Summary
The Marquis arrives with a horrifying demand: La Motte must murder Adeline that very night. What began as vague criminal cooperation now reveals its true, monstrous nature. La Motte finds himself trapped—refuse and face destruction from the Marquis's power; comply and become a murderer. The chapter exposes how gradual moral compromise leads to impossible choices, as La Motte realizes he's been led 'by slow gradations from folly to vice' until he faces 'an abyss of guilt.' Yet in a stunning reversal, La Motte's conscience awakens. Instead of killing Adeline, he helps her escape with Peter to Savoy, telling her 'I am not quite so bad as I have been tempted to be.' This act of unexpected redemption comes at great cost—when the Marquis discovers the deception, he has La Motte arrested. The chapter reveals the complex psychology of moral choice under extreme pressure, showing how even compromised people can find moments of courage. Adeline's journey up the Rhone toward the Alps represents both literal and symbolic movement toward freedom, while La Motte's arrest demonstrates that doing right doesn't guarantee safety. The story explores how power corrupts through incremental demands, but also how conscience can reassert itself even in the darkest circumstances.
Coming Up in Chapter 16
As Adeline travels toward what she hopes is safety in the mountains of Savoy, the Marquis's pursuit intensifies. Meanwhile, the consequences of La Motte's final act of conscience will reshape the fates of everyone involved.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Danger, whose limbs of giant mould What mortal eye can fixed behold? Who stalks his round, an hideous form! _Howling amidst the midnight storm!_---- And with him thousand phantoms join'd, _Who prompt to deeds accurst the mind!_ On whom that rav'ning brood of Fate Who lap the blood of Sorrow wait; Who, Fear! this ghastly train can see, And look not madly wild like thee! COLLINS. The Marquis was punctual to the hour. La Motte received him at the gate; but he declined entering, and said he preferred a walk in the forest. Thither, therefore, La Motte attended him. After some general conversation, Well, said the Marquis, have you considered what I said, and are you prepared to decide? I have, my Lord, and will quickly decide, when you shall further explain yourself: till then I can form no resolution. The Marquis appeared dissatisfied, and was a moment silent. Is it then possible, he at length resumed, that you do not understand? This ignorance is surely affected. La Motte, I expect sincerity. Tell me, therefore, is it necessary I should say more? It is, my Lord, said La Motte immediately. If you fear to confide in me freely, how can I fully accomplish your purpose? Before I proceed further, said the Marquis, let me administer some oath which shall bind you to secrecy. But this is scarcely necessary; for, could I even doubt your word of honour, the remembrance of a certain transaction would point out to you the necessity of being as silent yourself as you must wish me to be. There was now a pause of silence, during which both the Marquis and La Motte betrayed some confusion. I think, La Motte, said he, I have given you sufficient proof that I can be grateful: the services you have already rendered me with respect to Adeline have not been unrewarded. True, my Lord; I am ever willing to acknowledge this; and am sorry it has not been in my power to serve you more effectually. Your further views respecting her I am ready to assist. I thank you.--Adeline----the Marquis hesitated--Adeline, rejoined La Motte, eager to anticipate his wishes, has beauty worthy of your pursuit: she has inspired a passion of which she ought to be proud, and at any rate she shall soon be yours. Her charms are worthy of---- Yes, yes, interrupted the Marquis; but--he paused. But they have given you too much trouble in the pursuit, said La Motte; and to be sure, my Lord, it must be confessed they have; but this trouble is all over--you may now consider her as your own. I would do so, said the Marquis, fixing an eye of earnest regard upon La Motte--I would do so. Name your hour, my Lord; you shall not be interrupted. Beauty such as Adeline's-- Watch her closely, interrupted the Marquis, and on no account suffer her to leave her apartment. Where is she now? Confined in her chamber. Very well. But I am...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Incremental Compromise
How small ethical concessions create vulnerability to progressively larger demands, trapping people in situations they never intended to enter.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to spot the foot-in-the-door technique that traps people in increasingly unethical situations through small, seemingly manageable steps.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone asks for a favor that makes you slightly uncomfortable—that's your warning system telling you to ask what bigger request this might enable.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Gradual moral compromise
The process of making small ethical concessions that eventually lead to major wrongdoing. Each step seems manageable, but together they create a path to serious harm. Radcliffe shows how La Motte was led 'by slow gradations from folly to vice.'
