Summary
Marx breaks down the cold mathematics behind how capitalists extract profit from workers. He shows that surplus value—the profit owners make—comes from a simple formula: the rate of exploitation times the number of workers employed. If you pay a worker for 6 hours but make them work 12, you pocket 6 hours of unpaid labor. Scale this up across hundreds of workers, and the profits multiply accordingly. But Marx reveals crucial limits to this system. You can't make workers labor more than 24 hours a day, so there's a ceiling to how much you can squeeze from each person. This creates a fundamental tension—owners want maximum profit but face physical constraints on human endurance. The chapter exposes how this mathematical relationship shapes everything from factory schedules to hiring decisions. Marx also explains why you need substantial startup money to become a true capitalist—it's not just about having some cash, but having enough to employ multiple workers and live off their unpaid labor. The most chilling insight comes at the end, where Marx shows how this system inverts normal human relationships. Instead of workers using tools to create things, the tools (representing capital) now 'consume' the workers, feeding off their life energy. A Scottish factory owner's complaint about shorter work days perfectly illustrates this twisted logic—he genuinely believes his machines lose value if they can't extract as much unpaid labor from workers.
Coming Up in Chapter 12
Having established the mathematical limits of absolute surplus value, Marx now turns to a more sophisticated form of exploitation. What happens when capitalists can't simply force longer hours, but must find cleverer ways to extract more value from the same working time?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
RATE AND MASS OF SURPLUS-VALUE Economic Manuscripts: Capital Vol. I - Chapter Eleven Karl Marx. Capital Volume One Chapter Eleven: Rate and Mass of Surplus Value In this chapter, as hitherto, the value of labour-power, and therefore the part of the working day necessary for the reproduction or maintenance of that labour-power, are supposed to be given, constant magnitudes. This premised, with the rate, the mass is at the same time given of the surplus-value that the individual labourer furnishes to the capitalist in a definite period of time. If, e.g., the necessary labour amounts to 6 hours daily, expressed in a quantum of gold = 3 shillings, then 3s. is the daily value of one labour-power or the value of the capital advanced in the buying of one labour-power. If, further, the rate of surplus-value be = 100%, this variable capital of 3s. produces a mass of surplus-value of 3s., or the labourer supplies daily a mass of surplus labour equal to 6 hours. But the variable capital of a capitalist is the expression in money of the total value of all the labour-powers that he employs simultaneously. Its value is, therefore, equal to the average value of one labour-power, multiplied by the number of labour-powers employed. With a given value of labour-power, therefore, the magnitude of the variable capital varies directly as the number of labourers employed simultaneously. If the daily value of one labour-power = 3s., then a capital of 300s. must be advanced in order to exploit daily 100 labour-powers, of n times 3s., in order to exploit daily n labour-powers. In the same way, if a variable capital of 3s., being the daily value of one labour-power, produce a daily surplus-value of 3s., a variable capital of 300s. will produce a daily surplus-value of 300s., and one of n times 3s. a daily surplus-value of n × 3s. The mass of the surplus-value produced is therefore equal to the surplus-value which the working day of one labourer supplies multiplied by the number of labourers employed. But as further the mass of surplus-value which a single labourer produces, the value of labour-power being given, is determined by the rate of the surplus-value, this law follows: the mass of the surplus-value produced is equal to the amount of the variable capital advanced, multiplied by the rate of surplus-value, in other words: it is determined by the compound ratio between the number of labour-powers exploited simultaneously by the same capitalist and the degree of exploitation of each individual labour-power. Let the mass of the surplus-value be S, the surplus-value supplied by the individual labourer in the average day s the variable capital daily advanced in the purchase of one individual labour-power v, the sum total of the variable capital V, the value of an average labour-power P, its degree of exploitation (a'/a) (surplus-labour/necessary-labour) and the number of labourers employed n; we have: S = { (s/v) × VP × (a'/a) × n It is always supposed, not only...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Mathematical Exploitation - How Numbers Hide Human Cost
When human relationships are converted into numbers and formulas, making exploitation appear rational and justified.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to see the human price hidden behind business metrics and efficiency numbers.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when your workplace uses numbers to justify changes—ask yourself who benefits from these metrics and who pays the real cost.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Surplus Value
The profit a boss makes from your work beyond what they pay you. If you create $20 worth of value in an hour but only get paid $10, that extra $10 is surplus value that goes to the owner.
Modern Usage:
When your manager brags about record profits while you haven't gotten a raise in two years, that's surplus value in action.
Variable Capital
The money a business owner spends on wages - it's called 'variable' because it's the only part of their investment that actually creates new value and profit.
Modern Usage:
When companies talk about 'labor costs' as their biggest expense, they're really talking about variable capital - the workers who generate all their wealth.
Rate of Surplus Value
How much unpaid work you do compared to paid work. If you work 8 hours but only get paid for the value you create in 4 hours, your rate of exploitation is 100%.
Modern Usage:
Productivity has doubled since the 1970s but wages stayed flat - that's the rate of surplus value increasing dramatically.
Necessary Labor
The portion of your workday spent creating enough value to cover your own wages and benefits. Everything beyond that is free labor for your boss.
Modern Usage:
If you make your daily wage worth of value by 2pm but work until 6pm, those last 4 hours are pure profit for the company.
Labor Power
Your ability to work - not just your time, but your skills, energy, and capacity to create value. Bosses don't buy your labor directly, they rent your labor power.
Modern Usage:
When job ads say 'we're not just hiring you, we're hiring your potential,' they're literally talking about purchasing your labor power.
