Summary
Lily encounters George Dorset during a solitary walk, and he desperately begs for her forgiveness and help. He hints that she holds the key to his freedom from Bertha—clearly suggesting she could provide damaging testimony about his wife's affairs. The temptation is enormous: Lily could gain both revenge against Bertha and rehabilitation in society. But she recognizes the dangerous path this represents and firmly refuses, telling him 'I know nothing.' Meanwhile, Bertha Dorset has begun cultivating the socially ambitious Mrs. Gormer with suspicious neighborly visits, clearly positioning herself to poison Lily's current refuge. Feeling increasingly trapped, Lily moves to a modest hotel in town where George visits again, repeating his desperate pleas. Mrs. Fisher arranges a dinner where Lily encounters Rosedale, who shows unexpected kindness to Fisher's child. Fisher bluntly confirms that Bertha is indeed working to turn Mattie Gormer against Lily, and delivers an ultimatum: Lily must either use her knowledge to destroy Bertha by helping George Dorset, or save herself by marrying someone else—specifically Rosedale. The chapter reveals how social warfare operates through seemingly innocent gestures, and how isolation makes people vulnerable to both moral compromise and unwanted alliances.
Coming Up in Chapter 22
With her options narrowing and Bertha's campaign against her intensifying, Lily must confront the reality of her situation. Will she finally make the pragmatic choice that everyone keeps pushing her toward?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Book II, Chapter 6 As became persons of their rising consequence, the Gormers were engaged in building a country-house on Long Island; and it was a part of Miss Bart’s duty to attend her hostess on frequent visits of inspection to the new estate. There, while Mrs. Gormer plunged into problems of lighting and sanitation, Lily had leisure to wander, in the bright autumn air, along the tree-fringed bay to which the land declined. Little as she was addicted to solitude, there had come to be moments when it seemed a welcome escape from the empty noises of her life. She was weary of being swept passively along a current of pleasure and business in which she had no share; weary of seeing other people pursue amusement and squander money, while she felt herself of no more account among them than an expensive toy in the hands of a spoiled child. It was in this frame of mind that, striking back from the shore one morning into the windings of an unfamiliar lane, she came suddenly upon the figure of George Dorset. The Dorset place was in the immediate neighbourhood of the Gormers’ newly-acquired estate, and in her motor-flights thither with Mrs. Gormer, Lily had caught one or two passing glimpses of the couple; but they moved in so different an orbit that she had not considered the possibility of a direct encounter. Dorset, swinging along with bent head, in moody abstraction, did not see Miss Bart till he was close upon her; but the sight, instead of bringing him to a halt, as she had half-expected, sent him toward her with an eagerness which found expression in his opening words. “Miss Bart!—You’ll shake hands, won’t you? I’ve been hoping to meet you—I should have written to you if I’d dared.” His face, with its tossed red hair and straggling moustache, had a driven uneasy look, as though life had become an unceasing race between himself and the thoughts at his heels. The look drew a word of compassionate greeting from Lily, and he pressed on, as if encouraged by her tone: “I wanted to apologize—to ask you to forgive me for the miserable part I played——” She checked him with a quick gesture. “Don’t let us speak of it: I was very sorry for you,” she said, with a tinge of disdain which, as she instantly perceived, was not lost on him. He flushed to his haggard eyes, flushed so cruelly that she repented the thrust. “You might well be; you don’t know—you must let me explain. I was deceived: abominably deceived——” “I am still more sorry for you, then,” she interposed, without irony; “but you must see that I am not exactly the person with whom the subject can be discussed.” He met this with a look of genuine wonder. “Why not? Isn’t it to you, of all people, that I owe an explanation——” “No explanation is necessary: the situation was perfectly clear to me.” “Ah——” he murmured,...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Moral Blackmail - When Desperation Creates Corruption
When desperate people try to solve their problems by making others complicit in wrongdoing, framing refusal as cruelty or abandonment.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone frames their emergency as your moral obligation to compromise your principles.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's request requires you to violate your values, then practice saying 'I can't help you with that' without explaining why—explanations become negotiations.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Social orbit
The circle of people you move in based on your social class and status. Different orbits rarely intersect - the wealthy socialize with the wealthy, working class with working class. Moving between orbits requires careful navigation and often a sponsor.
Modern Usage:
We still talk about different social circles - work friends, college friends, neighborhood friends - and how awkward it can be when worlds collide.
Damaging testimony
Information that could destroy someone's reputation or marriage if revealed publicly. In Lily's world, knowing about affairs or scandals gave you power over people, but using that power made you dangerous to know.
Modern Usage:
Today we call this 'having dirt on someone' - knowing their secrets gives you leverage, but being known as someone who spills secrets makes people avoid you.
Social warfare
The way wealthy people destroy each other using gossip, exclusion, and manipulation instead of direct confrontation. Battles are fought through dinner invitations, charity committees, and strategic friendships.
Modern Usage:
Think office politics or neighborhood drama - people smile to your face while working behind the scenes to undermine you.
Cultivation
Deliberately befriending someone for strategic purposes, usually to gain information or influence. The cultivator appears generous and friendly while actually working toward their own agenda.
Modern Usage:
When someone suddenly becomes extra friendly because they want something from you or your boss - fake friendship with a purpose.
Moral compromise
Choosing to do something you know is wrong because it benefits you. The temptation to sacrifice your principles when you're desperate or when everyone else seems to be getting ahead by bending the rules.
Modern Usage:
Like lying on a resume when you need a job, or not reporting a coworker's mistake when it makes you look better by comparison.
Ultimatum
A final demand with serious consequences if refused. Usually delivered by someone who has power over your situation and is forcing you to choose between bad options.
