An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 2874 words)
was a new idea—the ecclesiastical and altruistic life as distinct
from the intellectual and emulative life. A man could preach and do
good to his fellow-creatures without taking double-firsts in the
schools of Christminster, or having anything but ordinary knowledge.
The old fancy which had led on to the culminating vision of the
bishopric had not been an ethical or theological enthusiasm at all, but
a mundane ambition masquerading in a surplice. He feared that his whole
scheme had degenerated to, even though it might not have originated in,
a social unrest which had no foundation in the nobler instincts; which
was purely an artificial product of civilization. There were thousands
of young men on the same self-seeking track at the present moment. The
sensual hind who ate, drank, and lived carelessly with his wife through
the days of his vanity was a more likable being than he.
But to enter the Church in such an unscholarly way that he could not in
any probability rise to a higher grade through all his career than that
of the humble curate wearing his life out in an obscure village or city
slum—that might have a touch of goodness and greatness in it; that
might be true religion, and a purgatorial course worthy of being
followed by a remorseful man.
The favourable light in which this new thought showed itself by
contrast with his foregone intentions cheered Jude, as he sat there,
shabby and lonely; and it may be said to have given, during the next
few days, the coup de grâce to his intellectual career—a career which
had extended over the greater part of a dozen years. He did nothing,
however, for some long stagnant time to advance his new desire,
occupying himself with little local jobs in putting up and lettering
headstones about the neighbouring villages, and submitting to be
regarded as a social failure, a returned purchase, by the half-dozen or
so of farmers and other country-people who condescended to nod to him.
The human interest of the new intention—and a human interest is
indispensable to the most spiritual and self-sacrificing—was created by
a letter from Sue, bearing a fresh postmark. She evidently wrote with
anxiety, and told very little about her own doings, more than that she
had passed some sort of examination for a Queen’s Scholarship, and was
going to enter a training college at Melchester to complete herself for
the vocation she had chosen, partly by his influence. There was a
theological college at Melchester; Melchester was a quiet and soothing
place, almost entirely ecclesiastical in its tone; a spot where worldly
learning and intellectual smartness had no establishment; where the
altruistic feeling that he did possess would perhaps be more highly
estimated than a brilliancy which he did not.
As it would be necessary that he should continue for a time to work at
his trade while reading up Divinity, which he had neglected at
Christminster for the ordinary classical grind, what better course for
him than to get employment at the further city, and pursue this plan of
reading? That his excessive human interest in the new place was
entirely of Sue’s making, while at the same time Sue was to be regarded
even less than formerly as proper to create it, had an ethical
contradictoriness to which he was not blind. But that much he conceded
to human frailty, and hoped to learn to love her only as a friend and
kinswoman.
He considered that he might so mark out his coming years as to begin
his ministry at the age of thirty—an age which much attracted him as
being that of his exemplar when he first began to teach in Galilee.
This would allow him plenty of time for deliberate study, and for
acquiring capital by his trade to help his aftercourse of keeping the
necessary terms at a theological college.
Christmas had come and passed, and Sue had gone to the Melchester
Normal School. The time was just the worst in the year for Jude to get
into new employment, and he had written suggesting to her that he
should postpone his arrival for a month or so, till the days had
lengthened. She had acquiesced so readily that he wished he had not
proposed it—she evidently did not much care about him, though she had
never once reproached him for his strange conduct in coming to her that
night, and his silent disappearance. Neither had she ever said a word
about her relations with Mr. Phillotson.
Suddenly, however, quite a passionate letter arrived from Sue. She was
quite lonely and miserable, she told him. She hated the place she was
in; it was worse than the ecclesiastical designer’s; worse than
anywhere. She felt utterly friendless; could he come
immediately?—though when he did come she would only be able to see him
at limited times, the rules of the establishment she found herself in
being strict to a degree. It was Mr. Phillotson who had advised her to
come there, and she wished she had never listened to him.
Phillotson’s suit was not exactly prospering, evidently; and Jude felt
unreasonably glad. He packed up his things and went to Melchester with
a lighter heart than he had known for months.
This being the turning over a new leaf he duly looked about for a
temperance hotel, and found a little establishment of that description
in the street leading from the station. When he had had something to
eat he walked out into the dull winter light over the town bridge, and
turned the corner towards the Close. The day was foggy, and standing
under the walls of the most graceful architectural pile in England he
paused and looked up. The lofty building was visible as far as the
roofridge; above, the dwindling spire rose more and more remotely, till
its apex was quite lost in the mist drifting across it.