Modern Usage:
We see this when people rationalize small lies at work until they're embezzling, or when relationships become abusive through incremental boundary violations.
Blackmail leverage
Having information or power over someone that forces their compliance with demands. The Marquis references 'a certain transaction' that binds La Motte to secrecy and obedience. This creates a trap where the victim feels they have no choice.
Modern Usage:
Abusers use this tactic by collecting embarrassing information, creating financial dependence, or threatening to reveal secrets to maintain control.
Point of no return
The moment when someone faces a choice that will fundamentally change who they are. La Motte must decide between murder and destruction, realizing he stands at 'an abyss of guilt' where any step forward means becoming someone irredeemably different.
Modern Usage:
People face this when asked to lie under oath, cover up serious wrongdoing at work, or betray someone who trusts them completely.
Conscience awakening
The sudden realization of moral boundaries that cannot be crossed, even under extreme pressure. Despite being trapped and compromised, La Motte discovers he 'is not quite so bad as he has been tempted to be' when faced with actual murder.
Modern Usage:
This happens when whistleblowers finally speak up, when people leave toxic jobs despite financial pressure, or when someone refuses family pressure to do something fundamentally wrong.
Symbolic journey
Physical movement that represents internal change or growth. Adeline's escape up the Rhone toward the Alps represents her movement from captivity toward freedom, from innocence toward self-determination.
Modern Usage:
We see this when someone moves across the country to escape an abusive situation, or when leaving home represents breaking free from family dysfunction.
Gothic atmosphere
The use of dark, mysterious, and supernatural elements to create mood and reflect internal psychological states. The opening poem about midnight phantoms and hideous forms sets the tone for the moral horror that follows.
Modern Usage:
Modern thrillers and horror movies use similar techniques, making external environments reflect characters' internal fears and moral struggles.
Characters in This Chapter
The Marquis
Primary antagonist
Reveals his true monstrous nature by demanding La Motte murder Adeline. He represents how power corrupts absolutely, using blackmail and threats to force others into evil acts. His casual approach to ordering murder shows complete moral bankruptcy.
Modern Equivalent:
The crime boss who starts with small favors then demands increasingly horrible acts, using past compliance as leverage
La Motte
Morally conflicted accomplice
Faces the ultimate test of his character when ordered to commit murder. Despite being trapped by past compromises, he finds the strength to refuse and help Adeline escape, showing that redemption remains possible even for the morally compromised.
Modern Equivalent:
The middle manager caught between corrupt executives and their own conscience, finally choosing to do right despite personal cost
Adeline
Innocent victim
Becomes the target of the Marquis's murderous plot, representing pure innocence threatened by corruption. Her successful escape with Peter's help shows that goodness can triumph, though it requires courage and assistance from unexpected sources.
Modern Equivalent:
The whistleblower or abuse survivor whose testimony threatens powerful people, requiring protection and safe passage to safety
Peter
Loyal protector
Helps facilitate Adeline's escape, demonstrating how ordinary people can become heroes when they choose to protect the innocent. His willingness to risk everything for Adeline shows the power of simple human decency.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who helps someone escape workplace harassment, or the neighbor who helps someone leave an abusive relationship
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am not quite so bad as I have been tempted to be"
Context: When he decides to help Adeline escape instead of murdering her
This reveals the moment La Motte's conscience finally asserts itself. Despite being led gradually into compromise and corruption, he discovers there are lines he cannot cross. It shows that even morally compromised people retain the capacity for redemption.
