An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1779 words)
vening.—Breakfast passed well over: I was calm and cool throughout. I
answered composedly all inquiries respecting my health; and whatever
was unusual in my look or manner was generally attributed to the
trifling indisposition that had occasioned my early retirement last
night. But how am I to get over the ten or twelve days that must yet
elapse before they go? Yet why so long for their departure? When they
are gone, how shall I get through the months or years of my future
life in company with that man—my greatest enemy? for none could injure
me as he has done. Oh! when I think how fondly, how foolishly I have
loved him, how madly I have trusted him, how constantly I have
laboured, and studied, and prayed, and struggled for his advantage; and
how cruelly he has trampled on my love, betrayed my trust, scorned my
prayers and tears, and efforts for his preservation, crushed my hopes,
destroyed my youth’s best feelings, and doomed me to a life of hopeless
misery, as far as man can do it, it is not enough to say that I no
longer love my husband—I HATE him! The word stares me in the face like
a guilty confession, but it is true: I hate him—I hate him! But God
have mercy on his miserable soul! and make him see and feel his guilt—I
ask no other vengeance! If he could but fully know and truly feel my
wrongs I should be well avenged, and I could freely pardon all; but he
is so lost, so hardened in his heartless depravity, that in this life I
believe he never will. But it is useless dwelling on this theme: let me
seek once more to dissipate reflection in the minor details of passing
events.
Mr. Hargrave has annoyed me all day long with his serious,
sympathising, and (as he thinks) unobtrusive politeness. If it were
more obtrusive it would trouble me less, for then I could snub him;
but, as it is, he contrives to appear so really kind and thoughtful
that I cannot do so without rudeness and seeming ingratitude. I
sometimes think I ought to give him credit for the good feeling he
simulates so well; and then again, I think it is my duty to suspect
him under the peculiar circumstances in which I am placed. His kindness
may not all be feigned; but still, let not the purest impulse of
gratitude to him induce me to forget myself: let me remember the game
of chess, the expressions he used on the occasion, and those
indescribable looks of his, that so justly roused my indignation, and I
think I shall be safe enough. I have done well to record them so
minutely.
I think he wishes to find an opportunity of speaking to me alone: he
has seemed to be on the watch all day; but I have taken care to
disappoint him—not that I fear anything he could say, but I have
trouble enough without the addition of his insulting consolations,
condolences, or whatever else he might attempt; and, for Milicent’s
sake, I do not wish to quarrel with him. He excused himself from going
out to shoot with the other gentlemen in the morning, under the pretext
of having letters to write; and instead of retiring for that purpose
into the library, he sent for his desk into the morning-room, where I
was seated with Milicent and Lady Lowborough. They had betaken
themselves to their work; I, less to divert my mind than to deprecate
conversation, had provided myself with a book. Milicent saw that I
wished to be quiet, and accordingly let me alone. Annabella, doubtless,
saw it too: but that was no reason why she should restrain her tongue,
or curb her cheerful spirits: she accordingly chatted away,
addressing herself almost exclusively to me, and with the utmost
assurance and familiarity, growing the more animated and friendly the
colder and briefer my answers became. Mr. Hargrave saw that I could ill
endure it, and, looking up from his desk, he answered her questions and
observations for me, as far as he could, and attempted to transfer her
social attentions from me to himself; but it would not do. Perhaps she
thought I had a headache, and could not bear to talk; at any rate, she
saw that her loquacious vivacity annoyed me, as I could tell by the
malicious pertinacity with which she persisted. But I checked it
effectually by putting into her hand the book I had been trying to
read, on the fly-leaf of which I had hastily scribbled,—
“I am too well acquainted with your character and conduct to feel any
real friendship for you, and as I am without your talent for
dissimulation, I cannot assume the appearance of it. I must, therefore,
beg that hereafter all familiar intercourse may cease between us; and
if I still continue to treat you with civility, as if you were a woman
worthy of consideration and respect, understand that it is out of
regard for your cousin Milicent’s feelings, not for yours.”
Upon perusing this she turned scarlet, and bit her lip. Covertly
tearing away the leaf, she crumpled it up and put it in the fire, and
then employed herself in turning over the pages of the book, and,
really or apparently, perusing its contents. In a little while Milicent
announced it her intention to repair to the nursery, and asked if I
would accompany her.