The lamps now began to be lighted, and turning to the west front he
walked round. He took it as a good omen that numerous blocks of stone
were lying about, which signified that the cathedral was undergoing
restoration or repair to a considerable extent. It seemed to him, full
of the superstitions of his beliefs, that this was an exercise of
forethought on the part of a ruling Power, that he might find plenty to
do in the art he practised while waiting for a call to higher labours.
Then a wave of warmth came over him as he thought how near he now stood
to the bright-eyed vivacious girl with the broad forehead and pile of
dark hair above it; the girl with the kindling glance, daringly soft at
times—something like that of the girls he had seen in engravings from
paintings of the Spanish school. She was here—actually in this Close—in
one of the houses confronting this very west façade.
He went down the broad gravel path towards the building. It was an
ancient edifice of the fifteenth century, once a palace, now a
training-school, with mullioned and transomed windows, and a courtyard
in front shut in from the road by a wall. Jude opened the gate and went
up to the door through which, on inquiring for his cousin, he was
gingerly admitted to a waiting-room, and in a few minutes she came.
Though she had been here such a short while, she was not as he had seen
her last. All her bounding manner was gone; her curves of motion had
become subdued lines. The screens and subtleties of convention had
likewise disappeared. Yet neither was she quite the woman who had
written the letter that summoned him. That had plainly been dashed off
in an impulse which second thoughts had somewhat regretted; thoughts
that were possibly of his recent self-disgrace. Jude was quite overcome
with emotion.
“You don’t—think me a demoralized wretch—for coming to you as I was—and
going so shamefully, Sue?”
“Oh, I have tried not to! You said enough to let me know what had
caused it. I hope I shall never have any doubt of your worthiness, my
poor Jude! And I am glad you have come!”
She wore a murrey-coloured gown with a little lace collar. It was made
quite plain, and hung about her slight figure with clinging
gracefulness. Her hair, which formerly she had worn according to the
custom of the day was now twisted up tightly, and she had altogether
the air of a woman clipped and pruned by severe discipline, an
under-brightness shining through from the depths which that discipline
had not yet been able to reach.
She had come forward prettily, but Jude felt that she had hardly
expected him to kiss her, as he was burning to do, under other colours
than those of cousinship. He could not perceive the least sign that Sue
regarded him as a lover, or ever would do so, now that she knew the
worst of him, even if he had the right to behave as one; and this
helped on his growing resolve to tell her of his matrimonial
entanglement, which he had put off doing from time to time in sheer
dread of losing the bliss of her company.
Sue came out into the town with him, and they walked and talked with
tongues centred only on the passing moments. Jude said he would like to
buy her a little present of some sort, and then she confessed, with
something of shame, that she was dreadfully hungry. They were kept on
very short allowances in the college, and a dinner, tea, and supper all
in one was the present she most desired in the world. Jude thereupon
took her to an inn and ordered whatever the house afforded, which was
not much. The place, however, gave them a delightful opportunity for a
tête-à-tête, nobody else being in the room, and they talked freely.
She told him about the school as it was at that date, and the rough
living, and the mixed character of her fellow-students, gathered
together from all parts of the diocese, and how she had to get up and
work by gas-light in the early morning, with all the bitterness of a
young person to whom restraint was new. To all this he listened; but it
was not what he wanted especially to know—her relations with
Phillotson. That was what she did not tell. When they had sat and
eaten, Jude impulsively placed his hand upon hers; she looked up and
smiled, and took his quite freely into her own little soft one,
dividing his fingers and coolly examining them, as if they were the
fingers of a glove she was purchasing.
“Your hands are rather rough, Jude, aren’t they?” she said.
“Yes. So would yours be if they held a mallet and chisel all day.”
“I don’t dislike it, you know. I think it is noble to see a man’s hands
subdued to what he works in… Well, I’m rather glad I came to this
training-school, after all. See how independent I shall be after the
two years’ training! I shall pass pretty high, I expect, and Mr.
Phillotson will use his influence to get me a big school.”
She had touched the subject at last. “I had a suspicion, a fear,” said
Jude, “that he—cared about you rather warmly, and perhaps wanted to
marry you.”
“Now don’t be such a silly boy!”
“He has said something about it, I expect.”
