Summary
Jude's health is failing rapidly while living with Arabella, who openly resents having to care for an invalid husband. Their daily arguments reveal the bitter reality of their remarriage—she married him expecting a healthy provider, not a dying man. When Jude asks Arabella to write to Sue, requesting one final visit, she initially refuses but eventually agrees, demanding to supervise any meeting. However, Arabella never actually sends the letter, choosing instead to pacify Jude with false hope while protecting her own interests. When Jude realizes he's been deceived, he makes a desperate decision that nearly kills him—traveling alone in terrible weather to see Sue one last time. Their final meeting in the church at Marygreen is heartbreaking and revelatory. Sue admits her marriage to Phillotson is only nominal, that she still loves Jude, and that her religious conversion has been a form of self-torture. They share passionate kisses and Jude begs her to run away with him, calling both their remarriages acts of intoxication—his by gin, hers by religious fervor. But Sue, despite her obvious love and anguish, refuses to abandon what she sees as her moral duty. She sends Jude away into the storm, and he makes the grueling journey back to Christminster, his body pushed beyond its limits. This chapter shows how people can become trapped by their own choices and society's expectations, even when those choices are destroying them. It's about the terrible cost of denying authentic love in favor of duty, convention, or spite.
Coming Up in Chapter 51
Jude returns to Christminster barely alive, where Arabella waits on the platform. His desperate journey to see Sue may have been his final act of defiance against a world that has crushed his dreams.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Michaelmas came and passed, and Jude and his wife, who had lived but a short time in her father’s house after their remarriage, were in lodgings on the top floor of a dwelling nearer to the centre of the city. He had done a few days’ work during the two or three months since the event, but his health had been indifferent, and it was now precarious. He was sitting in an arm-chair before the fire, and coughed a good deal. “I’ve got a bargain for my trouble in marrying thee over again!” Arabella was saying to him. “I shall have to keep ’ee entirely—that’s what ’twill come to! I shall have to make black-pot and sausages, and hawk ’em about the street, all to support an invalid husband I’d no business to be saddled with at all. Why didn’t you keep your health, deceiving one like this? You were well enough when the wedding was!” “Ah, yes!” said he, laughing acridly. “I have been thinking of my foolish feeling about the pig you and I killed during our first marriage. I feel now that the greatest mercy that could be vouchsafed to me would be that something should serve me as I served that animal.” This was the sort of discourse that went on between them every day now. The landlord of the lodging, who had heard that they were a queer couple, had doubted if they were married at all, especially as he had seen Arabella kiss Jude one evening when she had taken a little cordial; and he was about to give them notice to quit, till by chance overhearing her one night haranguing Jude in rattling terms, and ultimately flinging a shoe at his head, he recognized the note of genuine wedlock; and concluding that they must be respectable, said no more. Jude did not get any better, and one day he requested Arabella, with considerable hesitation, to execute a commission for him. She asked him indifferently what it was. “To write to Sue.” “What in the name—do you want me to write to her for?” “To ask how she is, and if she’ll come to see me, because I’m ill, and should like to see her—once again.” “It is like you to insult a lawful wife by asking such a thing!” “It is just in order not to insult you that I ask you to do it. You know I love Sue. I don’t wish to mince the matter—there stands the fact: I love her. I could find a dozen ways of sending a letter to her without your knowledge. But I wish to be quite above-board with you, and with her husband. A message through you asking her to come is at least free from any odour of intrigue. If she retains any of her old nature at all, she’ll come.” “You’ve no respect for marriage whatever, or its rights and duties!” “What _does_ it matter what my opinions are—a wretch like me! Can...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of False Mercy - When Kindness Becomes Cruelty
When avoiding difficult truths in the name of kindness creates more suffering than honesty would cause.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone claims they're protecting you but are actually protecting themselves from your reaction.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone says they 'didn't want to worry you' or 'thought it was better if you didn't know'—ask yourself what they were really avoiding.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Invalid husband
A man who can't work or provide for his family due to illness or disability. In Victorian times, this meant financial ruin for most families since there were no safety nets. Women were expected to care for sick husbands regardless of the burden.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this when someone becomes the sole caregiver for a chronically ill partner, often leading to resentment and financial strain.
Remarriage
Getting married again after divorce or death of a spouse. In Hardy's time, divorce was rare and remarriage often happened for practical rather than romantic reasons - financial security, social respectability, or family pressure.
Modern Usage:
We still see people remarry for security rather than love, or rush into second marriages without addressing the issues that ended the first one.
Lodgings
Rented rooms in someone else's house, usually just a bedroom and shared facilities. This was how poor people lived in Victorian cities - cramped, temporary, with landlords who watched your every move and judged your respectability.
Modern Usage:
Similar to today's boarding houses, extended-stay motels, or renting a room in someone's home when you can't afford your own place.
Black-pot and sausages
Blood pudding and cheap meat products that working-class women made and sold on the street to survive. This was backbreaking, low-status work that barely paid enough to live on, but it was one of the few ways women could earn money.
Modern Usage:
Like today's gig economy jobs - food trucks, selling crafts online, or any hustle work people do to make ends meet.
Nominal marriage
A marriage that exists in name only, without physical intimacy or emotional connection. Victorian society valued the appearance of marriage over the reality, so couples often stayed together for show while living separate lives.
