Summary
Jim watches from hiding as Pew and his gang of pirates ransack the Admiral Benbow inn, searching desperately for something more valuable than money. When they discover that Jim and his mother have already taken what they're after, Pew becomes increasingly frantic and abusive toward his own men. His greed and desperation reach a breaking point when warning signals indicate approaching danger. While his crew wants to flee with the money they've found, Pew refuses to give up the greater treasure, berating them as cowards and striking them with his stick. This toxic leadership backfires spectacularly—when revenue officers arrive on horseback, Pew's own men abandon him in his moment of greatest need. In his panic and blindness, both literal and metaphorical, Pew runs directly into the path of the horses and is trampled to death. The irony is stark: the man who called others cowards dies alone because his greed made him impossible to follow. Jim emerges to meet the revenue officers, led by Supervisor Dance, who arrived just in time thanks to a tip about suspicious activity. Though the main ship escapes, Jim realizes he possesses something the pirates desperately wanted—something he's kept hidden in his coat pocket. The chapter reveals how unchecked ambition destroys not just the leader, but relationships and loyalty. Pew's fate serves as a powerful reminder that leadership built on fear and greed ultimately leads to isolation and downfall.
Coming Up in Chapter 6
Jim finally reveals the mysterious object he's been hiding, and its contents will change everything. A meeting with Dr. Livesey and the squire sets the stage for an adventure that will take them far from home.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
The Last of the Blind Man My curiosity, in a sense, was stronger than my fear, for I could not remain where I was, but crept back to the bank again, whence, sheltering my head behind a bush of broom, I might command the road before our door. I was scarcely in position ere my enemies began to arrive, seven or eight of them, running hard, their feet beating out of time along the road and the man with the lantern some paces in front. Three men ran together, hand in hand; and I made out, even through the mist, that the middle man of this trio was the blind beggar. The next moment his voice showed me that I was right. “Down with the door!” he cried. “Aye, aye, sir!” answered two or three; and a rush was made upon the Admiral Benbow, the lantern-bearer following; and then I could see them pause, and hear speeches passed in a lower key, as if they were surprised to find the door open. But the pause was brief, for the blind man again issued his commands. His voice sounded louder and higher, as if he were afire with eagerness and rage. “In, in, in!” he shouted, and cursed them for their delay. Four or five of them obeyed at once, two remaining on the road with the formidable beggar. There was a pause, then a cry of surprise, and then a voice shouting from the house, “Bill’s dead.” But the blind man swore at them again for their delay. “Search him, some of you shirking lubbers, and the rest of you aloft and get the chest,” he cried. I could hear their feet rattling up our old stairs, so that the house must have shook with it. Promptly afterwards, fresh sounds of astonishment arose; the window of the captain’s room was thrown open with a slam and a jingle of broken glass, and a man leaned out into the moonlight, head and shoulders, and addressed the blind beggar on the road below him. “Pew,” he cried, “they’ve been before us. Someone’s turned the chest out alow and aloft.” “Is it there?” roared Pew. “The money’s there.” The blind man cursed the money. “Flint’s fist, I mean,” he cried. “We don’t see it here nohow,” returned the man. “Here, you below there, is it on Bill?” cried the blind man again. At that another fellow, probably him who had remained below to search the captain’s body, came to the door of the inn. “Bill’s been overhauled a’ready,” said he; “nothin’ left.” “It’s these people of the inn--it’s that boy. I wish I had put his eyes out!” cried the blind man, Pew. “There were no time ago--they had the door bolted when I tried it. Scatter, lads, and find ’em.” “Sure enough, they left their glim here,” said the fellow from the window. “Scatter and find ’em! Rout the house out!” reiterated Pew, striking with his stick upon the road. Then there...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Toxic Leadership
Leaders who rule through fear and greed create a downward spiral that ultimately destroys both their authority and their relationships.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when someone's desperation makes them dangerous to follow.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when authority figures become more controlling under pressure—that's when their true character shows and you need to protect yourself most.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Revenue officers
Government agents who collected taxes and fought smuggling in 18th century Britain. They were like early customs agents, patrolling coasts and investigating illegal trade. Pirates and smugglers were their main targets.
Modern Usage:
Today we'd call them federal agents or customs enforcement - the people who bust drug smugglers or tax evaders.
Admiral Benbow
The name of the inn Jim's family runs. Named after a real British naval hero, it represents respectability and lawful business. The pirates' invasion of this space shows the conflict between legitimate society and criminal underworld.
Modern Usage:
Like naming your restaurant after a war hero - it signals you're part of the respectable community.
Blind beggar
Pew's disguise as a helpless person asking for charity. This fake vulnerability lets him get close to victims and gather information. It's a classic con artist technique - appearing weak to catch people off guard.
Modern Usage:
We see this in modern scams where criminals pretend to be stranded motorists or lost tourists to get close to victims.
Lantern-bearer
The person carrying light for the group in pre-electric times. This role shows hierarchy - someone has to do the grunt work while others make decisions. It also reveals who's really in charge by who gives the orders.
Modern Usage:
Like being the designated driver or the person who has to carry everyone's stuff - you're useful but not the boss.