In Today's Words:
I may have made mistakes, but I'm not going to become a monster
"by slow gradations from folly to vice"
Context: Describing how La Motte was led into his current predicament
This captures the insidious nature of moral corruption - how small compromises build into major ethical failures. It explains how good people can find themselves in impossible situations through incremental poor choices.
In Today's Words:
One bad decision led to another until he was in way too deep
"could I even doubt your word of honour, the remembrance of a certain transaction would point out to you the necessity"
Context: Threatening La Motte with exposure of past crimes to ensure compliance
This shows how blackmail works - using past compromises to force present obedience. The Marquis doesn't need oaths because he has leverage. It demonstrates how corruption creates its own chains of control.
In Today's Words:
We both know what you did before, so you'll do what I say now
Thematic Threads
Moral Choice
In This Chapter
La Motte faces the ultimate moral test—murder an innocent—but finds unexpected strength to choose redemption over self-preservation
Development
Evolved from earlier themes of survival and compromise to this climactic moment where conscience reasserts itself
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when facing pressure to betray your values, discovering that your conscience speaks loudest in your darkest moments
Power Dynamics
In This Chapter
The Marquis uses incremental demands to trap La Motte, demonstrating how power corrupts through gradual escalation rather than sudden force
Development
Built from earlier hints of the Marquis's influence to reveal the full scope of his manipulative control
In Your Life:
You might see this in toxic relationships where partners gradually increase unreasonable demands, or workplaces where supervisors slowly expand inappropriate expectations
Redemption
In This Chapter
Despite his compromised position, La Motte chooses to save Adeline, proving that moral courage can emerge even from deeply flawed people
Development
Introduced here as a surprising reversal of La Motte's earlier moral decline
In Your Life:
You might find hope in this when you've made mistakes, realizing that your past compromises don't determine your future choices
Consequences
In This Chapter
La Motte's arrest shows that doing the right thing doesn't guarantee safety—moral courage often comes with real costs
Development
Continues the book's pattern that virtuous actions don't always lead to immediate rewards
In Your Life:
You might face this when considering whether to report wrongdoing or stand up to authority, knowing that integrity sometimes requires sacrifice
Freedom
In This Chapter
Adeline's escape toward the Alps represents both literal and symbolic movement toward liberation from corrupting influences
Development
Builds on earlier themes of confinement and constraint to show actual movement toward independence
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when leaving toxic situations, understanding that freedom often requires leaving familiar but harmful circumstances behind
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific demand does the Marquis make of La Motte, and how does La Motte ultimately respond?
analysis • surface - 2
How did La Motte end up in a position where he was being asked to commit murder? What were the steps that led him there?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of 'small compromises leading to big problems' in real life - either in your own experience or in news stories?
application • medium - 4
If you were in La Motte's position earlier in the story, at what point would you have tried to break free from the Marquis's influence? What would have been your strategy?
application • deep - 5
What does La Motte's last-minute decision to help Adeline escape tell us about the possibility of moral redemption, even after serious mistakes?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Non-Negotiables
Think about your own life and the pressures you face at work, in relationships, or in your community. Create a personal 'early warning system' by identifying three specific situations where you might be tempted to make small compromises that could lead to bigger problems. For each situation, write down what your absolute boundary would be - the line you refuse to cross, no matter what.
Consider:
- •Consider areas where you feel financial pressure, social pressure, or time pressure
- •Think about what small compromises in each area might lead to if they escalated
- •Remember that boundaries are easier to defend when you set them in advance, not in the heat of the moment
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you made a small compromise that led to a bigger problem, or when you successfully held a boundary under pressure. What did you learn from that experience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 16: Finding Sanctuary in Kindness
As the story unfolds, you'll explore genuine kindness can appear when we're most vulnerable, while uncovering the power of simple human compassion to transform lives. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.