An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2024 words)
Buon Dí Si Conosce Da Mattina [137]
Early the next morning the report spread through the town that many
lights had been seen in the cemetery on the previous night. The leader
of the Venerable Tertiary Order spoke of lighted candles, of their
shape and size, and, although he could not fix the exact number, had
counted more than twenty. Sister Sipa, of the Brotherhood of the Holy
Rosary, could not bear the thought that a member of a rival order
should alone boast of having seen this divine marvel, so she, even
though she did not live near the place, had heard cries and groans,
and even thought she recognized by their voices certain persons with
whom she, in other times,--but out of Christian charity she not only
forgave them but prayed for them and would keep their names secret,
for all of which she was declared on the spot to be a saint. Sister
Rufa was not so keen of hearing, but she could not suffer that Sister
Sipa had heard so much and she nothing, so she related a dream in
which there had appeared before her many souls--not only of the
dead but even of the living--souls in torment who begged for a part
of those indulgences of hers which were so carefully recorded and
treasured. She could furnish names to the families interested and
only asked for a few alms to succor the Pope in his needs. A little
fellow, a herder, who dared to assert that he had seen nothing more
than one light and two men in salakots had difficulty in escaping
with mere slaps and scoldings. Vainly he swore to it; there were his
carabaos with him and could verify his statement. "Do you pretend
to know more than the Warden and the Sisters, paracmason, [138]
heretic?" he was asked amid angry looks. The curate went up into the
pulpit and preached about purgatory so fervently that the pesos again
flowed forth from their hiding-places to pay for masses.
But let us leave the suffering souls and listen to the conversation
between Don Filipo and old Tasio in the lonely home of the latter. The
Sage, or Lunatic, was sick, having been for days unable to leave his
bed, prostrated by a malady that was rapidly growing worse.
"Really, I don't know whether to congratulate you or not that your
resignation has been accepted. Formerly, when the gobernadorcillo so
shamelessly disregarded the will of the majority, it was right for
you to tender it, but now that you are engaged in a contest with the
Civil Guard it's not quite proper. In time of war you ought to remain
at your post."
"Yes, but not when the general sells himself," answered Don
Filipo. "You know that on the following morning the gobernadorcillo
liberated the soldiers that I had succeeded in arresting and refused
to take any further action. Without the consent of my superior officer
I could do nothing."
"You alone, nothing; but with the rest, much. You should have
taken advantage of this opportunity to set an example to the other
towns. Above the ridiculous authority of the gobernadorcillo are the
rights of the people. It was the beginning of a good lesson and you
have neglected it."
"But what could I have done against the representative of the
interests? Here you have Señor Ibarra, he has bowed before the beliefs
of the crowd. Do you think that he believes in excommunications?"
"You are not in the same fix. Señor Ibarra is trying to sow the good
seed, and to do so he must bend himself and make what use he can of
the material at hand. Your mission was to stir things up, and for that
purpose initiative and force are required. Besides, the fight should
not be considered as merely against the gobernadorcillo. The principle
ought to be, against him who makes wrong use of his authority,
against him who disturbs the public peace, against him who fails in
his duty. You would not have been alone, for the country is not the
same now that it was twenty years ago."
"Do you think so?" asked Don Filipo.
"Don't you feel it?" rejoined the old man, sitting up in his bed. "Ah,
that is because you haven't seen the past, you haven't studied the
effect of European immigration, of the coming of new books, and
of the movement of our youth to Europe. Examine and compare these
facts. It is true that the Royal and Pontifical University of Santo
Tomas, with its most sapient faculty, still exists and that some
intelligences are yet exercised in formulating distinctions and in
penetrating the subtleties of scholasticism; but where will you now
find the metaphysical youth of our days, with their archaic education,
who tortured their brains and died in full pursuit of sophistries
in some corner of the provinces, without ever having succeeded in
understanding the attributes of being, or solving the problem of
essence and existence, those lofty concepts that made us forget
what was essential,--our own existence and our own individuality? Look
at the youth of today! Full of enthusiasm at the view of a wider
horizon, they study history, mathematics, geography, literature,
physical sciences, languages--all subjects that in our times we heard
mentioned with horror, as though they were heresies. The greatest
free-thinker of my day declared them inferior to the classifications of
Aristotle and the laws of the syllogism. Man has at last comprehended
that he is man; he has given up analyzing his God and searching into
the imperceptible, into what he has not seen; he has given up framing
laws for the phantasms of his brain; he comprehends that his heritage
is the vast world, dominion over which is within his reach; weary of
his useless and presumptuous toil, he lowers his head and examines what
surrounds him. See how poets are now springing up among us! The Muses
of Nature are gradually opening up their treasures to us and begin
to smile in encouragement on our efforts; the experimental sciences
have already borne their first-fruits; time only is lacking for their
development. The lawyers of today are being trained in the new forms of
the philosophy of law, some of them begin to shine in the midst of the
shadows which surround our courts of justice, indicating a change in
the course of affairs. Hear how the youth talk, visit the centers of
learning! Other names resound within the walls of the schools, there
where we heard only those of St. Thomas, Suarez, Amat, Sanchez, [139]
and others who were the idols of our times. In vain do the friars cry
out from the pulpits against our demoralization, as the fish-venders
cry out against the cupidity of their customers, disregarding the
fact that their wares are stale and unserviceable! In vain do the
conventos extend their ramifications to check the new current. The
gods are going! The roots of the tree may weaken the plants that
support themselves under it, but they cannot take away life from
those other beings, which, like birds, are soaring toward the sky."