“Annabella will excuse us,” said she; “she’s busy reading.”
“No, I won’t,” cried Annabella, suddenly looking up, and throwing her
book on the table; “I want to speak to Helen a minute. You may go,
Milicent, and she’ll follow in a while.” (Milicent went.) “Will you
oblige me, Helen?” continued she.
Her impudence astounded me; but I complied, and followed her into the
library. She closed the door, and walked up to the fire.
“Who told you this?” said she.
“No one: I am not incapable of seeing for myself.”
“Ah, you are suspicious!” cried she, smiling, with a gleam of hope.
Hitherto there had been a kind of desperation in her hardihood; now she
was evidently relieved.
“If I were suspicious,” I replied, “I should have discovered your
infamy long before. No, Lady Lowborough, I do not found my charge upon
suspicion.”
“On what do you found it, then?” said she, throwing herself into an
arm-chair, and stretching out her feet to the fender, with an obvious
effort to appear composed.
“I enjoy a moonlight ramble as well as you,” I answered, steadily
fixing my eyes upon her; “and the shrubbery happens to be one of my
favourite resorts.”
She coloured again excessively, and remained silent, pressing her
finger against her teeth, and gazing into the fire. I watched her a few
moments with a feeling of malevolent gratification; then, moving
towards the door, I calmly asked if she had anything more to say.
“Yes, yes!” cried she eagerly, starting up from her reclining posture.
“I want to know if you will tell Lord Lowborough?”
“Suppose I do?”
“Well, if you are disposed to publish the matter, I cannot dissuade
you, of course—but there will be terrible work if you do—and if you
don’t, I shall think you the most generous of mortal beings—and if
there is anything in the world I can do for you—anything short of—” she
hesitated.
“Short of renouncing your guilty connection with my husband, I suppose
you mean?” said I.
She paused, in evident disconcertion and perplexity, mingled with anger
she dared not show.
“I cannot renounce what is dearer than life,” she muttered, in a low,
hurried tone. Then, suddenly raising her head and fixing her gleaming
eyes upon me, she continued earnestly: “But, Helen—or Mrs. Huntingdon,
or whatever you would have me call you—will you tell him? If you are
generous, here is a fitting opportunity for the exercise of your
magnanimity: if you are proud, here am I—your rival—ready to
acknowledge myself your debtor for an act of the most noble
forbearance.”
“I shall not tell him.”
“You will not!” cried she, delightedly. “Accept my sincere thanks,
then!”
She sprang up, and offered me her hand. I drew back.
“Give me no thanks; it is not for your sake that I refrain. Neither
is it an act of any forbearance: I have no wish to publish your shame.
I should be sorry to distress your husband with the knowledge of it.”
“And Milicent? will you tell her?”
“No: on the contrary, I shall do my utmost to conceal it from her. I
would not for much that she should know the infamy and disgrace of her
relation!”
“You use hard words, Mrs. Huntingdon, but I can pardon you.”
“And now, Lady Lowborough,” continued I, “let me counsel you to leave
this house as soon as possible. You must be aware that your
continuance here is excessively disagreeable to me—not for Mr.
Huntingdon’s sake,” said I, observing the dawn of a malicious smile of
triumph on her face—“you are welcome to him, if you like him, as far as
I am concerned—but because it is painful to be always disguising my
true sentiments respecting you, and straining to keep up an appearance
of civility and respect towards one for whom I have not the most
distant shadow of esteem; and because, if you stay, your conduct cannot
possibly remain concealed much longer from the only two persons in the
house who do not know it already. And, for your husband’s sake,
Annabella, and even for your own, I wish—I earnestly advise and
entreat you to break off this unlawful connection at once, and return
to your duty while you may, before the dreadful consequences—”
“Yes, yes, of course,” said she, interrupting me with a gesture of
impatience. “But I cannot go, Helen, before the time appointed for our
departure. What possible pretext could I frame for such a thing?
Whether I proposed going back alone—which Lowborough would not hear
of—or taking him with me, the very circumstance itself would be certain
to excite suspicion—and when our visit is so nearly at an end
too—little more than a week—surely you can endure my presence so
long! I will not annoy you with any more of my friendly impertinences.”
