Summary
Dorothea finally learns the shocking truth about her late husband's will from her sister Celia. Casaubon has added a codicil stating that if Dorothea marries Will Ladislaw, she will lose her inheritance entirely. This revelation hits Dorothea like a thunderbolt, forcing her to confront the reality that her husband suspected her feelings for Will and tried to control her from beyond the grave. The discovery transforms everything - her view of her marriage, her understanding of Casaubon's character, and most disturbingly, her own feelings toward Will. She realizes that Casaubon's jealous manipulation has actually awakened emotions she never knew she had. Meanwhile, she must also deal with practical matters like choosing a new clergyman for the Lowick living. Dr. Lydgate recommends Mr. Farebrother over the supposedly 'apostolic' Mr. Tyke, describing Farebrother as a genuinely good man hampered by poverty and a gambling habit. The chapter explores how attempts to control others often reveal more about the controller's insecurities than the controlled person's intentions. Casaubon's codicil, meant to prevent scandal, actually creates the very situation he feared by forcing Dorothea to examine her true feelings. The dead husband's 'cold grasp' on his widow's life begins to slip as she starts to see their marriage clearly for the first time.
Coming Up in Chapter 51
Dorothea must now navigate the complex social and emotional aftermath of these revelations, while the question of Will Ladislaw's future - and her own feelings toward him - becomes increasingly urgent.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
CHAPTER L. “This Loller here wol precilen us somewhat.” “Nay by my father’s soule! that schal he nat,” Sayde the Schipman, ‘here schal he not preche, We schal no gospel glosen here ne teche. We leven all in the gret God,’ quod he. He wolden sowen some diffcultee.”—_Canterbury Tales_. Dorothea had been safe at Freshitt Hall nearly a week before she had asked any dangerous questions. Every morning now she sat with Celia in the prettiest of up-stairs sitting-rooms, opening into a small conservatory—Celia all in white and lavender like a bunch of mixed violets, watching the remarkable acts of the baby, which were so dubious to her inexperienced mind that all conversation was interrupted by appeals for their interpretation made to the oracular nurse. Dorothea sat by in her widow’s dress, with an expression which rather provoked Celia, as being much too sad; for not only was baby quite well, but really when a husband had been so dull and troublesome while he lived, and besides that had—well, well! Sir James, of course, had told Celia everything, with a strong representation how important it was that Dorothea should not know it sooner than was inevitable. But Mr. Brooke had been right in predicting that Dorothea would not long remain passive where action had been assigned to her; she knew the purport of her husband’s will made at the time of their marriage, and her mind, as soon as she was clearly conscious of her position, was silently occupied with what she ought to do as the owner of Lowick Manor with the patronage of the living attached to it. One morning when her uncle paid his usual visit, though with an unusual alacrity in his manner which he accounted for by saying that it was now pretty certain Parliament would be dissolved forthwith, Dorothea said— “Uncle, it is right now that I should consider who is to have the living at Lowick. After Mr. Tucker had been provided for, I never heard my husband say that he had any clergyman in his mind as a successor to himself. I think I ought to have the keys now and go to Lowick to examine all my husband’s papers. There may be something that would throw light on his wishes.” “No hurry, my dear,” said Mr. Brooke, quietly. “By-and-by, you know, you can go, if you like. But I cast my eyes over things in the desks and drawers—there was nothing—nothing but deep subjects, you know—besides the will. Everything can be done by-and-by. As to the living, I have had an application for interest already—I should say rather good. Mr. Tyke has been strongly recommended to me—I had something to do with getting him an appointment before. An apostolic man, I believe—the sort of thing that would suit you, my dear.” “I should like to have fuller knowledge about him, uncle, and judge for myself, if Mr. Casaubon has not left any expression of his wishes. He has perhaps made some...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Control Backfire
Attempts to control others through manipulation or coercion often create the exact outcome the controller was trying to prevent.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone's controlling behavior reveals their own insecurities rather than your untrustworthiness.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone tries to control your choices through guilt, threats, or surveillance—ask yourself what they're really afraid of losing.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Codicil
A legal addition to a will that changes or adds to the original terms. In this chapter, Casaubon added one after his marriage to control Dorothea's future choices. It's like a last-minute power grab from beyond the grave.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in prenups with cheating clauses or parents who threaten to cut kids out of wills over life choices.
Widow's portion
The money and property a woman inherited when her husband died, which was often her only financial security. Dorothea's inheritance comes with strings attached that reveal her husband's jealousy and need for control.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how divorce settlements or life insurance policies can be used as leverage to control someone's behavior even after a relationship ends.
Church living
A paid position as a parish priest that came with a house and income. These positions were often given based on connections rather than merit. Dorothea must choose who gets the Lowick living.
Modern Usage:
Like any job where the hiring is based on who you know rather than qualifications, or board positions handed out as favors.
Apostolic
Claiming to follow the original apostles' example of simple, pure Christianity. Mr. Tyke is described this way, but Eliot suggests such claims often mask less noble motives.
Modern Usage:
Anyone who claims to be more righteous or pure than others, like social media influencers who preach wellness while selling overpriced supplements.
Oracular
Speaking with mysterious authority, like the ancient Greek oracles who gave cryptic prophecies. Here it describes how the baby's nurse speaks with unquestionable authority about childcare.
Modern Usage:
Like parenting experts, life coaches, or anyone who speaks with absolute certainty about things that are actually complicated.
