Summary
Franklin Blake returns unexpectedly to the family estate, where faithful servant Betteredge greets him with his usual consultation of Robinson Crusoe—which he claims predicted Franklin's arrival. The house stands empty now, belonging to Rachel, and Franklin refuses to enter it given their estrangement. Betteredge offers characteristically blunt relationship advice, sharing how he once handled his wife's emotional manipulation by simply cooking his own dinner and refusing to engage her theatrics—suggesting Franklin take a similarly firm stance with Rachel. Despite Betteredge's practical wisdom about relationships, Franklin remains determined to solve the Moonstone mystery as his only path back to Rachel's good graces. When Betteredge warns him away from the cursed diamond and mentions that even the great Sergeant Cuff has retired to grow roses, Franklin persists. This persistence pays off when Betteredge finally reveals a crucial secret: Rosanna Spearman, the troubled maid who died, left behind a sealed letter addressed specifically to Franklin. The letter waits with Limping Lucy at Cobb's Hole, potentially holding the key to understanding both Rosanna's strange behavior and the diamond's disappearance. The chapter demonstrates how determination and genuine care for relationships can unlock information that others keep hidden, while also showing the value of practical wisdom in navigating emotional conflicts.
Coming Up in Chapter 37
Franklin settles in at Hotherstone's Farm for the night, but his recollections of what happens there remain mysteriously vague. Meanwhile, Rosanna's letter waits at Cobb's Hole, promising revelations that could change everything about the Moonstone case.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
B“etteredge!” I said, pointing to the well-remembered book on his knee, “has _Robinson Crusoe_ informed you, this evening, that you might expect to see Franklin Blake?” “By the lord Harry, Mr. Franklin!” cried the old man, “that’s exactly what _Robinson Crusoe_ has done!” He struggled to his feet with my assistance, and stood for a moment, looking backwards and forwards between _Robinson Crusoe_ and me, apparently at a loss to discover which of us had surprised him most. The verdict ended in favour of the book. Holding it open before him in both hands, he surveyed the wonderful volume with a stare of unutterable anticipation—as if he expected to see Robinson Crusoe himself walk out of the pages, and favour us with a personal interview. “Here’s the bit, Mr. Franklin!” he said, as soon as he had recovered the use of his speech. “As I live by bread, sir, here’s the bit I was reading, the moment before you came in! Page one hundred and fifty-six as follows:—‘I stood like one Thunderstruck, or as if I had seen an Apparition.’ If that isn’t as much as to say: ‘Expect the sudden appearance of Mr. Franklin Blake’—there’s no meaning in the English language!” said Betteredge, closing the book with a bang, and getting one of his hands free at last to take the hand which I offered him. I had expected him, naturally enough under the circumstances, to overwhelm me with questions. But no—the hospitable impulse was the uppermost impulse in the old servant’s mind, when a member of the family appeared (no matter how!) as a visitor at the house. “Walk in, Mr. Franklin,” he said, opening the door behind him, with his quaint old-fashioned bow. “I’ll ask what brings you here afterwards—I must make you comfortable first. There have been sad changes, since you went away. The house is shut up, and the servants are gone. Never mind that! I’ll cook your dinner; and the gardener’s wife will make your bed—and if there’s a bottle of our famous Latour claret left in the cellar, down your throat, Mr. Franklin, that bottle shall go. I bid you welcome, sir! I bid you heartily welcome!” said the poor old fellow, fighting manfully against the gloom of the deserted house, and receiving me with the sociable and courteous attention of the bygone time. It vexed me to disappoint him. But the house was Rachel’s house, now. Could I eat in it, or sleep in it, after what had happened in London? The commonest sense of self-respect forbade me—properly forbade me—to cross the threshold. I took Betteredge by the arm, and led him out into the garden. There was no help for it. I was obliged to tell him the truth. Between his attachment to Rachel, and his attachment to me, he was sorely puzzled and distressed at the turn things had taken. His opinion, when he expressed it, was given in his usual downright manner, and was agreeably redolent of the most...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Earned Trust - When Persistence Unlocks Hidden Information
People release crucial information only to those who demonstrate genuine commitment and proven reliability over time.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when people are withholding crucial information and the specific behaviors that convince them to share it.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone seems to know more than they're saying, then focus on demonstrating genuine investment in their concerns rather than pressing for immediate answers.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Divination by book
The practice of opening a random book to find guidance or predict the future, like Betteredge does with Robinson Crusoe. In Victorian times, people often turned to religious texts or beloved books for answers to life's questions.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this when people scroll social media looking for 'signs' or open fortune cookies expecting meaningful guidance.
Servant's loyalty
The deep personal attachment servants developed to wealthy families they served for decades. Betteredge has worked for the Verinder family his whole life and genuinely cares about Franklin's wellbeing.
Modern Usage:
Like a longtime employee who stays loyal to a company through good and bad times, or a family friend who gives tough love advice.
Emotional manipulation
Using tears, sulking, or dramatic behavior to control others' actions. Betteredge describes how his wife used crying fits to get her way until he stopped responding to them.
Modern Usage:
We see this in relationships where someone uses guilt trips, silent treatment, or tears to avoid responsibility or get what they want.
