An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1710 words)
anuary 10th, 1827.—While writing the above, yesterday evening, I sat
in the drawing-room. Mr. Huntingdon was present, but, as I thought,
asleep on the sofa behind me. He had risen, however, unknown to me,
and, actuated by some base spirit of curiosity, been looking over my
shoulder for I know not how long; for when I had laid aside my pen, and
was about to close the book, he suddenly placed his hand upon it, and
saying,—“With your leave, my dear, I’ll have a look at this,” forcibly
wrested it from me, and, drawing a chair to the table, composedly sat
down to examine it: turning back leaf after leaf to find an explanation
of what he had read. Unluckily for me, he was more sober that night
than he usually is at such an hour.
Of course I did not leave him to pursue this occupation in quiet: I
made several attempts to snatch the book from his hands, but he held it
too firmly for that; I upbraided him in bitterness and scorn for his
mean and dishonourable conduct, but that had no effect upon him; and,
finally, I extinguished both the candles, but he only wheeled round to
the fire, and raising a blaze sufficient for his purposes, calmly
continued the investigation. I had serious thoughts of getting a
pitcher of water and extinguishing that light too; but it was evident
his curiosity was too keenly excited to be quenched by that, and the
more I manifested my anxiety to baffle his scrutiny, the greater would
be his determination to persist in it, besides it was too late.
“It seems very interesting, love,” said he, lifting his head and
turning to where I stood, wringing my hands in silent rage and anguish;
“but it’s rather long; I’ll look at it some other time; and meanwhile
I’ll trouble you for your keys, my dear.”
“What keys?”
“The keys of your cabinet, desk, drawers, and whatever else you
possess,” said he, rising and holding out his hand.
“I’ve not got them,” I replied. The key of my desk, in fact, was at
that moment in the lock, and the others were attached to it.
“Then you must send for them,” said he; “and if that old devil, Rachel,
doesn’t immediately deliver them up, she tramps bag and baggage
tomorrow.”
“She doesn’t know where they are,” I answered, quietly placing my hand
upon them, and taking them from the desk, as I thought, unobserved.
“I know, but I shall not give them up without a reason.”
“And I know, too,” said he, suddenly seizing my closed hand and
rudely abstracting them from it. He then took up one of the candles and
relighted it by thrusting it into the fire.
“Now, then,” sneered he, “we must have a confiscation of property. But,
first, let us take a peep into the studio.”
And putting the keys into his pocket, he walked into the library. I
followed, whether with the dim idea of preventing mischief, or only to
know the worst, I can hardly tell. My painting materials were laid
together on the corner table, ready for to-morrow’s use, and only
covered with a cloth. He soon spied them out, and putting down the
candle, deliberately proceeded to cast them into the fire: palette,
paints, bladders, pencils, brushes, varnish: I saw them all consumed:
the palette-knives snapped in two, the oil and turpentine sent hissing
and roaring up the chimney. He then rang the bell.
“Benson, take those things away,” said he, pointing to the easel,
canvas, and stretcher; “and tell the housemaid she may kindle the fire
with them: your mistress won’t want them any more.”
Benson paused aghast and looked at me.
“Take them away, Benson,” said I; and his master muttered an oath.
“And this and all, sir?” said the astonished servant, referring to the
half-finished picture.
“That and all,” replied the master; and the things were cleared away.
Mr. Huntingdon then went up-stairs. I did not attempt to follow him,
but remained seated in the arm-chair, speechless, tearless, and almost
motionless, till he returned about half-an-hour after, and walking up
to me, held the candle in my face and peered into my eyes with looks
and laughter too insulting to be borne. With a sudden stroke of my hand
I dashed the candle to the floor.
“Hal-lo!” muttered he, starting back; “she’s the very devil for spite.
Did ever any mortal see such eyes?—they shine in the dark like a
cat’s. Oh, you’re a sweet one!” So saying, he gathered up the candle
and the candlestick. The former being broken as well as extinguished,
he rang for another.
