Summary
Tess begins her work caring for Mrs. d'Urberville's prized fowls in a converted cottage that was once a family home. The irony isn't lost on her—a house where generations lived and loved is now just a chicken coop, showing how quickly circumstances can change. She meets the elderly, blind Mrs. d'Urberville, who examines each bird by touch with remarkable skill and immediately assigns Tess an unexpected task: whistling to her caged bullfinches. When Tess struggles to remember how to whistle properly, Alec d'Urberville appears and offers to teach her, maintaining physical distance but clearly enjoying her discomfort. His behavior reveals a pattern—he's helpful but intrusive, respectful of stated boundaries while pushing others. Tess finds herself caught between needing this job and feeling increasingly uncomfortable with Alec's attention. She successfully learns to whistle for the birds, finding genuine pleasure in the task when alone. However, she begins to suspect Alec is secretly watching her practice sessions, hiding behind bedroom curtains. This chapter establishes the power dynamics that will define Tess's time here: she's economically dependent on the d'Urberville family, which gives Alec leverage to insert himself into her daily life. Hardy shows how vulnerability and dependence can make someone susceptible to manipulation, even when they recognize what's happening.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
As Tess settles into her routine at the d'Urberville estate, Alec's interest in her becomes more persistent. The whistling lessons are just the beginning of his campaign to win her attention.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
The community of fowls to which Tess had been appointed as supervisor, purveyor, nurse, surgeon, and friend made its headquarters in an old thatched cottage standing in an enclosure that had once been a garden, but was now a trampled and sanded square. The house was overrun with ivy, its chimney being enlarged by the boughs of the parasite to the aspect of a ruined tower. The lower rooms were entirely given over to the birds, who walked about them with a proprietary air, as though the place had been built by themselves, and not by certain dusty copyholders who now lay east and west in the churchyard. The descendants of these bygone owners felt it almost as a slight to their family when the house which had so much of their affection, had cost so much of their forefathers’ money, and had been in their possession for several generations before the d’Urbervilles came and built here, was indifferently turned into a fowl-house by Mrs Stoke-d’Urberville as soon as the property fell into hand according to law. “’Twas good enough for Christians in grandfather’s time,” they said. The rooms wherein dozens of infants had wailed at their nursing now resounded with the tapping of nascent chicks. Distracted hens in coops occupied spots where formerly stood chairs supporting sedate agriculturists. The chimney-corner and once-blazing hearth was now filled with inverted beehives, in which the hens laid their eggs; while out of doors the plots that each succeeding householder had carefully shaped with his spade were torn by the cocks in wildest fashion. The garden in which the cottage stood was surrounded by a wall, and could only be entered through a door. When Tess had occupied herself about an hour the next morning in altering and improving the arrangements, according to her skilled ideas as the daughter of a professed poulterer, the door in the wall opened and a servant in white cap and apron entered. She had come from the manor-house. “Mrs d’Urberville wants the fowls as usual,” she said; but perceiving that Tess did not quite understand, she explained, “Mis’ess is a old lady, and blind.” “Blind!” said Tess. Almost before her misgiving at the news could find time to shape itself she took, under her companion’s direction, two of the most beautiful of the Hamburghs in her arms, and followed the maid-servant, who had likewise taken two, to the adjacent mansion, which, though ornate and imposing, showed traces everywhere on this side that some occupant of its chambers could bend to the love of dumb creatures—feathers floating within view of the front, and hen-coops standing on the grass. In a sitting-room on the ground-floor, ensconced in an armchair with her back to the light, was the owner and mistress of the estate, a white-haired woman of not more than sixty, or even less, wearing a large cap. She had the mobile face frequent in those whose sight has decayed by stages, has been laboriously striven after, and reluctantly...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Economic Leverage - When Need Creates Vulnerability
When someone controls your basic needs, they can gradually expand their access to you by making boundary violations seem like the price of survival.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone uses economic leverage to gradually push boundaries through helpful behavior.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone with power over your job, housing, or benefits offers help that requires increasing personal access or makes you uncomfortable while maintaining plausible deniability.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Copyholder
A tenant farmer who held land by copy of court roll, meaning they had legal rights to the property but didn't own it outright. These were working-class families who had lived on the same land for generations, building lives and memories there.
Modern Usage:
Like longtime renters who've made a place home, only to have new landlords change everything without considering the history.
Proprietary air
Acting like you own something when you don't. Hardy uses this to describe how the chickens strut around the old house as if they built it themselves, which mirrors how the d'Urbervilles treat property that was never really theirs.
Modern Usage:
When your boss's nephew acts like he runs the place on his first day, or when gentrifiers move into a neighborhood and immediately start changing everything.
Economic dependency
When you need someone else's money or job so badly that you can't say no to things that make you uncomfortable. Tess needs this work to help her family, which gives Alec power over her.
Modern Usage:
Staying in a job with a creepy manager because you can't afford to quit, or accepting help that comes with strings attached.
Boundary testing
When someone pushes against your limits little by little to see what they can get away with. They start small and helpful, then gradually become more invasive while maintaining plausible deniability.
Modern Usage:
A coworker who stands too close, texts after hours, or shows up uninvited but always has an excuse for why it's innocent.
Class displacement
When economic changes force people from their traditional social positions. The old farming families lost their homes to become servants to the wealthy d'Urbervilles who bought their way into status.
