An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2944 words)
HE SHADOW OF DEATH.
“Trust in that veiled hand, which leads
None by the path that he would go;
And always be for change prepared,
For the world’s law is ebb and flow.”
FROM THE ARABIC.
The next afternoon Dr. Donaldson came to pay his first visit to Mrs.
Hale. The mystery that Margaret hoped their late habits of intimacy had
broken through was resumed. She was excluded from the room, while Dixon
was admitted. Margaret was not a ready lover, but where she loved she
loved passionately, and with no small degree of jealousy.
She went into her mother’s bed-room, just behind the drawing-room, and
paced it up and down, while awaiting the doctor’s coming out. Every now
and then she stopped to listen; she fancied she heard a moan. She
clenched her hands tight, and held her breath. She was sure she heard a
moan. Then all was still for a few minutes more; and then there was the
moving of chairs, the raised voices, all the little disturbances of
leave-taking.
When she heard the door open, she went quickly out of the bedroom.
“My father is from home, Dr. Donaldson; he has to attend a pupil at this
hour. May I trouble you to come into his room downstairs?”
She saw, and triumphed over all the obstacles which Dixon threw in her
way; assuming her rightful position as daughter of the house in
something of the spirit of the Elder Brother, which quelled the old
servant’s officiousness very effectually. Margaret’s conscious
assumption of this unusual dignity of demeanour towards Dixon, gave her
an instant’s amusement in the midst of her anxiety. She knew, from the
surprised expression on Dixon’s face, how ridiculously grand she herself
must be looking; and the idea carried her downstairs into the room; it
gave her that length of oblivion from the keen sharpness of the
recollection of the actual business in hand. Now, that came back, and
seemed to take away her breath. It was a moment or two before she could
utter a word.
But she spoke with an air of command, as she asked—
“What is the matter with mamma? You will oblige me by telling the simple
truth.” Then, seeing a slight hesitation on the doctor’s part, she
added—
“I am the only child she has—here, I mean. My father is not
sufficiently alarmed, I fear: and, therefore, if there is any serious
apprehension, it must be broken to him gently. I can do this. I can
nurse my mother. Pray, speak, sir; to see your face, and not be able to
read it, gives me a worse dread than I trust any words of yours will
justify.”
“My dear young lady, your mother seems to have a most attentive and
efficient servant, who is more like her friend——”
“I am her daughter, sir.”
“But when I tell you she expressly desired that you might not be
told——”
“I am not good or patient enough to submit to the prohibition. Besides,
I am sure, you are too wise—too experienced to have promised to keep
the secret.”
“Well,” said he, half-smiling, though sadly enough, “there you are
right. I did not promise. In fact, I fear, the secret will be known soon
enough without my revealing it.”
He paused. Margaret then went very white, and compressed her lips a
little more. Otherwise not a feature moved. With the quick insight into
character, without which no medical man can rise to the eminence of Dr.
Donaldson, he saw that she would exact the full truth; that she would
know if one iota was withheld; and that the withholding would be torture
more acute than the knowledge of it. He spoke two short sentences in a
low voice, watching her all the time; for the pupils of her eyes dilated
into a black horror, and the whiteness of her complexion became livid.
He ceased speaking. He waited for that look to go off,—for her gasping
breath to come. Then she said:—
“I thank you most truly, sir, for your confidence. That dread has
haunted me for many weeks. It is a true, real agony. My poor, poor
mother!” Her lips now began to quiver, and he let her have the relief of
tears, sure of her power of self-control to check them.
A few tears—those were all she shed, before she recollected the many
questions she longed to ask.
“Will there be much suffering?”
He shook his head. “That we cannot tell. It depends on constitution; on
a thousand things. But the late discoveries of medical science have
given us large power of alleviation.”
“My father!” said Margaret, trembling all over.
“I do not know Mr. Hale. I mean, it is difficult to give advice. But I
should say, bear on, with the knowledge you have forced me to give you
so abruptly, till the fact which I could not withhold has become in some
degree familiar to you, so that you may without too great an effort, be
able to give what comfort you can to your father. Before then,—my
visits, which of course, I shall repeat from time to time, although I
fear I can do nothing but alleviate,—a thousand little circumstances
will have occurred to awaken his alarm, to deepen it—so that he will be
all the better prepared.—Nay, my dear young lady—nay, my dear—I saw
Mr. Thornton, and I honour your father for the sacrifice he has made,
however mistaken I may believe him to be.—Well, this once, if it will
please you, my dear. Only remember, when I come again, I come as a
friend. And you must learn to look upon me as such, because seeing each
other—getting to know each other at such times as these, is worth years
of morning calls.”
