Summary
The entire community waits anxiously as Boldwood faces trial for Troy's murder. When investigators search his home, they discover a heartbreaking collection: dresses, jewelry, and gifts all labeled 'Bathsheba Boldwood' with dates years in the future. These pathetic treasures reveal the depth of his mental breakdown—he'd been living in a fantasy where she would eventually marry him. The evidence of his deteriorating mental state changes everything. While Boldwood pleads guilty and receives a death sentence, the community now understands he wasn't in his right mind. A petition for mercy circulates, though it struggles to gain signatures since Boldwood had few friends in town due to his business practices. Gabriel visits him in prison, unable to honestly say whether Boldwood was truly insane during the murder, yet hoping for clemency. Meanwhile, Bathsheba remains devastated, barely recovered from her Christmas trauma. As the execution date approaches, the entire village gathers to await word from a final messenger. The tension breaks when news arrives: Boldwood's sentence has been commuted to life imprisonment. The community erupts in relief, recognizing that sometimes mercy matters more than strict justice. This chapter explores how mental illness complicates our understanding of right and wrong, and how a community's compassion can triumph over legal rigidity.
Coming Up in Chapter 56
With Boldwood's fate decided, Bathsheba must finally confront her own future. The final chapter promises resolution and perhaps the peace that has eluded her for so long.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
THE MARCH FOLLOWING—“BATHSHEBA BOLDWOOD” We pass rapidly on into the month of March, to a breezy day without sunshine, frost, or dew. On Yalbury Hill, about midway between Weatherbury and Casterbridge, where the turnpike road passes over the crest, a numerous concourse of people had gathered, the eyes of the greater number being frequently stretched afar in a northerly direction. The groups consisted of a throng of idlers, a party of javelin-men, and two trumpeters, and in the midst were carriages, one of which contained the high sheriff. With the idlers, many of whom had mounted to the top of a cutting formed for the road, were several Weatherbury men and boys—among others Poorgrass, Coggan, and Cain Ball. At the end of half-an-hour a faint dust was seen in the expected quarter, and shortly after a travelling-carriage, bringing one of the two judges on the Western Circuit, came up the hill and halted on the top. The judge changed carriages whilst a flourish was blown by the big-cheeked trumpeters, and a procession being formed of the vehicles and javelin-men, they all proceeded towards the town, excepting the Weatherbury men, who as soon as they had seen the judge move off returned home again to their work. “Joseph, I seed you squeezing close to the carriage,” said Coggan, as they walked. “Did ye notice my lord judge’s face?” “I did,” said Poorgrass. “I looked hard at en, as if I would read his very soul; and there was mercy in his eyes—or to speak with the exact truth required of us at this solemn time, in the eye that was towards me.” “Well, I hope for the best,” said Coggan, “though bad that must be. However, I shan’t go to the trial, and I’d advise the rest of ye that bain’t wanted to bide away. ’Twill disturb his mind more than anything to see us there staring at him as if he were a show.” “The very thing I said this morning,” observed Joseph, “‘Justice is come to weigh him in the balances,’ I said in my reflectious way, ‘and if he’s found wanting, so be it unto him,’ and a bystander said ‘Hear, hear! A man who can talk like that ought to be heard.’ But I don’t like dwelling upon it, for my few words are my few words, and not much; though the speech of some men is rumoured abroad as though by nature formed for such.” “So ’tis, Joseph. And now, neighbours, as I said, every man bide at home.” The resolution was adhered to; and all waited anxiously for the news next day. Their suspense was diverted, however, by a discovery which was made in the afternoon, throwing more light on Boldwood’s conduct and condition than any details which had preceded it. That he had been from the time of Greenhill Fair until the fatal Christmas Eve in excited and unusual moods was known to those who had been intimate with him; but nobody imagined that...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Compassionate Justice
True justice requires weighing both the harm caused and the mental state that caused it, seeking accountability that heals rather than simply punishes.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between character flaws and mental health symptoms that drive destructive behavior.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's behavior seems inexplicably destructive or obsessive—look for patterns of escalating dysfunction rather than assuming malice.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Western Circuit
A traveling court system where judges rode from town to town to hold trials. In rural areas like Weatherbury, this was the only way to get serious criminal cases heard by proper courts.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in federal judges who travel between districts, or how specialized courts handle cases across regions.
High Sheriff
The Crown's chief law enforcement officer in a county, responsible for executing court orders and overseeing major trials. A position of significant local authority and ceremony.
Modern Usage:
Similar to today's county sheriffs who oversee court security and serve legal papers, though with less pomp and ceremony.
Javelin-men
Armed guards who accompanied judges and sheriffs as both protection and symbols of legal authority. They carried ceremonial weapons and wore official uniforms.
Modern Usage:
Like modern court bailiffs or the security details that accompany high-ranking officials during public appearances.
Petition for mercy
A formal request to spare someone's life, usually signed by community members and sent to higher authorities. It was often the only hope for someone facing execution.
Modern Usage:
Today we see online petitions for clemency, social media campaigns to commute death sentences, or community letters supporting reduced sentences.
Commuted sentence
When a death sentence is reduced to life imprisonment or a lesser punishment. This was considered an act of mercy, often based on mental illness or community support.
Modern Usage:
Still happens today when governors commute death sentences to life without parole, often citing new evidence or mental health issues.
Mental breakdown
What Hardy's era called severe mental illness or psychological collapse. The discovery of Boldwood's fantasy items revealed he'd lost touch with reality over time.
