An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1546 words)
he next day passed for Valancy like a dream. She could not make
herself or anything she did seem real. She saw nothing of Barney,
though she expected he must go rattling past on his way to the Port for
a license.
Perhaps he had changed his mind.
But at dusk the lights of Lady Jane suddenly swooped over the crest of
the wooded hill beyond the lane. Valancy was waiting at the gate for
her bridegroom. She wore her green dress and her green hat because she
had nothing else to wear. She did not look or feel at all
bride-like—she really looked like a wild elf strayed out of the
greenwood. But that did not matter. Nothing at all mattered except that
Barney was coming for her.
“Ready?” said Barney, stopping Lady Jane with some new, horrible
noises.
“Yes.” Valancy stepped in and sat down. Barney was in his blue shirt
and overalls. But they were clean overalls. He was smoking a
villainous-looking pipe and he was bareheaded. But he had a pair of
oddly smart boots on under his shabby overalls. And he was shaved. They
clattered into Deerwood and through Deerwood and hit the long, wooded
road to the Port.
“Haven’t changed your mind?” said Barney.
“No. Have you?”
“No.”
That was their whole conversation on the fifteen miles. Everything was
more dream-like than ever. Valancy didn’t know whether she felt happy.
Or terrified. Or just plain fool.
Then the lights of Port Lawrence were about them. Valancy felt as if
she were surrounded by the gleaming, hungry eyes of hundreds of great,
stealthy panthers. Barney briefly asked where Mr. Towers lived, and
Valancy as briefly told him. They stopped before the shabby little
house in an unfashionable street. They went in to the small, shabby
parlour. Barney produced his license. So he had got it. Also a ring.
This thing was real. She, Valancy Stirling, was actually on the point
of being married.
They were standing up together before Mr. Towers. Valancy heard Mr.
Towers and Barney saying things. She heard some other person saying
things. She herself was thinking of the way she had once planned to be
married—away back in her early teens when such a thing had not seemed
impossible. White silk and tulle veil and orange-blossoms; no
bridesmaid. But one flower girl, in a frock of cream shadow lace over
pale pink, with a wreath of flowers in her hair, carrying a basket of
roses and lilies-of-the-valley. And the groom, a noble-looking
creature, irreproachably clad in whatever the fashion of the day
decreed. Valancy lifted her eyes and saw herself and Barney in the
little, slanting, distorting mirror over the mantelpiece. She in her
odd, unbridal green hat and dress; Barney in shirt and overalls. But it
was Barney. That was all that mattered. No veil—no flowers—no guests—no
presents—no wedding-cake—but just Barney. For all the rest of her life
there would be Barney.
“Mrs. Snaith, I hope you will be very happy,” Mr. Towers was saying.
He had not seemed surprised at their appearance—not even at Barney’s
overalls. He had seen plenty of queer weddings “up back.” He did not
know Valancy was one of the Deerwood Stirlings—he did not even know
there were Deerwood Stirlings. He did not know Barney Snaith was a
fugitive from justice. Really, he was an incredibly ignorant old man.
Therefore he married them and gave them his blessing very gently and
solemnly and prayed for them that night after they had gone away. His
conscience did not trouble him at all.
“What a nice way to get married!” Barney was saying as he put Lady Jane
in gear. “No fuss and flub-dub. I never supposed it was half so easy.”
“For heaven’s sake,” said Valancy suddenly, “let’s forget we are
married and talk as if we weren’t. I can’t stand another drive like the
one we had coming in.”
Barney howled and threw Lady Jane into high with an infernal noise.
“And I thought I was making it easy for you,” he said. “You didn’t seem
to want to talk.”
“I didn’t. But I wanted you to talk. I don’t want you to make love to
me, but I want you to act like an ordinary human being. Tell me about
this island of yours. What sort of a place is it?”
