Summary
When the Community Turns Against You
Noli Me Tángere by José Rizal
The arrested men are loaded onto a cart for transport to Manila, and the town erupts in grief and rage. Families of the prisoners gather outside the jail, desperate and heartbroken. Doray clutches her baby, wondering why he should live without a father. Capitana Maria watches silently as her twin sons are taken away. But the crowd's sorrow quickly transforms into fury—directed not at the authorities, but at Ibarra. The townspeople blame him for starting the rebellion that destroyed their families. As the cart rolls through town, people throw stones and curse him. 'You're a coward!' they shout. 'Accursed be your family's gold!' Even former friends hide indoors rather than show support. Ibarra, now bound at his own request to share the prisoners' fate, endures the assault without complaint. He sees the smoking ruins of his ancestral home and finally breaks down, realizing he has lost everything—country, home, love, friends, and future. From a distance, the old philosopher Tasio watches the procession with his failing strength, then slowly makes his way home. The next day, herders find him dead on his threshold. This chapter reveals how quickly communities can turn a crisis into a search for someone to blame, and how isolation becomes complete when public opinion shifts against you.
Coming Up in Chapter 59
As the prisoners are transported away, the story shifts to examine how personal ambitions and political calculations continue even amid tragedy. The final threads of this colonial drama begin to weave together.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
The Accursed Soon the news spread through the town that the prisoners were about to set out. At first it was heard with terror; afterward came the weeping and wailing. The families of the prisoners ran about in distraction, going from the convento to the barracks, from the barracks to the town hall, and finding no consolation anywhere, filled the air with cries and groans. The curate had shut himself up on a plea of illness; the alferez had increased the guards, who received the supplicating women with the butts of their rifles; the gobernadorcillo, at best a useless creature, seemed to be more foolish and more useless than ever. In front of the jail the women who still had strength enough ran to and fro, while those who had not sat down on the ground and called upon the names of their beloved. Although the sun beat down fiercely, not one of these unfortunates thought of going away. Doray, the erstwhile merry and happy wife of Don Filipo, wandered about dejectedly, carrying in her arms their infant son, both weeping. To the advice of friends that she go back home to avoid exposing her baby to an attack of fever, the disconsolate woman replied, "Why should he live, if he isn't going to have a father to rear him?" "Your husband is innocent. Perhaps he'll come back." "Yes, after we're all dead!" Capitana Tinay wept and called upon her son Antonio. The courageous Capitana Maria gazed silently toward the small grating behind which were her twin-boys, her only sons. There was present also the mother-in-law of the pruner of coco-palms, but she was not weeping; instead, she paced back and forth, gesticulating with uplifted arms, and haranguing the crowd: "Did you ever see anything like it? To arrest my Andong, to shoot at him, to put him in the stocks, to take him to the capital, and only because--because he had a new pair of pantaloons! This calls for vengeance! The civil-guards are committing abuses! I swear that if I ever again catch one of them in my garden, as has often happened, I'll chop him up, I'll chop him up, or else--let him try to chop me up!" Few persons, however, joined in the protests of the Mussulmanish mother-in-law. "Don Crisostomo is to blame for all this," sighed a woman. The schoolmaster was also in the crowd, wandering about bewildered. Ñor Juan did not rub his hands, nor was he carrying his rule and plumb-bob; he was dressed in black, for he had heard the bad news and, true to his habit of looking upon the future as already assured, was in mourning for Ibarra's death. At two o'clock in the afternoon an open cart drawn by two oxen stopped in front of the town hall. This was at once set upon by the people, who attempted to unhitch the oxen and destroy it. "Don't do that!" said Capitana Maria. "Do you want to make them walk?" This...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Scapegoating
Communities in crisis redirect their anger from powerful, untouchable sources toward visible, vulnerable individuals.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when groups redirect legitimate anger toward convenient targets instead of actual power sources.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when people blame the messenger instead of the message sender—watch for anger flowing downward toward the vulnerable, not upward toward the powerful.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Scapegoating
When a community blames one person for all their problems, even when the real causes are much more complex. The townspeople turn on Ibarra because it's easier than facing the corrupt system that actually destroyed their families.
Modern Usage:
We see this when people blame immigrants for job losses instead of looking at corporate outsourcing, or when a workplace crisis gets pinned on one employee.
Colonial justice
A legal system designed to protect the colonizers, not deliver actual justice. The Spanish authorities arrest innocent Filipinos to show power, while the real conspirators often escape punishment.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how wealthy defendants get better legal representation and lighter sentences than poor defendants for the same crimes.
Mob mentality
When grief and fear turn a crowd into something dangerous. Individual people who might normally be reasonable become part of a group that throws stones and curses at someone they once respected.
Modern Usage:
We see this in online pile-ons where thousands attack someone based on incomplete information, or when peaceful protests turn destructive.
Social exile
When someone becomes so unpopular that even former friends won't associate with them publicly. Ibarra's supporters hide indoors rather than risk being seen as sympathetic to him.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone gets 'canceled' and their friends distance themselves to protect their own reputations.
