Summary
Defending Her Heart Against Disappointment
Evelina, Or, the History of a Young Lady's Entrance into the World by Fanny Burney
Evelina writes to her friend Maria, defending herself against suggestions that she's romantically attached to Lord Orville. She insists her distress comes from disappointment in his character, not romantic feelings. The mysterious letter she received from him was so disrespectful and presumptuous that she's shocked someone she held in such high regard could write it. She regrets keeping this whole affair secret from Mr. Villars, her guardian, admitting that her 'false delicacy' in protecting Lord Orville's reputation has only made things worse. Everyone around her notices she's changed - she's grave and dejected, which worries Mr. Villars terribly. When Mrs. Selwyn offers to take her to Bristol for her health, Evelina refuses, preferring to stay with her beloved guardian rather than face more of the world. She reflects on how wrong she was about Lord Orville's character, having once imagined him as noble and honorable as Mr. Villars. The chapter reveals Evelina's struggle between her need to process betrayal and her tendency to withdraw from life entirely. Her idealization of both men - one who disappointed her, one who continues to support her - shows how young people often see the world in extremes when learning to navigate trust and disappointment.
Coming Up in Chapter 60
As Evelina tries to settle into quiet country life, new developments may force her to confront the very situations and people she's trying to avoid.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
LETTER LIX. EVELINA IN CONTINUATION. Berry Hill, July 29th. I MUST own myself somewhat distressed how to answer your raillery: yet, believe me, my dear Maria, your suggestions are those of fancy, not of truth. I am unconscious of the weakness you suspect; yet, to dispel your doubts, I will animate myself more than ever to conquer my chagrin, and to recover my spirits. You wonder, you say, since my heart takes no part in this affair, why it should make me so unhappy? And can you, acquainted as you are with the high opinion I entertained of Lord Orville, can you wonder that so great a disappointment in his character should affect me? Indeed, had so strange a letter been sent to me from any body, it could not have failed shocking me; how much more sensibly, then, must I feel such an affront, when received from the man in the world I had imagined least capable of giving it? You are glad I made no reply; assure yourself, my dear friend, had this letter been the most respectful that could be written, the clandestine air given to it, by his proposal of sending his servant for my answer, instead of having it directed to his house, would effectually have prevented my writing. Indeed, I have an aversion the most sincere to all mysteries, all private actions; however foolishly and blameably, in regard to this letter, I have deviated from the open path which, from my earliest infancy, I was taught to tread. He talks of my having commenced a correspondence with him: and could Lord Orville indeed believe I had such a design? believe me so forward, so bold, so strangely ridiculous? I know not if his man called or not; but I rejoice that I quitted London before he came, and without leaving any message for him. What, indeed, could I have said? it would have been a condescension very unmerited to have taken any, the least notice of such a letter. Never shall I cease to wonder how he could write it. Oh, Maria! what, what could induce him so causelessly to wound and affront one who would sooner have died than wilfully offended him? -How mortifying a freedom of style! how cruel an implication conveyed by his thanks and expressions of gratitude! Is it not astonishing, that any man can appear so modest, who is so vain? Every hour I regret the secrecy I have observed with my beloved Mr. Villars; I know not what bewitched me, but I felt at first a repugnance to publishing this affair that I could not surmount;-and now, I am ashamed of confessing that I have any thing to confess! Yet I deserve to be punished for the false delicacy which occasioned my silence, since, if Lord Orville himself was contented to forfeit his character, was it for me, almost at the expense of my own, to support it? Yet I believe I should be very easy, now the...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Idealization Crash
When we build someone up as perfect, their inevitable human flaws feel like devastating betrayals rather than normal disappointments.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how putting people on pedestals sets us up for devastating disappointment.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you catch yourself thinking someone is 'perfect' or 'not like other people'—that's your warning signal to gather more information before trusting completely.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
raillery
Gentle teasing or good-natured mockery between friends. In this chapter, Maria has been teasing Evelina about having romantic feelings for Lord Orville. It's the kind of ribbing friends do when they think they see something you're not admitting to yourself.
Modern Usage:
We still do this when friends tease us about crushes or call out our obvious feelings before we're ready to admit them.
clandestine air
The secretive, sneaky feeling that comes from doing things in hidden ways. Evelina is disturbed that Lord Orville suggested sending a servant for her reply instead of having her send it to his house openly. She sees this as shady behavior.
Modern Usage:
Today we'd be suspicious if someone asked us to text back through a friend instead of responding directly, or wanted to meet in secret parking lots instead of public places.
false delicacy
Being overly concerned with protecting someone's reputation or feelings when honesty would be better. Evelina admits she made things worse by trying to shield Lord Orville from consequences instead of telling her guardian the truth immediately.
Modern Usage:
This happens when we cover for toxic people at work or don't report harassment because we're worried about the perpetrator's career.
high opinion
Thinking very well of someone's character and abilities. Evelina had put Lord Orville on a pedestal, believing him to be honorable and noble. Her disappointment is so severe because she expected so much better from him.
Modern Usage:
We experience this when mentors, role models, or people we looked up to turn out to be different than we thought - the higher the pedestal, the harder the fall.
open path
Living with honesty and transparency, without secrets or hidden agendas. Evelina has always prided herself on being straightforward, which makes this secretive situation feel wrong to her.
Modern Usage:
This is like someone who's always been honest suddenly finding themselves keeping secrets and feeling uncomfortable about it.
dejected
Feeling sad, discouraged, and low in spirits. Everyone around Evelina can see that she's changed from her usual self - she's withdrawn and gloomy, which worries the people who care about her.
