Summary
The feud between Tom and Philip deepens after their fight about Philip's father. Tom sees their conflict as just another quarrel to forget, but Philip feels the wound more deeply—Tom hit his most sensitive spot without even realizing it. When Maggie arrives for her visit, she immediately notices Philip and feels drawn to him, partly because she has a tender heart for anyone who seems different or vulnerable. She tries to defend Philip to Tom, arguing that children shouldn't be blamed for their parents' actions, but Tom brushes off her concerns. Later, while the boys study, Tom decides to show Maggie his secret—he's been playing dress-up as a warrior, complete with costume and sword. What starts as innocent fun turns terrifying when Tom, dressed as the Duke of Wellington, begins sword-fighting demonstrations. Despite Maggie's pleas to stop, Tom continues his performance until disaster strikes: the sword falls and cuts his foot, causing him to faint. Maggie's terror that her beloved brother might be dead reveals the depth of their bond, even as their different temperaments create friction. The chapter shows how childhood conflicts can have lasting effects, how empathy works differently in different people, and how the games we play often mask deeper emotional needs—Tom's need to feel powerful and important, Maggie's need to feel loved and included, Philip's need to be accepted despite his differences.
Coming Up in Chapter 19
With Tom injured and emotions running high, the stage is set for deeper connections to form. The next chapter promises revelations about love and relationships that will reshape the dynamics between all three young people.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Maggie’s Second Visit This last breach between the two lads was not readily mended, and for some time they spoke to each other no more than was necessary. Their natural antipathy of temperament made resentment an easy passage to hatred, and in Philip the transition seemed to have begun; there was no malignity in his disposition, but there was a susceptibility that made him peculiarly liable to a strong sense of repulsion. The ox—we may venture to assert it on the authority of a great classic—is not given to use his teeth as an instrument of attack, and Tom was an excellent bovine lad, who ran at questionable objects in a truly ingenious bovine manner; but he had blundered on Philip’s tenderest point, and had caused him as much acute pain as if he had studied the means with the nicest precision and the most envenomed spite. Tom saw no reason why they should not make up this quarrel as they had done many others, by behaving as if nothing had happened; for though he had never before said to Philip that his father was a rogue, this idea had so habitually made part of his feeling as to the relation between himself and his dubious schoolfellow, whom he could neither like nor dislike, that the mere utterance did not make such an epoch to him as it did to Philip. And he had a right to say so when Philip hectored over _him_, and called him names. But perceiving that his first advances toward amity were not met, he relapsed into his least favourable disposition toward Philip, and resolved never to appeal to him either about drawing or exercise again. They were only so far civil to each other as was necessary to prevent their state of feud from being observed by Mr Stelling, who would have “put down” such nonsense with great vigor. When Maggie came, however, she could not help looking with growing interest at the new schoolfellow, although he was the son of that wicked Lawyer Wakem, who made her father so angry. She had arrived in the middle of school-hours, and had sat by while Philip went through his lessons with Mr Stelling. Tom, some weeks ago, had sent her word that Philip knew no end of stories,—not stupid stories like hers; and she was convinced now from her own observation that he must be very clever; she hoped he would think _her_ rather clever too, when she came to talk to him. Maggie, moreover, had rather a tenderness for deformed things; she preferred the wry-necked lambs, because it seemed to her that the lambs which were quite strong and well made wouldn’t mind so much about being petted; and she was especially fond of petting objects that would think it very delightful to be petted by her. She loved Tom very dearly, but she often wished that he _cared_ more about her loving him. “I think Philip Wakem seems a nice boy, Tom,” she...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Misplaced Protection
We create emotional distance from others to protect ourselves or our loyalties, often missing opportunities for genuine connection and growth.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between necessary boundaries and defensive walls that hurt everyone involved.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's coldness or aggression might actually be fear—ask yourself what they're trying to protect before responding.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Natural antipathy
An instinctive dislike between people that seems built into their personalities. Some people just clash without being able to explain why - their temperaments naturally repel each other.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplaces where two people who aren't bad individually just can't get along, or in families where siblings have completely different personalities that create friction.
Susceptibility
Being easily hurt or affected by things, especially emotional wounds. Someone with high susceptibility feels slights and injuries more deeply than others might.
Modern Usage:
This is like being a highly sensitive person who takes criticism harder than others, or someone who remembers hurtful comments for years while others forget them quickly.
Bovine manner
Acting like a bull or ox - charging forward without thinking, being stubborn and direct rather than subtle. Eliot uses this to describe how Tom approaches conflicts.
Modern Usage:
We might call someone a 'bull in a china shop' - they mean well but handle delicate situations with too much force and not enough finesse.
Tenderest point
Someone's most vulnerable spot emotionally - the thing that hurts them most when attacked. Everyone has topics or insecurities that cut deepest.
Modern Usage:
Like bringing up someone's divorce during an argument, or commenting on an insecurity they've shared with you - hitting where you know it will hurt most.
Dubious schoolfellow
A classmate or peer whose reputation or family background makes others uncertain about associating with them. Tom sees Philip this way because of his father's business dealings.
Modern Usage:
This happens when someone's family has a bad reputation in town, or when a coworker's past makes others hesitant to be too friendly with them.
Hectored
Being bullied or dominated through aggressive talk and intimidation. When someone lectures you harshly or tries to control you through verbal pressure.