Modern Usage:
Factory workers becoming gig drivers, or longtime residents priced out when their neighborhood gets expensive.
Surveillance disguised as care
Watching someone under the pretense of helping or protecting them. Alec claims he's teaching Tess to whistle, but really he's creating opportunities to observe and control her.
Modern Usage:
A partner who checks your phone 'for your safety' or a boss who monitors your every move 'to help you improve.'
Characters in This Chapter
Tess Durbeyfield
Protagonist under pressure
Works as supervisor of the fowls, learning to whistle for Mrs. d'Urberville's bullfinches. She's caught between needing the job and feeling increasingly uncomfortable with Alec's attention and boundary-pushing behavior.
Modern Equivalent:
The single mom working for a family business where the owner's son won't leave her alone
Mrs. d'Urberville
Blind employer
The elderly, blind matriarch who examines her prized fowls by touch with remarkable skill. She assigns Tess the unexpected task of whistling to her caged bullfinches, showing how the wealthy find elaborate ways to use their servants.
Modern Equivalent:
The eccentric rich widow with very specific demands about how things must be done
Alec d'Urberville
Predatory manipulator
Appears when Tess struggles with whistling and offers to teach her. He maintains physical boundaries while pushing emotional ones, and Tess suspects he secretly watches her practice sessions from behind curtains.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss's son who's always 'helping' but makes you feel watched and uncomfortable
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The descendants of these bygone owners felt it almost as a slight to their family when the house which had so much of their affection, had cost so much of their forefathers' money, and had been in their possession for several generations before the d'Urbervilles came and built here, was indifferently turned into a fowl-house."
Context: Describing how the original farming families feel about their ancestral home being converted to a chicken coop
This shows how quickly family history and emotional investment can be erased by economic power. The d'Urbervilles treat casually what meant everything to the previous families, highlighting the callousness of class privilege.
In Today's Words:
Imagine your childhood home being turned into storage space by people who bought it cheap and don't care about the memories there.
"'Twas good enough for Christians in grandfather's time."
Context: Their bitter comment about the house that once sheltered generations now housing only chickens
This reveals the deep resentment of working families who've been displaced by wealth. They're pointing out the absurdity that what was worthy of human families is now just animal housing.
In Today's Words:
Real families used to live here, and now it's just for chickens - shows what they think we're worth.
"The rooms wherein dozens of infants had wailed at their nursing now resounded with the tapping of nascent chicks."
Context: Contrasting the house's past as a family home with its present as a poultry facility
Hardy uses this poetic contrast to show how human stories get replaced by economic utility. Where babies once cried, now only chicks peep - human life reduced to mere function.
In Today's Words:
Where kids used to play, now there are just animals - it's like all the family history got wiped out.
Thematic Threads
Economic Dependence
In This Chapter
Tess must accept Alec's intrusive behavior because she needs the job to support her family
Development
Building from her family's financial desperation established in earlier chapters
In Your Life:
When your boss, landlord, or anyone who controls your livelihood starts pushing personal boundaries, your financial need makes it harder to say no.
Boundary Testing
In This Chapter
Alec maintains physical distance while inserting himself into Tess's daily routine and secretly watching her
Development
Escalating from his earlier forward behavior at their first meeting
In Your Life:
Someone who respects your stated boundaries while finding ways around them is testing how much they can get away with.
Class Power
In This Chapter
Mrs. d'Urberville assigns tasks while Alec has the freedom to appear whenever he wants in Tess's workspace
Development
Continuing the theme of upper-class privilege from previous chapters
In Your Life:
People with higher social or economic status often feel entitled to access your time and space in ways they'd never tolerate themselves.
Isolation
In This Chapter
Tess works alone with the birds, making her vulnerable to Alec's unannounced visits and secret observation
Development
Building on her separation from her familiar community
In Your Life:
Predatory behavior thrives in isolated situations where there are no witnesses to hold someone accountable.
Lost Heritage
In This Chapter
The cottage where generations once lived is now just a chicken coop, symbolizing how quickly circumstances can change
Development
Reinforcing the family's fall from their supposed noble origins
In Your Life:
What seems permanent in your life—your job, your home, your security—can change faster than you think.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific job does Tess get at the d'Urberville estate, and what makes Alec's teaching method feel uncomfortable to her?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Alec's behavior feel manipulative even though he maintains physical distance and accepts her 'no'?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today—someone using economic power to slowly push boundaries while appearing helpful?
application • medium - 4
If you were advising Tess, what specific steps would you tell her to take to protect herself while keeping the job she needs?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how power imbalances can make normal interactions feel threatening?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Power Dynamics
Think about your current work, housing, or family situations. Identify one relationship where someone has economic or practical power over you. Write down three specific ways this person could (or does) use that power to push boundaries. Then brainstorm three concrete steps you could take to build alternative options or document problematic behavior.
Consider:
- •Power doesn't always look aggressive—it can appear as helpfulness or special attention
- •Small boundary violations often test your response to bigger ones
- •Having backup plans reduces someone's ability to exploit your dependence
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt trapped between needing something from someone and feeling uncomfortable with their behavior. What would you do differently now with what you know about power dynamics?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 10: Dancing with Danger
In the next chapter, you'll discover peer pressure can lead us into situations that compromise our values, and learn alcohol and group dynamics create dangerous blind spots. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.