Summary
Selden works behind the scenes to prevent the Dorset marriage from exploding into public scandal, knowing that Lily would be caught in the crossfire. He counsels George Dorset to stay calm and act normal while he figures out how to manage the situation. Meanwhile, Lily tries desperately to help repair the marriage, but Bertha Dorset mysteriously shuts her out, leaving Lily confused and helpless. The tension builds throughout a formal dinner party where everyone pretends everything is fine. Then, in a shocking moment of calculated cruelty, Bertha publicly abandons Lily at the restaurant, announcing that she won't be returning to the yacht. This isn't just about the affair—it's Bertha's strategic move to sacrifice Lily as a scapegoat, protecting herself by destroying someone else. Lily handles the public humiliation with remarkable dignity, but she's now completely alone and vulnerable. Selden, horrified by what he's witnessed, tries to help by arranging for her to stay with her cousins, the Stepneys, though even this refuge comes with conditions and shame. The chapter reveals how quickly social protection can evaporate when powerful people decide you're expendable. Lily's grace under pressure shows her true character, but also highlights how little that matters when you're fighting a rigged game.
Coming Up in Chapter 19
Cast out from her social circle and dependent on reluctant relatives, Lily must navigate her new reality as a social pariah. The consequences of Bertha's betrayal will reshape everything about how Lily sees herself and her future.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Book II, Chapter 3 Miss Bart’s telegram caught Lawrence Selden at the door of his hotel; and having read it, he turned back to wait for Dorset. The message necessarily left large gaps for conjecture; but all that he had recently heard and seen made these but too easy to fill in. On the whole he was surprised; for though he had perceived that the situation contained all the elements of an explosion, he had often enough, in the range of his personal experience, seen just such combinations subside into harmlessness. Still, Dorset’s spasmodic temper, and his wife’s reckless disregard of appearances, gave the situation a peculiar insecurity; and it was less from the sense of any special relation to the case than from a purely professional zeal, that Selden resolved to guide the pair to safety. Whether, in the present instance, safety for either lay in repairing so damaged a tie, it was no business of his to consider: he had only, on general principles, to think of averting a scandal, and his desire to avert it was increased by his fear of its involving Miss Bart. There was nothing specific in this apprehension; he merely wished to spare her the embarrassment of being ever so remotely connected with the public washing of the Dorset linen. How exhaustive and unpleasant such a process would be, he saw even more vividly after his two hours’ talk with poor Dorset. If anything came out at all, it would be such a vast unpacking of accumulated moral rags as left him, after his visitor had gone, with the feeling that he must fling open the windows and have his room swept out. But nothing should come out; and happily for his side of the case, the dirty rags, however pieced together, could not, without considerable difficulty, be turned into a homogeneous grievance. The torn edges did not always fit—there were missing bits, there were disparities of size and colour, all of which it was naturally Selden’s business to make the most of in putting them under his client’s eye. But to a man in Dorset’s mood the completest demonstration could not carry conviction, and Selden saw that for the moment all he could do was to soothe and temporize, to offer sympathy and to counsel prudence. He let Dorset depart charged to the brim with the sense that, till their next meeting, he must maintain a strictly noncommittal attitude; that, in short, his share in the game consisted for the present in looking on. Selden knew, however, that he could not long keep such violences in equilibrium; and he promised to meet Dorset, the next morning, at an hotel in Monte Carlo. Meanwhile he counted not a little on the reaction of weakness and self-distrust that, in such natures, follows on every unwonted expenditure of moral force; and his telegraphic reply to Miss Bart consisted simply in the injunction: “Assume that everything is as usual.” On this assumption, in fact, the early...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Strategic Sacrifice
When people in power protect themselves by deliberately destroying someone weaker to serve as a scapegoat and distraction from their own wrongdoing.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone in power is positioning you to take the blame for their mistakes.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when managers or supervisors start asking you to handle tasks that could go wrong, or when they begin distancing themselves from decisions you were involved in.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Scapegoating
The practice of blaming one person for problems they didn't cause, usually to protect someone more powerful. In this chapter, Bertha sacrifices Lily to save her own reputation after her affair.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplaces when management blames one employee for systemic failures, or when politicians throw staffers under the bus.
Social exile
Being cut off from your social group as punishment. Once you're marked as 'unacceptable,' doors close and invitations stop coming. It was a powerful weapon in Lily's world.
Modern Usage:
Today it's cancel culture, being frozen out of friend groups, or losing your professional network after a scandal.
Damage control
Managing a crisis to minimize harm to your reputation. Selden tries to prevent the Dorset marriage scandal from exploding publicly, knowing it would hurt everyone involved.
Modern Usage:
Modern PR teams do this constantly - spinning stories, managing narratives, and controlling information flow after scandals.
Public washing of linen
Airing private, embarrassing matters in public. The phrase refers to literally hanging dirty laundry outside for all to see - a metaphor for exposing family secrets.
Modern Usage:
Today it's messy divorces played out on social media, or workplace drama that becomes public gossip.
Grace under pressure
Maintaining dignity and composure when facing humiliation or crisis. Lily handles her public abandonment with remarkable poise, showing her true character.
Modern Usage:
We admire people who stay classy during public breakups, job losses, or other humiliating situations instead of lashing out.
