Summary
When Protection Becomes Possession
Evelina, Or, the History of a Young Lady's Entrance into the World by Fanny Burney
Evelina witnesses a disturbing spectacle as Lord Merton and Mr. Coverley force two elderly women to race for their entertainment, betting on the outcome like a sporting event. The scene reveals the casual cruelty of the wealthy toward those they consider beneath them. When one woman falls and is injured, the men show no genuine concern, only anger about their wager. Lord Orville alone appears disgusted by the display. Later, emboldened by alcohol and his betting win, Lord Merton abandons all pretense of propriety despite being engaged to Lady Louisa. He corners Evelina, grabbing her hand and making inappropriate advances, treating her like his private entertainment. His behavior escalates until Mrs. Beaumont intervenes, but not before Lady Louisa becomes jealous and angry. The situation reaches a crisis when Evelina, feeling completely unprotected, cries out that she wishes she had a brother to defend her. Lord Orville immediately steps forward, offering to serve as her protector and escorting both women safely inside. His intervention reveals the stark contrast between genuine respect and predatory behavior. Lady Louisa, humiliated by her fiancé's conduct and her brother's attention to Evelina, storms off in fury. The chapter exposes how quickly social situations can become dangerous for unprotected women, and how true character emerges under pressure. Evelina learns to distinguish between those who would exploit her vulnerability and those who would genuinely shield her from harm.
Coming Up in Chapter 69
After Lord Orville's protective intervention, Evelina must navigate the aftermath of the evening's dramatic events. With Lady Louisa's anger simmering and Lord Merton's behavior exposed, the social dynamics at Clifton have shifted dangerously.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
LETTER LXVIII. EVELINA TO THE REV. MR. VILLARS. Clifton, Sept. 28th. SWEETLY, most sweetly, have two days more passed since I wrote: but I have been too much engaged to be exact in my journal. To-day has been less tranquil. It was destined for the decision of the important bet, and has been productive of general confusion throughout the house. It was settled that the race should be run at five o'clock in the afternoon. Lord Merton breakfasted here, and staid till noon. He wanted to engage the ladies to bet on his side, in the true spirit of gaming, without seeing the racers. But he could only prevail on Lady Louisa, as Mrs. Selwyn said she never laid a wager against her own wishes, and Mrs. Beaumont would not take sides. As for me, I was not applied to. It is impossible for negligence to be more pointed than that of Lord Merton to me, in the presence of Lady Louisa. But, just before dinner, I happened to be alone in the drawing-room, when his Lordship suddenly returned; and, coming in with his usual familiarity, he was beginning, "You see, Lady Louisa,-" but stopping short, "Pray, where's every body gone?" "Indeed I don't know, my Lord." He then shut the door; and, with a great alteration in his face and manner, advanced eagerly towards me, and said, "How glad I am, my sweet girl, to meet you, at last, alone! By my soul I began to think there was a plot against me, for I've never been able to have you a minute to myself." And very freely he seized my hand. I was so much surprised at this address, after having been so long totally neglected, that I could make no other answer, than staring at him with unfeigned astonishment. "Why now," continued he, "if you was not the cruellest little angel in the world, you would have helped me to some expedient: for you see how I am watched here; Lady Louisa's eyes are never off me. She gives me a charming foretaste of the pleasures of a wife! However, it won't last long." Disgusted to the greatest degree, I attempted to draw away my hand; but I believe I should not have succeeded if Mrs. Beaumont had not made her appearance. He turned from me with the greatest assurance, and said, "How are you, Ma'am?-how is Lady Louisa?-you see I can't live a moment out of the house." Could you, my dearest Sir, have believed it possible for such effrontery to be in man? Before dinner came Mr. Coverley, and, before five o'clock, Mr. Lovel and some other company. The place marked out for the race, was a gravel-walk in Mrs. Beaumont's garden, and the length of the ground twenty yards. When we were summoned to the course, the two poor old women made their appearance. Though they seemed very healthy for their time of life, they yet looked so weak, so infirm, so feeble, that...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Power Without Consequence
Unchecked power inevitably escalates abuse until met by equal or greater authority.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify who holds real authority in any social situation and how unchecked power always escalates.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone starts with small boundary violations—watch if they escalate when no one objects, and identify who has the actual authority to stop them.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Pointed negligence
Deliberately ignoring someone in an obvious, public way to send a message. In Burney's time, this was a calculated social snub used to show disapproval or establish hierarchy. The behavior is so obvious that everyone notices.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplaces when someone gets excluded from meetings or group chats, or when someone gets the silent treatment at family gatherings.
Gaming spirit
The mentality of treating everything like a bet or game, even when real people get hurt. This refers to the wealthy's tendency to gamble on anything for entertainment, regardless of consequences to others.
Modern Usage:
Like people who bet on office drama or make light of serious situations because they're not personally affected.
Familiar address
Speaking to someone in an overly casual, intimate way when you don't have that relationship. In the 18th century, this violated strict social boundaries and was a form of disrespect or sexual aggression.
Modern Usage:
When someone you barely know calls you 'honey' or gets too personal too fast, crossing boundaries you haven't invited them to cross.
Want of protection
Being vulnerable because you don't have male relatives or social connections to defend you. In Burney's world, unprotected women were easy targets for predatory behavior.
Modern Usage:
Like being the only woman in a hostile work environment, or not having backup when someone is harassing you.