“Benson, your mistress has broken the candle; bring another.”
“You expose yourself finely,” observed I, as the man departed.
“I didn’t say I’d broken it, did I?” returned he. He then threw my
keys into my lap, saying,—“There! you’ll find nothing gone but your
money, and the jewels, and a few little trifles I thought it advisable
to take into my own possession, lest your mercantile spirit should be
tempted to turn them into gold. I’ve left you a few sovereigns in your
purse, which I expect to last you through the month; at all events,
when you want more you will be so good as to give me an account of how
that’s spent. I shall put you upon a small monthly allowance, in
future, for your own private expenses; and you needn’t trouble yourself
any more about my concerns; I shall look out for a steward, my dear—I
won’t expose you to the temptation. And as for the household matters,
Mrs. Greaves must be very particular in keeping her accounts; we must
go upon an entirely new plan—”
“What great discovery have you made now, Mr. Huntingdon? Have I
attempted to defraud you?”
“Not in money matters, exactly, it seems; but it’s best to keep out of
the way of temptation.”
Here Benson entered with the candles, and there followed a brief
interval of silence; I sitting still in my chair, and he standing with
his back to the fire, silently triumphing in my despair.
“And so,” said he at length, “you thought to disgrace me, did you, by
running away and turning artist, and supporting yourself by the labour
of your hands, forsooth? And you thought to rob me of my son, too, and
bring him up to be a dirty Yankee tradesman, or a low, beggarly
painter?”
“Yes, to obviate his becoming such a gentleman as his father.”
“It’s well you couldn’t keep your own secret—ha, ha! It’s well these
women must be blabbing. If they haven’t a friend to talk to, they must
whisper their secrets to the fishes, or write them on the sand, or
something; and it’s well, too, I wasn’t over full to-night, now I think
of it, or I might have snoozed away and never dreamt of looking what my
sweet lady was about; or I might have lacked the sense or the power to
carry my point like a man, as I have done.”
Leaving him to his self-congratulations, I rose to secure my
manuscript, for I now remembered it had been left upon the drawing-room
table, and I determined, if possible, to save myself the humiliation of
seeing it in his hands again. I could not bear the idea of his amusing
himself over my secret thoughts and recollections; though, to be sure,
he would find little good of himself therein indited, except in the
former part; and oh, I would sooner burn it all than he should read
what I had written when I was such a fool as to love him!
“And by-the-by,” cried he, as I was leaving the room, “you’d better
tell that d—d old sneak of a nurse to keep out of my way for a day or
two; I’d pay her her wages and send her packing to-morrow, but I know
she’d do more mischief out of the house than in it.”
And as I departed, he went on cursing and abusing my faithful friend
and servant with epithets I will not defile this paper with repeating.
I went to her as soon as I had put away my book, and told her how our
project was defeated. She was as much distressed and horrified as I
was—and more so than I was that night, for I was partly stunned by the
blow, and partly excited and supported against it by the bitterness of
my wrath. But in the morning, when I woke without that cheering hope
that had been my secret comfort and support so long, and all this day,
when I have wandered about restless and objectless, shunning my
husband, shrinking even from my child, knowing that I am unfit to be
his teacher or companion, hoping nothing for his future life, and
fervently wishing he had never been born,—I felt the full extent of my
calamity, and I feel it now. I know that day after day such feelings
will return upon me. I am a slave—a prisoner—but that is nothing; if it
were myself alone I would not complain, but I am forbidden to rescue my
son from ruin, and what was once my only consolation is become the
crowning source of my despair.
