An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1990 words)
he Fall of a Chieftain
There never was such an overturn in this world. Each of these six men
was as though he had been struck. But with Silver the blow passed almost
instantly. Every thought of his soul had been set full-stretch, like a
racer, on that money; well, he was brought up, in a single second, dead;
and he kept his head, found his temper, and changed his plan before the
others had had time to realize the disappointment.
“Jim,” he whispered, “take that, and stand by for trouble.”
And he passed me a double-barrelled pistol.
At the same time, he began quietly moving northward, and in a few steps
had put the hollow between us two and the other five. Then he looked at
me and nodded, as much as to say, “Here is a narrow corner,” as, indeed,
I thought it was. His looks were not quite friendly, and I was so
revolted at these constant changes that I could not forbear whispering,
“So you’ve changed sides again.”
There was no time left for him to answer in. The buccaneers, with oaths
and cries, began to leap, one after another, into the pit and to dig
with their fingers, throwing the boards aside as they did so. Morgan
found a piece of gold. He held it up with a perfect spout of oaths. It
was a two-guinea piece, and it went from hand to hand among them for a
quarter of a minute.
“Two guineas!” roared Merry, shaking it at Silver. “That’s your seven
hundred thousand pounds, is it? You’re the man for bargains, ain’t you?
You’re him that never bungled nothing, you wooden-headed lubber!”
“Dig away, boys,” said Silver with the coolest insolence; “you’ll find
some pig-nuts and I shouldn’t wonder.”
“Pig-nuts!” repeated Merry, in a scream. “Mates, do you hear that? I
tell you now, that man there knew it all along. Look in the face of him
and you’ll see it wrote there.”
“Ah, Merry,” remarked Silver, “standing for cap’n again? You’re a
pushing lad, to be sure.”
But this time everyone was entirely in Merry’s favour. They began to
scramble out of the excavation, darting furious glances behind them. One
thing I observed, which looked well for us: they all got out upon the
opposite side from Silver.
Well, there we stood, two on one side, five on the other, the pit
between us, and nobody screwed up high enough to offer the first blow.
Silver never moved; he watched them, very upright on his crutch, and
looked as cool as ever I saw him. He was brave, and no mistake.
At last Merry seemed to think a speech might help matters.
“Mates,” says he, “there’s two of them alone there; one’s the old
cripple that brought us all here and blundered us down to this; the
other’s that cub that I mean to have the heart of. Now, mates--”
He was raising his arm and his voice, and plainly meant to lead a
charge. But just then--crack! crack! crack!--three musket-shots flashed
out of the thicket. Merry tumbled head foremost into the excavation; the
man with the bandage spun round like a teetotum and fell all his length
upon his side, where he lay dead, but still twitching; and the other
three turned and ran for it with all their might.
Before you could wink, Long John had fired two barrels of a pistol into
the struggling Merry, and as the man rolled up his eyes at him in the
last agony, “George,” said he, “I reckon I settled you.”
At the same moment, the doctor, Gray, and Ben Gunn joined us, with
smoking muskets, from among the nutmeg-trees.
“Forward!” cried the doctor. “Double quick, my lads. We must head ’em
off the boats.”
And we set off at a great pace, sometimes plunging through the bushes to
the chest.
I tell you, but Silver was anxious to keep up with us. The work that man
went through, leaping on his crutch till the muscles of his chest were
fit to burst, was work no sound man ever equalled; and so thinks the
doctor. As it was, he was already thirty yards behind us and on the
verge of strangling when we reached the brow of the slope.
“Doctor,” he hailed, “see there! No hurry!”
Sure enough there was no hurry. In a more open part of the plateau, we
could see the three survivors still running in the same direction as
they had started, right for Mizzenmast Hill. We were already between
them and the boats; and so we four sat down to breathe, while Long John,
mopping his face, came slowly up with us.
“Thank ye kindly, doctor,” says he. “You came in in about the nick, I
guess, for me and Hawkins. And so it’s you, Ben Gunn!” he added. “Well,
you’re a nice one, to be sure.”
“I’m Ben Gunn, I am,” replied the maroon, wriggling like an eel in his
embarrassment. “And,” he added, after a long pause, “how do, Mr. Silver?
Pretty well, I thank ye, says you.”
“Ben, Ben,” murmured Silver, “to think as you’ve done me!”
The doctor sent back Gray for one of the pick-axes deserted, in their
flight, by the mutineers, and then as we proceeded leisurely downhill to
where the boats were lying, related in a few words what had taken place.
It was a story that profoundly interested Silver; and Ben Gunn, the
half-idiot maroon, was the hero from beginning to end.