The Sage spoke with animation, his eyes gleamed.
"Still, the new seed is small," objected Don Filipo incredulously. "If
all enter upon the progress we purchase so dearly, it may be stifled."
"Stifled! Who will stifle it? Man, that weak dwarf, stifle progress,
the powerful child of time and action? When has he been able to do
so? Bigotry, the gibbet, the stake, by endeavoring to stifle it,
have hurried it along. E pur si muove, [140] said Galileo, when
the Dominicans forced him to declare that the earth does not move,
and the same statement might be applied to human progress. Some wills
are broken down, some individuals sacrificed, but that is of little
import; progress continues on its way, and from the blood of those
who fall new and vigorous offspring is born. See, the press itself,
however backward it may wish to be, is taking a step forward. The
Dominicans themselves do not escape the operation of this law, but are
imitating the Jesuits, their irreconcilable enemies. They hold fiestas
in their cloisters, they erect little theaters, they compose poems,
because, as they are not devoid of intelligence in spite of believing
in the fifteenth century, they realize that the Jesuits are right,
and they will still take part in the future of the younger peoples
that they have reared."
"So, according to you, the Jesuits keep up with progress?" asked Don
Filipo in wonder. "Why, then, are they opposed in Europe?"
"I will answer you like an old scholastic," replied the Sage, lying
down again and resuming his jesting expression. "There are three
ways in which one may accompany the course of progress: in front of,
beside, or behind it. The first guide it, the second suffer themselves
to be carried along with it, and the last are dragged after it and to
these last the Jesuits belong. They would like to direct it, but as
they see that it is strong and has other tendencies, they capitulate,
preferring to follow rather than to be crushed or left alone among the
shadows by the wayside. Well now, we in the Philippines are moving
along at least three centuries behind the car of progress; we are
barely beginning to emerge from the Middle Ages. Hence the Jesuits,
who are reactionary in Europe, when seen from our point of view,
represent progress. To them the Philippines owes her dawning system
of instruction in the natural sciences, the soul of the nineteenth
century, as she owed to the Dominicans scholasticism, already dead
in spite of Leo XIII, for there is no Pope who can revive what common
sense has judged and condemned.
"But where are we getting to?" he asked with a change of tone. "Ah,
we were speaking of the present condition of the Philippines. Yes,
we are now entering upon a period of strife, or rather, I should say
that you are, for my generation belongs to the night, we are passing
away. This strife is between the past, which seizes and strives
with curses to cling to the tottering feudal castle, and the future,
whose song of triumph may be heard from afar amid the splendors of the
coming dawn, bringing the message of Good-News from other lands. Who
will fall and be buried in the moldering ruins?"
The old man paused. Noticing that Don Filipo was gazing at him
thoughtfully, he said with a smile, "I can almost guess what you
are thinking."
"Really?"
"You are thinking of how easily I may be mistaken," was the answer
with a sad smile. "Today I am feverish, and I am not infallible: homo
sum et nihil humani a me alienum puto, [141] said Terence, and if
at any time one is allowed to dream, why not dream pleasantly in the
last hours of life? And after all, I have lived only in dreams! You
are right, it is a dream! Our youths think only of love affairs and
dissipations; they expend more time and work harder to deceive and
dishonor a maiden than in thinking about the welfare of their country;
our women, in order to care for the house and family of God, neglect
their own: our men are active only in vice and heroic only in shame;
childhood develops amid ignorance and routine, youth lives its best
years without ideals, and a sterile manhood serves only as an example
for corrupting youth. Gladly do I die! Claudite iam rivos, pueri!"
[142]
"Don't you want some medicine?" asked Don Filipo in order to change
the course of the conversation, which had darkened the old man's face.
"The dying need no medicines; you who remain need them. Tell Don
Crisostomo to come and see me tomorrow, for I have some important
things to say to him. In a few days I am going away. The Philippines
is in darkness!"