Margaret could not speak for crying; but she wrang his hand at parting.
“That’s what I call a fine girl!” thought Dr. Donaldson, when he was
seated in his carriage, and had time to examine his ringed hand, which
had slightly suffered from her pressure. “Who would have thought that
little hand could have given such a squeeze? But the bones were well put
together, and that gives immense power. What a queen she is! With her
head thrown back at first, to force me into speaking the truth; and then
bent so eagerly forward to listen. Poor thing! I must see she does not
overstrain herself. Though it’s astonishing how much these thorough-bred
creatures can do and suffer. That girl’s game to the back-bone. Another,
who had gone that deadly colour, could never have come round without
either fainting or hysterics. But she wouldn’t do either—not she! And
the very force of her will brought her round. Such a girl as that would
win my heart, if I were thirty years younger. It’s too late now. Ah;
here we are at the Archers’.” So out he jumped, with thought, wisdom,
experience, sympathy, and ready to attend to any of the calls made upon
them by this family, just as if there were none other in the world.
Meanwhile, Margaret had returned into her father’s study for a moment,
to recover strength before going upstairs into her mother’s presence.
“Oh, my God, my God! but this is terrible. How shall I bear it? Such a
deadly disease! no hope! Oh, mamma, mamma, I wish I had never gone to
aunt Shaw’s, and been all those precious years away from you! Poor
mamma! how much she must have borne! Oh, pray thee, my God, that her
sufferings may not be too acute, too dreadful. How shall I bear to see
them? How can I bear papa’s agony? He must not be told yet; not all at
once. It would kill him. But I won’t lose another moment of my own dear,
precious mother.”
She ran upstairs. Dixon was not in the room. Mrs. Hale lay back in an
easy chair, with a soft white shawl wrapped around her, and a becoming
cap put on, in expectation of the doctor’s visit. Her face had a little
faint colour in it, and the very exhaustion after the examination gave
it a peaceful look. Margaret was surprised to see her look so calm.
“Why, Margaret, how strange you look! What is the matter?” And then, as
the idea stole into her mind of what was indeed the real state of the
case, she added, as if a little displeased: “you have not been seeing
Dr. Donaldson, and asking him any questions—have you child?” Margaret
did not reply—only looked wistfully towards her. Mrs. Hale became more
displeased. “He would not surely break his word to me, and”—
“Oh yes, mamma, he did. I made him. It was I—blame me.” She knelt down
by her mother’s side, and caught her hand—she would not let it go,
though Mrs. Hale tried to pull it away. She kept kissing it, and the hot
tears she shed bathed it.
“Margaret, it was very wrong of you. You knew I did not wish you to
know.” But, as if tired with the contest, she left her hand in
Margaret’s clasp, and by-and-by she returned the pressure faintly. That
encouraged Margaret to speak.
“Oh, mamma! let me be your nurse. I will learn anything Dixon can teach
me. But you know I am your child, and I do think I have a right to do
everything for you.”
“You don’t know what you are asking,” said Mrs. Hale, with a shudder.
“Yes, I do. I know a great deal more than you are aware of. Let me be
your nurse. Let me try, at any rate. No one has ever, shall ever try so
hard as I will do. It will be such a comfort, mamma.”
“My poor child! Well, you shall try. Do you know, Margaret, Dixon and I
thought you would quite shrink from me if you knew—”
“Dixon thought!” said Margaret, her lip curling. “Dixon could not give
me credit for enough true love—for as much as herself! She thought, I
suppose, that I was one of those poor sickly women who like to lie on
rose leaves, and be fanned all day. Don’t let Dixon’s fancies come any
more between you and me, mamma. Don’t please!” implored she.
“Don’t be angry with Dixon,” said Mrs. Hale, anxiously. Margaret
recovered herself.
“No! I won’t. I will try and be humble, and learn her ways, if you will
only let me do all I can for you. Let me be in the first place,
mother—I am greedy of that. I used to fancy you would forget me while I
was away at aunt Shaw’s, and cry myself to sleep at nights with that
notion in my head.”
“And I used to think, how will Margaret bear our make-shift poverty
after the thorough comfort and luxury in Harley Street, till I have many
a time been more ashamed of your seeing our contrivances at Helstone
than of any stranger finding them out.”
“Oh, mamma! and I did so enjoy them. They were so much more amusing than
all the jog-trot Harley Street ways. The wardrobe shelf with handles
that served as a supper-tray on grand occasions! And the old tea-chests
stuffed and covered for ottomans! I think what you call the make-shift
contrivances at dear Helstone were a charming part of the life there.”