Absolute Limits
The physical boundaries on how much work can be extracted from humans - you can't work more than 24 hours a day or survive without rest and food.
Modern Usage:
When companies push for longer hours and fewer breaks, they're testing the absolute limits of what workers can endure before breaking down.
Characters in This Chapter
The Individual Laborer
The exploited worker
Marx uses this worker to show the basic math of exploitation. This person works 12 hours but only gets paid for 6 hours worth of value, with the other 6 hours becoming pure profit for the boss.
Modern Equivalent:
The warehouse worker who hits all their targets but watches the company post record profits while their wages stay stagnant
The Capitalist
The profit-extracting owner
The business owner who employs multiple workers and lives off their unpaid labor. Marx shows how this person needs substantial money upfront to become a true capitalist who can live without working.
Modern Equivalent:
The franchise owner who owns multiple locations and makes money from other people's work while playing golf
The Scottish Factory Owner
Real-world example of capitalist logic
Marx quotes this actual factory owner complaining that shorter work days hurt his profits. The owner genuinely believes his machines lose value if they can't extract maximum labor from workers.
Modern Equivalent:
The CEO who complains that work-from-home policies hurt productivity because they can't monitor every minute of employee time
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The rate of surplus-value is therefore an exact expression for the degree of exploitation of labour-power by capital, or of the labourer by the capitalist."
Context: Marx is explaining how to measure exactly how much workers are being ripped off
This quote cuts through all the business jargon about 'human resources' and 'team members' to show the cold mathematical reality. Marx is saying we can calculate precisely how much unpaid work you're doing for your boss.
In Today's Words:
You can do the math on exactly how badly you're getting screwed at work.
"Capital is reckless of the health or length of life of the laborer, unless under compulsion from society."
Context: Marx is explaining why workplace safety laws had to be forced on employers
This reveals the fundamental conflict between profit and human welfare. Left to their own devices, employers will work people to death if it increases profits. Only laws and worker organizing force them to care about human limits.
In Today's Words:
Your boss doesn't care if the job kills you unless they're legally forced to care.
"The capitalist buys labour-power in order to use it; and labour-power can be used only by working."
Context: Marx is explaining the basic transaction between worker and boss
This simple statement reveals something profound - when you get hired, your boss isn't paying for your time, they're paying for your ability to create value. They want to squeeze as much work as possible from that purchase.
In Today's Words:
When they hire you, they're not buying your hours - they're buying your ability to make them money.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Marx exposes the mathematical relationship between owners and workers, showing how class position determines who extracts value and who provides it
Development
Building from earlier chapters about labor value, now showing the precise formulas that govern class exploitation
In Your Life:
You might see this in how management treats workers as 'human resources' with calculated productivity expectations rather than as people with limits and needs
Power
In This Chapter
The chapter reveals how having enough capital to employ multiple workers creates a fundamentally different power position in society
Development
Expanding on power dynamics to show the mathematical threshold that separates true capitalists from workers
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in how having enough savings changes your relationship to work—you can take risks others can't afford
Dehumanization
In This Chapter
Marx shows how the system inverts human relationships, making tools 'consume' workers rather than workers using tools
Development
Introduced here as the ultimate consequence of treating human labor as just another input in mathematical formulas
In Your Life:
You might feel this when your workplace treats you like a machine that should run at maximum efficiency without considering your human needs
Limits
In This Chapter
The chapter emphasizes physical constraints on exploitation—workers can't labor more than 24 hours a day
Development
Building on earlier themes about labor time to show how natural limits create tensions in the capitalist system
In Your Life:
You might see this in your own burnout when employers push you beyond sustainable limits, creating inevitable breaking points
Identity
In This Chapter
Marx reveals how the system shapes identity by determining whether you live off your own labor or others' unpaid work
Development
Deepening the exploration of how economic position fundamentally shapes who you become
In Your Life:
You might notice how your relationship to money and work shapes your sense of self and your relationships with others
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Marx shows that profit comes from unpaid labor - paying workers for 6 hours but making them work 12. Where do you see this 'time theft' happening in modern workplaces?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Marx say you need substantial startup money to become a true capitalist? What does this reveal about who gets to be an owner versus who stays a worker?
analysis • medium - 3
Marx describes how 'machines consume workers' instead of workers using machines. Where do you see technology or systems treating people as fuel to be burned up?
application • medium - 4
The Scottish factory owner complained that shorter work days made his machines 'lose value.' How do managers today use similar logic to justify overworking people?
application • deep - 5
Marx reveals how mathematical formulas can hide human exploitation. What does this teach us about the difference between being efficient and being ethical?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Numbers Game
Think of a workplace metric you encounter - productivity scores, customer satisfaction ratings, efficiency targets, or performance reviews. Write down what the numbers supposedly measure, then identify what human costs or experiences those numbers might be hiding. Finally, rewrite that metric to include what it's actually asking of people.
Consider:
- •Numbers always tell a story - but whose story gets heard?
- •What gets measured often becomes what gets valued, regardless of real importance
- •The more complex the formula, the easier it is to hide who's paying the real price
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were reduced to a number or metric at work, school, or in healthcare. How did it feel to be measured that way? What important parts of your contribution or experience did those numbers miss?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 12: Working Smarter, Not Harder: The Productivity Trap
The coming pages reveal increasing productivity can actually hurt workers despite making things cheaper, and teach us employers push efficiency improvements that don't reduce your working hours. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.