Convento
The priest's residence and center of religious power in Spanish colonial towns. When the curate shuts himself in the convento claiming illness, he's avoiding responsibility for the crisis.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how powerful people often become 'unavailable' when there's a scandal or crisis they helped create.
Gobernadorcillo
A local Filipino official under Spanish rule, often powerless to actually help his own people. He's described as 'useless' because he has no real authority to stop the injustice.
Modern Usage:
Like middle managers who can't make real decisions or local politicians who have to follow orders from higher up.
Characters in This Chapter
Ibarra
Fallen protagonist
Once the town's golden boy, now bound and blamed for everyone's suffering. He watches his ancestral home burn and realizes he's lost everything - his country, his love, his friends, his future.
Modern Equivalent:
The whistleblower who gets destroyed for exposing corruption
Doray
Grieving wife
Don Filipo's wife, once happy and carefree, now wandering with her baby asking why her child should live without a father. She represents how political upheaval destroys ordinary families.
Modern Equivalent:
The military spouse wondering how to raise kids alone after deployment goes wrong
Capitana Maria
Stoic mother
Watches silently as her twin sons are taken away. Her quiet strength contrasts with the wailing of other mothers, showing different ways people handle devastating loss.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who stays strong on the outside while watching their kids struggle with addiction or legal trouble
Don Filipo
Imprisoned leader
Former town leader now chained in the cart, leaving behind his wife and infant son. His arrest shows how the Spanish target natural leaders to prevent organized resistance.
Modern Equivalent:
The union organizer who gets fired and blacklisted
Tasio
Dying philosopher
The old philosopher watches the procession with his failing strength, then goes home to die. His death symbolizes the end of wisdom and learning in a community torn apart by violence.
Modern Equivalent:
The retired teacher who sees their community falling apart and feels powerless to help
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Why should he live, if he isn't going to have a father to rear him?"
Context: She's carrying her baby while watching her husband being taken to prison
This heartbreaking question shows how political violence destroys not just the present but the future. Doray can't imagine hope for her son in a world where good men are destroyed.
In Today's Words:
What's the point if his dad won't be there to raise him?
"You're a coward! Accursed be your family's gold!"
Context: Townspeople shouting at Ibarra as he passes in the cart
The crowd blames Ibarra's wealth and privilege for their suffering, not understanding that he's also a victim of the same corrupt system. Their anger is misdirected but understandable.
In Today's Words:
This is all your fault, rich boy!
"Yes, after we're all dead!"
Context: Responding to friends who say her husband might return because he's innocent
Doray understands what others won't admit - that innocence doesn't matter in a corrupt system. She knows her husband won't survive long enough to come home.
In Today's Words:
Yeah right, by the time he gets out, we'll all be gone!
Thematic Threads
Betrayal
In This Chapter
The townspeople turn against Ibarra despite his efforts to help them, choosing to blame him rather than face the real sources of their suffering
Development
Evolved from personal betrayals to community-wide abandonment
In Your Life:
You might experience this when colleagues blame you for company problems you tried to solve.
Isolation
In This Chapter
Ibarra becomes completely alone as former friends hide indoors and the community actively attacks him
Development
Progressed from social exclusion to total abandonment and hostility
In Your Life:
You might feel this when taking an unpopular stand at work or in your family.
Class
In This Chapter
The crowd specifically curses Ibarra's family wealth, revealing resentment about economic privilege during their suffering
Development
Class tensions now explode into open hostility and blame
In Your Life:
You might see this when economic stress makes people resent anyone who seems better off.
Loss
In This Chapter
Ibarra loses everything—home, community, love, future—while watching his ancestral house burn
Development
Individual losses have accumulated into total devastation
In Your Life:
You might experience this when a major life change strips away multiple sources of identity at once.
Death
In This Chapter
Tasio dies alone after witnessing the community's destruction, symbolizing the death of wisdom and reason
Development
Death now represents the end of hope and rational discourse
In Your Life:
You might feel this when the voices of reason in your workplace or community are silenced or ignored.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why do the townspeople blame Ibarra instead of the Spanish authorities who actually arrested their family members?
analysis • surface - 2
What makes someone an easy target for blame when a community is hurting?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen people blame the messenger instead of addressing the real problem?
application • medium - 4
How would you protect yourself if you were trying to help but the community turned against you?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how fear and powerlessness affect our judgment?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Real Power Structure
Think of a situation where people are angry about a problem in your workplace, school, or community. Draw two columns: 'Who Gets Blamed' and 'Who Actually Has Power.' Fill in both sides, then identify the gap between where anger goes and where change could actually happen.
Consider:
- •Notice how blame often flows downward to people with less power
- •Consider why it feels safer to blame certain people over others
- •Think about what would happen if anger was directed at the real decision-makers
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were blamed for something beyond your control, or when you joined others in blaming someone who was just the messenger. What was really happening underneath the surface anger?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 59: When Fear Rules the Streets
Moving forward, we'll examine rumors and fear can destroy communities faster than any actual threat, and understand people in power often sacrifice others to protect themselves. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.