“The jolliest place in the world. You’re going to love it. The first
time I saw it I loved it. Old Tom MacMurray owned it then. He built the
little shack on it, lived there in winter and rented it to Toronto
people in summer. I bought it from him—became by that one simple
transaction a landed proprietor owning a house and an island. There is
something so satisfying in owning a whole island. And isn’t an
uninhabited island a charming idea? I’d wanted to own one ever since
I’d read Robinson Crusoe. It seemed too good to be true. And beauty!
Most of the scenery belongs to the government, but they don’t tax you
for looking at it, and the moon belongs to everybody. You won’t find my
shack very tidy. I suppose you’ll want to make it tidy.”
“Yes,” said Valancy honestly. “I have to be tidy. I don’t really
want to be. But untidiness hurts me. Yes, I’ll have to tidy up your
shack.”
“I was prepared for that,” said Barney, with a hollow groan.
“But,” continued Valancy relentingly, “I won’t insist on your wiping
your feet when you come in.”
“No, you’ll only sweep up after me with the air of a martyr,” said
Barney. “Well, anyway, you can’t tidy the lean-to. You can’t even enter
it. The door will be locked and I shall keep the key.”
“Bluebeard’s chamber,” said Valancy. “I shan’t even think of it. I
don’t care how many wives you have hanging up in it. So long as they’re
really dead.”
“Dead as door-nails. You can do as you like in the rest of the house.
There’s not much of it—just one big living-room and one small bedroom.
Well built, though. Old Tom loved his job. The beams of our house are
cedar and the rafters fir. Our living-room windows face west and east.
It’s wonderful to have a room where you can see both sunrise and
sunset. I have two cats there. Banjo and Good Luck. Adorable animals.
Banjo is a big, enchanting, grey devil-cat. Striped, of course. I don’t
care a hang for any cat that hasn’t stripes. I never knew a cat who
could swear as genteelly and effectively as Banjo. His only fault is
that he snores horribly when he is asleep. Luck is a dainty little cat.
Always looking wistfully at you, as if he wanted to tell you something.
Maybe he will pull it off sometime. Once in a thousand years, you know,
one cat is allowed to speak. My cats are philosophers—neither of them
ever cries over spilt milk.
“Two old crows live in a pine-tree on the point and are reasonably
neighbourly. Call ’em Nip and Tuck. And I have a demure little tame
owl. Name, Leander. I brought him up from a baby and he lives over on
the mainland and chuckles to himself o’ nights. And bats—it’s a great
place for bats at night. Scared of bats?”
“No; I like them.”
“So do I. Nice, queer, uncanny, mysterious creatures. Coming from
nowhere—going nowhere. Swoop! Banjo likes ’em, too. Eats ’em. I have a
canoe and a disappearing propeller boat. Went to the Port in it today
to get my license. Quieter than Lady Jane.”
“I thought you hadn’t gone at all—that you had changed your mind,”
admitted Valancy.
Barney laughed—the laugh Valancy did not like—the little, bitter,
cynical laugh.
“I never change my mind,” he said shortly.
They went back through Deerwood. Up the Muskoka road. Past Roaring
Abel’s. Over the rocky, daisied lane. The dark pine woods swallowed
them up. Through the pine woods, where the air was sweet with the
incense of the unseen, fragile bells of the linnæas that carpeted the
banks of the trail. Out to the shore of Mistawis. Lady Jane must be
left here. They got out. Barney led the way down a little path to the
edge of the lake.
“There’s our island,” he said gloatingly.
Valancy looked—and looked—and looked again. There was a diaphanous,
lilac mist on the lake, shrouding the island. Through it the two
enormous pine-trees that clasped hands over Barney’s shack loomed out
like dark turrets. Behind them was a sky still rose-hued in the
afterlight, and a pale young moon.
Valancy shivered like a tree the wind stirs suddenly. Something seemed
to sweep over her soul.
“My Blue Castle!” she said. “Oh, my Blue Castle!”