“If he had, what would it matter? An old man like him!”
“Oh, come, Sue; he’s not so very old. And I know what I saw him doing—”
“Not kissing me—that I’m certain!”
“No. But putting his arm round your waist.”
“Ah—I remember. But I didn’t know he was going to.”
“You are wriggling out if it, Sue, and it isn’t quite kind!”
Her ever-sensitive lip began to quiver, and her eye to blink, at
something this reproof was deciding her to say.
“I know you’ll be angry if I tell you everything, and that’s why I
don’t want to!”
“Very well, then, dear,” he said soothingly. “I have no real right to
ask you, and I don’t wish to know.”
“I shall tell you!” said she, with the perverseness that was part of
her. “This is what I have done: I have promised—I have promised—that I
will marry him when I come out of the training-school two years hence,
and have got my certificate; his plan being that we shall then take a
large double school in a great town—he the boys’ and I the girls’—as
married school-teachers often do, and make a good income between us.”
“Oh, Sue! … But of course it is right—you couldn’t have done better!”
He glanced at her and their eyes met, the reproach in his own belying
his words. Then he drew his hand quite away from hers, and turned his
face in estrangement from her to the window. Sue regarded him passively
without moving.
“I knew you would be angry!” she said with an air of no emotion
whatever. “Very well—I am wrong, I suppose! I ought not to have let you
come to see me! We had better not meet again; and we’ll only correspond
at long intervals, on purely business matters!”
This was just the one thing he would not be able to bear, as she
probably knew, and it brought him round at once. “Oh yes, we will,” he
said quickly. “Your being engaged can make no difference to me
whatever. I have a perfect right to see you when I want to; and I
shall!”
“Then don’t let us talk of it any more. It is quite spoiling our
evening together. What does it matter about what one is going to do two
years hence!”
She was something of a riddle to him, and he let the subject drift
away. “Shall we go and sit in the cathedral?” he asked, when their meal
was finished.
“Cathedral? Yes. Though I think I’d rather sit in the railway station,”
she answered, a remnant of vexation still in her voice. “That’s the
centre of the town life now. The cathedral has had its day!”
“How modern you are!”
“So would you be if you had lived so much in the Middle Ages as I have
done these last few years! The cathedral was a very good place four or
five centuries ago; but it is played out now… I am not modern, either.
I am more ancient than mediævalism, if you only knew.”
Jude looked distressed.
“There—I won’t say any more of that!” she cried. “Only you don’t know
how bad I am, from your point of view, or you wouldn’t think so much of
me, or care whether I was engaged or not. Now there’s just time for us
to walk round the Close, then I must go in, or I shall be locked out
for the night.”
He took her to the gate and they parted. Jude had a conviction that his
unhappy visit to her on that sad night had precipitated this marriage
engagement, and it did anything but add to his happiness. Her reproach
had taken that shape, then, and not the shape of words. However, next
day he set about seeking employment, which it was not so easy to get as
at Christminster, there being, as a rule, less stone-cutting in
progress in this quiet city, and hands being mostly permanent. But he
edged himself in by degrees. His first work was some carving at the
cemetery on the hill; and ultimately he became engaged on the labour he
most desired—the cathedral repairs, which were very extensive, the
whole interior stonework having been overhauled, to be largely replaced
by new. It might be a labour of years to get it all done, and he had
confidence enough in his own skill with the mallet and chisel to feel
that it would be a matter of choice with himself how long he would
stay.
The lodgings he took near the Close Gate would not have disgraced a
curate, the rent representing a higher percentage on his wages than
mechanics of any sort usually care to pay. His combined bed and
sitting-room was furnished with framed photographs of the rectories and
deaneries at which his landlady had lived as trusted servant in her
time, and the parlour downstairs bore a clock on the mantelpiece
inscribed to the effect that it was presented to the same
serious-minded woman by her fellow-servants on the occasion of her
marriage. Jude added to the furniture of his room by unpacking
photographs of the ecclesiastical carvings and monuments that he had
executed with his own hands; and he was deemed a satisfactory
acquisition as tenant of the vacant apartment.
He found an ample supply of theological books in the city book-shops,
and with these his studies were recommenced in a different spirit and
direction from his former course. As a relaxation from the Fathers, and
such stock works as Paley and Butler, he read Newman, Pusey, and many
other modern lights. He hired a harmonium, set it up in his lodging,
and practised chants thereon, single and double.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
When original ambitions fail, we pivot to related goals while creating noble explanations that mask our real motivations.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when we're telling ourselves noble stories to cover up our real motivations for big life changes.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you or someone close to you makes a sudden major decision—ask 'What's the story they're telling themselves, and what might they really be chasing?'