Modern Usage:
When your boss says 'fix this or you're fired' or when someone says 'it's him or me' - being forced to make a choice you don't want to make.
Characters in This Chapter
Lily Bart
Trapped protagonist
Faces the ultimate moral test when George offers her a way out through revenge. Her refusal to destroy Bertha shows her integrity, but leaves her more vulnerable than ever. She's caught between maintaining her principles and surviving socially.
Modern Equivalent:
The whistleblower who could save their career by throwing someone under the bus but refuses to do it
George Dorset
Desperate supplicant
Appears twice begging Lily to help him escape his marriage by providing testimony against Bertha. His desperation reveals how trapped he feels, but also how willing he is to drag others into his mess to save himself.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend going through a messy divorce who keeps asking you to lie in court for them
Bertha Dorset
Strategic antagonist
Though not physically present, her influence dominates the chapter as she works to poison Mrs. Gormer against Lily through seemingly innocent neighborly visits. Shows how social warfare operates through indirect manipulation.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who befriends your boss while subtly undermining you in every conversation
Mrs. Fisher
Blunt truth-teller
Delivers the harsh reality of Lily's situation and forces her to face her limited options. Acts as both friend and pragmatist, showing genuine care while refusing to sugarcoat the truth.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who tells you exactly what you don't want to hear because they care about you
Rosedale
Unexpected ally
Shows surprising kindness and humanity when interacting with Fisher's child, revealing depths beyond his usual social climbing. Represents a potential escape route that Lily hasn't fully considered.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy you always dismissed who turns out to be genuinely decent when you see him with kids or animals
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I know nothing"
Context: Her firm response to George Dorset's pleas for her to provide damaging testimony against Bertha
This simple phrase represents Lily's moral line in the sand. She could gain revenge and social rehabilitation by destroying Bertha, but refuses to compromise her integrity even when desperate. It shows her fundamental decency but also seals her fate.
In Today's Words:
I'm not getting involved in your drama, even if it would help me
"She was weary of being swept passively along a current of pleasure and business in which she had no share"
Context: Describing Lily's state of mind during her solitary walks at the Gormer estate
Captures the exhaustion of being a social accessory rather than an active participant in your own life. Lily feels like expensive decoration in other people's lives rather than living her own.
In Today's Words:
She was tired of watching everyone else live their lives while she just went along for the ride
"You must either use your knowledge or marry someone who can use it for you"
Context: Delivering her ultimatum to Lily about her limited options for survival
Fisher strips away all illusions and presents Lily's stark choice: become a player in the social warfare game or find protection through marriage. Shows how women's options were limited to manipulation or dependence.
In Today's Words:
Either play dirty or find someone who'll protect you - those are your only choices
Thematic Threads
Moral Compromise
In This Chapter
Lily faces intense pressure to use her knowledge against Bertha, with both George and Mrs. Fisher presenting it as her only viable option
Development
Previously Lily made small compromises for social survival; now she faces a major moral crossroads that would fundamentally change who she is
In Your Life:
You might face this when someone asks you to lie, cheat, or betray others to solve their problems or advance your position.
False Choices
In This Chapter
Mrs. Fisher presents only two options: destroy Bertha or marry Rosedale, ignoring other possibilities like maintaining integrity despite hardship
Development
Throughout the novel, Lily has been presented with increasingly narrow choices, each eliminating paths that preserve her values
In Your Life:
You encounter this when people insist you must choose between two unacceptable options, ignoring alternatives that preserve your principles.
Social Warfare
In This Chapter
Bertha's 'neighborly visits' to Mrs. Gormer are strategic moves to isolate Lily, disguised as innocent social calls
Development
Bertha's campaign against Lily has evolved from direct confrontation to subtle manipulation of Lily's support network
In Your Life:
You see this in office politics when someone undermines you through seemingly friendly conversations with your allies.
Desperation
In This Chapter
George Dorset's repeated pleas reveal how desperation makes people manipulative, trying to drag others into their moral compromises
Development
Desperation has become a driving force for multiple characters, leading them to increasingly unethical behavior
In Your Life:
You might experience this when financial pressure, relationship problems, or career stress tempt you to compromise your values.
Isolation
In This Chapter
Lily's move to a modest hotel symbolizes her increasing separation from her former world and growing vulnerability
Development
Lily's isolation has progressed from social exclusion to physical separation, making her more susceptible to manipulation
In Your Life:
You feel this when losing friends or support systems makes you more likely to accept help from questionable sources.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What exactly does George Dorset want from Lily, and how does he try to convince her to help him?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does George frame Lily's refusal to help as cruelty, and what does this reveal about his character?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of someone making their problem your moral obligation - at work, in family, or friendships?
application • medium - 4
How would you respond to someone who says 'you're the only one who can help me' when they're asking you to do something that compromises your values?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about how desperate people try to make others complicit in their bad choices?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Recognize the Moral Blackmail Script
Think of a time when someone pressured you to help them in a way that made you uncomfortable. Write down the exact words they used to convince you. Now rewrite their request three different ways: as an honest ask for help, as manipulation, and as a boundary-respecting request. Notice how the language changes in each version.
Consider:
- •Pay attention to phrases that make you responsible for their feelings or outcomes
- •Notice how manipulative requests often include urgency or claims that you're the 'only one' who can help
- •Observe how respectful requests give you genuine choice without guilt or pressure
Journaling Prompt
Write about a situation where you wish you had said no to someone's request for help. What would you say differently now, and what boundaries would you set?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 22: The Blackmail Proposition
The coming pages reveal desperation can make morally questionable options seem reasonable, and teach us people sometimes reveal their true character when they think they have leverage. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.