempting such a catastrophe? I was not angry, and
had no wish in the world to leave her. I could hardly get another
employer whose yoke would be so light and so easy of carriage; and
truly I liked Madame for her capital sense, whatever I might think of
her principles: as to her system, it did me no harm; she might work me
with it to her heart’s content: nothing would come of the operation.
Loverless and inexpectant of love, I was as safe from spies in my
heart-poverty, as the beggar from thieves in his destitution of purse.
I turned, then, and fled; descending the stairs with progress as swift
and soundless as that of the spider, which at the same instant ran down
the bannister.
How I laughed when I reached the schoolroom. I knew now she had
certainly seen Dr. John in the garden; I knew what her thoughts were.
The spectacle of a suspicious nature so far misled by its own
inventions, tickled me much. Yet as the laugh died, a kind of wrath
smote me, and then bitterness followed: it was the rock struck, and
Meribah’s waters gushing out. I never had felt so strange and
contradictory an inward tumult as I felt for an hour that evening:
soreness and laughter, and fire, and grief, shared my heart between
them. I cried hot tears: not because Madame mistrusted me—I did not
care twopence for her mistrust—but for other reasons. Complicated,
disquieting thoughts broke up the whole repose of my nature. However,
that turmoil subsided: next day I was again Lucy Snowe.
On revisiting my drawers, I found them all securely locked; the closest
subsequent examination could not discover change or apparent
disturbance in the position of one object. My few dresses were folded
as I had left them; a certain little bunch of white violets that had
once been silently presented to me by a stranger (a stranger to me, for
we had never exchanged words), and which I had dried and kept for its
sweet perfume between the folds of my best dress, lay there unstirred;
my black silk scarf, my lace chemisette and collars, were unrumpled.
Had she creased one solitary article, I own I should have felt much
greater difficulty in forgiving her; but finding all straight and
orderly, I said, “Let bygones be bygones. I am unharmed: why should I
bear malice?”
A thing there was which puzzled myself, and I sought in my brain a key
to that riddle almost as sedulously as Madame had sought a guide to
useful knowledge in my toilet drawers. How was it that Dr. John, if he
had not been accessory to the dropping of that casket into the garden,
should have known that it was dropped, and appeared so promptly on
the spot to seek it? So strong was the wish to clear up this point that
I began to entertain this daring suggestion: “Why may I not, in case I
should ever have the opportunity, ask Dr. John himself to explain this
coincidence?”
And so long as Dr. John was absent, I really believed I had courage to
test him with such a question.
Little Georgette was now convalescent; and her physician accordingly
made his visits very rare: indeed, he would have ceased them
altogether, had not Madame insisted on his giving an occasional call
till the child should be quite well.
She came into the nursery one evening just after I had listened to
Georgette’s lisped and broken prayer, and had put her to bed. Taking
the little one’s hand, she said, “Cette enfant a toujours un peu de
fièvre.” And presently afterwards, looking at me with a quicker glance
than was habitual to her quiet eye, “Le Docteur John l’a-t-il vue
dernièrement? Non, n’est-ce pas?”
Of course she knew this better than any other person in the house.
“Well,” she continued, “I am going out, pour faire quelques courses en
fiacre. I shall call on Dr. John, and send him to the child. I will
that he sees her this evening; her cheeks are flushed, her pulse is
quick; you will receive him—for my part, I shall be from home.”
Now the child was well enough, only warm with the warmth of July; it
was scarcely less needful to send for a priest to administer extreme
unction than for a doctor to prescribe a dose; also Madame rarely made
“courses,” as she called them, in the evening: moreover, this was the
first time she had chosen to absent herself on the occasion of a visit
from Dr. John. The whole arrangement indicated some plan; this I saw,
but without the least anxiety. “Ha! ha! Madame,” laughed Light-heart
the Beggar, “your crafty wits are on the wrong tack.”
She departed, attired very smartly, in a shawl of price, and a certain
chapeau vert tendre—hazardous, as to its tint, for any complexion
less fresh than her own, but, to her, not unbecoming. I wondered what
she intended: whether she really would send Dr. John or not; or whether
indeed he would come: he might be engaged.