“Well, I have nothing more to say to you.”
“Have you mentioned this affair to Huntingdon?” asked she, as I was
leaving the room.
“How dare you mention his name to me!” was the only answer I gave.
No words have passed between us since, but such as outward decency or
pure necessity demanded.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Using direct honesty to break free from manipulative situations where your politeness has become a prison.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone uses your social conditioning and desire to 'be nice' as a tool to continue harmful behavior.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's bad behavior continues because you're being 'polite'—then practice one direct, honest response instead of staying silent.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I no longer love my husband—I HATE him! The word stares me in the face like a guilty confession, but it is true: I hate him—I hate him!"
Context: Writing in her diary after cataloging all of Arthur's betrayals
This marks Helen's complete emotional transformation. The repetition and capitalization show how shocking this admission is even to her. She's moved beyond hurt to active hatred.
In Today's Words:
I'm done pretending I still love him - I actually hate his guts, and admitting that terrifies me.
"If he could but fully know and truly feel my wrongs I should be well avenged"
Context: After admitting she hates Arthur, explaining what revenge would look like to her
Helen doesn't want to destroy Arthur - she wants him to understand the pain he's caused. This shows her moral complexity and desire for justice rather than mere vengeance.
In Today's Words:
I don't want to ruin him - I just want him to actually understand how much he hurt me.
"I have no desire to injure you, but I have a right to save myself from injury"
Context: Confronting Annabella about ending their fake friendship
Helen establishes boundaries using moral authority. She's not attacking but protecting herself, which is harder to argue against than pure aggression.
In Today's Words:
I'm not trying to hurt you, but I'm not going to let you keep hurting me either.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Helen discovers she has more power than she realized through moral authority and strategic truth-telling
Development
Evolution from powerless victim to someone who can wield truth as a weapon
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize your silence is actually giving others permission to treat you badly.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Helen breaks free from the expectation that women must remain polite even when being betrayed
Development
Continued rebellion against feminine social conditioning that demands silence
In Your Life:
You see this when you feel obligated to be 'nice' to people who are actively harming you.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Helen transforms from someone who hopes for the best to someone who acts decisively based on reality
Development
Major milestone in her journey from naive optimist to strategic realist
In Your Life:
This appears when you stop making excuses for people's behavior and start responding to what they actually do.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Helen learns to distinguish between protecting innocent people and protecting guilty ones
Development
Growing sophistication in understanding who deserves her loyalty and protection
In Your Life:
You might struggle with this when trying to decide whether to expose someone's bad behavior or stay quiet.
Identity
In This Chapter
Helen embraces being seen as 'harsh' rather than continuing to be taken advantage of
Development
Continued evolution from people-pleaser to someone with firm boundaries
In Your Life:
This shows up when you have to choose between being liked and being respected.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What finally pushes Helen to write that brutal note to Annabella, and how does Annabella react when confronted?
analysis • surface - 2
Why has Helen's politeness been working against her, and how does she use strategic truth-telling to shift the power dynamic?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today using others' politeness or 'niceness' against them to get away with bad behavior?
application • medium - 4
When someone is counting on your silence to continue hurting you, how do you decide between keeping the peace and speaking up directly?
application • deep - 5
What does Helen's choice to protect Lord Lowborough while refusing to protect Annabella teach us about strategic compassion?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Politeness Trap
Think of a situation where someone is taking advantage of your politeness or reluctance to make waves. Write down exactly what they're doing, how they're counting on your silence, and what direct truth you could tell them. Then consider who would be helped vs. hurt if you spoke up honestly.
Consider:
- •Notice how manipulative people often frame directness as 'meanness' to keep you quiet
- •Consider whether your silence is actually protecting innocent people or just enabling bad behavior
- •Think about the difference between being kind and being a pushover
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you stayed quiet to 'keep the peace' but later realized your silence was making things worse. What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 35: The Final Provocations
With her confrontation behind her, Helen must now endure Annabella's increasingly bold behavior as the woman grows confident that her secret is safe. But Helen's newfound directness may have consequences she didn't anticipate.