They got into the canoe and paddled out to it. They left behind the
realm of everyday and things known and landed on a realm of mystery and
enchantment where anything might happen—anything might be true. Barney
lifted Valancy out of the canoe and swung her to a lichen-covered rock
under a young pine-tree. His arms were about her and suddenly his lips
were on hers. Valancy found herself shivering with the rapture of her
first kiss.
“Welcome home, dear,” Barney was saying.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Choices aligned with your true values create satisfaction regardless of external validation, while choices made for appearances always feel hollow.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when you're making decisions based on your genuine values versus what will look good to others.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you're about to make a choice and ask yourself: 'Am I choosing this because it's right for me, or because it looks right to others?'
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Ready?"
Context: His simple question when he arrives to take Valancy to their wedding
This one word carries enormous weight - he's asking if she's ready to leave her old life forever. The simplicity shows their relationship is built on honesty, not flowery romance.
In Today's Words:
Are you sure about this? Are we really doing this?
"She really looked like a wild elf strayed out of the greenwood."
Context: Describing Valancy in her simple green dress on her wedding day
Instead of traditional bridal beauty, Valancy embodies natural freedom. The 'wild elf' image suggests she's finally becoming her true, untamed self.
In Today's Words:
She looked like someone who belonged in nature, not a stuffy drawing room.
"My Blue Castle."
Context: Her whispered recognition when she first sees Barney's island home
This moment represents the fulfillment of her deepest dreams. The place she's imagined her whole life actually exists, proving that sometimes our wildest hopes can come true.
In Today's Words:
This is it. This is exactly what I've been dreaming of.
Thematic Threads
Authenticity
In This Chapter
Valancy chooses a simple ceremony that reflects her true desires rather than society's expectations for weddings
Development
Evolution from her early people-pleasing to this moment of complete self-determination
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you choose what genuinely makes you happy instead of what looks impressive to others.
Class
In This Chapter
The shabby parlor and simple ceremony contrast sharply with traditional upper-class wedding expectations
Development
Continues her rejection of social status markers in favor of personal meaning
In Your Life:
You might see this when you realize expensive doesn't always mean better, and simple can be more meaningful.
Belonging
In This Chapter
Valancy recognizes Barney's island as her 'Blue Castle'—the place she's always dreamed of belonging
Development
Culmination of her search for a place where she can be herself completely
In Your Life:
You might feel this when you find a person, place, or situation where you can finally drop all pretenses.
Love
In This Chapter
Their first kiss and her sense of arriving home show love as recognition rather than conquest
Development
Deepens from her initial attraction to this profound sense of rightness and completion
In Your Life:
You might experience this when you find someone who sees and accepts your authentic self.
Transformation
In This Chapter
Valancy shifts from escaping her past to actively embracing her chosen future
Development
Completes her journey from passive victim to active creator of her own life
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you stop running from what you don't want and start moving toward what you do want.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Valancy choose for her wedding, and how does it differ from what society expects?
analysis • surface - 2
Why doesn't Valancy feel disappointed by the shabby parlor and distorted mirror during her ceremony?
analysis • medium - 3
When have you seen someone make an unconventional choice that seemed right for them but looked wrong to others?
application • medium - 4
How would you recognize the difference between making a choice because it's right for you versus making it to impress others?
application • deep - 5
What does Valancy's wedding reveal about the relationship between external validation and internal satisfaction?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Audit Your Recent Choices
Think of three significant choices you've made in the past month—what to wear, where to go, what to buy, how to spend time. For each choice, write down whether you made it primarily for yourself or primarily for how it would look to others. Be honest about your motivations.
Consider:
- •Notice which choices felt most satisfying afterward—were they the authentic ones or the performance ones?
- •Consider how much mental energy you spent worrying about others' reactions to each choice
- •Think about what your 'authentic choice' pattern reveals about your actual values versus your performed values
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you made an unconventional choice that felt absolutely right for you, even if others didn't understand it. What made you trust your own judgment over outside opinions?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 27: Breaking the News
Now Valancy must navigate her first days as a married woman on a mysterious island, discovering what it truly means to build a life with someone who remains largely unknown to her.