Cold grasp
Eliot's metaphor for how the dead can still control the living through wills, debts, or emotional manipulation. Casaubon's codicil is his attempt to control Dorothea from the grave.
Modern Usage:
When someone's influence continues after they're gone or out of your life - like an ex who still controls you through guilt or shared finances.
Characters in This Chapter
Dorothea
Protagonist discovering truth
Finally learns about her husband's manipulative codicil and begins to understand both his jealousy and her own suppressed feelings for Will. The revelation forces her to see her marriage clearly for the first time.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman who discovers her husband's been tracking her phone and realizes the relationship was never what she thought
Celia
Sister and truth-teller
Reveals the shocking truth about Casaubon's codicil to Dorothea. She's been protecting her sister but finally decides she needs to know, despite Sir James's wishes.
Modern Equivalent:
The sister who finally tells you what everyone else has been saying behind your back
Casaubon
Dead controlling husband
Though dead, his codicil reveals his deep insecurity and jealousy. His attempt to control Dorothea from beyond the grave actually awakens the very feelings he feared.
Modern Equivalent:
The controlling partner whose jealousy and restrictions make you realize what you actually want
Dr. Lydgate
Advisor and voice of reason
Recommends Mr. Farebrother over Mr. Tyke for the church living, arguing that genuine goodness matters more than religious posturing. Represents practical wisdom over appearances.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who tells you to hire based on character rather than whoever talks the best game
Mr. Farebrother
Flawed but genuine candidate
The clergyman Lydgate recommends despite his gambling habit and financial troubles. Represents the idea that real goodness comes with human flaws, not perfect appearances.
Modern Equivalent:
The job candidate with a messy past but genuine heart versus the one with a perfect resume but questionable motives
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The dead hand had been removed, but the effect of its grasp was still there."
Context: Describing how Casaubon's codicil continues to control Dorothea even after his death
This powerful metaphor shows how people can manipulate us from beyond the grave through legal documents, guilt, or ingrained patterns. The 'dead hand' represents all the ways the past keeps its grip on us.
In Today's Words:
Even though he was gone, his control freak moves were still messing with her life.
"It was not in Dorothea's nature to prolong the torment of suspense."
Context: Explaining why Dorothea must know the truth about the codicil
This reveals Dorothea's character - she faces difficult truths head-on rather than living in denial. It's both her strength and what makes her vulnerable to being hurt.
In Today's Words:
She wasn't the type to just sit there wondering - she needed to know, even if it hurt.
"He had been trying to imagine what sort of a woman she was, and how far he could trust her."
Context: Describing Casaubon's mindset when creating the codicil
This shows the tragic irony of their marriage - instead of getting to know his wife, Casaubon spent his time suspicious and scheming. His lack of trust created the very situation he feared.
In Today's Words:
Instead of actually talking to her, he was playing detective and planning his next move.
Thematic Threads
Control
In This Chapter
Casaubon's posthumous codicil attempts to control Dorothea's future choices through financial threat
Development
Evolved from his living attempts to control her intellectual development and social interactions
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone uses money, guilt, or threats to force your decisions rather than earning your genuine agreement.
Awakening
In This Chapter
Dorothea realizes her true feelings for Will only after learning of the codicil designed to prevent them
Development
Building from her gradual disillusionment with Casaubon throughout their marriage
In Your Life:
You might discover your true desires only when someone tries to forbid them or make them impossible.
Class
In This Chapter
The codicil reveals class-based fears about Dorothea marrying 'beneath' her station
Development
Continues the book's exploration of how class anxiety drives behavior and relationships
In Your Life:
You might face family pressure about who you date, marry, or associate with based on social or economic status.
Truth
In This Chapter
Dorothea finally sees her marriage clearly after learning about Casaubon's manipulative final act
Development
Culminates her slow recognition of her husband's true character throughout the book
In Your Life:
You might suddenly understand a relationship's true nature when faced with evidence of hidden manipulation or control.
Legacy
In This Chapter
Casaubon tries to extend his influence beyond death through his will's conditions
Development
Introduced here as exploration of how the dead attempt to control the living
In Your Life:
You might feel controlled by family expectations, traditions, or guilt about what deceased relatives would have wanted.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Casaubon's codicil reveal about his true feelings toward Dorothea and Will?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Casaubon's attempt to control Dorothea from beyond the grave actually backfire?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of control creating the exact outcome someone was trying to prevent in modern relationships or workplaces?
application • medium - 4
If you were Dorothea's friend, how would you advise her to handle this situation without letting Casaubon's manipulation control her choices?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the difference between genuine influence and manipulative control?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Control Backfire
Think of a situation where someone tried to control you or someone you know through threats, guilt, or manipulation. Map out what they were trying to prevent, what methods they used, and what actually happened as a result. Then identify the pattern: how did their controlling behavior create the very outcome they feared?
Consider:
- •Focus on the controller's underlying fear or insecurity that drove their behavior
- •Notice how the controlling behavior revealed their weakness rather than their strength
- •Consider how the controlled person's response was shaped by recognizing the manipulation
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt tempted to control someone else's choices. What were you really afraid of losing? How might you have built genuine influence instead of trying to force an outcome?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 51: The Political Disaster
As the story unfolds, you'll explore public humiliation can reveal character strengths and weaknesses, while uncovering staying in difficult situations sometimes requires deeper motivations than pride. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.