Ben, in his long, lonely wanderings about the island, had found the
skeleton--it was he that had rifled it; he had found the treasure; he
had dug it up (it was the haft of his pick-axe that lay broken in the
excavation); he had carried it on his back, in many weary journeys, from
the foot of the tall pine to a cave he had on the two-pointed hill at
the north-east angle of the island, and there it had lain stored in
safety since two months before the arrival of the HISPANIOLA.
When the doctor had wormed this secret from him on the afternoon of the
attack, and when next morning he saw the anchorage deserted, he had gone
to Silver, given him the chart, which was now useless--given him the
stores, for Ben Gunn’s cave was well supplied with goats’ meat salted
by himself--given anything and everything to get a chance of moving in
safety from the stockade to the two-pointed hill, there to be clear of
malaria and keep a guard upon the money.
“As for you, Jim,” he said, “it went against my heart, but I did what I
thought best for those who had stood by their duty; and if you were not
one of these, whose fault was it?”
That morning, finding that I was to be involved in the horrid
disappointment he had prepared for the mutineers, he had run all the way
to the cave, and leaving the squire to guard the captain, had taken Gray
and the maroon and started, making the diagonal across the island to be
at hand beside the pine. Soon, however, he saw that our party had the
start of him; and Ben Gunn, being fleet of foot, had been dispatched in
front to do his best alone. Then it had occurred to him to work upon the
superstitions of his former shipmates, and he was so far successful that
Gray and the doctor had come up and were already ambushed before the
arrival of the treasure-hunters.
“Ah,” said Silver, “it were fortunate for me that I had Hawkins here.
You would have let old John be cut to bits, and never given it a
thought, doctor.”
“Not a thought,” replied Dr. Livesey cheerily.
And by this time we had reached the gigs. The doctor, with the pick-axe,
demolished one of them, and then we all got aboard the other and set out
to go round by sea for North Inlet.
This was a run of eight or nine miles. Silver, though he was almost
killed already with fatigue, was set to an oar, like the rest of us, and
we were soon skimming swiftly over a smooth sea. Soon we passed out
of the straits and doubled the south-east corner of the island, round
which, four days ago, we had towed the HISPANIOLA.
As we passed the two-pointed hill, we could see the black mouth of Ben
Gunn’s cave and a figure standing by it, leaning on a musket. It was the
squire, and we waved a handkerchief and gave him three cheers, in which
the voice of Silver joined as heartily as any.
Three miles farther, just inside the mouth of North Inlet, what should
we meet but the HISPANIOLA, cruising by herself? The last flood had
lifted her, and had there been much wind or a strong tide current, as
in the southern anchorage, we should never have found her more, or found
her stranded beyond help. As it was, there was little amiss beyond the
wreck of the main-sail. Another anchor was got ready and dropped in a
fathom and a half of water. We all pulled round again to Rum Cove,
the nearest point for Ben Gunn’s treasure-house; and then Gray,
single-handed, returned with the gig to the HISPANIOLA, where he was to
pass the night on guard.
A gentle slope ran up from the beach to the entrance of the cave. At the
top, the squire met us. To me he was cordial and kind, saying nothing
of my escapade either in the way of blame or praise. At Silver’s polite
salute he somewhat flushed.
“John Silver,” he said, “you’re a prodigious villain and imposter--a
monstrous imposter, sir. I am told I am not to prosecute you. Well,
then, I will not. But the dead men, sir, hang about your neck like
mill-stones.”
“Thank you kindly, sir,” replied Long John, again saluting.
“I dare you to thank me!” cried the squire. “It is a gross dereliction
of my duty. Stand back.”
And thereupon we all entered the cave. It was a large, airy place, with
a little spring and a pool of clear water, overhung with ferns. The
floor was sand. Before a big fire lay Captain Smollett; and in a far
corner, only duskily flickered over by the blaze, I beheld great heaps
of coin and quadrilaterals built of bars of gold. That was Flint’s
treasure that we had come so far to seek and that had cost already the
lives of seventeen men from the HISPANIOLA. How many it had cost in the
amassing, what blood and sorrow, what good ships scuttled on the deep,
what brave men walking the plank blindfold, what shot of cannon, what
shame and lies and cruelty, perhaps no man alive could tell. Yet there
were still three upon that island--Silver, and old Morgan, and Ben
Gunn--who had each taken his share in these crimes, as each had hoped in
vain to share in the reward.
“Come in, Jim,” said the captain. “You’re a good boy in your line, Jim,
but I don’t think you and me’ll go to sea again. You’re too much of the
born favourite for me. Is that you, John Silver? What brings you here,
man?”
