Summary
The Stirling family is finally catching on that something has fundamentally changed in Valancy. What started with her defiant rosebush moment has escalated into a series of small but shocking rebellions: refusing her medications, rejecting her childhood nickname 'Doss,' sliding down the bannister like a child, and threatening to switch churches just to spite her mother. The family doesn't want to admit she's having a breakdown, but Uncle Benjamin bluntly calls her 'dippy' after her wedding dinner outburst. Mrs. Frederick tries tears when her usual stern authority fails, but Valancy remains unmoved by guilt trips about being an ungrateful daughter. The chapter captures that delicate moment when someone who has been controlled their entire life begins pushing back in ways both petty and profound. Valancy's decision to wave at the town drunk, Roaring Abel, shows her growing identification with outsiders and rebels. She sees him as a kindred spirit—someone who refuses to conform to Deerwood's suffocating respectability, even if his rebellion comes through drinking rather than dreams. As they arrive at Uncle Herbert's ostentatious house for the silver wedding celebration, Valancy calls the building 'a blasphemy,' shocking her mother with this unexpected poetic criticism. Her mother's final plea to 'remember you're a lady' receives the devastating response that Valancy wishes she could forget being one entirely. This chapter perfectly captures how family systems struggle to adapt when the 'good girl' stops being good.
Coming Up in Chapter 10
The silver wedding celebration is about to begin, and Valancy is armed with a new perspective on her relatives and a dangerous willingness to speak her mind. With her declaration of independence ready to deploy, the family gathering promises to be anything but peaceful.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Uncle Herbert and Aunt Alberta’s silver wedding was delicately referred to among the Stirlings during the following weeks as “the time we first noticed poor Valancy was—a little—_you_ understand?” Not for worlds would any of the Stirlings have said out and out at first that Valancy had gone mildly insane or even that her mind was slightly deranged. Uncle Benjamin was considered to have gone entirely too far when he had ejaculated, “She’s dippy—I tell you, she’s dippy,” and was only excused because of the outrageousness of Valancy’s conduct at the aforesaid wedding dinner. But Mrs. Frederick and Cousin Stickles had noticed a few things that made them uneasy _before_ the dinner. It had begun with the rosebush, of course; and Valancy never was really “quite right” again. She did not seem to worry in the least over the fact that her mother was not speaking to her. You would never suppose she noticed it at all. She had flatly refused to take either Purple Pills or Redfern’s Bitters. She had announced coolly that she did not intend to answer to the name of “Doss” any longer. She had told Cousin Stickles that she wished she would give up wearing that brooch with Cousin Artemas Stickles’ hair in it. She had moved her bed in her room to the opposite corner. She had read _Magic of Wings_ Sunday afternoon. When Cousin Stickles had rebuked her Valancy had said indifferently, “Oh, I forgot it was Sunday”—and _had gone on reading it_. Cousin Stickles had seen a terrible thing—she had caught Valancy sliding down the bannister. Cousin Stickles did not tell Mrs. Frederick this—poor Amelia was worried enough as it was. But it was Valancy’s announcement on Saturday night that she was not going to go to the Anglican church any more that broke through Mrs. Frederick’s stony silence. “Not going to church any more! Doss, have you absolutely taken leave——” “Oh, I’m going to church,” said Valancy airily. “I’m going to the Presbyterian church. But to the Anglican church I will not go.” This was even worse. Mrs. Frederick had recourse to tears, having found outraged majesty had ceased to be effective. “What have you got against the Anglican church?” she sobbed. “Nothing—only just that you’ve always made me go there. If you’d made me go to the Presbyterian church I’d want to go to the Anglican.” “Is that a nice thing to say to your mother? Oh, how true it is that it is sharper than a serpent’s tooth to have a thankless child.” “Is that a nice thing to say to your daughter?” said unrepentant Valancy. So Valancy’s behaviour at the silver wedding was not quite the surprise to Mrs. Frederick and Christine Stickles that it was to the rest. They were doubtful about the wisdom of taking her, but concluded it would “make talk” if they didn’t. Perhaps she would behave herself, and so far no outsider suspected there was anything queer about her. By a special mercy...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Controlled Rebellion
The incremental process by which chronically controlled people begin asserting independence through small acts of defiance that build toward larger boundary-setting.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how controlling families use shame, guilt, and dismissal to maintain power over adults who should be free.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when family members use phrases like 'after all I've done for you' or 'you're being selfish' to shut down your boundaries—those are control tactics, not legitimate concerns.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Silver wedding
A celebration of 25 years of marriage, traditionally marked with silver gifts and formal gatherings. In 1926, this was a major social milestone that required elaborate entertaining and demonstrated family status in small communities.
Modern Usage:
We still celebrate 25th anniversaries, though usually with less formal family obligations and social pressure.
Patent medicines
Over-the-counter remedies like 'Purple Pills' and 'Redfern's Bitters' that were heavily marketed but often contained alcohol or questionable ingredients. Families relied on these for everything from nerves to digestion.
Modern Usage:
Today's equivalent would be wellness supplements, essential oils, or any product promising to cure vague symptoms without real medical backing.
Family scapegoat
The person in a dysfunctional family system who gets blamed for everything that goes wrong and is expected to absorb everyone else's anxiety. They're kept in line through guilt, shame, and isolation.
Modern Usage:
Every family has someone who gets the 'you're being dramatic' treatment when they try to set boundaries or speak up about problems.
Respectability politics
The unwritten rules about how to behave to maintain social standing in a community. Breaking these rules meant social exile, especially for unmarried women who had no independent status.
