Summary
Thornton is consumed by jealousy, tormented by the image of Margaret with another man at the station. He believes she lied to protect a lover, and this thought drives him to distraction. When his mother mentions the gossip about Margaret's nighttime encounter, Thornton surprises her by defending Margaret despite his own pain. He asks his mother to counsel Margaret, believing she's in some kind of trouble. Mrs. Thornton visits Margaret with harsh words about her reputation, but Margaret's dignified response—and her refusal to explain herself—leaves Mrs. Thornton somewhat impressed despite herself. Meanwhile, Higgins waits five hours outside Thornton's mill, hoping for work to support Boucher's widow and children. When they finally meet, Thornton's prejudice against union leaders clashes with Higgins's desperate pride. Higgins offers to work under any conditions and promises not to cause trouble, but Thornton refuses, seeing him as a troublemaker. The chapter reveals how assumptions and wounded pride create barriers between people who might otherwise understand each other. Thornton's defense of Margaret shows his deeper character, while his rejection of Higgins reveals his blind spots. Both Margaret and Higgins maintain their dignity under attack, suggesting that true character emerges not in comfort, but when we're cornered.
Coming Up in Chapter 39
As tensions simmer beneath the surface, unexpected encounters will force both masters and workers to confront the true cost of their stubborn pride. Sometimes help comes from the most surprising sources.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
PROMISES FULFILLED. “Then proudly, proudly up she rose, Tho’ the tear was in her e’e, Whate’er ye say, think what ye may, Ye’s get na word frae me!” SCOTCH BALLAD. It was not merely that Margaret was known to Mr. Thornton to have spoken falsely,—though she imagined that for this reason only was she so turned in his opinion,—but that this falsehood of hers bore a distinct reference in his mind to some other lover. He could not forget the fond and earnest look that had passed between her and some other man—the attitude of familiar confidence, if not of positive endearment. The thought of this perpetually stung him; it was a picture before his eyes, wherever he went and whatever he was doing. In addition to this (and he ground his teeth as he remembered it), was the hour, dusky twilight; the place, so far away from home, and comparatively unfrequented. His nobler self had said at first, that all this last might be accidental, innocent, justifiable; but once allow her right to love and be beloved (and had he any reason to deny her right?—had not her words been severely explicit when she cast his love away from her?), she might easily have been beguiled into a longer walk, on to a later hour than she had anticipated. But that falsehood! which showed a fatal consciousness of something wrong, and to be concealed, which was unlike her. He did her that justice, though all the time it would have been a relief to believe her utterly unworthy of his esteem. It was this that made the misery—that he passionately loved her, and thought her, even with all her faults, more lovely and more excellent than any other woman; yet he deemed her so attached to some other man, so led away by her affection for him, as to violate her truthful nature. The very falsehood that stained her, was a proof how blindly she loved another—this dark, slight, elegant, handsome man—while he himself was rough, and stern, and strongly made. He lashed himself into an agony of fierce jealousy. He thought of that look, that attitude!—how he would have laid his life at her feet for such tender glances, such fond detention! He mocked at himself, for having valued the mechanical way in which she had protected him from the fury of the mob; now he had seen how soft and bewitching she looked when with a man she really loved. He remembered, point by point, the sharpness of her words—“There was not a man in all that crowd for whom she would not have done as much, far more readily than for him.” He shared with the mob, in her desire of averting bloodshed from them; but this man, this hidden lover, shared with nobody; he had looks, words, hand-cleavings, lies, concealment, all to himself. Mr. Thornton was conscious that he had never been so irritable as he was now, in all his life long; he felt...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Defensive Pride - When Protection Becomes Prison
When past wounds make us reject the very connections and opportunities we most need, disguised as self-protection.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine principle and wounded ego disguised as protection.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone defends you but attacks others unfairly—ask whether their protection serves justice or just their own narrative.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
False consciousness
When someone believes something untrue about a situation, often because they lack crucial information. Thornton thinks Margaret lied to protect a lover, but he doesn't know the real reason.
Modern Usage:
Like when you assume your coworker got promoted because they're the boss's favorite, not knowing they've been working overtime for months.
Social reputation
In Victorian times, a woman's reputation was everything - one whisper of impropriety could ruin her marriage prospects and social standing. Margaret is being gossiped about for being seen with a man at night.
Modern Usage:
Today it's like having rumors spread about you at work or on social media that could affect your job or relationships.
Class prejudice
Pre-judging someone based on their social class or background. Thornton refuses to hire Higgins partly because he sees union leaders as troublemakers, not individuals.
Modern Usage:
Like assuming someone with tattoos or a certain accent won't be a good employee before you even interview them.
Wounded pride
When your ego is hurt, it can make you act irrationally or cruelly. Both Thornton and Higgins let their hurt feelings drive their decisions in this chapter.
Modern Usage:
When you're so hurt by someone that you can't think clearly - like staying mad at a friend who apologized because your feelings are still raw.
Dignified silence
Choosing not to defend yourself when you're being attacked, either because explaining would make things worse or because you refuse to lower yourself to argue.
Modern Usage:
Like not engaging with online trolls or not defending yourself to a toxic boss because you know it won't help.