“I shall never see Helstone again, Margaret,” said Mrs. Hale, the tears
welling up into her eyes. Margaret could not reply. Mrs. Hale went on.
“While I was there, I was for ever wanting to leave it. Every place
seemed pleasanter. And now I shall die far away from it. I am rightly
punished.”
“You must not talk so,” said Margaret impatiently. “He said you might
live for years. Oh, mother! we will have you back at Helstone yet.”
“No, never! That I must take as a just penance. But,
Margaret—Frederick!”
At the mention of that one word, she suddenly cried out loud, as in some
sharp agony. It seemed as if the thought of him upset all her composure,
destroyed the calm, overcame the exhaustion. Wild passionate cry
succeeded to cry—“Frederick! Frederick! Come to me. I am dying. Little
first-born child, come to me once again!”
She was in violent hysterics. Margaret went and called Dixon in terror.
Dixon came in a huff, and accused Margaret of having over-excited her
mother. Margaret bore all meekly, only trusting that her father might
not return. In spite of her alarm, which was even greater than the
occasion warranted, she obeyed all Dixon’s directions promptly and well
without a word of self-justification. By so doing she mollified her
accuser. They put her mother to bed, and Margaret sate by her till she
fell asleep, and afterwards till Dixon beckoned her out of the room,
and, with a sour face, as if doing something against the grain, she bade
her drink a cup of coffee which she had prepared for her in the
drawing-room, and stood over her in a commanding attitude as she did so.
“You shouldn’t have been so curious, Miss, and then you wouldn’t have
needed to fret before your time. It would have come soon enough. And
now, I suppose, you’ll tell master, and a pretty household I shall have
of you!”
“No, Dixon,” said Margaret, sorrowfully, “I will not tell papa. He could
not bear it as I can.” And by way of proving how well she bore it, she
burst into tears.
“Ay! I knew how it would be. Now you’ll waken your mamma, just after
she’s gone to sleep so quietly. Miss Margaret my dear, I’ve had to keep
it down this many a week: and though I don’t pretend I can love her as
you do, yet I loved her better than any other man, woman, or child—no
one but Master Frederick ever came near her in my mind. Ever since Lady
Beresford’s maid first took me in to see her dressed out in white crape,
and corn-ears, and scarlet poppies, and I ran a needle down into my
finger, and broke it in, and she tore up her worked pocket-handkerchief,
after they’d cut it out, and came in to wet the bandages again with
lotion when she returned from the ball—where she’d been the prettiest
young lady of all—I’ve never loved any one like her. I little thought
then that I should live to see her brought so low. I don’t mean no
reproach to nobody. Many a one calls you pretty and handsome, and what
not. Even in this smoky place, enough to blind one’s eyes, the owls can
see that. But you’ll never be like your mother for beauty—never; not if
you live to be a hundred.”
“Mamma is very pretty still. Poor mamma!”
“Now don’t ye set off again, or I shall give way at last” (whimpering).
“You’ll never stand master’s coming home, and questioning, at this rate.
Go out and take a walk, and come in something like. Many’s the time I’ve
longed to walk it off—the thought of what was the matter with her, and
how it must all end.”
“Oh, Dixon!” said Margaret, “how often I’ve been cross with you, not
knowing what a terrible secret you had to bear!”
“Bless you, child! I like to see you showing a bit of a spirit. It’s the
good old Beresford blood. Why, the last Sir John but two shot his
steward down, there where he stood, for just telling him that he racked
the tenants, and he’d racked the tenants till he could get no more money
off them than he could get skin off a flint.”
“Well, Dixon, I won’t shoot you, and I’ll try not to be cross again.”
“You never have. If I’ve said it at times, it has always been to myself,
just in private, by way of making a little agreeable conversation, for
there’s no one here fit to talk to. And when you fire up you’re the very
image of Master Frederick. I could find in my heart to put you in a
passion any day just to see his stormy look coming like a great cloud
over your face. But now you go out, Miss. I’ll watch over Missus; and as
for master, his books are company enough for him, if he should come in.”
“I will go,” said Margaret. She hung about Dixon for a minute or so, as
if afraid and irresolute; then, suddenly kissing her, she went quickly
out of the room.
“Bless her!” said Dixon. “She’s as sweet as a nut. There are three
people I love; its Missus, Master Frederick, and her. Just them three.