Modern Usage:
We see this in marriages where couples stay together for the kids, financial reasons, or social expectations but have no real relationship.
Religious conversion
Dramatically changing your religious beliefs, often as a response to trauma or guilt. In Victorian times, intense religious devotion was sometimes a way to punish yourself for past 'sins' or cope with unbearable circumstances.
Modern Usage:
Today people might throw themselves into extreme diets, wellness culture, or political movements as a way to cope with guilt or trauma.
Moral duty
What society tells you is right, even when it destroys your happiness. Victorian moral duty often meant staying in bad marriages, sacrificing personal desires, and following rules that served others' interests more than your own.
Modern Usage:
We still see people stay in toxic situations because they think it's 'the right thing to do' or worry about what others will think.
Characters in This Chapter
Jude
Dying protagonist
His health is failing and he's trapped in a loveless marriage with Arabella, who resents caring for him. He desperately wants to see Sue one last time and makes a dangerous journey that nearly kills him, showing how love can drive people to self-destructive acts.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who ruins their health chasing someone who's moved on
Arabella
Resentful wife
She openly admits she married Jude expecting a provider, not an invalid, and lies to him about contacting Sue. She represents people who marry for practical reasons and become bitter when those reasons disappear.
Modern Equivalent:
The spouse who married for security and becomes cruel when the money runs out
Sue
Conflicted former lover
She still loves Jude but refuses to leave her marriage to Phillotson, choosing duty over happiness. Her religious conversion is revealed as self-torture, showing how people punish themselves for past choices.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex who still has feelings but won't leave their current relationship
Phillotson
Absent husband
Though not physically present, his marriage to Sue is revealed as nominal - they live as strangers. He represents the hollow marriages people maintain for appearance's sake.
Modern Equivalent:
The husband who stays married on paper but lives a separate life
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I've got a bargain for my trouble in marrying thee over again!"
Context: She's complaining about having to care for sick Jude
This reveals the transactional nature of their remarriage. Arabella expected a healthy provider and feels cheated by getting a dying man instead. It shows how some marriages are business deals that turn bitter when the terms change.
In Today's Words:
What a raw deal I got remarrying you!
"I feel now that the greatest mercy that could be vouchsafed to me would be that something should serve me as I served that animal."
Context: He's wishing for death, comparing himself to a pig they once slaughtered
Jude sees death as mercy, showing how completely his spirit is broken. The pig reference connects to their first marriage's brutality and suggests he feels like livestock being used up by others.
In Today's Words:
I wish someone would put me out of my misery like we did that pig.
"We are acting by the letter; and the letter killeth!"
Context: He's arguing that following religious law is destroying their lives
This biblical reference shows how rigid adherence to rules can be more destructive than breaking them. Jude recognizes that their 'moral' choices are actually killing their souls and happiness.
In Today's Words:
Following the rules is destroying us!
Thematic Threads
Deception
In This Chapter
Arabella lies about sending the letter; Sue lies about her true feelings and motivations
Development
Evolved from earlier self-deception to deliberate deception of others
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself telling small lies to avoid difficult conversations that need to happen.
Duty
In This Chapter
Sue chooses perceived moral duty over authentic love, trapping herself and Jude in misery
Development
Intensified from earlier questioning of social expectations to rigid adherence despite personal cost
In Your Life:
You might stay in situations that destroy you because you think it's the 'right' thing to do.
Class
In This Chapter
Jude's poverty and illness make him completely dependent on Arabella's grudging care
Development
Continued theme of how economic vulnerability strips away dignity and choice
In Your Life:
You might recognize how financial dependence can trap you in relationships or situations you'd otherwise leave.
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Both Jude and Sue acknowledge their true feelings but can't act on them due to social constraints
Development
Reached peak tension between authentic self and social expectations
In Your Life:
You might feel torn between who you really are and who others expect you to be.
Sacrifice
In This Chapter
Jude sacrifices his health for one last meeting; Sue sacrifices her happiness for perceived virtue
Development
Escalated from small compromises to life-destroying sacrifices
In Your Life:
You might find yourself sacrificing so much for others that you lose yourself completely.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Arabella do when Jude asks her to write to Sue, and why does she make this choice?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do both Arabella and Sue convince themselves they're being kind when their actions actually cause more suffering?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'false mercy' in modern workplaces, families, or relationships?
application • medium - 4
How can you tell the difference between protecting someone and protecting yourself from their reaction?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how fear of causing immediate pain can lead to much greater long-term damage?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
The False Mercy Audit
Think of a situation where you're avoiding a difficult conversation or withholding information to 'protect' someone. Write down what you're actually protecting them from versus what you might be protecting yourself from. Then consider: what would true mercy look like in this situation?
Consider:
- •Ask yourself if you're preventing short-term discomfort but enabling long-term harm
- •Consider whether the other person has the right to make informed decisions about their own life
- •Think about whether your 'protection' is actually removing their agency and choice
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone's 'false mercy' toward you actually made things worse, or when someone's difficult honesty ultimately helped you. What did you learn about the difference?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 51: The Final Walk and Terrible Duty
As the story unfolds, you'll explore people can destroy themselves through impossible choices between desire and duty, while uncovering forcing yourself against your nature creates suffering for everyone involved. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.