Summary
A Mother's Dying Plea
Evelina, Or, the History of a Young Lady's Entrance into the World by Fanny Burney
In this devastating letter, we discover the full tragedy behind Evelina's birth. Lady Belmont, Evelina's dying mother, makes one final desperate appeal to Sir John Belmont, her husband who has abandoned and denied both her and their unborn child. Writing as she faces death in childbirth, Caroline Belmont pours out eighteen years of pain, betrayal, and heartbreak. She recounts how the man she trusted as husband, father, lover, and friend has failed her in every possible way. Yet even in her anguish, she transforms her personal suffering into a mother's protective instinct. She sets clear conditions for his forgiveness: he must publicly acknowledge their marriage and accept Evelina as his legitimate daughter. The letter reveals the cruel irony that while Sir John rescued Caroline from one forced marriage, he then betrayed her himself. Most powerfully, Caroline's anger gradually softens into pity as she imagines the guilt that will eventually consume him. She even warns that if Evelina resembles her, he shouldn't reject the child for that reason. The letter ends with a remarkable act of grace - despite everything, Caroline offers prayers and forgiveness. This chapter explains the mystery that has haunted the entire novel: why Evelina has been raised in obscurity and why her parentage is disputed. It shows how a woman with no legal power can still fight for her child's future, using moral authority and the weight of truth as her weapons.
Coming Up in Chapter 75
With Lady Belmont's dying words revealed, the stage is set for a confrontation that will determine Evelina's fate. Will Sir John Belmont finally face the truth of what he's done?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
LETTER LXXIV. [Inclosed in the preceding Letter.] LADY BELMONT TO SIR JOHN BELMONT. IN the firm hope that the moment of anguish which approaches will prove the period of my sufferings, once more I address myself to Sir John Belmont, in behalf of the child, who, if it survives its mother, will hereafter be the bearer of this letter. Yet, in what terms,-Oh, most cruel of men!-can the lost Caroline address you, and not address you in vain? Oh, deaf to the voice of compassion-deaf to the sting of truth-deaf to every tie of honour-say, in what terms may the lost Caroline address you, and not address you in vain! Shall I call you by the loved, the respected title of husband?-No, you disclaim it!-the father of my infant?-No, you doom it to infamy!-the lover who rescued me from a forced marriage?-No, you have yourself betrayed me!-the friend from whom I hoped succour and protection?-No, you have consigned me to misery and destruction! Oh, hardened against every plea of justice, remorse, or pity! how, and in what manner, may I hope to move thee? Is there one method I have left untried? remains there one resource unessayed? No! I have exhausted all the bitterness of reproach, and drained every sluice of compassion! Hopeless, and almost desperate, twenty times have I flung away my pen;-but the feelings of a mother, a mother agonizing for the fate of her child, again animating my courage, as often I have resumed it. Perhaps when I am no more, when the measure of my woes is completed, and the still, silent, unreproaching dust has received my sad remains,-then, perhaps, when accusation is no longer to be feared, nor detection to be dreaded, the voice of equity and the cry of nature may be heard. Listen, Oh Belmont, to their dictates! reprobate not your child, though you have reprobated its mother. The evils that are past, perhaps, when too late, you may wish to recal; the young creature you have persecuted, perhaps, when too late, you may regret that you have destroyed;-you may think with horror of the deceptions you have practised, and the pangs of remorse may follow me to the tomb:-Oh, Belmont, all my resentment softens into pity at the thought! what will become of thee, good Heaven, when, with the eye of penitence, thou reviewest thy past conduct! Hear, then, the solemn, the last address, with which the unhappy Caoline will importune thee. If when the time of thy contrition arrives,-for arrive it must!-when the sense of thy treachery shall rob thee of almost every other, if then thy tortured heart shall sigh to expiate thy guilt,-mark the conditions upon which I leave thee my forgiveness. Thou knowest I am thy wife!-clear, then, to the world the reputation thou hast sullied, and receive, as thy lawful successor, the child who will present thee this, my dying request! The worthiest, the most benevolent, the best of men, to whose consoling kindness I owe the...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Moral Leverage - When You Have No Power But Truth
Using truth and moral authority as weapons when traditional power has been stripped away.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to transform victimhood into power by maintaining moral high ground while systematically exposing someone's failures.
Practice This Today
Next time someone with more power wrongs you, document facts calmly, use their own stated values against them, and offer grace while making consequences clear.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Deathbed letter
A final written appeal made by someone facing death, often containing confessions, pleas, or last wishes. These letters carried enormous moral weight in the 18th century because they were seen as someone's final truthful words before meeting God.
Modern Usage:
We still see this in farewell videos, final social media posts, or letters left by terminally ill patients trying to protect their families.
Legitimacy
Legal recognition of a child born within marriage, which determined inheritance rights and social standing. Without legitimacy, children had no legal claims and faced lifelong social stigma.
Modern Usage:
Today this shows up in custody battles, paternity tests, and fights over inheritance when fathers deny their children.
Moral authority
The power to influence others through righteousness and virtue rather than legal or physical force. Women in the 18th century often had to rely on moral authority since they had few legal rights.
Modern Usage:
We see this when whistleblowers, activists, or wronged parties use public shame and moral pressure to get justice.
