Summary
Valancy finally returns to Dr. Trent to get the medical clearance she needs, but what she discovers shatters her world in an entirely unexpected way. The doctor doesn't recognize her at first—she's transformed so completely from the timid, sickly woman who visited him over a year ago. When she reminds him of her heart condition diagnosis, he's confused and insists he told her nothing was seriously wrong. The truth emerges in a moment of horrifying clarity: Dr. Trent had mixed up two letters. The death sentence he'd given Valancy—angina pectoris, aneurism, less than a year to live—was meant for an elderly woman named Miss Jane Sterling from Port Lawrence. Valancy had received the wrong diagnosis entirely. Her actual condition, pseudo-angina, was never fatal and has already cleared up, likely cured by the 'shock of joy' she felt when Barney returned safely from the storm. Dr. Trent is mortified by his mistake, but Valancy feels devastated rather than relieved. The year she thought was borrowed time—the year that gave her courage to break free, marry Barney, and finally live—was built on a lie. Now she faces a terrible irony: she's perfectly healthy and could live to be a hundred, but she's trapped in a marriage she entered under false pretenses. The doctor assumes she's unhappy because she married badly, not knowing that her despair comes from realizing her entire transformation was based on believing she was dying. The mistake that freed her has now become her prison.
Coming Up in Chapter 38
Armed with the devastating knowledge that she's perfectly healthy, Valancy must now confront what her marriage to Barney really means. Will she tell him the truth about why she married him, knowing it could destroy everything they've built together?
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Dr. Trent looked at her blankly and fumbled among his recollections. “Er—Miss—Miss—” “Mrs. Snaith,” said Valancy quietly. “I was Miss Valancy Stirling when I came to you last May—over a year ago. I wanted to consult you about my heart.” Dr. Trent’s face cleared. “Oh, of course. I remember now. I’m really not to blame for not knowing you. You’ve changed—splendidly. And married. Well, well, it has agreed with you. You don’t look much like an invalid now, hey? I remember that day. I was badly upset. Hearing about poor Ned bowled me over. But Ned’s as good as new and you, too, evidently. I told you so, you know—told you there was nothing to worry over.” Valancy looked at him. “You told me, in your letter,” she said slowly, with a curious feeling that some one else was talking through her lips, “that I had angina pectoris—in the last stages—complicated with an aneurism. That I might die any minute—that I couldn’t live longer than a year.” Dr. Trent stared at her. “Impossible!” he said blankly. “I couldn’t have told you that!” Valancy took his letter from her bag and handed it to him. “Miss Valancy Stirling,” he read. “Yes—yes. Of course I wrote you—on the train—that night. But I _told_ you there was nothing serious——” “Read your letter,” insisted Valancy. Dr. Trent took it out—unfolded it—glanced over it. A dismayed look came into his face. He jumped to his feet and strode agitatedly about the room. “Good heavens! This is the letter I meant for old Miss Jane Sterling. From Port Lawrence. She was here that day, too. I sent you the wrong letter. What unpardonable carelessness! But I was beside myself that night. My God, and you believed that—you believed—but you didn’t—you went to another doctor——” Valancy stood up, turned round, looked foolishly about her and sat down again. “I believed it,” she said faintly. “I didn’t go to any other doctor. I—I—it would take too long to explain. But I believed I was going to die soon.” Dr. Trent halted before her. “I can never forgive myself. What a year you must have had! But you don’t look—I can’t understand!” “Never mind,” said Valancy dully. “And so there’s nothing the matter with my heart?” “Well, nothing serious. You had what is called pseudo-angina. It’s never fatal—passes away completely with proper treatment. Or sometimes with a shock of joy. Have you been troubled much with it?” “Not at all since March,” answered Valancy. She remembered the marvellous feeling of re-creation she had had when she saw Barney coming home safe after the storm. Had that “shock of joy” cured her? “Then likely you’re all right. I told you what to do in the letter you should have got. _And_ of course I supposed you’d go to another doctor. Child, why didn’t you?” “I didn’t want anybody to know.” “Idiot,” said Dr. Trent bluntly. “I can’t understand such folly. And poor old Miss Sterling. She must have got your...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of False Foundations - When Wrong Reasons Lead to Right Places
Attributing personal growth to wrong external sources, making us vulnerable when those sources disappear.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to separate the circumstances that revealed your strength from the strength itself.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you credit external situations for your capabilities—ask yourself what internal qualities you're actually drawing on.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Angina pectoris
A serious heart condition causing chest pain due to reduced blood flow to the heart. In the 1920s, this diagnosis was often a death sentence with limited treatment options available.
Modern Usage:
Today we have medications, procedures, and lifestyle changes that make this very manageable, but a misdiagnosis like this would still cause massive psychological trauma.
Aneurism
A dangerous bulge in a blood vessel that can burst and cause death. Combined with angina, this would have been considered an immediate death threat in 1926.
Modern Usage:
We still fear aneurysms today, but advanced imaging and surgical techniques make them much more treatable than they were a century ago.
Pseudo-angina
A condition that mimics real heart disease but isn't actually dangerous - often caused by stress, anxiety, or other non-cardiac factors. The symptoms feel real but the heart is healthy.
Modern Usage:
We now call this 'anxiety-related chest pain' or 'stress-induced symptoms' - very common and treatable with stress management.