Modern Usage:
Like a boss who yells at employees instead of giving constructive feedback, or someone who tries to win arguments through volume and aggression rather than reason.
Characters in This Chapter
Tom Tulliver
Protagonist's brother
Shows his inability to understand how deeply his words hurt Philip. He sees their fight as just another quarrel to forget, not realizing he struck Philip's deepest wound. His sword-playing reveals his need to feel powerful and important.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who says hurtful things without thinking, then can't understand why people stay mad
Philip Wakem
Sensitive outsider
Demonstrates how some people feel wounds more deeply than others. Tom's casual cruelty about his father cuts him to the core, showing his vulnerability and isolation from his peers.
Modern Equivalent:
The quiet kid who gets picked on and remembers every cruel comment while the bullies forget immediately
Maggie Tulliver
Protagonist
Shows her natural empathy by immediately noticing and defending Philip. Her terror when Tom gets hurt reveals how much she loves her brother despite their differences. She tries to be the peacemaker.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who always tries to smooth things over and feels responsible for everyone's feelings
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The ox is not given to use his teeth as an instrument of attack, and Tom was an excellent bovine lad, who ran at questionable objects in a truly ingenious bovine manner"
Context: Describing how Tom handles conflicts with Philip
Eliot compares Tom to a bull to show he's not malicious, just blunt and direct. He charges at problems without subtlety, hurting people without meaning to through sheer force rather than calculated cruelty.
In Today's Words:
Tom wasn't mean-spirited, just the type who bulldozes through situations without thinking about the damage he causes
"He had blundered on Philip's tenderest point, and had caused him as much acute pain as if he had studied the means with the nicest precision"
Context: Explaining how Tom's thoughtless comment about Philip's father wounded Philip deeply
This shows how accidental cruelty can be just as devastating as intentional cruelty. Tom hit Philip's biggest insecurity without even trying, which almost makes it worse because it shows how little Tom thinks about Philip's feelings.
In Today's Words:
He accidentally hit Philip's biggest sore spot and hurt him as badly as if he'd planned it that way
"Tom saw no reason why they should not make up this quarrel as they had done many others, by behaving as if nothing had happened"
Context: Describing Tom's attitude toward their fight
This reveals Tom's emotional limitations - he thinks you can just ignore serious hurts and move on. He doesn't understand that some wounds need acknowledgment and healing, not just time.
In Today's Words:
Tom figured they'd just pretend nothing happened and everything would go back to normal, like always
Thematic Threads
Loyalty
In This Chapter
Tom's loyalty to his family prevents him from seeing Philip as an individual, while Maggie's broader loyalty to humanity creates conflict with family expectations
Development
Building from earlier chapters where family loyalty was protective, now showing how it can become limiting
In Your Life:
You might find yourself dismissing coworkers' ideas because they're from a different department or 'opposing' team.
Power
In This Chapter
Tom uses his warrior costume and sword-play to practice feeling powerful and in control, but the sword ultimately wounds him
Development
Expanding from Tom's need to be right to his need to feel physically and socially dominant
In Your Life:
You might recognize times when you've used your expertise or position to shut down conversations that make you uncomfortable.
Empathy
In This Chapter
Maggie instinctively understands Philip's vulnerability while Tom cannot allow himself to see it
Development
Deepening the contrast between Maggie's expansive emotional intelligence and Tom's protective narrowness
In Your Life:
You might notice how your capacity for empathy changes based on whether someone is 'your people' or not.
Identity
In This Chapter
Tom needs to be the heroic protector, Philip struggles with being seen beyond his disability, Maggie wants to be the peacemaker
Development
Each character's identity becomes more defined through conflict and social pressure
In Your Life:
You might find yourself playing familiar roles even when they no longer serve you or the situation.
Consequences
In This Chapter
Tom's need to demonstrate power through sword-play literally backfires, injuring him in front of those he wanted to impress
Development
Introduced here as a theme about how our protective mechanisms can become self-destructive
In Your Life:
You might recognize how your attempts to appear strong or in control sometimes create the very problems you're trying to avoid.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Tom dismiss Philip's hurt feelings after their fight, while Philip feels wounded much more deeply?
analysis • surface - 2
What's really happening when Tom shuts down Maggie's attempt to defend Philip? What is Tom protecting?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'protecting ourselves by not seeing others fully' in your workplace, family, or community?
application • medium - 4
How could Tom have acknowledged Philip's humanity while still maintaining his loyalty to his family?
application • deep - 5
What does Tom's warrior costume reveal about how people use displays of power when they feel emotionally threatened?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Protection Patterns
Think of someone you've dismissed or kept at distance (coworker, neighbor, family member of someone who hurt you). Write down what you're protecting by not seeing them fully. Then identify one human detail about them you could acknowledge without abandoning your boundaries.
Consider:
- •Protection can be necessary and healthy - the goal isn't to be vulnerable to everyone
- •Notice the difference between conscious boundaries and unconscious dismissal
- •Small acknowledgments of humanity don't require friendship or trust
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone dismissed you to protect themselves or their group. How did it feel? What would you have wanted them to see about you as an individual?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 19: When Pain Breaks Down Walls
Moving forward, we'll examine shared vulnerability can temporarily bridge even deep differences, and understand some friendships fade when the crisis that created them passes. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.