Summary
Seneca writes to Lucilius with the unmistakable pride of a mentor watching his student flourish. He compares himself to a farmer delighting in his tree's fruit or a shepherd pleased with his growing flock—but his joy runs deeper because he's helped shape a human mind. Seneca claims ownership of Lucilius's growth, not in a possessive way, but with the satisfaction of someone who saw potential and helped nurture it into reality. He describes how he initially had to push and prod Lucilius forward, but now they're running the race together, each encouraging the other. When Lucilius asks what more Seneca wants from him, the philosopher's answer cuts to the heart of personal transformation: 'The will is still mine.' Seneca explains that willpower isn't just half the battle—it's almost everything, especially when it comes to matters of the soul. He defines a truly good person as someone who is complete and finished, someone whom no external pressure or circumstance can corrupt. He sees this potential in Lucilius, but warns that consistency is crucial. All of a person's actions and words must harmonize with each other, stamped from the same moral mold. If someone's behavior is inconsistent, Seneca warns, their soul becomes crooked. This letter captures the beautiful dynamic of mentorship where teacher and student eventually become peers, each inspiring the other's continued growth.
Coming Up in Chapter 35
Seneca reveals that his intense focus on Lucilius's development isn't purely altruistic—he has his own interests at heart. The next letter explores how true friendship can only exist between minds that understand each other deeply.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 435 words)
L←etter 33. On the futility of learning maximsMoral letters to Luciliusby Seneca, translated by Richard Mott GummereLetter 34. On a promising pupilLetter 35. On the friendship of kindred minds→482920Moral letters to Lucilius — Letter 34. On a promising pupilRichard Mott GummereSeneca ​ XXXIV. ON A PROMISING PUPIL 1. I grow in spirit and leap for joy and shake off my years and my blood runs warm again, whenever I understand, from your actions and your letters, how far you have outdone yourself; for as to the ordinary man, you left him in the rear long ago. If the farmer is pleased when his tree develops so that it bears fruit, if the shepherd takes pleasure in the increase of his flocks, if every man regards his pupil as though he discerned in him his own early manhood,—what, then, do you think are the feelings of those who have trained a mind and moulded a young idea, when they see it suddenly grown to maturity? 2. I claim you for myself; you are my handiwork. When I saw your abilities, I laid my hand upon you,[1] I exhorted you, I applied the goad and did not permit you to march lazily, but roused you continually. And now I do the same; but by this time I am cheering on one who is in the race and so in turn cheers me on.  ​3. “What else do you want of me, then?” you ask; “the will is still mine.” Well, the will in this case is almost everything, and not merely the half, as in the proverb “A task once begun is half done.” It is more than half, for the matter of which we speak is determined by the soul.[2] Hence it is that the larger part of goodness is the will to become good. You know what I mean by a good man? One who is complete, finished,—whom no constraint or need can render bad. 4. I see such a person in you, if only you go steadily on and bend to your task, and see to it that all your actions and words harmonize and correspond with each other and are stamped in the same mould. If a man’s acts are out of harmony, his soul is crooked. Farewell.    ↑ A reference to the act (iniectio) by which a Roman took possession of a thing belonging to him, e.g., a runaway slave,—without a decision of the court. ↑ i.e., the proverb may apply to tasks which a man performs with his hands, but it is an understatement when applied to the tasks of the soul.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Earned Authority
True authority comes from measurably improving others until they no longer need your direct guidance.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between authority that empowers others versus authority that creates dependence.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when leaders around you make others stronger versus when they keep people needing constant approval—the difference reveals their true motives.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Stoic Mentorship
A teaching relationship focused on developing wisdom, character, and emotional resilience rather than just academic knowledge. The mentor guides the student toward self-mastery and virtue through practical philosophy.
Modern Usage:
Like a life coach who doesn't just give advice but helps you build the mental tools to handle whatever life throws at you.
Will (Voluntas)
In Stoic philosophy, the will represents our power to choose our responses and attitudes. It's the one thing that remains completely under our control regardless of external circumstances.
Modern Usage:
Your mindset and attitude when facing challenges - the part of you that decides whether to give up or keep going.
Moral Consistency
Living according to the same principles in all situations, ensuring your actions and words align with your stated values. For Stoics, this consistency was essential for a well-lived life.
Modern Usage:
Being the same person whether your boss is watching or not, treating the janitor with the same respect as the CEO.
Handiwork (Opus)
Seneca's term for claiming responsibility for Lucilius's development, like an artist taking pride in their creation. It shows the deep investment mentors have in their students' growth.
Modern Usage:
When a trainer takes pride in their athlete's success, or a teacher beams when their former student achieves something great.
Applied Goad
A goad was a sharp stick used to motivate cattle. Seneca uses this metaphor for the necessary pressure and challenge a mentor provides to push a student beyond their comfort zone.