“Come back to my dooty, sir,” returned Silver.
“Ah!” said the captain, and that was all he said.
What a supper I had of it that night, with all my friends around me; and
what a meal it was, with Ben Gunn’s salted goat and some delicacies and
a bottle of old wine from the HISPANIOLA. Never, I am sure, were people
gayer or happier. And there was Silver, sitting back almost out of the
firelight, but eating heartily, prompt to spring forward when anything
was wanted, even joining quietly in our laughter--the same bland,
polite, obsequious seaman of the voyage out.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
The ability to completely flip allegiances, values, and actions the moment circumstances change, without emotional cost or internal conflict.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when someone's loyalty depends entirely on what benefits them in the moment.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when people change their position without acknowledging they've changed—that's a red flag for future betrayals.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"So you've changed sides again."
Context: Jim whispers this to Silver when he sees him switching alliances once more as the treasure hunt fails.
This captures Jim's moral exhaustion with Silver's constant betrayals. Even though Silver's move saves their lives, Jim is disgusted by how easily he abandons his followers when it suits him.
In Today's Words:
Here you go again, throwing people under the bus to save yourself.
"Here is a narrow corner."
Context: Silver signals to Jim that they're in deadly danger from the furious pirates who just discovered the empty treasure chest.
Silver's understated way of acknowledging mortal peril shows his ability to stay calm under pressure. He's already planning their survival while the other pirates are still processing their disappointment.
In Today's Words:
We're in deep trouble here.
"Two guineas!"
Context: One of the pirates holds up the pathetic remains of what should have been an enormous treasure.
This roar of outrage represents the moment when disappointed greed turns deadly. The pirates realize they've been betrayed or cheated, and their fury will demand blood as compensation.
In Today's Words:
This is all we get?!
Thematic Threads
Survival
In This Chapter
Silver instantly switches sides when the treasure hunt fails, choosing survival over loyalty to his pirate crew
Development
Evolved from earlier themes of physical survival to psychological and social survival through adaptation
In Your Life:
You might see this when colleagues abandon team projects the moment they become unpopular with management
Loyalty
In This Chapter
All previous alliances crumble—Silver betrays the pirates, the pirates turn on Silver, showing loyalty as purely transactional
Development
Culmination of the book's exploration of how loyalty breaks under pressure
In Your Life:
You might experience this during family crises when relatives choose sides based on who's winning rather than what's right
Deception
In This Chapter
The entire treasure hunt was based on false information—Ben Gunn had already moved the treasure, making the map worthless
Development
Final revelation that layers of deception have driven the entire adventure
In Your Life:
You might encounter this when discovering that workplace promises were made knowing they couldn't be kept
Identity
In This Chapter
Silver seamlessly shifts from pirate leader to humble servant again, showing identity as performance rather than core self
Development
Completes Silver's arc as someone whose identity is completely fluid and strategic
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in people who present completely different personalities depending on who they're trying to impress
Consequences
In This Chapter
The treasure represents seventeen lives lost from their ship alone, plus countless victims of Flint's original crimes
Development
Final accounting of the human cost behind the adventure and wealth
In Your Life:
You might face this when realizing that your workplace success came at the cost of others' wellbeing or job security
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Silver's behavior change the moment he realizes the treasure chest is empty, and what does this reveal about his true priorities?
analysis • surface - 2
Why was Dr. Livesey willing to give Silver the treasure map, and what does this teach us about the value of information?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about your workplace or social circles - who switches sides quickly when circumstances change? What warning signs do you notice?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Jim's position, how would you protect yourself from someone like Silver who can flip loyalties instantly?
application • deep - 5
Captain Smollett says Jim is 'too much of the born favourite' for dangerous adventures. What does this suggest about the difference between being lucky and being wise?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Alliance Network
Draw a simple map of the important relationships in your life - family, work, friends. For each person, ask yourself: Are they loyal to you as a person, or to what you can do for them? Mark each relationship as 'principle-based' (they'd stick with you through hard times) or 'benefit-based' (they're there for what you provide). This isn't about judging people, but about understanding the true nature of your connections.
Consider:
- •Benefit-based relationships aren't necessarily bad - they just require different boundaries
- •Look for patterns in who switches sides when your circumstances change
- •Consider whether you've been a 'Silver' to others - adapting your loyalty based on convenience
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's loyalty to you shifted dramatically when circumstances changed. What did you learn about reading people's true motivations, and how do you protect yourself now while still staying open to genuine relationships?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 34: The Price of Adventure
With the treasure finally secured and the surviving pirates defeated, the adventure nears its end. But what becomes of Long John Silver, and how does Jim's journey home change him forever?