That’s all. The rest be hanged, for I don’t know what they’re in the
world for. Master was born, I suppose, for to marry missus. If I thought
he loved her properly, I might get to love him in time. But he should
ha’ made a deal more on her, and not been always reading, reading,
thinking, thinking. See what it has brought him to. Many a one who never
reads or thinks either, gets to be Rector, and Dean, and what not; and I
daresay master might, if he’d just minded missus, and let the weary
reading and thinking alone.—There she goes” (looking out of the window
as she heard the front door shut). “Poor young lady! her clothes look
shabby to what they did when she came to Helstone a year ago. Then she
hadn’t so much as a darned stocking or a cleaned pair of gloves in all
her wardrobe. And now—!”
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When attempts to shield others from painful truths end up stealing their agency and amplifying everyone's suffering.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when people use 'kindness' to steal your agency and make decisions for you.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone says 'I didn't want to worry you'—ask yourself if they're protecting your feelings or their own comfort with difficult conversations.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am not a child. I am past eighteen. I must, and I will know."
Context: Margaret confronts Dr. Donaldson when he tries to avoid telling her about her mother's condition
This quote marks Margaret's transformation from sheltered daughter to adult family member. She's claiming her right to share in family burdens and rejecting the Victorian notion that young women need protection from harsh realities.
In Today's Words:
I'm an adult and I have a right to know what's happening in my own family
"Oh, Frederick! Frederick! Come home to me. I am dying. I am dying!"
Context: Mrs. Hale breaks down emotionally after Margaret confronts her about hiding her illness
This desperate cry reveals the depth of Mrs. Hale's anguish about dying separated from her son. It shows how family secrets and separations compound the pain of terminal illness.
In Today's Words:
I need my son here with me. I can't die without seeing him again
"I have loved you all, as if you were my own family."
Context: Dixon finally opens up to Margaret about her feelings for the family
This quote reveals the complex emotional reality of servant-family relationships. Dixon's love is genuine, but her position remains precarious - she loves 'as if' they were family, highlighting the gap that class creates.
In Today's Words:
You're like family to me, even though I know that's not really what I am to you
Thematic Threads
Truth vs Protection
In This Chapter
Margaret demands to know about her mother's condition despite everyone's attempts to shield her from the painful reality
Development
Building from earlier hints of family secrets, now exploding into direct confrontation
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when family members whisper and change the subject when you enter the room
Class and Service
In This Chapter
Dixon's complex relationship with the family—servant yet confidante, carrying emotional burdens across class lines
Development
Deepening exploration of how class boundaries blur in intimate family relationships
In Your Life:
You see this in how healthcare workers, nannies, or elder care providers often know family secrets that blood relatives don't share
Female Agency
In This Chapter
Margaret refuses to be treated as fragile, demanding her right to care for her mother and handle family crises
Development
Accelerating Margaret's transformation from protected daughter to family decision-maker
In Your Life:
You might face this when others assume you can't handle difficult information because of your age, gender, or perceived sensitivity
Hidden Burdens
In This Chapter
Dixon has been carrying the secret of Mrs. Hale's illness alone, while Mrs. Hale suffers thinking of her absent son Frederick
Development
Revealing the emotional weight that characters have been bearing privately throughout the story
In Your Life:
You experience this when you're the only one who knows about a family member's addiction, debt, or health crisis
Family Loyalty
In This Chapter
Margaret immediately shifts into protector mode, planning how to shield her father while caring for her mother
Development
Showing how crisis reveals and reshapes family roles and responsibilities
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you become the family member everyone turns to during emergencies, regardless of your age or experience
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Margaret discover about her mother, and how does she force the truth from Dr. Donaldson?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do you think Mrs. Hale, Dr. Donaldson, and Dixon all agreed to keep Margaret in the dark about her mother's condition?
analysis • medium - 3
When have you seen families, workplaces, or friend groups try to 'protect' someone by hiding difficult news? How did it work out?
application • medium - 4
Margaret insists she's strong enough to handle the truth and care for her mother. How do you know when someone is ready for difficult information versus when they genuinely need protection?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between love that protects and love that empowers?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Protection Web
Draw a simple diagram showing who was protecting whom in this chapter and what information each person had. Then think of a situation in your own life where people are 'protecting' each other with partial truths. Map that situation the same way, showing who knows what and who's being kept in the dark.
Consider:
- •Notice how protective lies often protect the secret-keeper more than the person being 'shielded'
- •Consider what each person loses when they don't have complete information
- •Think about the emotional cost of carrying secrets versus sharing difficult truths
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone tried to protect you by hiding something important, or when you did this for someone else. What were the real consequences of that choice?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: The Strike Explained
With the terrible truth now in the open, Margaret must navigate the delicate balance of caring for her dying mother while shielding her father from knowledge that could destroy him. But keeping such a devastating secret may prove more challenging than she imagined.