Modern Usage:
We see this in workplace culture, social media behavior, or any situation where people police each other's choices to maintain group acceptance.
Spinster daughter role
The unmarried daughter who was expected to stay home and care for aging parents, sacrificing her own life for family duty. This was seen as her natural purpose if marriage didn't happen.
Modern Usage:
Today it's the adult child who's expected to handle all family crises, coordinate care for parents, and put their own life on hold because 'you're the responsible one.'
Social ostracism
Being deliberately excluded from community life as punishment for not conforming to expected behavior. In small towns, this could destroy someone's entire support system and livelihood.
Modern Usage:
Cancel culture, workplace freezeouts, or being blocked from friend groups when you don't go along with the crowd.
Characters in This Chapter
Valancy Stirling
Protagonist in rebellion
Finally pushing back against decades of family control through small but shocking acts of defiance. Her refusal to take medicine, rejection of her nickname, and casual rule-breaking show someone discovering their own power.
Modern Equivalent:
The people-pleaser who finally starts saying no and watching everyone lose their minds over it
Mrs. Frederick
Controlling mother
Desperately trying to regain control over Valancy through guilt trips and emotional manipulation. Her tears and appeals to being a 'lady' show how threatened she feels by losing her compliant daughter.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who uses guilt and 'after everything I've done for you' when their adult child starts setting boundaries
Uncle Benjamin
Family truth-teller
The only one willing to say out loud what everyone's thinking - that Valancy has snapped. His blunt 'she's dippy' comment breaks the family's polite denial about the situation.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative who says what everyone's thinking at family gatherings and makes everyone uncomfortable
Cousin Stickles
Family enforcer
Acts as Mrs. Frederick's ally in trying to control Valancy through criticism and social pressure. Her shock at Valancy's new behavior shows how the whole family system is threatened.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who reports back to your parents about everything you do and tries to shame you into compliance
Roaring Abel
Town outcast
The village drunk who represents complete rejection of social expectations. Valancy's decision to wave at him shows her growing identification with outsiders and rebels.
Modern Equivalent:
The person in town everyone talks about and avoids - the one who doesn't play by society's rules
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She's dippy—I tell you, she's dippy"
Context: His blunt assessment of Valancy's behavior after the wedding dinner incident
This quote shows how the family can no longer maintain polite denial about Valancy's transformation. Benjamin's crude honesty cuts through their careful euphemisms and forces them to confront reality.
In Today's Words:
She's lost it - I'm telling you, she's completely lost it
"Oh, I forgot it was Sunday"
Context: Her response when criticized for reading secular literature on the Sabbath
This seemingly innocent comment is actually revolutionary - it shows Valancy no longer automatically follows religious rules that once governed every aspect of her life. Her casual indifference is more shocking than open rebellion would be.
In Today's Words:
Oops, my bad - but I'm not stopping
"I wish I could forget I was a lady"
Context: Her response to her mother's plea to 'remember you're a lady'
This reveals Valancy's growing understanding that being a 'lady' has been a prison. She's beginning to see how these social expectations have limited her entire existence and stolen her authentic self.
In Today's Words:
I'm sick of having to be the good girl all the time
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Valancy rejects her childhood nickname 'Doss' and begins defining herself against family expectations
Development
Evolved from her earlier passive acceptance to active self-definition
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you start correcting people who use outdated versions of your name or identity.
Class
In This Chapter
Valancy identifies with 'Roaring Abel' the town drunk, seeing him as a fellow rebel against respectability
Development
Building on her growing rejection of middle-class propriety
In Your Life:
You might find yourself sympathizing with people your family or social circle looks down on.
Family Systems
In This Chapter
The family struggles to maintain control as Valancy's small rebellions disrupt their established dynamics
Development
Escalated from their initial dismissal to Uncle Benjamin's blunt assessment that she's 'dippy'
In Your Life:
You might see this when your family can't adjust to your new boundaries and labels your growth as problems.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Valancy's mother's desperate plea to 'remember you're a lady' meets with Valancy's wish she could forget it
Development
Intensified from earlier chapters where Valancy simply ignored expectations
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you're tired of being the 'good' one who always follows the rules.
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Valancy's growing confidence shows in her poetic criticism of Uncle Herbert's house as 'a blasphemy'
Development
Advanced from her earlier timid observations to bold aesthetic judgments
In Your Life:
You might notice this when you start expressing opinions you used to keep to yourself.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific acts of rebellion does Valancy engage in, and how does her family react to each one?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Valancy identify with Roaring Abel, and what does this tell us about how she sees herself changing?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of 'controlled rebellion' in your own life or workplace—someone who's always been compliant suddenly pushing back in small ways?
application • medium - 4
When someone you know starts setting boundaries after years of going along with everything, how should you respond to support their growth?
application • deep - 5
What does Valancy's journey teach us about the relationship between control and eventual rebellion in human nature?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Own Rebellion Pattern
Think of a time when you started pushing back against expectations—at work, in family, or relationships. Create a timeline of your small acts of resistance, from the first tiny boundary to bigger changes. Notice the pattern: What gave you courage for each next step? How did others react?
Consider:
- •Small rebellions often feel scarier to us than they appear to others
- •Each successful boundary builds confidence for the next one
- •Family or workplace systems resist change even when it's healthy growth
Journaling Prompt
Write about a current situation where you're feeling controlled or overlooked. What would your version of 'refusing the medicine' or 'sliding down the bannister' look like? What small boundary could you set this week?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 10: Seeing Through New Eyes
In the next chapter, you'll discover fear can make us invisible in social situations, and learn the power of shifting perspective to see people clearly. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.