Modern Usage:
We now understand this as serious mental health conditions like delusional disorders, obsessive behaviors, or psychotic breaks from reality.
Characters in This Chapter
Boldwood
Tragic antagonist facing consequences
On trial for Troy's murder, his mental state becomes clear when investigators find his pathetic collection of gifts labeled for a future marriage to Bathsheba. His delusions show he wasn't in his right mind.
Modern Equivalent:
The stalker whose apartment reveals years of obsessive planning and fantasy relationships
Gabriel Oak
Loyal friend and moral compass
Visits Boldwood in prison, struggling with whether to testify about his mental state. Shows compassion even for someone who caused so much pain, representing the community's better nature.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who visits you in rehab or prison, even when everyone else has given up
Bathsheba
Traumatized protagonist
Still recovering from the Christmas shooting, she's devastated by the whole situation. The discovery of Boldwood's fantasy gifts about their future marriage adds to her guilt and horror.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman dealing with PTSD after a violent incident, feeling responsible for someone else's obsession
Poorgrass
Community observer
Represents the common people watching the legal proceedings with fascination and fear. His comments show how the working class views justice and authority.
Modern Equivalent:
The neighbor who knows all the courthouse gossip and follows every detail of local crime cases
The Judge
Symbol of legal authority
Arrives with ceremony and pomp, representing the formal justice system that must decide Boldwood's fate. His presence shows how seriously the law takes this case.
Modern Equivalent:
The federal judge who comes to town for high-profile cases that make national news
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I looked hard at en, as if I would read his very soul; and there was mercy in his eyes—or to speak with the exact truth that the case required, I thought there was."
Context: Describing his attempt to read the judge's face for signs of mercy toward Boldwood
Shows how desperately the community wants to believe in compassion over strict justice. Poorgrass's honesty about maybe seeing what he wanted to see reveals human hope in dark times.
In Today's Words:
I stared at him trying to figure out if he'd go easy on Boldwood—or maybe I just saw what I wanted to see.
"The clothes were all carefully arranged, and bore in every case a paper label with the words 'Bathsheba Boldwood' written upon it, and a date some years in advance in every instance."
Context: Describing the heartbreaking discovery in Boldwood's home of gifts prepared for a fantasy future
This devastating evidence shows Boldwood's complete break from reality. The future dates reveal he'd been living in a delusion for years, making his crime more tragic than evil.
In Today's Words:
He had wedding gifts all laid out with her name on them, dated for years that hadn't even happened yet.
"The petition was handed round, but it was signed by only a few names, the farming community being but little disposed to show mercy to one who had shown so little mercy to them."
Context: Explaining why the mercy petition struggled to get signatures despite Boldwood's mental state
Reveals how past behavior affects community sympathy. Even mental illness doesn't erase the memory of Boldwood's harsh business practices and lack of kindness to others.
In Today's Words:
Nobody wanted to sign because he'd been such a jerk to everyone when he was doing well.
Thematic Threads
Mental Health
In This Chapter
Boldwood's collection of fantasy gifts reveals severe mental breakdown, changing how the community views his crime
Development
Introduced here as explanation for his escalating obsession throughout the book
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone's behavior becomes increasingly erratic or disconnected from reality
Community Responsibility
In This Chapter
The village struggles to sign the mercy petition despite recognizing Boldwood's mental state, showing how social isolation compounds tragedy
Development
Evolved from earlier themes of gossip and judgment to collective moral decision-making
In Your Life:
You face this when deciding whether to support someone whose actions have caused harm but who clearly needs help
Justice vs Mercy
In This Chapter
The death sentence is commuted to life imprisonment, balancing accountability with recognition of mental illness
Development
Introduced here as the climax of Boldwood's destructive arc
In Your Life:
You encounter this when someone you know faces consequences for actions driven by mental health struggles
Social Isolation
In This Chapter
Boldwood has few friends to support his mercy petition due to his cold business practices, showing how isolation enabled his breakdown
Development
Built from his earlier characterization as a distant, proud landowner
In Your Life:
You might see this in yourself or others who maintain professional success while lacking genuine human connections
Reality vs Fantasy
In This Chapter
The labeled gifts with future dates show how completely Boldwood had retreated into delusion about his relationship with Bathsheba
Development
Culmination of his inability to accept rejection throughout the story
In Your Life:
You might recognize this pattern when someone refuses to accept clear boundaries or creates elaborate scenarios that ignore obvious reality
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What did investigators find in Boldwood's house that changed how people viewed his crime?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did the community's attitude toward Boldwood shift from demanding justice to supporting mercy?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today - someone's destructive behavior being driven by untreated mental struggles?
application • medium - 4
How do you balance holding someone accountable for harm they caused while still showing compassion for their mental state?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about the difference between explanation and excuse when it comes to harmful behavior?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Warning Signs
Think of someone in your life whose behavior has become increasingly concerning or destructive. Map out the warning signs that preceded their current crisis - what red flags did you or others notice but dismiss? Consider how early intervention might have changed the outcome.
Consider:
- •Focus on patterns of behavior, not just isolated incidents
- •Consider what support systems were available but not utilized
- •Think about how stigma around mental health prevented early help
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you recognized someone was struggling but weren't sure how to help. What would you do differently now, knowing what you know about mental health and early intervention?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 56: Love Found in Honest Conversation
As the story unfolds, you'll explore grief can become a teacher rather than just a destroyer, while uncovering honest communication is essential for resolving relationship misunderstandings. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.