Calculated cruelty
Deliberately hurting someone as part of a strategic plan. Bertha's abandonment of Lily isn't emotional - it's coldly planned to shift blame and protect herself.
Modern Usage:
This happens in toxic relationships, workplace politics, and social media pile-ons where the attack serves a specific purpose.
Characters in This Chapter
Lawrence Selden
Would-be protector
He tries to manage the Dorset crisis professionally, wanting to shield Lily from scandal. His horror at Bertha's cruelty shows he truly cares, but he's always one step behind the real power players.
Modern Equivalent:
The well-meaning friend who tries to help but doesn't understand how ruthless the game really is
Bertha Dorset
Strategic antagonist
She executes a masterful but cruel plan, publicly abandoning Lily to save herself from scandal. Her calculated cruelty reveals someone who will destroy others to protect her own position.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who throws you under the bus to save their own job
Lily Bart
Sacrificial victim
She tries desperately to help repair the Dorset marriage but gets shut out, then faces public humiliation with remarkable dignity. Her grace under pressure shows her true character.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who gets blamed for everyone else's mess but handles it with class
George Dorset
Volatile wild card
His unpredictable temper makes the whole situation dangerous. Selden has to manage him carefully to prevent an explosion that would hurt everyone.
Modern Equivalent:
The unstable person whose drama could blow up everyone's life if not handled carefully
Key Quotes & Analysis
"he had only, on general principles, to think of averting a scandal, and his desire to avert it was increased by his fear of its involving Miss Bart"
Context: Selden decides to help manage the Dorset crisis
This reveals Selden's protective feelings toward Lily, but also his limited understanding of the situation. He thinks he can control scandal through professional management, not realizing Bertha has already decided to sacrifice Lily.
In Today's Words:
He wanted to keep the drama from exploding, especially because he was worried about Lily getting caught in the crossfire
"How exhaustive and unpleasant such a process would be, he saw even more vividly after his two hours' talk with poor Dorset"
Context: Selden realizes how messy a public scandal would be
Selden understands that once private matters become public, the damage spreads far beyond the original players. His concern shows both wisdom and naivety about who really controls the narrative.
In Today's Words:
After talking to George, he realized how ugly things would get if this all came out publicly
"Miss Bart had in fact been included in the Dorset invitation, but at the last moment a disconcerting message from her hostess had caused her to withdraw"
Context: Bertha suddenly shuts Lily out of dinner plans
This seemingly small social slight is actually Bertha beginning to isolate Lily before the final betrayal. It shows how social exclusion starts with tiny cuts before the major wound.
In Today's Words:
Lily was supposed to come to dinner, but Bertha sent a last-minute message uninviting her
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Bertha wields her social power like a weapon, strategically sacrificing Lily to protect herself from scandal
Development
Power has shifted from subtle influence to open cruelty—Bertha no longer needs to hide her manipulation
In Your Life:
You might see this when a boss throws you under the bus to save their own reputation with upper management
Loyalty
In This Chapter
Lily's loyalty to the Dorsets becomes her downfall when Bertha betrays her despite Lily's attempts to help save the marriage
Development
Loyalty continues to be a liability in this world—those who give it are destroyed by those who exploit it
In Your Life:
You might experience this when your dedication to a friend or employer is repaid with betrayal when they need someone to blame
Reputation
In This Chapter
Lily's reputation is publicly destroyed in one calculated moment, showing how quickly social standing can evaporate
Development
Reputation has become weaponized—no longer just about maintaining status, but about survival itself
In Your Life:
You might face this when someone spreads rumors about you at work or in your community to deflect from their own problems
Isolation
In This Chapter
Lily finds herself completely alone and vulnerable, with even potential helpers like Selden able to offer only limited, conditional aid
Development
Isolation has become complete—Lily now has no secure social connections or financial safety net
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you realize that the people you thought would support you in a crisis are nowhere to be found
Dignity
In This Chapter
Despite public humiliation, Lily maintains her composure and grace, revealing her true character under extreme pressure
Development
Dignity emerges as Lily's only remaining asset—the one thing that can't be taken from her
In Your Life:
You might draw on this when facing your own public embarrassment or professional setback, choosing how to respond with integrity
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What exactly does Bertha Dorset do to Lily at the restaurant, and why is this moment so devastating?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Bertha choose to sacrifice Lily instead of dealing with her own affair directly? What does she gain by creating this public drama?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen someone throw another person 'under the bus' to protect themselves? What did that situation teach you about workplace or family dynamics?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Lily's position and sensed someone was setting you up as a scapegoat, what specific steps would you take to protect yourself?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how power really works - not the official rules, but the hidden patterns of who gets protected and who gets sacrificed?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Scapegoat Strategy
Think of a recent situation where someone in power faced criticism or consequences. Write down: What was their original problem? Who did they blame or redirect attention toward? What story did they create to shift focus? How did the innocent person end up looking worse than the guilty party?
Consider:
- •Notice how the powerful person never directly denies their guilt - they just make something else seem more important
- •Look for timing - scapegoating often happens right when pressure is building on the real culprit
- •Pay attention to who has the most to lose versus who actually gets punished
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were blamed for something that wasn't entirely your fault. What was the real issue that someone wanted to avoid discussing? How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 19: The Will That Changes Everything
Moving forward, we'll examine financial expectations can blind us to relationship reality, and understand reputation matters more than truth in social circles. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.