Summary
Troy asks Bathsheba for twenty pounds, claiming it's not for gambling but refusing to explain what it's actually for. Their argument escalates when Bathsheba accidentally sees a lock of blonde hair hidden in Troy's watch—hair that clearly isn't hers. When confronted, Troy lies, then admits it belongs to a woman he almost married before meeting Bathsheba. The revelation devastates Bathsheba, who realizes how much she's sacrificed her independence and pride for a man who doesn't truly value her. She reflects bitterly on how she once scorned women who threw themselves at men, yet here she is, begging for her husband's attention and honesty. The next morning, Troy leaves early for his mysterious business. Meanwhile, news arrives that Fanny Robin—a former servant—has died at the workhouse in Casterbridge. Bathsheba insists on personally arranging Fanny's burial, showing her compassionate nature despite her own troubles. When she learns that Fanny had blonde hair and was involved with a soldier in Troy's regiment, terrible suspicions begin forming. The chapter masterfully shows how secrets poison relationships and how the past refuses to stay buried. Bathsheba's journey from proud independence to desperate pleading illustrates the dangerous vulnerability that comes with loving someone who doesn't love you back equally.
Coming Up in Chapter 42
Joseph sets out to collect Fanny's body from the workhouse, but the journey back will reveal secrets that could destroy what remains of Bathsheba's marriage. Sometimes the dead carry truths the living aren't prepared to face.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
SUSPICION—FANNY IS SENT FOR Bathsheba said very little to her husband all that evening of their return from market, and he was not disposed to say much to her. He exhibited the unpleasant combination of a restless condition with a silent tongue. The next day, which was Sunday, passed nearly in the same manner as regarded their taciturnity, Bathsheba going to church both morning and afternoon. This was the day before the Budmouth races. In the evening Troy said, suddenly— “Bathsheba, could you let me have twenty pounds?” Her countenance instantly sank. “Twenty pounds?” she said. “The fact is, I want it badly.” The anxiety upon Troy’s face was unusual and very marked. It was a culmination of the mood he had been in all the day. “Ah! for those races to-morrow.” Troy for the moment made no reply. Her mistake had its advantages to a man who shrank from having his mind inspected as he did now. “Well, suppose I do want it for races?” he said, at last. “Oh, Frank!” Bathsheba replied, and there was such a volume of entreaty in the words. “Only such a few weeks ago you said that I was far sweeter than all your other pleasures put together, and that you would give them all up for me; and now, won’t you give up this one, which is more a worry than a pleasure? Do, Frank. Come, let me fascinate you by all I can do—by pretty words and pretty looks, and everything I can think of—to stay at home. Say yes to your wife—say yes!” The tenderest and softest phases of Bathsheba’s nature were prominent now—advanced impulsively for his acceptance, without any of the disguises and defences which the wariness of her character when she was cool too frequently threw over them. Few men could have resisted the arch yet dignified entreaty of the beautiful face, thrown a little back and sideways in the well known attitude that expresses more than the words it accompanies, and which seems to have been designed for these special occasions. Had the woman not been his wife, Troy would have succumbed instantly; as it was, he thought he would not deceive her longer. “The money is not wanted for racing debts at all,” he said. “What is it for?” she asked. “You worry me a great deal by these mysterious responsibilities, Frank.” Troy hesitated. He did not now love her enough to allow himself to be carried too far by her ways. Yet it was necessary to be civil. “You wrong me by such a suspicious manner,” he said. “Such strait-waistcoating as you treat me to is not becoming in you at so early a date.” “I think that I have a right to grumble a little if I pay,” she said, with features between a smile and a pout. “Exactly; and, the former being done, suppose we proceed to the latter. Bathsheba, fun is all very well, but don’t go too far, or you may...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Emotional Blackmail - When Love Becomes Leverage
When someone exploits your feelings for them to manipulate your behavior while avoiding accountability for their own actions.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone uses your feelings as leverage to avoid accountability or extract resources.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone deflects your reasonable questions with emotional manipulation—making you feel guilty for asking, or withholding affection until you stop pressing for answers.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Taciturnity
The habit of being quiet and not talking much, especially when you're upset or angry. In this chapter, both Bathsheba and Troy are giving each other the silent treatment after their market trip. It's the kind of cold silence that fills a house with tension.
Modern Usage:
We see this in relationships today when couples stop communicating and just exist in the same space without really talking.
Countenance
A person's facial expression, especially when it shows their emotions clearly. When Troy asks for money, Bathsheba's face immediately shows her worry and disappointment. Your countenance gives you away even when you try to hide your feelings.
Modern Usage:
Today we might say someone's face 'fell' or they 'looked stricken' when bad news hits.
Workhouse
A place where poor people went to live and work when they had nowhere else to go in Victorian England. It was basically government housing for the destitute, but harsh and stigmatized. Fanny Robin dies in one, showing how far she'd fallen.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how we view homeless shelters or welfare housing today - necessary but often seen as places of last resort.
Watch-chain trinket
A small keepsake attached to a pocket watch, often containing something sentimental like hair or a photo. Troy hides blonde hair in his watch, which was a common way Victorian men kept mementos of lovers. It's his secret he carries everywhere.
Modern Usage:
Like keeping your ex's photo in your phone or wallet - a hidden reminder of someone from your past.
Entreaty
A desperate, heartfelt plea or request. When Bathsheba begs Troy not to gamble, there's a 'volume of entreaty' in her words - she's not just asking, she's pleading with everything she has. It shows how powerless she feels.
Modern Usage:
When someone is begging their partner not to do something destructive, putting their whole heart into the request.
