Summary
A violent mob of unemployed workers storms the Thornton mill, furious that Irish workers have been brought in to replace them at lower wages. Margaret finds herself trapped in the house as the crowd batters down the gates, their rage focused on mill owner John Thornton. When Margaret challenges Thornton to face the mob like a man rather than wait for soldiers, he goes out to confront them alone. But as the crowd prepares to attack him with wooden clogs, Margaret makes a split-second decision that changes everything—she rushes outside and shields Thornton with her own body. A stone meant for him strikes her in the head instead, and the sight of her blood shames the mob into retreating. This moment of physical courage reveals Margaret's deeper feelings and forces both her and Thornton to confront emotions they've been avoiding. The chapter shows how crisis strips away social pretense and reveals who people really are. Margaret, who feared she might be a coward, discovers she's capable of extraordinary bravery when someone she cares about is in danger. Meanwhile, Thornton witnesses Margaret's sacrifice and finally understands the depth of his feelings for her. The aftermath is awkward and complicated—servants gossip about seeing Margaret with her arms around their master, and the incident creates an intimacy between Margaret and Thornton that neither knows how to handle. Gaskell masterfully shows how one moment of authentic action can cut through months of misunderstanding and social barriers.
Coming Up in Chapter 23
Margaret must face the aftermath of her impulsive act of courage. How will she explain her actions to her family, and what will the consequences be for her relationship with Thornton now that their feelings have been so dramatically exposed?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
A BLOW AND ITS CONSEQUENCES. “But work grew scarce, while bread grew dear, And wages lessened, too; For Irish hordes were bidders here, Our half-paid work to do.” CORN LAW RHYMES. Margaret was shown into the drawing-room. It had returned into its normal state of bag and covering. The windows were half open because of the heat, and the Venetian blinds covered the glass,—so that a gray grim light, reflected from the pavement below, threw all the shadows wrong, and combined with the green-tinged upper light to make even Margaret’s own face, as she caught it in the mirrors, look ghastly and wan. She sat and waited; no one came. Every now and then, the wind seemed to bear the distant multitudinous sound nearer; and yet there was no wind! It died away into profound stillness between whiles. Fanny came in at last. “Mamma will come directly, Miss Hale. She desired me to apologise to you as it is. Perhaps you know my brother has imported hands from Ireland, and it has irritated the Milton people excessively—as if he hadn’t a right to get labour where he could; and the stupid wretches here wouldn’t work for him; and now they’ve frightened these poor Irish starvelings so with their threats, that we daren’t let them out. You may see them huddled in that top room in the mill,—and they’re to sleep there, to keep them safe from those brutes, who will neither work or let them work. And mamma is seeing about their food, and John is speaking to them, for some of the women are crying to go back. Ah! here’s mamma!” Mrs. Thornton came in with a look of black sternness on her face, which made Margaret feel she had arrived at a bad time to trouble her with her request. However, it was only in compliance with Mrs. Thornton’s expressed desire, that she would ask for whatever they might want in the progress of her mother’s illness. Mrs. Thornton’s brow contracted, and her mouth grew set, while Margaret spoke with gentle modesty of her mother’s restlessness, and Dr. Donaldson’s wish that she should have the relief of a water-bed. She ceased. Mrs. Thornton did not reply immediately. Then she started up and exclaimed— “They’re at the gates! Call John, Fanny,—call him in from the mill! They’re at the gates! They’ll batter them in! Call John, I say!” And simultaneously, the gathering tramp—to which she had been listening, instead of heeding Margaret’s words—was heard just right outside the wall, and an increasing din of angry voices raged behind the wooden barrier, which shook as if the unseen maddened crowd made battering rams of their bodies, and retreated a short space only to come with more united steady impetus against it, till their great beats made the strong gates quiver, like reeds before the wind. The women gathered round the windows, fascinated to look on the scene which terrified them. Mrs. Thornton, the women-servants, Margaret,—all were there. Fanny had returned,...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Crisis Courage - When Danger Reveals Who You Really Are
Emergency situations strip away social performance and reveal people's authentic values and character traits.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify someone's true nature by watching their instinctive responses during high-pressure moments.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when stress hits your workplace or family—pay attention to who steps up versus who disappears, and use this information to make better decisions about trust.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Imported hands
Workers brought in from outside the local area, usually willing to work for lower wages than local workers. In this chapter, Irish workers are brought to Milton to replace striking English mill workers. This was a common practice during industrial disputes.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this when companies hire temporary workers or contractors during strikes, or when businesses relocate to areas with cheaper labor.
Corn Law Rhymes
Popular protest songs and poems criticizing the Corn Laws, which kept grain prices artificially high to protect wealthy landowners. The verse at the chapter's start reflects working-class anger about Irish workers taking jobs for lower pay.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how protest songs and viral social media posts today express frustration about economic policies or job competition.
Mill owner
The person who owns a textile factory during the Industrial Revolution. They controlled workers' wages, hours, and working conditions. Mill owners had enormous power over entire communities but also faced financial risks and worker unrest.
Modern Usage:
Like today's CEOs or factory owners who make decisions about hiring, wages, and outsourcing that affect whole communities.
Mob violence
When angry crowds turn to physical force and destruction to express their grievances. In this chapter, unemployed workers storm the mill with violent intent when peaceful protest fails to get results.
Modern Usage:
We see this pattern in riots during economic crises, labor disputes, or when people feel the system has completely failed them.
Class barriers
The social rules and expectations that kept different economic classes separate. Margaret crossing these barriers to protect Thornton shocks everyone because ladies weren't supposed to involve themselves in working-class conflicts.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone from a wealthy neighborhood gets involved in a working-class struggle, or when social expectations limit who can speak up about certain issues.