Madame had charged me not to let Georgette sleep till the doctor came;
I had therefore sufficient occupation in telling her nursery tales and
palavering the little language for her benefit. I affected Georgette;
she was a sensitive and a loving child: to hold her in my lap, or carry
her in my arms, was to me a treat. To-night she would have me lay my
head on the pillow of her crib; she even put her little arms round my
neck. Her clasp, and the nestling action with which she pressed her
cheek to mine, made me almost cry with a tender pain. Feeling of no
kind abounded in that house; this pure little drop from a pure little
source was too sweet: it penetrated deep, and subdued the heart, and
sent a gush to the eyes. Half an hour or an hour passed; Georgette
murmured in her soft lisp that she was growing sleepy. “And you shall
sleep,” thought I, “malgré maman and médecin, if they are not here in
ten minutes.”
Hark! There was the ring, and there the tread, astonishing the
staircase by the fleetness with which it left the steps behind. Rosine
introduced Dr. John, and, with a freedom of manner not altogether
peculiar to herself, but characteristic of the domestics of Villette
generally, she stayed to hear what he had to say. Madame’s presence
would have awed her back to her own realm of the vestibule and the
cabinet—for mine, or that of any other teacher or pupil, she cared not
a jot. Smart, trim and pert, she stood, a hand in each pocket of her
gay grisette apron, eyeing Dr. John with no more fear or shyness than
if he had been a picture instead of a living gentleman.
“Le marmot n’a rien n’est ce pas?” said she, indicating Georgette with
a jerk of her chin.
“Pas beaucoup,” was the answer, as the doctor hastily scribbled with
his pencil some harmless prescription.
“Eh bien!” pursued Rosine, approaching him quite near, while he put up
his pencil. “And the box—did you get it? Monsieur went off like a
coup-de-vent the other night; I had not time to ask him.”
“I found it: yes.”
“And who threw it, then?” continued Rosine, speaking quite freely the
very words I should so much have wished to say, but had no address or
courage to bring it out: how short some people make the road to a point
which, for others, seems unattainable!
“That may be my secret,” rejoined Dr. John briefly, but with no sort of
hauteur: he seemed quite to understand the Rosine or grisette
character.
“Mais enfin,” continued she, nothing abashed, “monsieur knew it was
thrown, since he came to seek it—how did he know?”
“I was attending a little patient in the college near,” said he, “and
saw it dropped out of his chamber window, and so came to pick it up.”
How simple the whole explanation! The note had alluded to a physician
as then examining “Gustave.”
“Ah ça!” pursued Rosine; “il n’y a donc rien là-dessous: pas de
mystère, pas d’amourette, par exemple?”
“Pas plus que sur ma main,” responded the doctor, showing his palm.
“Quel dommage!” responded the grisette: “et moi—à qui tout cela
commençait à donner des idées.”
“Vraiment! vous en êtes pour vos frais,” was the doctor’s cool
rejoinder.
She pouted. The doctor could not help laughing at the sort of “moue”
she made: when he laughed, he had something peculiarly good-natured and
genial in his look. I saw his hand incline to his pocket.
“How many times have you opened the door for me within this last
month?” he asked.
“Monsieur ought to have kept count of that,” said Rosine, quite
readily.
“As if I had not something better to do!” rejoined he; but I saw him
give her a piece of gold, which she took unscrupulously, and then
danced off to answer the door-bell, ringing just now every five
minutes, as the various servants came to fetch the half-boarders.
The reader must not think too hardly of Rosine; on the whole, she was
not a bad sort of person, and had no idea there could be any disgrace
in grasping at whatever she could get, or any effrontery in chattering
like a pie to the best gentleman in Christendom.
I had learnt something from the above scene besides what concerned the
ivory box: viz., that not on the robe de jaconas, pink or grey, nor yet
on the frilled and pocketed apron, lay the blame of breaking Dr. John’s
heart: these items of array were obviously guiltless as Georgette’s
little blue tunic. So much the better. But who then was the culprit?
What was the ground—what the origin—what the perfect explanation of the
whole business? Some points had been cleared, but how many yet remained
obscure as night!
“However,” I said to myself, “it is no affair of yours;” and turning
from the face on which I had been unconsciously dwelling with a
questioning gaze, I looked through the window which commanded the
garden below. Dr. John, meantime, standing by the bed-side, was slowly
drawing on his gloves and watching his little patient, as her eyes
closed and her rosy lips parted in coming sleep. I waited till he
should depart as usual, with a quick bow and scarce articulate
“good-night.”. Just as he took his hat, my eyes, fixed on the tall
houses bounding the garden, saw the one lattice, already commemorated,
cautiously open; forth from the aperture projected a hand and a white
handkerchief; both waved. I know not whether the signal was answered
from some viewless quarter of our own dwelling; but immediately after
there fluttered from the lattice a falling object, white and
light—billet the second, of course.