Formidable
Inspiring fear or respect through being impressively powerful or intense. Stevenson uses this to describe Pew, showing how his reputation and presence intimidate others despite his physical blindness.
Modern Usage:
We use this for anyone who commands respect through skill or intensity - a formidable opponent, boss, or competitor.
Ransack
To search through something thoroughly and roughly, usually leaving destruction behind. The pirates tear apart the inn looking for treasure, showing their desperation and disregard for others' property.
Modern Usage:
Police ransack a suspect's house, or you ransack your room looking for lost keys - searching destructively.
Characters in This Chapter
Jim Hawkins
Protagonist observer
Jim hides and watches the pirates destroy his family's inn, showing courage by staying to gather intelligence. He possesses something valuable the pirates want but keeps it secret. His decision to observe rather than flee shows growing maturity.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who witnesses a crime and has to decide whether to get involved or stay safe
Pew
Primary antagonist
The blind pirate leader who commands through fear and violence. His greed for treasure overrides all sense, leading him to abuse his own men and ultimately causing his death when they abandon him. Shows how toxic leadership destroys itself.
Modern Equivalent:
The abusive boss who screams at employees until they all quit and leave him to fail alone
Supervisor Dance
Authority figure/rescuer
The revenue officer who arrives with his men to investigate suspicious activity. Represents legitimate authority and law enforcement. His timely arrival saves Jim and shows that sometimes the system does work to protect innocent people.
Modern Equivalent:
The police supervisor who responds to a domestic disturbance call just in time
The pirate gang
Conflicted followers
Pew's crew who follow orders but grow increasingly uncomfortable with his leadership. They want to escape with what money they found, but Pew's obsession with greater treasure puts them all at risk. They ultimately abandon him to save themselves.
Modern Equivalent:
Employees who finally walk out on an impossible boss, even if it means losing their jobs
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Down with the door!"
Context: Pew commands his men to break into the Admiral Benbow inn
This shows Pew's immediate resort to violence and destruction. He doesn't try stealth or negotiation - just brute force. It reveals his desperation and the urgency of whatever he's seeking.
In Today's Words:
Break it down! We're going in hard!
"Bill's dead."
Context: The pirates discover Billy Bones has died in the inn
This moment shifts everything - they realize their target is gone but whatever he had might still be there. It creates both opportunity and greater urgency for the treasure hunt.
In Today's Words:
The old man's already dead.
"In, in, in!"
Context: Pew frantically urges his men to search the inn faster
The repetition shows Pew's growing panic and desperation. His leadership style is all commands and no patience. This kind of pressure creates mistakes and resentment among followers.
In Today's Words:
Move, move, move! Get in there now!
Thematic Threads
Leadership
In This Chapter
Pew's abusive, fear-based leadership style backfires when his men abandon him in crisis
Development
Building from Billy Bones' paranoid authority—showing how bad leadership escalates
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in bosses who rule through intimidation rather than earning respect.
Greed
In This Chapter
Pew's obsession with the treasure blinds him to danger and destroys his judgment
Development
Escalating from earlier hints about pirates' desperation for Flint's map
In Your Life:
You see this when someone becomes so focused on what they want that they ignore obvious warning signs.
Loyalty
In This Chapter
Pew's men abandon him because he's given them no reason to stay loyal beyond fear
Development
Contrasts with Jim's growing loyalty to his mother through shared hardship
In Your Life:
You experience this when deciding whether to stick with someone who only takes but never gives.
Justice
In This Chapter
Pew's death feels like cosmic justice—his own character flaws directly cause his downfall
Development
Building the theme that actions have consequences, started with Billy Bones' death
In Your Life:
You witness this when someone's persistent bad behavior finally catches up with them.
Class
In This Chapter
The revenue officers represent legitimate authority versus the pirates' lawless violence
Development
Continuing the contrast between respectable society and criminal underworld
In Your Life:
You navigate this when choosing between taking shortcuts and following proper procedures.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What happens to Pew when his own men abandon him, and why do they leave him behind?
analysis • surface - 2
How does Pew's treatment of his crew throughout the search create the conditions for his own downfall?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen leaders who demand loyalty but offer nothing but criticism and abuse in return? What usually happens to those relationships?
application • medium - 4
If you were one of Pew's crew members, what would you have needed from him to stay loyal during the crisis?
application • deep - 5
What does Pew's fate reveal about the difference between leadership based on fear versus leadership based on respect?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Toxic Leadership Warning Signs Checklist
Create a practical checklist of warning signs that someone is becoming a toxic leader like Pew. Think about behaviors you've witnessed in bosses, family members, or group leaders. Then flip it: what are the green flags of healthy leadership? Use this chapter's events as your starting point, but draw from your own experiences.
Consider:
- •Consider both obvious signs (yelling, blaming) and subtle ones (taking all credit, never admitting mistakes)
- •Think about how toxic leaders respond differently to stress versus how good leaders handle pressure
- •Remember that people can change these patterns if they recognize them early enough
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you either followed a toxic leader or caught yourself displaying some of these warning signs. What did you learn about loyalty, respect, and how people respond to different leadership styles?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 6: The Map Changes Everything
As the story unfolds, you'll explore the right documents can completely transform your life's trajectory, while uncovering keeping secrets requires discipline when stakes are high. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.