Class boundaries
The social rules that kept servants and employers in separate worlds, even when they cared about each other. Franklin and Betteredge are close but their relationship has limits.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how workplace hierarchies create boundaries between managers and employees, even when they're friendly.
Posthumous revelation
Information that comes to light only after someone's death, like Rosanna's letter. Dead people can't defend themselves or explain, making these revelations both powerful and potentially unreliable.
Modern Usage:
Like finding someone's diary after they die, or discovering secrets through old text messages or emails.
Persistence vs. obstinacy
The fine line between admirable determination and stubborn refusal to accept reality. Franklin's quest could be either heroic persistence or foolish obsession.
Modern Usage:
The difference between someone who won't give up on their dreams and someone who can't accept when a relationship is over.
Characters in This Chapter
Franklin Blake
Determined protagonist
Returns unexpectedly to solve the mystery and win back Rachel. His refusal to enter the house shows respect for boundaries, but his obsession with the diamond reveals his desperation to fix things.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex who shows up wanting to 'explain everything' and make things right
Betteredge
Wise mentor figure
Provides both comic relief with his Robinson Crusoe obsession and genuine wisdom about relationships. His blunt advice about handling emotional manipulation shows practical life experience.
Modern Equivalent:
The older coworker who's seen it all and gives no-nonsense relationship advice
Rachel Verinder
Absent but powerful presence
Though not physically present, she controls the entire situation. Her ownership of the house and her estrangement from Franklin drive all his actions in this chapter.
Modern Equivalent:
The person everyone's talking about but who won't answer their phone
Rosanna Spearman
Posthumous mystery keeper
Dead but still influencing events through her hidden letter. Her secret knowledge may hold the key to everything, making her death even more tragic.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who died with secrets that could change everything
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I stood like one Thunderstruck, or as if I had seen an Apparition"
Context: Betteredge claims this passage predicted Franklin's surprise arrival
Shows how people find meaning in coincidences when they need guidance. Betteredge's faith in his book provides comfort and structure in an uncertain world.
In Today's Words:
I was totally shocked, like I'd seen a ghost
"I just got up, and went into the kitchen, and got myself my own tea"
Context: Describing how he handled his wife's emotional manipulation
Practical advice about not rewarding bad behavior. Sometimes the best response to drama is to simply take care of yourself and refuse to engage.
In Today's Words:
I stopped playing her games and just took care of myself
"The Diamond has been the ruin of everybody who has come near it"
Context: Warning Franklin away from pursuing the mystery
Recognizes that some problems are bigger than they appear and that obsessing over them can destroy relationships and peace of mind.
In Today's Words:
That thing has been nothing but trouble for everyone involved
Thematic Threads
Trust
In This Chapter
Betteredge finally reveals Rosanna's letter after seeing Franklin's persistent, genuine commitment to understanding the truth
Development
Evolved from earlier mistrust and secrecy to selective disclosure based on proven character
In Your Life:
You might see this when trying to understand workplace dynamics or family history that people only share with those they truly trust
Class
In This Chapter
Betteredge's practical wisdom about relationships contrasts with Franklin's more romantic approach, showing different class perspectives on problem-solving
Development
Continues the theme of servants often having more practical wisdom than their employers
In Your Life:
You might notice how people from different backgrounds approach the same problem with completely different strategies
Persistence
In This Chapter
Franklin's refusal to give up on solving the mystery despite obstacles and discouragement finally pays off with new information
Development
Shows persistence as a virtue when motivated by genuine care rather than stubborn pride
In Your Life:
You might face situations where giving up seems easier, but continued effort based on real concern eventually opens doors
Hidden Information
In This Chapter
Rosanna's letter represents crucial knowledge that was always available but required the right relationship to access
Development
Builds on earlier themes of secrets and concealment, showing how information emerges through trust
In Your Life:
You might find that the answers you need are often held by people who are waiting to see if you're worthy of receiving them
Practical Wisdom
In This Chapter
Betteredge's advice about handling relationship conflicts through firm but non-dramatic action shows life experience
Development
Continues his role as the voice of practical common sense throughout the story
In Your Life:
You might benefit from seeking advice from people who've actually navigated similar challenges rather than those who just theorize about them
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why did Betteredge wait so long to tell Franklin about Rosanna's letter, and what finally made him reveal it?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Betteredge's advice about handling his wife's emotional manipulation reveal about his approach to relationships?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about your workplace or community - when have you seen people withhold important information until someone proved they were genuinely committed?
application • medium - 4
If you needed crucial information from someone who didn't trust you yet, how would you demonstrate genuine investment rather than just demanding answers?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter suggest about the difference between information you can demand and information you must earn?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Information Networks
Think of a situation where you need information or insight from someone - at work, in your family, or community. Draw a simple map showing who holds the information you need and what you think motivates them to share or withhold it. Then identify one concrete action you could take to demonstrate genuine investment in their concerns.
Consider:
- •Consider what the information holder values most - respect, loyalty, competence, or something else
- •Think about what evidence you could provide that your motives align with theirs
- •Remember that rushing the process often backfires - trust builds through consistent actions over time
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone finally shared important information with you after initially holding back. What changed their mind, and what does this teach you about building trust?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 37: The Shocking Discovery in the Sand
The coming pages reveal to follow through on difficult investigations even when the truth might hurt, and teach us paying attention to physical evidence can reveal uncomfortable realities. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.