Regiment
A large military unit of soldiers. Troy was a soldier, and Fanny was involved with someone from his same regiment. This connection makes Bathsheba's suspicions even more pointed - it's too much of a coincidence.
Modern Usage:
Like finding out your partner's ex worked at the same company or hung out in the same social circle.
Characters in This Chapter
Bathsheba
Protagonist in crisis
She's desperately trying to hold her marriage together while discovering devastating secrets. She begs Troy for honesty, finds the blonde hair, and realizes she's become everything she once despised - a woman pleading for a man's attention. Yet she still shows compassion by arranging Fanny's burial.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman who gave up her independence for a man who's clearly hiding things from her
Troy
Deceptive husband
He's secretive about needing money, lies about the blonde hair, then admits it belongs to a woman he 'almost married.' He's emotionally absent and manipulative, letting Bathsheba think it's about gambling when it's something worse. He leaves early the next morning on mysterious business.
Modern Equivalent:
The husband who's clearly having an affair but gaslights his wife when she asks questions
Fanny Robin
The ghost from the past
Though dead, she becomes the center of the drama. She was Bathsheba's former servant who died at the workhouse, had blonde hair, and was involved with someone from Troy's regiment. Her death forces all the buried secrets to surface.
Modern Equivalent:
The ex who died but whose presence still haunts the current relationship
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Only such a few weeks ago you said that I was far sweeter than all your other pleasures put together, and that you would give them all up for me; and now, won't you give up this one"
Context: She's begging Troy not to gamble, reminding him of his earlier promises
This shows how Bathsheba is clinging to Troy's past words while he's already moved on. She's using his own promises against him, but it reveals how desperate she's become. The contrast between his earlier sweet talk and current indifference is painful.
In Today's Words:
You literally just told me I was more important than anything else, and now you won't even give up this one thing for me?
"Her mistake had its advantages to a man who shrank from having his mind inspected as he did now"
Context: When Bathsheba assumes Troy wants money for gambling, he's relieved she's wrong about the real reason
This reveals Troy's manipulative nature - he's happy to let her believe a lie because the truth is worse. The phrase 'shrank from having his mind inspected' shows he knows he's doing wrong and fears being found out.
In Today's Words:
He was relieved she guessed wrong because he definitely didn't want her knowing what he was really up to
"Oh, Frank! and there was such a volume of entreaty in the words"
Context: Bathsheba's desperate response when she thinks Troy wants to gamble
The narrator emphasizes how much emotion Bathsheba packs into just two words. 'Volume of entreaty' suggests she's putting her whole heart into this plea, showing how much power Troy has over her and how far she's fallen from her earlier independence.
In Today's Words:
She said his name with so much desperate pleading in her voice
Thematic Threads
Independence
In This Chapter
Bathsheba reflects bitterly on how she once scorned women who threw themselves at men, yet now finds herself begging for Troy's attention and honesty
Development
Her fierce independence has been systematically eroded through marriage to Troy
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you catch yourself compromising values you once held firm just to keep someone's approval.
Deception
In This Chapter
Troy's lies about the blonde hair and his refusal to explain what he needs money for create a web of half-truths and manipulation
Development
Troy's deceptive nature, hinted at earlier, now directly damages his marriage
In Your Life:
You see this when someone gives you just enough truth to stop you from asking more questions, but never the whole story.
Class
In This Chapter
Bathsheba's compassionate response to Fanny Robin's death shows her sense of responsibility toward those beneath her social station
Development
Continues Bathsheba's pattern of caring for her workers and social inferiors despite her own troubles
In Your Life:
You might show this when you help others even while dealing with your own problems, because you understand what it's like to need support.
Secrets
In This Chapter
The blonde hair in Troy's watch represents hidden connections to his past that poison his present relationship
Development
Introduced here as a major threat to the marriage
In Your Life:
You experience this when someone's undisclosed past relationships or commitments suddenly surface and threaten your current relationship.
Pride
In This Chapter
Bathsheba's pride is wounded not just by Troy's deception, but by her own recognition that she's become what she once despised
Development
Her pride has transformed from protective strength to painful self-awareness of her vulnerability
In Your Life:
You feel this when you realize you've become someone you wouldn't have respected in the past, all for love of someone who doesn't seem to value you.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors does Troy use to avoid giving Bathsheba straight answers about the money and the hair?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Troy's partial truth about the hair ('a woman I almost married') hurt Bathsheba more than a complete lie might have?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of 'artificial scarcity'—someone withholding information or affection to maintain control—in modern relationships or workplaces?
application • medium - 4
If you were Bathsheba's friend, what specific advice would you give her about setting boundaries with Troy?
application • deep - 5
What does Bathsheba's transformation from independent woman to someone 'begging for scraps of honesty' reveal about how manipulation works over time?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Spot the Manipulation Playbook
Create a two-column chart. In the left column, list Troy's specific tactics from this chapter (demanding money without explanation, deflecting questions, using partial truths). In the right column, write how each tactic would look in a modern setting—workplace, family, friendship, or romantic relationship. This exercise helps you recognize these patterns before they escalate.
Consider:
- •Notice how manipulators often give just enough information to stop you from asking more questions
- •Pay attention to how they make you feel guilty or unreasonable for wanting basic honesty
- •Consider why partial truths can be more damaging than outright lies
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone used your care for them as leverage to avoid accountability. What would you do differently now that you can name the pattern?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 42: When Duty Meets Temptation
The coming pages reveal small compromises can derail important responsibilities, and teach us the power of peer pressure to override personal judgment. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.