Modern Usage:
Tough love - when someone who cares about you refuses to let you settle for less than your potential.
Soul's Crookedness
Seneca's description of what happens when someone's behavior is inconsistent with their stated values. The soul becomes 'crooked' or warped, lacking integrity.
Modern Usage:
When someone talks about family values but never shows up for their kids, or preaches honesty but lies to get ahead.
Characters in This Chapter
Seneca
Proud mentor and teacher
Expresses deep satisfaction in Lucilius's growth and development. Claims ownership of his student's progress while acknowledging they now encourage each other as equals in the philosophical journey.
Modern Equivalent:
The veteran nurse who trained you and still checks in, beaming with pride at how far you've come
Lucilius
Advancing student and mentee
Has progressed from needing constant encouragement to becoming someone who can inspire his former teacher. Represents the successful outcome of dedicated mentorship and personal commitment to growth.
Modern Equivalent:
The former trainee who's now training others but still values their original mentor's guidance
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I claim you for myself; you are my handiwork."
Context: Seneca expresses his pride in Lucilius's development and takes credit for nurturing his growth
This reveals the deep investment mentors make in their students and the legitimate pride they feel in their success. It also shows how personal transformation often requires someone who believes in us before we believe in ourselves.
In Today's Words:
I'm taking credit for how amazing you've become - you're proof of what I can help people achieve.
"The will is still mine."
Context: Responding to Lucilius asking what more Seneca wants from him
This emphasizes that willpower and determination remain the most crucial elements in personal development. External guidance can only go so far - the real work happens through individual choice and commitment.
In Today's Words:
At the end of the day, it all comes down to whether you really want to change or not.
"If every man regards his pupil as though he discerned in him his own early manhood, what do you think are the feelings of those who have trained a mind?"
Context: Comparing his joy in Lucilius's growth to that of farmers and shepherds with their crops and flocks
This highlights how mentoring someone's character and mind creates a deeper satisfaction than other forms of nurturing. It suggests that helping someone become their best self is one of life's greatest rewards.
In Today's Words:
If people get excited watching their gardens grow, imagine how it feels to watch someone you've guided become an amazing person.
Thematic Threads
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Seneca celebrates Lucilius's transformation from student to peer, emphasizing how growth creates new dynamics in relationships
Development
Evolution from earlier focus on individual development to recognition that growth changes relationships
In Your Life:
You might notice how your own growth changes the power dynamics with family, friends, or coworkers
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
The mentor-student relationship evolving into mutual encouragement between equals
Development
Building on earlier letters about friendship to show how relationships can transform through shared growth
In Your Life:
You might see this in how your relationship with a boss, parent, or mentor shifts as you become more capable
Identity
In This Chapter
Seneca defines identity through consistency—a truly good person whose actions and words harmonize
Development
Deepening the earlier theme of authentic self-presentation with emphasis on internal consistency
In Your Life:
You might recognize when your actions don't match your stated values, creating internal conflict
Class
In This Chapter
Seneca takes pride in developing another person's character, showing how true worth comes from contribution to others
Development
Expanding beyond social status to demonstrate how real value comes from measurable impact on others
In Your Life:
You might find your sense of worth shifting from what you have to what you've helped others achieve
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The expectation that mentors should maintain superiority is challenged as Seneca celebrates becoming equals with Lucilius
Development
Contrasting with earlier discussions of social roles by showing authentic relationships transcend traditional hierarchies
In Your Life:
You might question whether you're maintaining artificial distance from people who could be peers
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Seneca describe his relationship with Lucilius changing over time, and what does this tell us about effective mentoring?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Seneca say 'The will is still mine' when Lucilius asks what more he wants from him, and what does this reveal about personal transformation?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about a boss, teacher, or mentor in your life. Do they create dependence or independence? How can you tell the difference?
application • medium - 4
Seneca warns that inconsistent behavior makes the soul 'crooked.' How would you apply this principle when dealing with difficult people at work or in your family?
application • deep - 5
What does this letter teach us about the difference between real authority and just having power over people?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Authority Audit
Think of someone in your life who has real authority over you—not just a title or position, but someone whose guidance you actually value and follow. Now think of someone who has power over you but lacks real authority. Write down three specific differences in how these two people interact with you and influence your behavior.
Consider:
- •Does this person make you stronger or more dependent on them?
- •How do you feel and behave when they're not around?
- •Do they push you forward or hold you back from growth?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to earn authority with someone (a child, coworker, or friend). What did you do differently than just demanding compliance? How did you know when you had truly earned their respect?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 35: Love vs. True Friendship
In the next chapter, you'll discover the crucial difference between loving someone and being their true friend, and learn personal growth creates the foundation for deeper relationships. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.