Modern Usage:
When coworkers or family notice you're 'not yourself' and ask if everything's okay because your whole energy has shifted.
Characters in This Chapter
Evelina
protagonist
She's defending herself against accusations of being in love while processing deep disappointment in someone she respected. Her struggle shows how young people often withdraw when their trust is broken, and how hard it is to admit when we've misjudged someone's character.
Modern Equivalent:
The young person who trusted the wrong mentor and is now questioning their judgment about everyone
Maria
friend and correspondent
She's the friend who sees what Evelina won't admit - that her feelings run deeper than disappointment. Maria represents the outside perspective that often sees our blind spots more clearly than we do.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who calls you out on your obvious feelings and won't let you lie to yourself
Lord Orville
source of disappointment
Though not present, he dominates the chapter as the person who shattered Evelina's faith. His mysterious, disrespectful letter has revealed a character completely different from what she believed him to be.
Modern Equivalent:
The respected boss or mentor who turns out to be a creep and makes you question your ability to judge people
Mr. Villars
guardian and moral compass
He represents the stable, trustworthy relationship in Evelina's life. His worry about her changed behavior shows how our pain affects the people who love us, and he serves as her standard for what good character looks like.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent or guardian who notices when you're struggling and whose steady presence reminds you what healthy relationships look like
Mrs. Selwyn
well-meaning acquaintance
She offers to take Evelina to Bristol for her health, representing the world's attempts to fix us with distractions when what we really need is time to process and heal.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who suggests girls' trips or retail therapy when you're dealing with something deeper
Key Quotes & Analysis
"th. I am unconscious of the weakness you suspect; yet, to dispel your doubts, I will animate myself more than ever to conquer my chagrin, and to recover my spirits. You wonder, you say, since"
Context: She's responding to Maria's teasing about having romantic feelings for Lord Orville
This shows classic denial - she's protesting too much and promising to 'get over it' in a way that suggests the feelings are exactly what Maria thinks they are. Her formal language can't hide the emotional intensity underneath.
In Today's Words:
I don't have feelings for him like you think, but fine, I'll prove it by getting over this whole thing faster.
"ting. Indeed, I have an aversion the most sincere to all mysteries, all private actions; however"
Context: She's explaining why she won't respond to Lord Orville's secretive letter
This reveals her core values about honesty and transparency. It also shows the irony - she hates secrets but is keeping this whole situation secret from her guardian, which she later admits was wrong.
In Today's Words:
I really hate sneaky, shady behavior and people who can't be straightforward.
"me; how much more sensibly, then, must I feel such an affront, when received from the man in the world I had imagined least capable of giving it? You are glad I made n"
Context: She's explaining why Lord Orville's letter was so devastating
This captures the specific pain of betrayal by someone we trusted completely. The higher our expectations, the more crushing the disappointment. She's learning that putting people on pedestals sets us up for devastating falls.
In Today's Words:
It hurt so much worse because he was literally the last person I would have expected to treat me this way.
Thematic Threads
Trust
In This Chapter
Evelina's complete shock at Lord Orville's letter shows how her trust was based on idealization rather than realistic assessment
Development
Evolved from her initial social anxiety to now questioning her ability to judge character entirely
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone you trusted completely lets you down and you feel like you can't trust your own judgment anymore.
Identity
In This Chapter
Evelina defines herself through others' opinions and her ability to read character correctly
Development
Progressed from seeking approval to now having her self-worth shattered by misjudging someone
In Your Life:
You might see this when a relationship disappointment makes you question who you are as a person.
Social Navigation
In This Chapter
Her withdrawal from Bristol shows how betrayal can make us retreat from all social engagement
Development
Moved from eager social participation to complete social withdrawal as protection
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when one bad experience makes you want to avoid similar situations entirely.
Communication
In This Chapter
Her regret about keeping secrets from Mr. Villars reveals how protecting others can backfire
Development
Developed from initial openness to secretiveness and back to recognizing the value of honest communication
In Your Life:
You might see this when trying to 'protect' someone by not telling them about a problem actually makes everything worse.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific evidence does Evelina give to prove she's not romantically interested in Lord Orville?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Evelina regret keeping the mysterious letter secret from Mr. Villars, and what does this reveal about the cost of trying to protect someone's reputation?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today putting others on pedestals the way Evelina idealized Lord Orville, and what usually happens when reality hits?
application • medium - 4
How would you advise someone who's discovered that a person they deeply respected has disappointed them - should they withdraw like Evelina or take a different approach?
application • deep - 5
What does Evelina's shock at Lord Orville's apparent character change teach us about the danger of seeing people as either perfect or terrible, rather than complex humans?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Build a Reality Check System
Think of someone you currently hold in very high regard - a boss, friend, family member, or public figure. Write down three specific qualities you admire about them. Then, for each quality, imagine a realistic scenario where that person might disappoint you or act differently than expected. This isn't about becoming cynical - it's about building emotional resilience.
Consider:
- •Consider what you don't know about this person's full character or circumstances
- •Think about how you would maintain the relationship if they disappointed you in small ways
- •Reflect on whether your admiration is based on complete information or idealized assumptions
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone you respected let you down. How did you handle it, and what would you do differently now with more life experience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 60: Breaking Down Walls of Silence
In the next chapter, you'll discover emotional walls we build to protect ourselves can hurt those who love us most, and learn the healing power of honest conversation when we're struggling internally. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.