After a few moments more of talk, Don Filipo left the sick man's house,
grave and thoughtful.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When truth threatens existing power or profit structures, institutions systematically replace it with more profitable or comfortable narratives while silencing truth-tellers.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when organizations replace inconvenient truths with profitable stories.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when workplace problems get reframed as opportunities, or when simple explanations get replaced with dramatic ones that serve someone's interests.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"And yet it moves"
Context: Tasio references Galileo's famous words when discussing the unstoppable progress of knowledge and enlightenment in the Philippines
This quote captures the central tension of the novel - that truth and progress will ultimately prevail despite institutional resistance. Tasio sees the intellectual awakening of Filipino youth as an unstoppable force, like the earth's rotation that the Church tried to deny.
In Today's Words:
The truth is going to come out no matter how hard they try to stop it
"The youth no longer study scholasticism"
Context: Tasio explains to Don Filipo how the new generation is abandoning medieval learning for modern sciences and literature
This represents the fundamental shift Rizal saw happening in Philippine society - from blind acceptance of authority to critical thinking. It's both hopeful and threatening to the colonial system that depends on intellectual submission.
In Today's Words:
Kids today aren't just memorizing what they're told - they're actually learning to think for themselves
"Out of Christian charity she not only forgave them but prayed for them"
Context: Describing Sister Sipa's claim about recognizing voices of the dead while positioning herself as saintly
Rizal exposes the hypocrisy of performative piety - how people use religion to gain social status while actually being judgmental and self-serving. The irony is thick as she claims charity while gossiping.
In Today's Words:
She acted all holy and forgiving, but really she was just showing off and talking trash about people
Thematic Threads
Truth vs. Profit
In This Chapter
Religious leaders turn the cemetery incident into fundraising opportunities with supernatural explanations while silencing the herder's simple truth
Development
Builds on earlier themes of institutional corruption, now showing how truth itself becomes a commodity
In Your Life:
You might see this when your workplace spins layoffs as 'rightsizing' while punishing anyone who mentions the real financial mismanagement
Intellectual Awakening
In This Chapter
Tasio describes young Filipinos abandoning medieval scholasticism for modern sciences and critical thinking as an unstoppable force
Development
Introduced here as the hopeful counterforce to institutional corruption
In Your Life:
You experience this when you start questioning systems you once accepted without thinking—whether it's healthcare protocols, family traditions, or workplace policies
Courage vs. Resignation
In This Chapter
Tasio criticizes Don Filipo for resigning his position just when courage was needed most to fight corruption
Development
Continues the theme of moral responsibility from earlier chapters, now focusing on the cost of giving up
In Your Life:
You face this choice when deciding whether to speak up about problems at work or in your community, knowing it might cost you personally
Generational Change
In This Chapter
Tasio sees intellectual progress happening across generations despite institutional resistance, comparing it to Galileo's defiant truth
Development
Expands on earlier themes of social transformation to show how change actually occurs over time
In Your Life:
You might notice this in how your children question things you accepted, or how your own thinking has evolved beyond what your parents believed
Hope vs. Despair
In This Chapter
Tasio oscillates between optimism about intellectual awakening and despair over corruption, youth vice, and social decay
Development
Deepens the emotional complexity introduced in earlier chapters about the psychological cost of seeing clearly
In Your Life:
You experience this tension when you see both progress and setbacks in areas you care about—your workplace improving in some ways while getting worse in others
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why do the religious leaders compete to claim the most dramatic supernatural visions about the cemetery incident, while the herder who reports seeing two men gets shouted down?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Tasio mean when he criticizes Don Filipo for resigning his position 'just when courage was needed most'? How does timing affect leadership effectiveness?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today—truth-tellers getting silenced while dramatic storytellers get platforms and resources?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Don Filipo's position, facing corruption and knowing that speaking up might destroy your ability to help from within, how would you decide when to stay and when to leave?
application • deep - 5
Tasio sees both hope in young people embracing modern ideas and despair at the corruption around him. What does this tension between progress and resistance teach us about how change actually happens?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Follow the Money Trail
Think of a situation in your life where different versions of the same story compete for attention—at work, in your family, or in your community. Map out who benefits from each version of the story. Who gets resources, attention, or power from their narrative? Who gets silenced or dismissed? Write down what you discover about the connection between profit and 'truth.'
Consider:
- •Look for who gains money, status, or comfort from each version
- •Notice who gets labeled as 'negative' or 'troublemaker' for telling inconvenient truths
- •Consider how timing affects which story wins—some truths are profitable only after circumstances change
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to choose between speaking an uncomfortable truth and maintaining peace. What factors influenced your decision, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 54: When Allies Become Enemies
Tasio has urgent matters to discuss with Crisostomo before his time runs out. What final wisdom will the dying philosopher share, and how will it shape the coming confrontation?