Alteration in manner
When someone suddenly changes their behavior completely, usually dropping their public mask to reveal their true intentions. This shift often signals danger, especially for women.
Modern Usage:
When someone who's been polite suddenly gets aggressive, or when a date's whole personality changes once you're alone.
Social spectacle
Entertainment created by humiliating or exploiting vulnerable people for the amusement of those in power. The wealthy often treated the poor as objects for their entertainment.
Modern Usage:
Like reality TV that exploits people's struggles, or viral videos that mock someone's misfortune for likes and shares.
Characters in This Chapter
Lord Merton
Primary antagonist
Shows his true predatory nature by organizing cruel entertainment and then cornering Evelina when drunk. Despite being engaged, he treats women as objects for his amusement and gratification.
Modern Equivalent:
The entitled guy who thinks his status gives him the right to whatever he wants
Evelina
Vulnerable protagonist
Experiences the terror of being cornered by a predator with no protection. Her cry for a brother reveals her desperate need for someone to defend her in a hostile social world.
Modern Equivalent:
The young woman navigating spaces where powerful men feel entitled to her attention
Lord Orville
Protective figure
Immediately steps up when Evelina cries out for protection, showing what genuine respect looks like. His intervention contrasts sharply with Merton's predatory behavior.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who actually intervenes when they see harassment happening
Lady Louisa
Jealous rival
Becomes furious when her fiancé pursues Evelina and her brother protects her. Her anger is misdirected at Evelina rather than at Merton's inappropriate behavior.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman who blames the other woman instead of holding her partner accountable
Mrs. Beaumont
Ineffective chaperone
Intervenes only after the damage is done, representing the failure of social systems meant to protect young women from predatory men.
Modern Equivalent:
The supervisor who only acts after someone complains, never preventing problems
Key Quotes & Analysis
"said, "How glad I am, my sweet girl, to meet you, at last, alone!"
Context: When he finds Evelina alone and immediately changes his manner from cold to predatory
This reveals his calculated behavior - he's been waiting for an opportunity to corner her without witnesses. The sudden shift from ignoring her to calling her 'sweet girl' shows his predatory intentions.
In Today's Words:
Finally, I've got you alone where no one can see what I'm really like.
"Oh that I had a brother in the world, that I might have a natural claim to his protection!"
Context: Her desperate cry when Lord Merton becomes physically aggressive
This shows her complete vulnerability in a world where women need male protection to be safe. Her wish for a brother reveals how alone and defenseless she feels against predatory men.
In Today's Words:
I need someone in my corner who will actually stand up for me when men won't take no for an answer.
"Will you allow me the honour of taking that title?"
Context: His immediate response to Evelina's cry for a brother's protection
This shows genuine respect and protection without expecting anything in return. He offers help when she needs it most, contrasting sharply with Merton's exploitation of her vulnerability.
In Today's Words:
I'll be that person who has your back - no strings attached.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Lord Merton's progression from cruel entertainment to sexual assault, stopped only by Lord Orville's equal status
Development
Evolved from earlier displays of class privilege to outright predatory behavior
In Your Life:
You might see this in workplace harassment that escalates until someone with real authority intervenes.
Protection
In This Chapter
Evelina's desperate cry for a brother reveals how unprotected women navigate dangerous social situations
Development
Built from earlier scenes of Evelina feeling vulnerable and seeking guidance
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you need an ally with authority to stand up for you in difficult situations.
Class
In This Chapter
The elderly women are treated as entertainment objects, their suffering irrelevant to their social superiors
Development
Intensified from previous examples of class-based dismissal to outright cruelty
In Your Life:
You might see this when people with money or status treat service workers as disposable entertainment.
Character
In This Chapter
Lord Orville's immediate intervention contrasts sharply with other men's indifference or participation
Development
Continued demonstration of his consistent moral compass under pressure
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when crisis situations reveal who will actually stand up for what's right.
Vulnerability
In This Chapter
Alcohol and winning money strip away Merton's social pretenses, revealing his true predatory nature
Development
Built from earlier hints of his character flaws into full dangerous behavior
In Your Life:
You might see this when stress or success reveals someone's true character underneath their public persona.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What progression do you see in Lord Merton's behavior from the afternoon race to his treatment of Evelina that evening?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Lord Merton feel confident enough to escalate his behavior throughout the day, and what finally stops him?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of unchecked power leading to escalating abuse in workplaces, families, or communities today?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Evelina's position with someone overstepping boundaries, how would you identify who has the power to effectively intervene?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between appealing to someone's conscience versus finding someone with equal power to stop them?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Power Network
Think of a situation where someone has been pushing boundaries with you or someone you care about. Create a simple map showing who has the actual power to intervene effectively. List the boundary-pusher at the center, then draw lines to people who could realistically stop the behavior - supervisors, authorities, family members with influence, legal resources, or community leaders.
Consider:
- •Focus on people with equal or greater authority than the boundary-pusher, not just people who might sympathize
- •Consider both formal power (job titles, legal authority) and informal power (respect, influence, resources)
- •Think about documentation you might need to make your case to these power-holders
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you tried to reason with someone who was escalating bad behavior. What happened? Looking back, who had the real power to stop them, and how might approaching that person have changed the outcome?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 69: The Shocking Discovery at the Assembly
Moving forward, we'll examine unexpected revelations can shatter our understanding of our own identity, and understand having trusted allies who know your full story. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.
