Summary
As New York's social season begins, Mrs. Archer holds her annual Thanksgiving dinner where the family dissects society's moral decline. The conversation reveals how Ellen Olenska has fallen from grace by refusing to return to her husband and associating with questionable people like Mrs. Struthers. When Ellen's name comes up, May blushes mysteriously, suggesting she knows more about the situation than she lets on. Later, Mr. Sillerton Jackson privately tells Archer that Ellen's family has cut her allowance as punishment for defying them, and with the Beaufort financial scandal brewing, she may soon be left destitute. Jackson hints that people are gossiping about Ellen's relationship with Archer himself. That evening, May demonstrates the sophisticated art of marital communication when she tells Archer he should visit Ellen in Washington—seemingly supportive words that actually carry a complex message of warning, understanding, and expectation. Through her careful phrasing, May reveals she knows about the gossip, understands Archer's involvement in Ellen's decisions, and expects him to use this visit to convince Ellen to return to her husband. The chapter masterfully shows how upper-class society uses financial pressure and social isolation to enforce conformity, while married couples navigate dangerous territory through coded conversations that say everything while appearing to say nothing at all.
Coming Up in Chapter 27
Archer heads to Washington with May's blessing and warning ringing in his ears. His reunion with Ellen will force both of them to confront the impossible choice between love and duty, while the Beaufort scandal threatens to destroy the very social order they're both struggling against.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Every year on the fifteenth of October Fifth Avenue opened its shutters, unrolled its carpets and hung up its triple layer of window-curtains. By the first of November this household ritual was over, and society had begun to look about and take stock of itself. By the fifteenth the season was in full blast, Opera and theatres were putting forth their new attractions, dinner-engagements were accumulating, and dates for dances being fixed. And punctually at about this time Mrs. Archer always said that New York was very much changed. Observing it from the lofty stand-point of a non-participant, she was able, with the help of Mr. Sillerton Jackson and Miss Sophy, to trace each new crack in its surface, and all the strange weeds pushing up between the ordered rows of social vegetables. It had been one of the amusements of Archer's youth to wait for this annual pronouncement of his mother's, and to hear her enumerate the minute signs of disintegration that his careless gaze had overlooked. For New York, to Mrs. Archer's mind, never changed without changing for the worse; and in this view Miss Sophy Jackson heartily concurred. Mr. Sillerton Jackson, as became a man of the world, suspended his judgment and listened with an amused impartiality to the lamentations of the ladies. But even he never denied that New York had changed; and Newland Archer, in the winter of the second year of his marriage, was himself obliged to admit that if it had not actually changed it was certainly changing. These points had been raised, as usual, at Mrs. Archer's Thanksgiving dinner. At the date when she was officially enjoined to give thanks for the blessings of the year it was her habit to take a mournful though not embittered stock of her world, and wonder what there was to be thankful for. At any rate, not the state of society; society, if it could be said to exist, was rather a spectacle on which to call down Biblical imprecations--and in fact, every one knew what the Reverend Dr. Ashmore meant when he chose a text from Jeremiah (chap. ii., verse 25) for his Thanksgiving sermon. Dr. Ashmore, the new Rector of St. Matthew's, had been chosen because he was very "advanced": his sermons were considered bold in thought and novel in language. When he fulminated against fashionable society he always spoke of its "trend"; and to Mrs. Archer it was terrifying and yet fascinating to feel herself part of a community that was trending. "There's no doubt that Dr. Ashmore is right: there IS a marked trend," she said, as if it were something visible and measurable, like a crack in a house. "It was odd, though, to preach about it on Thanksgiving," Miss Jackson opined; and her hostess drily rejoined: "Oh, he means us to give thanks for what's left." Archer had been wont to smile at these annual vaticinations of his mother's; but this year even he was obliged to acknowledge, as...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Controlled Pressure - How Power Uses Isolation to Force Compliance
When someone defies group expectations, power structures use coordinated financial and social pressure to force conformity through isolation.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when multiple authority figures coordinate pressure to enforce compliance through seemingly unrelated actions.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when criticism or consequences for someone come from multiple directions at once - that's usually coordinated, not coincidental.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Social Season
The period from October to spring when wealthy families returned to the city for parties, theater, and matchmaking. It was a carefully orchestrated calendar of events that determined who was 'in' or 'out' of society.
Modern Usage:
Like today's awards season in Hollywood or the social media influencer event circuit - it's when the elite gather to see and be seen.
Financial Coercion
Using money as a weapon to control someone's behavior. Ellen's family cuts her allowance to force her back to her abusive husband, knowing she has no other income source.
Modern Usage:
When parents threaten to cut off college tuition to control their adult child's choices, or when someone uses financial dependency to trap a partner.
Coded Conversation
Speaking in a way that appears polite and supportive on the surface but carries hidden warnings or messages underneath. May masters this art when discussing Ellen with Archer.
Modern Usage:
Like when your boss says 'I trust you'll make the right decision' - it sounds supportive but really means 'do what I want or else.'
Social Ostracism
Deliberately excluding someone from social groups and activities as punishment for breaking unwritten rules. Ellen faces this for refusing to return to her husband.
Modern Usage:
Cancel culture, workplace freezing out, or being blocked from group chats - using social isolation to punish nonconformity.
Reputation Currency
In high society, your good name was literally worth money - it affected marriage prospects, business deals, and social access. Once damaged, it was nearly impossible to repair.