Medical malpractice
When a doctor makes a serious error that harms a patient. Mixing up diagnoses like Dr. Trent did would destroy lives and careers, even in the 1920s.
Modern Usage:
Today this would result in massive lawsuits, license suspension, and systematic changes to prevent mix-ups through electronic records.
False pretenses
Entering into a relationship or agreement based on lies or misunderstandings. Valancy feels her marriage is invalid because she only had courage to marry when she thought she was dying.
Modern Usage:
We see this in relationships where someone discovers their partner wasn't honest about fundamental things - job, finances, past relationships, or intentions.
Borrowed time
Living with the belief that death is imminent, so every moment is precious and stolen from fate. This mindset gave Valancy permission to break all social rules.
Modern Usage:
People facing terminal diagnoses, major life changes, or deadlines often describe feeling like they're living on borrowed time.
Characters in This Chapter
Valancy
Protagonist in crisis
Discovers her entire year of freedom was based on a lie. Instead of relief at being healthy, she feels devastated because her courage came from thinking she was dying.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who finally stands up to their family after a health scare, only to discover the scare was false
Dr. Trent
Negligent authority figure
Reveals he mixed up two patients' diagnoses, giving Valancy a death sentence meant for someone else. His carelessness destroyed and then rebuilt a life.
Modern Equivalent:
The distracted professional whose mistake has massive consequences - like mixing up test results or sending the wrong email
Miss Jane Sterling
Unseen victim
The elderly woman who actually had the fatal diagnosis but received Valancy's clean bill of health instead. Her fate remains unknown but implied to be tragic.
Modern Equivalent:
The other person affected by a bureaucratic mix-up who never gets their story told
Key Quotes & Analysis
"You told me, in your letter, that I had angina pectoris—in the last stages—complicated with an aneurism. That I might die any minute—that I couldn't live longer than a year."
Context: Confronting Dr. Trent with his written diagnosis that changed her entire life
This moment reveals the power of medical authority and how a single piece of paper can completely transform someone's existence. Valancy's calm delivery shows how this false diagnosis became her truth.
In Today's Words:
You told me I was dying and had less than a year to live.
"Good God! I've sent this letter to the wrong person!"
Context: Realizing his catastrophic mistake after reading his own letter
The horror of professional negligence hitting home. His casual mistake had life-altering consequences, showing how authority figures' carelessness can devastate ordinary people's lives.
In Today's Words:
Oh no, I sent the wrong test results to the wrong patient!
"The shock of joy when your husband returned safely from that storm probably cured you completely."
Context: Explaining how Valancy's pseudo-angina was healed by emotional relief
Ironically, the fake diagnosis led to real healing through the joy and love Valancy found. Her emotional transformation had actual physical benefits, even though the original threat was imaginary.
In Today's Words:
The happiness and relief you felt probably fixed your stress-related symptoms completely.
Thematic Threads
Identity
In This Chapter
Valancy's entire sense of self was built on believing she was dying—now she doesn't know who she is as a healthy woman
Development
Evolved from her initial self-hatred to transformation through 'borrowed time' to this crisis of authentic selfhood
In Your Life:
You might question your worth when external validation disappears, forgetting your inherent value
Truth
In This Chapter
The medical mix-up reveals how a lie accidentally freed Valancy, but now the truth feels like a prison
Development
Built from earlier themes about family lies and social pretenses to this ultimate irony about liberating falsehood
In Your Life:
You might discover that something you believed was wrong but led to positive changes in your life
Class
In This Chapter
Dr. Trent's careless mistake with patient files shows how working-class lives can be casually damaged by professional errors
Development
Continues the theme of how class differences create power imbalances that harm ordinary people
In Your Life:
You might experience consequences from others' professional mistakes that they can easily dismiss but that devastate your life
Agency
In This Chapter
Valancy feels her agency was fake—based on thinking she had nothing to lose rather than choosing to gain something
Development
Challenges her earlier empowerment by questioning whether courage from desperation counts as real choice
In Your Life:
You might doubt decisions made during crisis, wondering if they reflect your true self or just circumstances
Irony
In This Chapter
The mistake that freed her has become her trap—health feels like a curse when it undermines the foundation of her courage
Development
Culminates the book's pattern of unexpected reversals where apparent disasters become blessings and vice versa
In Your Life:
You might find that getting what you thought you wanted creates new problems you never anticipated
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What shocking discovery does Valancy make when she returns to Dr. Trent, and how does he explain what happened?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Valancy feel devastated rather than relieved when she learns she's perfectly healthy?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about times when people make major life changes 'because of' a crisis or deadline. What happens when that external pressure disappears?
application • medium - 4
If you were Valancy's friend, how would you help her see that her courage and growth were real, not just products of believing she was dying?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between external motivations and internal strength?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Audit Your Power Sources
List three areas where you feel confident or strong. For each one, write down what you think gives you that confidence. Then ask: if that external thing disappeared tomorrow, would your ability disappear too? This exercise helps you separate true internal strength from borrowed external props.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns where you credit circumstances rather than your own choices and skills
- •Notice if your confidence depends heavily on other people's approval or specific situations
- •Consider how your past successes reveal capabilities that live inside you, not outside
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you surprised yourself with your own strength or capability. What does this reveal about resources you already possess but might not fully recognize?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 38: When Wealth Changes Everything
What lies ahead teaches us sudden revelations can completely reframe our understanding of a situation, and shows us assumptions about someone's circumstances can blind us to reality. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.