“There!” I ejaculated involuntarily.
“Where?”, asked Dr. John with energy, making direct for the window.
“What, is it?”
“They have gone and done it again,” was my reply. “A handkerchief waved
and something fell:” and I pointed to the lattice, now closed and
looking hypocritically blank.
“Go, at once; pick it up and bring it here,” was his prompt direction;
adding, “Nobody will take notice of you: I should be seen.”
Straight I went. After some little search, I found a folded paper,
lodged on the lower branch of a shrub; I seized and brought it direct
to Dr. John. This time, I believe not even Rosine saw me.
He instantly tore the billet into small pieces, without reading it. “It
is not in the least her fault, you must remember,” he said, looking
at me.
“Whose fault?” I asked. “Who is it?”
“You don’t yet know, then?”
“Not in the least.”
“Have you no guess?”
“None.”
“If I knew you better, I might be tempted to risk some confidence, and
thus secure you as guardian over a most innocent and excellent, but
somewhat inexperienced being.”
“As a duenna?” I asked.
“Yes,” said he abstractedly. “What snares are round her!” he added,
musingly: and now, certainly for the first time, he examined my face,
anxious, doubtless, to see if any kindly expression there, would
warrant him in recommending to my care and indulgence some ethereal
creature, against whom powers of darkness were plotting. I felt no
particular vocation to undertake the surveillance of ethereal
creatures; but recalling the scene at the bureau, it seemed to me that
I owed him a good turn: if I could help him then I would, and it
lay not with me to decide how. With as little reluctance as might be, I
intimated that “I was willing to do what I could towards taking care of
any person in whom he might be interested.”.
“I am no farther interested than as a spectator,” said he, with a
modesty, admirable, as I thought, to witness. “I happen to be
acquainted with the rather worthless character of the person, who, from
the house opposite, has now twice invaded the sanctity of this place; I
have also met in society the object at whom these vulgar attempts are
aimed. Her exquisite superiority and innate refinement ought, one would
think, to scare impertinence from her very idea. It is not so, however;
and innocent, unsuspicious as she is, I would guard her from evil if I
could. In person, however, I can do nothing, I cannot come near her”—he
paused.
“Well, I am willing to help you,” said I, “only tell me how.” And
busily, in my own mind, I ran over the list of our inmates, seeking
this paragon, this pearl of great price, this gem without flaw. “It
must be Madame,” I concluded. “She only, amongst us all, has the art
even to seem superior: but as to being unsuspicious, inexperienced,
&c., Dr. John need not distract himself about that. However, this is
just his whim, and I will not contradict him; he shall be humoured: his
angel shall be an angel.”
“Just notify the quarter to which my care is to be directed,” I
continued gravely: chuckling, however, to myself over the thought of
being set to chaperon Madame Beck or any of her pupils. Now Dr. John
had a fine set of nerves, and he at once felt by instinct, what no more
coarsely constituted mind would have detected; namely, that I was a
little amused at him. The colour rose to his cheek; with half a smile
he turned and took his hat—he was going. My heart smote me.
“I will—I will help you,” said I eagerly. “I will do what you wish. I
will watch over your angel; I will take care of her, only tell me who
she is.”
“But you must know,” said he then with earnestness, yet speaking very
low. “So spotless, so good, so unspeakably beautiful! impossible that
one house should contain two like her. I allude, of course—”
Here the latch of Madame Beck’s chamber-door (opening into the nursery)
gave a sudden click, as if the hand holding it had been slightly
convulsed; there was the suppressed explosion of an irrepressible
sneeze. These little accidents will happen to the best of us.
Madame—excellent woman! was then on duty. She had come home quietly,
stolen up-stairs on tip-toe; she was in her chamber. If she had not
sneezed, she would have heard all, and so should I; but that unlucky
sternutation routed Dr. John. While he stood aghast, she came forward
alert, composed, in the best yet most tranquil spirits: no novice to
her habits but would have thought she had just come in, and scouted the
idea of her ear having been glued to the key-hole for at least ten
minutes. She affected to sneeze again, declared she was “enrhumée,” and
then proceeded volubly to recount her “courses en fiacre.” The
prayer-bell rang, and I left her with the doctor.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Choosing not to confront when the cost of fighting exceeds the potential benefit, while quietly gathering information and preserving your position.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone is testing your boundaries and gathering information to use against you.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone asks seemingly innocent questions about your personal life or work methods—they might be building a case rather than making conversation.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Their seclusion was now become precarious; their calm—insecure."