Have I no faith in God? I try to look to Him and raise my heart to
heaven, but it will cleave to the dust. I can only say, “He hath hedged
me about, that I cannot get out: He hath made my chain heavy. He hath
filled me with bitterness—He hath made me drunken with wormwood.” I
forget to add, “But though He cause grief, yet will He have compassion
according to the multitude of His mercies. For He doth not afflict
willingly nor grieve the children of men.” I ought to think of this;
and if there be nothing but sorrow for me in this world, what is the
longest life of misery to a whole eternity of peace? And for my little
Arthur—has he no friend but me? Who was it said, “It is not the will of
your Father which is in heaven that one of these little ones should
perish?”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Controllers eliminate not just current resistance but future possibilities by methodically destroying tools, resources, and sources of hope.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between emotional reactions and calculated elimination of your future options.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone doesn't just oppose your current plan but tries to undermine your ability to make future plans—that's the pattern revealing itself.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"With your leave, my dear, I'll have a look at this"
Context: Said mockingly as he forcibly takes Helen's diary after reading over her shoulder
The false politeness makes his violation even more cruel. He's not asking permission - he's announcing his power to take what he wants while pretending to be civilized about it.
In Today's Words:
I'm going through your stuff whether you like it or not, but I'll be polite about it
"I had serious thoughts of getting a pitcher of water and extinguishing that light too"
Context: After Huntingdon moves to the firelight to continue reading her diary
Shows Helen's desperate attempts to stop the violation of her privacy. Her escalating tactics reveal both her panic and her powerlessness against his determination.
In Today's Words:
I was ready to do anything to stop him from reading my private thoughts
"The more I manifested my anxiety to get it from him, the greater would be his determination to retain it"
Context: Helen realizes that fighting him only makes him more determined to violate her privacy
Reveals the cruel psychology of abuse - resistance becomes entertainment. Helen learns that showing her pain only feeds his sadistic pleasure in controlling her.
In Today's Words:
The more upset I got, the more he enjoyed having power over me
Thematic Threads
Control
In This Chapter
Huntingdon systematically destroys Helen's means of independence—art supplies, money, autonomy
Development
Evolved from emotional abuse to calculated psychological warfare
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone doesn't just say no but makes sure you can't ask again.
Independence
In This Chapter
Helen's artistic skills and financial plans represent her path to self-sufficiency, now destroyed
Development
Her growing independence has been completely dismantled
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when your tools for self-reliance are systematically removed or undermined.
Hope
In This Chapter
Huntingdon doesn't just stop Helen's escape—he mocks her dreams to crush future attempts
Development
Hope has transformed from Helen's strength to her greatest vulnerability
In Your Life:
You might experience this when someone attacks not just what you're doing but what you're dreaming of doing.
Power
In This Chapter
Huntingdon wields complete financial and emotional control, reducing Helen to child-like dependence
Development
His power has evolved from social dominance to total domination
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone uses their authority to strip away your adult autonomy and decision-making power.
Faith
In This Chapter
Helen struggles to maintain religious faith when God seems absent from her suffering
Development
Her faith has become a source of questioning rather than comfort
In Your Life:
You might relate to this when your beliefs are tested by circumstances that seem to contradict everything you were taught to expect.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific items did Huntingdon destroy or take away from Helen, and why were each of these particularly devastating to her plans?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did Huntingdon burn Helen's painting supplies rather than simply hiding them? What does this tell us about his strategy?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'systematic disarmament' in modern situations - removing not just current threats but future possibilities?
application • medium - 4
If you were advising someone in Helen's position today, what backup plans or hidden resources would you suggest they develop?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between reactive punishment and strategic control?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Control Strategy
Create a two-column list: on the left, write each thing Huntingdon destroyed or controlled. On the right, write what future possibility each item represented for Helen. Then identify what someone in your life relies on for independence or hope, and consider how those things could be protected.
Consider:
- •Controllers often target the tools that create independence, not just current escape attempts
- •Financial resources, creative outlets, and support networks are common targets
- •The goal is to make resistance seem impossible, not just difficult
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone tried to limit not just what you were doing, but what you could imagine doing in the future. How did you recognize it, and how did you respond?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 41: A Mother's Desperate Strategy
Two months later, with Huntingdon temporarily away, Helen begins to breathe again. Though escape seems impossible, she finds new determination to fight for Arthur's future in whatever ways remain available to her.