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The old fancy which had led on to the culminating vision of the bishopric had not been an ethical or theological enthusiasm at all, but a mundane ambition masquerading in a surplice."
Context: Jude reflecting on his true motivations for wanting to join the church
This moment of brutal self-honesty shows Jude recognizing that his religious calling was really about wanting status and respect. The metaphor of ambition 'masquerading in a surplice' reveals how we can deceive ourselves about our real motives.
In Today's Words:
I wasn't really called to serve God - I just wanted people to look up to me and think I was important.
"The sensual hind who ate, drank, and lived carelessly with his wife through the days of his vanity was a more likable being than he."
Context: Jude comparing himself unfavorably to simple, honest working people
Jude realizes that ordinary people living without pretense are more authentic than educated people pursuing false ambitions. This shows his growing appreciation for honest, humble life over intellectual pretension.
In Today's Words:
The regular guy who just enjoys life with his family without trying to be somebody special is better than me with all my schemes.
"A man could preach and do good to his fellow-creatures without taking double-firsts in the schools of Christminster, or having anything but ordinary knowledge."
Context: Jude's realization about alternative paths to meaningful service
This represents Jude's major shift from believing he needs elite credentials to serve others, to understanding that genuine help comes from the heart, not from degrees or social position.
In Today's Words:
You don't need a fancy degree to actually help people - you just need to care and be willing to do the work.
Thematic Threads
Self-Deception
In This Chapter
Jude convinces himself he's choosing humble service over ambition, when he's really following Sue
Development
Evolved from earlier chapters where Jude deceived himself about his academic prospects
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself creating noble reasons for decisions that are really driven by fear, attraction, or ego protection
Class
In This Chapter
Jude finally acknowledges his bishop dreams were about social climbing, not genuine calling
Development
Deepened from his earlier struggles with academic access and social barriers
In Your Life:
You might recognize how much of your career ambitions are about status rather than actual interest or service
Unrequited Love
In This Chapter
Jude follows Sue to Melchester despite her engagement, pretending to support her marriage
Development
Intensified from their earlier intellectual connection and growing attraction
In Your Life:
You might find yourself making major life decisions to stay close to someone who doesn't return your feelings
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Jude begins to find meaning in practical work combined with spiritual study rather than pure ambition
Development
New development showing potential maturation from his earlier academic fantasies
In Your Life:
You might discover that combining your existing skills with new interests creates more satisfaction than chasing prestige
Adaptation
In This Chapter
Jude adjusts his goals when faced with reality, finding work that uses his stone-carving skills in a religious context
Development
Shows evolution from his rigid focus on classical education to more flexible life planning
In Your Life:
You might need to adapt your career path when original plans don't work out, finding ways to use existing skills in new contexts
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What major shift happens in Jude's career goals, and what triggers his move to Melchester?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Jude tell himself he's choosing to become a humble curate rather than pursue being a bishop? What are his real motivations versus his stated reasons?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about career changes you've seen people make after setbacks. How often do people admit their real reasons versus creating noble-sounding explanations?
application • medium - 4
When have you redirected your goals after a disappointment? How did you distinguish between genuine growth and protecting your ego?
reflection • deep - 5
What does Jude's pattern reveal about how we handle the gap between our dreams and reality? How can someone navigate this more successfully?
application • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode Your Own Pivot Story
Think of a major change you made in your life - career, relationship, living situation, or major goal. Write down both the story you told others about why you made the change and your completely honest, private reasons. Look for patterns: Are you following someone? Avoiding failure? Protecting your ego? Genuinely choosing something better?
Consider:
- •Notice the difference between your public explanation and private motivations
- •Ask yourself: What was I really chasing in this change?
- •Consider whether the redirected path actually served you better, regardless of motivation
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to choose between what you wanted and what might actually be good for you. How did you handle the internal conflict, and what did you learn about your own decision-making patterns?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 20: Outside All Laws
Sue mentions a 'grand day' coming up, hinting at some special occasion or outing. What could bring joy to their complicated situation, and how will Jude handle spending more time with his newly-engaged cousin?