Modern Usage:
Like online reviews, credit scores, or LinkedIn endorsements - your reputation directly impacts your opportunities and earning potential.
Marital Diplomacy
The careful art of communicating with your spouse about sensitive topics without directly confronting them. May excels at saying what she means without saying it.
Modern Usage:
When couples have 'the conversation' about money, in-laws, or problems without actually naming the real issue they're discussing.
Characters in This Chapter
Mrs. Archer
Social commentator
Newland's mother who annually declares that New York society is declining. She represents the older generation's resistance to any social change, viewing all progress as moral decay.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative who complains every holiday that 'things were better in my day'
May Welland Archer
Strategic wife
Demonstrates sophisticated emotional intelligence by encouraging Archer to visit Ellen while subtly communicating her awareness of the situation and her expectations for the outcome.
Modern Equivalent:
The spouse who says 'do whatever you think is best' but makes their position crystal clear
Mr. Sillerton Jackson
Society gossip broker
Serves as the information network for high society, privately warning Archer that people are talking about him and Ellen while the Beaufort scandal unfolds.
Modern Equivalent:
The office gossip who always knows everyone's business and strategically shares information
Ellen Olenska
Social exile
Though not physically present, she dominates the chapter as the subject of family disapproval and financial punishment for refusing to conform to society's expectations.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who gets cut off for making choices the family doesn't approve of
Newland Archer
Conflicted protagonist
Caught between his desire to help Ellen and the growing pressure from society and his wife. He's beginning to understand the real consequences of his involvement.
Modern Equivalent:
The person torn between doing what's right and protecting their own reputation and marriage
Key Quotes & Analysis
"For New York, to Mrs. Archer's mind, never changed without changing for the worse"
Context: Describing Mrs. Archer's annual assessment of society's decline
This reveals how the established elite view any change as a threat to their power. Mrs. Archer's perspective shows the fear that drives resistance to social progress.
In Today's Words:
Things were so much better back in my day - everything now is going to hell
"I think you ought to go to Washington and see Ellen yourself"
Context: May suggesting Archer visit Ellen after learning about the family's financial pressure
This appears supportive but is actually a masterful piece of marital communication. May is acknowledging she knows about the situation while setting clear expectations for Archer's behavior.
In Today's Words:
I know what's going on, and I'm giving you one chance to fix this mess before it destroys our marriage
"The talk is of you and the Countess Olenska"
Context: Warning Archer privately about the gossip circulating in society
This direct statement cuts through all social pleasantries to deliver a clear warning. Jackson is telling Archer that his reputation is now at stake.
In Today's Words:
People are talking about you two, and it's not good
Thematic Threads
Class Control
In This Chapter
The wealthy Mingott family cuts Ellen's allowance to punish her defiance, using money as a weapon of social control
Development
Evolved from subtle social pressure to direct financial punishment
In Your Life:
You might see this when family members use money or resources to control your life choices
Marital Strategy
In This Chapter
May uses sophisticated coded language to warn Archer while appearing supportive, demonstrating advanced relationship navigation
Development
May's evolution from naive bride to strategic partner becomes clear
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in how couples communicate dangerous topics through careful word choices
Social Surveillance
In This Chapter
Jackson reveals that society is actively gossiping about Archer and Ellen's relationship, showing how communities police behavior
Development
Gossip networks have moved from background observation to active threat
In Your Life:
You might experience this in small communities where everyone watches and judges your personal business
Economic Vulnerability
In This Chapter
Ellen faces potential destitution as both family support and the Beaufort fortune collapse simultaneously
Development
Financial precariousness becomes a tool of social enforcement
In Your Life:
You might face this when speaking up puts your job or financial security at risk
Coded Communication
In This Chapter
The Thanksgiving dinner conversation uses euphemisms and implications to discuss Ellen's fall from grace without direct statements
Development
Indirect communication has become the primary way dangerous topics are addressed
In Your Life:
You might use this when discussing sensitive family or workplace issues that can't be spoken about directly
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How does Ellen's family punish her for refusing to return to her husband, and what does this reveal about how power works in their society?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does May encourage Archer to visit Ellen while simultaneously warning him through her tone and timing? What is she really communicating?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this same pattern today - people being financially or socially punished for refusing to conform to what others expect of them?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Ellen's position - facing financial pressure and social isolation for standing up for yourself - what strategies would you use to survive and maintain your independence?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter teach us about how groups maintain control over individuals, and why do these tactics work so effectively on most people?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Pressure Campaign
Think of someone you know who faced pressure to conform - maybe at work, in their family, or in a relationship. Draw or list all the different ways pressure was applied: financial, social, emotional, professional. Then identify which tactics were most effective and why. Finally, brainstorm three alternative support systems that person could have built to resist the pressure.
Consider:
- •Notice how multiple pressure points work together - it's rarely just one thing
- •Consider both obvious pressure (cutting off money) and subtle pressure (changed tone of voice, exclusion from conversations)
- •Think about why timing matters - when people are most vulnerable to these tactics
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt pressured to conform to something that didn't feel right to you. What forms did the pressure take? How did you respond? What would you do differently now with more experience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 27: When Scandals Shake the Foundation
The coming pages reveal financial crises reveal true character and social priorities, and teach us family loyalty has limits when honor is at stake. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.