Strike breaking
The practice of hiring replacement workers during a labor strike to keep production going. This undermines the strikers' leverage and often leads to violence and lasting bitterness in the community.
Modern Usage:
Still happens today when companies hire temporary workers or move operations during strikes, often creating the same tensions and conflicts.
Characters in This Chapter
Margaret Hale
Protagonist
Makes a split-second decision to shield Thornton from the violent mob, getting injured in the process. This moment reveals her true courage and forces her to confront her feelings for Thornton, even though the aftermath is socially awkward.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who jumps into a dangerous situation to protect someone, then has to deal with the complicated feelings that follow.
John Thornton
Mill owner and love interest
Faces down an angry mob alone after Margaret challenges his courage. His willingness to confront the workers personally shows his integrity, but he's also the cause of their anger by hiring Irish replacement workers.
Modern Equivalent:
The business owner who makes tough decisions that hurt the community but then faces the consequences personally.
Fanny Thornton
Privileged observer
Explains the situation to Margaret with casual dismissal of the workers' concerns, calling them 'stupid wretches' and 'brutes.' Her attitude shows how the wealthy view labor disputes as mere inconveniences.
Modern Equivalent:
The privileged person who complains about protesters while completely missing why they're angry.
The mob
Collective antagonist
Represents the desperation and rage of unemployed workers who see their jobs given to outsiders for lower pay. Their violence is wrong, but their anger comes from real economic hardship and betrayal.
Modern Equivalent:
Workers who turn to destructive protest when they feel completely powerless against economic forces.
Irish workers
Pawns in economic conflict
Trapped in the mill for their own safety, these workers are caught between needing jobs and facing violent threats. They represent how desperate people get used in economic conflicts between other groups.
Modern Equivalent:
Immigrant workers or temp workers who get blamed for taking jobs when they're just trying to survive.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Go down this instant, if you are not a coward. Go down and face them like a man."
Context: Margaret challenges Thornton when he hesitates to face the angry mob personally.
This quote shows Margaret pushing Thornton to act with courage and integrity rather than hiding behind his social position. It reveals her own moral courage and sets up the moment when she'll have to back up her words with action.
In Today's Words:
Stop hiding and deal with this situation like an adult.
"Oh, God! that I knew how to comfort you!"
Context: Thornton speaks to the unconscious Margaret after she's been injured protecting him.
This moment of vulnerability reveals Thornton's true feelings and his helplessness in the face of Margaret's sacrifice. It shows how crisis strips away social pretense and reveals genuine emotion.
In Today's Words:
I wish I knew how to make this better for you.
"The stones were flying thick and fast."
Context: Describing the moment when the mob begins throwing projectiles at Thornton.
This simple statement captures the sudden escalation from angry words to physical violence. It shows how quickly a tense situation can turn deadly and sets up Margaret's heroic intervention.
In Today's Words:
Things got violent fast.
"She had thrown her arms around him; she had shielded him from violence."
Context: Describing Margaret's protective action and its social implications.
This quote highlights both Margaret's physical courage and the scandal her action creates. In her society, such intimate physical contact between unmarried people was shocking, making her sacrifice even more significant.
In Today's Words:
She put herself between him and danger, and everyone saw it.
Thematic Threads
Courage
In This Chapter
Margaret discovers physical bravery she didn't know she possessed when she shields Thornton from the mob
Development
Introduced here as a defining moment of character revelation
In Your Life:
You might discover unexpected courage when someone you care about faces real danger or crisis.
Class
In This Chapter
The mob's fury stems from being replaced by cheaper Irish workers, while Margaret's protective act crosses class boundaries
Development
Evolved from abstract social differences to violent economic conflict with personal consequences
In Your Life:
You see this when economic pressure pits different groups of workers against each other instead of addressing systemic issues.
Identity
In This Chapter
Margaret learns she's not the coward she feared but someone capable of extraordinary sacrifice
Development
Builds on her ongoing struggle to understand who she is outside social expectations
In Your Life:
Crisis moments might reveal strengths or values you didn't know you had, changing how you see yourself.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Margaret abandons all propriety to save Thornton, creating scandal among the servants who witness their intimacy
Development
Escalated from internal conflict to public action that defies social norms
In Your Life:
You face this when doing the right thing means breaking social rules or professional boundaries.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
The crisis creates unwanted intimacy between Margaret and Thornton that neither knows how to handle
Development
Transformed from mutual antagonism to forced emotional honesty through shared trauma
In Your Life:
Crisis can create intense bonds with people you weren't close to, leading to complicated relationship dynamics.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What made Margaret suddenly rush outside to protect Thornton when she had been criticizing him moments before?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does crisis strip away the social masks people usually wear, and what does this reveal about how we normally interact?
analysis • medium - 3
Think of a recent crisis in your community or workplace. Who surprised you by stepping up, and who disappointed you by backing down?
application • medium - 4
When you're under extreme pressure, what values drive your instinctive actions? How might this differ from how you present yourself day-to-day?
reflection • deep - 5
How can recognizing that crisis reveals true character help you make better decisions about who to trust in your personal and professional life?
application • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Crisis Character Audit
Think of three people in your life and recall how they behaved during a recent stressful situation—a family emergency, workplace crisis, or community challenge. Write down what their actions revealed about their true character versus how they normally present themselves. Then honestly assess your own behavior during a recent crisis.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns between what people say they value and how they actually behave under pressure
- •Notice the difference between performative concern and genuine action
- •Consider how your own crisis behavior might surprise others who only know your 'good day' self
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when crisis revealed something unexpected about your own character—either discovering strength you didn't know you had, or recognizing a weakness you'd been hiding from yourself.
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 23: The Weight of Misunderstood Actions
What lies ahead teaches us good intentions can be misinterpreted by others, and shows us the courage it takes to act on principle despite social judgment. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.