Context: Lucy reflects on how the garden spaces that once felt private and safe now feel exposed and watched.
This shows how violation of privacy changes everything - once you know you're being watched, nowhere feels safe anymore. Lucy's sanctuary has been compromised, and she can't get that feeling of security back.
In Today's Words:
My safe space didn't feel safe anymore - I knew someone was always watching.
"That casement which rained billets, had vulgarized the once dear nook it overlooked."
Context: Lucy describes how discovering the secret love letters has changed her perception of the garden space.
The romantic drama has made her peaceful spot feel cheap and tainted. Sometimes learning about other people's business ruins places that used to bring us comfort.
In Today's Words:
Finding out about the secret texting ruined my favorite quiet spot.
"Some battles aren't worth fighting, especially when your job security depends on maintaining peace."
Context: Lucy's internal reasoning for not confronting Madame Beck about searching through her belongings.
This shows Lucy's growing wisdom about workplace politics. She recognizes that being right isn't always worth the consequences, especially when you need the job more than you need to prove a point.
In Today's Words:
I need this job more than I need to call out my boss for going through my stuff.
"The eyes of the flowers had gained vision, and the knots in the tree-boles listened like secret ears."
Context: Lucy describes how the garden now feels like it's watching her, after discovering all the secret activity.
This poetic description captures the paranoid feeling of being watched. Once you know people are spying and keeping secrets, even nature seems to have eyes and ears.
In Today's Words:
It felt like everything was watching me and listening to my business.
Thematic Threads
Power Dynamics
In This Chapter
Lucy recognizes Madame Beck's authority and chooses not to challenge it directly, understanding her vulnerable position as an employee
Development
Evolved from Lucy's earlier passive acceptance to active strategic thinking about power relationships
In Your Life:
You might see this when deciding whether to challenge your boss's unfair decision or when dealing with difficult family members who hold financial power over you.
Information Control
In This Chapter
Madame Beck searches Lucy's belongings for information while Dr. John's interrupted revelation shows how timing controls what we learn
Development
Building from earlier chapters where Lucy observed others' secrets, now she's both target and observer of information gathering
In Your Life:
You experience this when coworkers fish for information about your personal life or when family members try to control narratives about family events.
Workplace Survival
In This Chapter
Lucy prioritizes job security over personal dignity, understanding that her economic survival depends on maintaining her employer's favor
Development
Deepened from Lucy's initial job anxiety to sophisticated understanding of workplace politics
In Your Life:
You face this when deciding whether to report workplace harassment or when choosing to smile through unfair treatment to keep your paycheck.
Emotional Intelligence
In This Chapter
Lucy reads the situation accurately and chooses the response that serves her long-term interests rather than her immediate emotions
Development
Significant growth from Lucy's earlier impulsive reactions to calculated emotional responses
In Your Life:
You use this when your teenager pushes your buttons but you choose not to escalate, or when a difficult customer tests your patience at work.
Social Surveillance
In This Chapter
Everyone watches everyone else - Madame Beck spies on Lucy, Lucy observes the mysterious letters, and conversations are constantly interrupted by strategic timing
Development
Expanded from individual observation to understanding the entire social ecosystem as a surveillance network
In Your Life:
You see this in small workplaces where everyone knows everyone's business, or in tight-knit neighborhoods where privacy is nearly impossible.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Lucy choose not to confront Madame Beck when she catches her searching through her belongings?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Lucy's strategic silence reveal about her understanding of workplace power dynamics?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of 'strategic silence' play out in modern workplaces or family situations?
application • medium - 4
How do you decide when a battle is worth fighting versus when silence serves you better?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the relationship between pride and survival in hierarchical relationships?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Power Dynamics
Think of a current situation where someone has power over you (boss, landlord, family member, teacher). Draw or write out the power structure: who holds what cards, what you need from them, what they could take away. Then identify one recent moment where you had to choose between speaking up and staying silent.
Consider:
- •What did you actually have the power to change in that situation?
- •What would you have risked by confronting the issue directly?
- •What information did staying silent allow you to gather or preserve?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when staying quiet felt like giving up, but later proved to be the smarter choice. What did that experience teach you about picking your battles?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 14: The Reluctant Performer
A special celebration is coming to the school, and with it, new opportunities for secrets to surface and relationships to shift in unexpected ways.