Mill owner
In industrial England, these were the factory owners who employed hundreds of workers. They had enormous power over people's livelihoods and were often seen as either saviors or tyrants.
Modern Usage:
Think of today's major employers in small towns - like the plant manager at the biggest factory or the hospital administrator who decides staffing.
Characters in This Chapter
John Thornton
Male protagonist
He's tormented by jealousy, imagining Margaret with another man. Despite his pain, he defends her to his mother and asks her to help Margaret, showing his deeper character even when he's hurting.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who's still protective of his ex even though he thinks she cheated on him
Margaret Hale
Female protagonist
She maintains her dignity when Mrs. Thornton confronts her about the gossip, refusing to explain herself or beg for understanding. Her composure actually impresses her critic.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman who won't explain herself to the office gossips, even when it would be easier
Mrs. Thornton
Antagonistic mother figure
She visits Margaret to scold her about her reputation, but finds herself somewhat impressed by Margaret's dignified response. She's protective of her son but beginning to see Margaret differently.
Modern Equivalent:
The mother-in-law who comes ready to fight but leaves grudgingly respecting you
Nicholas Higgins
Working-class advocate
He waits five hours outside Thornton's mill, swallowing his pride to beg for work so he can support Boucher's widow and children. Despite offering to work under any conditions, he's rejected.
Modern Equivalent:
The laid-off union rep who has to ask his former enemy for a job to feed his family
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He could not forget the fond and earnest look that had passed between her and some other man—the attitude of familiar confidence, if not of positive endearment."
Context: Describing Thornton's torment over what he saw at the train station
This shows how jealousy distorts perception. Thornton is replaying this scene obsessively, probably making it seem more romantic than it was. His pain is making him see betrayal everywhere.
In Today's Words:
He couldn't stop picturing her looking at another guy like she cared about him - maybe even loved him.
"But that falsehood! which showed a fatal consciousness of something wrong, and to be concealed, which was unlike her."
Context: Thornton's thoughts about Margaret's lie to the inspector
Even in his anger, Thornton recognizes that lying isn't typical behavior for Margaret. This suggests he still knows her character, even though he's hurt and confused.
In Today's Words:
But that lie! It proved she knew she was doing something wrong and had to hide it, which just wasn't like her.
"I'm not above being thankful to any man as gives me work for love of my fellow-creatures; but I won't take it for love o' me."
Context: Higgins explaining to Thornton why he needs work
Higgins is trying to preserve his dignity while begging for help. He'll accept charity for the sake of the widow and children he's supporting, but not pity for himself.
In Today's Words:
I'll take help if it's because you care about people in need, but I won't take a handout just because you feel sorry for me.
Thematic Threads
Pride
In This Chapter
Thornton's wounded pride makes him defend Margaret publicly while rejecting Higgins privately; Higgins swallows pride to beg for work
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters where pride drove conflict—now showing how it can both protect and destroy
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you find yourself helping strangers while pushing away family members who've hurt you.
Class
In This Chapter
Thornton sees Higgins as a permanent troublemaker because of his union leadership, unable to separate past from present need
Development
Deepened from strike conflicts—now showing how class prejudice persists even in individual desperation
In Your Life:
You see this when someone's job title or background makes you assume things about their character or intentions.
Judgment
In This Chapter
Mrs. Thornton judges Margaret's reputation while Margaret refuses to explain herself; Thornton prejudges Higgins
Development
Intensified from earlier moral judgments—now showing how assumptions prevent understanding
In Your Life:
You experience this when you form opinions about people based on limited information or gossip.
Dignity
In This Chapter
Margaret maintains composure under attack; Higgins keeps his dignity while begging; both refuse to grovel
Development
Consistent theme—showing how true character emerges under pressure
In Your Life:
You face this choice when criticized unfairly—whether to defend yourself desperately or maintain quiet strength.
Responsibility
In This Chapter
Higgins takes on Boucher's widow and children despite his own struggles; Thornton feels responsible for Margaret's reputation
Development
Evolved from individual concerns to broader community obligations
In Your Life:
You encounter this when deciding how much of other people's burdens you should carry as your own.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Thornton defend Margaret to his mother when he's privately convinced she's been dishonest with him?
analysis • surface - 2
What prevents Thornton from seeing Higgins as a desperate man trying to feed children rather than a troublemaker?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of wounded people rejecting help or connection in your workplace or community?
application • medium - 4
How could Higgins have approached Thornton differently to overcome the prejudice against his union background?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how our past wounds shape our ability to see present situations clearly?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Rewrite the Job Interview
Imagine you're coaching Higgins before his meeting with Thornton. Knowing Thornton's concerns about union troublemakers, rewrite what Higgins could have said to address those fears while still maintaining his dignity. Focus on specific words and phrases that acknowledge the past without being defensive.
Consider:
- •What evidence could Higgins provide that he's genuinely changed his approach?
- •How might he acknowledge Thornton's business concerns without groveling?
- •What concrete commitments could he offer that would feel meaningful to an employer?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when your past reputation or mistakes prevented someone from giving you a fair chance. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 39: When Pride Meets Understanding
Moving forward, we'll examine misunderstandings compound when people won't communicate directly, and understand swallowing pride can lead to unexpected mutual respect. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.