Coverture
The legal doctrine that a married woman's rights and property were controlled by her husband. This meant women had no independent legal existence and couldn't own property or make contracts.
Modern Usage:
This echoes in modern situations where one partner controls all the finances or legal decisions in a relationship.
Reproach
Sharp criticism or blame, especially when someone has failed in their moral duties. Caroline uses reproach as a weapon when she has no legal recourse against her husband's betrayal.
Modern Usage:
This is what happens in public call-outs on social media or when someone airs their grievances publicly to shame someone who wronged them.
Maternal sacrifice
The idea that mothers will endure any suffering to protect their children's future. Caroline transforms her personal pain into a fight for Evelina's rights and recognition.
Modern Usage:
We see this in single mothers working multiple jobs, parents sacrificing careers for their kids, or mothers fighting the system for their children's needs.
Characters in This Chapter
Lady Belmont (Caroline)
Tragic mother and moral crusader
Writing on her deathbed, she makes a final desperate appeal for her unborn child's legitimacy. She transforms from victim to fierce protector, using moral authority as her only weapon against a husband who has abandoned them both.
Modern Equivalent:
The single mother fighting for child support and recognition from a deadbeat dad
Sir John Belmont
Absent antagonist
Though not present in the scene, he looms over every word as the man who rescued Caroline from one forced marriage only to betray her himself. His denial of both wife and child drives the entire tragedy.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who promises everything, gets you pregnant, then ghosts when real responsibility hits
Evelina (unborn)
Innocent victim and future hope
Though not yet born, she is the center of Caroline's desperate plea. Her future legitimacy and social standing depend entirely on whether her father will acknowledge her existence.
Modern Equivalent:
The child caught in the middle of a paternity dispute
Key Quotes & Analysis
"ain? Oh, deaf to the voice of compassion-deaf to the sting of truth-deaf to every tie of honour-say, in what"
Context: Caroline describes how Sir John has ignored all her previous appeals for help
This repetition of 'deaf' shows how completely Sir John has shut out his responsibilities. Caroline escalates from compassion to truth to honor, showing she's tried every possible appeal to his conscience.
In Today's Words:
You won't listen to me begging, you won't face the facts, and you don't care about doing the right thing
"pen;-but the feelings of a mother, a mother agonizing for the fate of her child, again animating my courage, as often"
Context: Caroline explains why she keeps writing despite feeling hopeless
This shows the transformation from personal pain to maternal protection. Even facing death, her love for Evelina gives her strength to keep fighting for her child's future.
In Today's Words:
Every time I wanted to give up, thinking about my kid's future made me keep going
"ain! Shall I call you by the loved, the respected title of husband?-No, you disclaim it!-the fathe"
Context: Caroline lists all the ways Sir John has failed in his relationships to her
The rhetorical questions and immediate denials create a devastating catalog of betrayal. Each role he should have played becomes evidence of his complete failure.
In Today's Words:
What am I supposed to call you? My husband? No, you won't even admit we're married!
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Caroline transforms powerlessness into moral authority through strategic truth-telling
Development
Evolved from Evelina's social powerlessness to Caroline's ultimate demonstration of alternative power sources
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you're documenting workplace issues or setting boundaries with family members who have more traditional authority than you do.
Identity
In This Chapter
Caroline fights for Evelina's legitimate identity and social standing from beyond the grave
Development
This reveals the source of Evelina's identity crisis - her mother's battle for recognition
In Your Life:
You might see this when advocating for your children's opportunities or fighting for recognition of your own contributions.
Class
In This Chapter
Legal marriage and legitimate birth determine everything about social standing and future opportunities
Development
Shows how class distinctions can be weaponized to destroy lives and deny basic rights
In Your Life:
You might experience this when educational credentials or family background affect how you're treated in professional settings.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Caroline demonstrates how to maintain dignity while calling out betrayal
Development
Contrasts with earlier chapters showing surface social relationships versus deep moral bonds
In Your Life:
You might need this approach when confronting someone who has violated your trust while maintaining your own integrity.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Caroline transforms personal suffering into protective action for her daughter
Development
Shows mature response to trauma - using pain to prevent future harm rather than seeking revenge
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when channeling your own difficult experiences into advocacy or protection for others.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific strategies does Caroline use in her letter to make Sir John face the truth about his actions?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Caroline shift from anger to offering forgiveness and prayers at the end of her letter?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen someone use moral authority as their main weapon when they had no other power?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Caroline's position - powerless but morally right - how would you structure your final appeal?
application • deep - 5
What does Caroline's letter reveal about how people can maintain dignity and influence even when they've lost everything else?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Draft Your Own Moral Leverage Letter
Think of a situation where someone wronged you but you had little formal power to fight back. Draft a letter using Caroline's strategy: state facts calmly, name the consequences they'll face, and end with unexpected grace. Don't send it - this is about understanding the pattern of moral leverage.
Consider:
- •Focus on their future guilt and reputation, not your past pain
- •Use their own stated values against them
- •Document specific actions and dates - make denial impossible
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to fight for what was right without traditional power. What weapons did you use instead? How did offering grace or forgiveness change the dynamic?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 75: The Garden Confrontation Reveals All
In the next chapter, you'll discover to recognize when someone uses manipulation through false vulnerability, and learn clear boundaries when rejecting unwanted advances. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.
