Summary
Newland returns from Florida to find that Ellen has visited his family, creating subtle tensions about her unconventional style and behavior. His mother and sister clearly prefer the conventional May to the mysterious Ellen. When Newland visits old Mrs. Mingott, she playfully asks why he didn't marry Ellen instead, creating an awkward moment when Ellen herself appears. Ellen mentions sending Newland an unanswered letter and seems hurt by his silence, though she masks it with forced gaiety. She's moving soon and agrees to see him the next evening. When Newland arrives at Ellen's house, he discovers she's entertaining an eccentric group including her aunt, the Marchioness Manson, who has just returned from Cuba. The Marchioness drops a bombshell: Ellen's husband, Count Olenski, has written begging Ellen to return to him on her own terms. The aunt describes the luxurious life Ellen gave up - magnificent homes, jewels, art, and the attention of great artists who painted her portrait nine times. She hints that Ellen might be wavering, asking Newland if he prefers 'that' (pointing to flowers, symbolizing her simple American life) over all the European splendor. The chapter ends with Ellen about to enter the room, unaware that her aunt has revealed the Count's plea. This development threatens to upend Ellen's hard-won freedom and puts Newland in an impossible position between his duty to May and his feelings for Ellen.
Coming Up in Chapter 18
Ellen enters to find Newland shaken by her aunt's revelation about the Count's letter. The confrontation that follows will force both Ellen and Newland to confront what they truly want - and what they're willing to sacrifice for it.
Share it with friends
An excerpt from the original text.(~500 words)
Y"our cousin the Countess called on mother while you were away," Janey Archer announced to her brother on the evening of his return. The young man, who was dining alone with his mother and sister, glanced up in surprise and saw Mrs. Archer's gaze demurely bent on her plate. Mrs. Archer did not regard her seclusion from the world as a reason for being forgotten by it; and Newland guessed that she was slightly annoyed that he should be surprised by Madame Olenska's visit. "She had on a black velvet polonaise with jet buttons, and a tiny green monkey muff; I never saw her so stylishly dressed," Janey continued. "She came alone, early on Sunday afternoon; luckily the fire was lit in the drawing-room. She had one of those new card-cases. She said she wanted to know us because you'd been so good to her." Newland laughed. "Madame Olenska always takes that tone about her friends. She's very happy at being among her own people again." "Yes, so she told us," said Mrs. Archer. "I must say she seems thankful to be here." "I hope you liked her, mother." Mrs. Archer drew her lips together. "She certainly lays herself out to please, even when she is calling on an old lady." "Mother doesn't think her simple," Janey interjected, her eyes screwed upon her brother's face. "It's just my old-fashioned feeling; dear May is my ideal," said Mrs. Archer. "Ah," said her son, "they're not alike." Archer had left St. Augustine charged with many messages for old Mrs. Mingott; and a day or two after his return to town he called on her. The old lady received him with unusual warmth; she was grateful to him for persuading the Countess Olenska to give up the idea of a divorce; and when he told her that he had deserted the office without leave, and rushed down to St. Augustine simply because he wanted to see May, she gave an adipose chuckle and patted his knee with her puff-ball hand. "Ah, ah--so you kicked over the traces, did you? And I suppose Augusta and Welland pulled long faces, and behaved as if the end of the world had come? But little May--she knew better, I'll be bound?" "I hoped she did; but after all she wouldn't agree to what I'd gone down to ask for." "Wouldn't she indeed? And what was that?" "I wanted to get her to promise that we should be married in April. What's the use of our wasting another year?" Mrs. Manson Mingott screwed up her little mouth into a grimace of mimic prudery and twinkled at him through malicious lids. "'Ask Mamma,' I suppose--the usual story. Ah, these Mingotts--all alike! Born in a rut, and you can't root 'em out of it. When I built this house you'd have thought I was moving to California! Nobody ever HAD built above Fortieth Street--no, says I, nor above the Battery either, before Christopher Columbus discovered America. No, no; not one...
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Hidden Leverage - When Others Control Your Options
When others control the timing and framing of information to manipulate your decisions while making you feel like you're choosing freely.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone controls what you know and when you know it to influence your decisions.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone shares 'urgent' information right before asking for something - pause and ask yourself who benefits from you deciding immediately.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Terms to Know
Polonaise
A fitted, formal dress with a long overskirt, popular in the 1870s. It was considered very fashionable and expensive. The detailed description of Ellen's outfit shows how her European style stands out in conservative New York society.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone shows up to a casual office in designer clothes - technically appropriate but signals they're from a different world.
Drawing-room
The formal living room where wealthy families received important guests. It was kept pristine and only used for special occasions. Having the fire lit shows Mrs. Archer treated Ellen's visit as significant.
Modern Usage:
Like having a formal dining room that only gets used for holidays or when the boss comes over for dinner.
Card-case
A small, decorative case for holding calling cards - business cards that wealthy people left when visiting. Having a new, fashionable one was a status symbol that showed you were keeping up with social trends.
Modern Usage:
Like having the latest iPhone or designer handbag - a small item that signals your social status and wealth.
Old New York society
The established wealthy families who controlled New York's social scene in the 1870s. They valued tradition, conformity, and following strict unwritten rules. Anyone who acted differently was viewed with suspicion.
Modern Usage:
Like exclusive country clubs or elite neighborhoods where everyone knows the unspoken rules and outsiders stick out.
Calling on
Making formal social visits during specific hours and following strict etiquette. It was how wealthy people maintained their social networks and showed respect. Not following the rules could damage your reputation.
Modern Usage:
Like networking events or making sure to attend your boss's retirement party - social obligations that maintain your standing.
Countess
Ellen's title from her marriage to a European count. In America, this made her exotic and interesting but also suspect - people wondered what she was hiding and why she left her wealthy husband.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who moved back from living overseas with a rich spouse - people are curious but also judgmental about why they returned.
Characters in This Chapter
Janey Archer
Social gossip and family watchdog
She eagerly reports Ellen's visit with detailed observations about her clothes and behavior. Her focus on appearances and her comment that Ellen 'lays herself out to please' shows she's suspicious of Ellen's motives and authenticity.
Modern Equivalent:
The family member who notices everything and loves sharing gossip about who's 'putting on airs'
Mrs. Archer
Conservative family matriarch
She's politely critical of Ellen, preferring May's conventional behavior. Her comment about Ellen not being 'simple' reveals her distrust of anyone who doesn't fit the expected mold of proper womanhood.
Modern Equivalent:
The traditional mother-in-law who thinks your partner could do better and isn't shy about her preferences
Newland Archer
Conflicted protagonist
He's caught between defending Ellen to his family while trying not to reveal his own feelings. His awkward responses show he's struggling to maintain proper appearances while being drawn to Ellen's unconventional nature.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy trying to stay loyal to his fiancée while being attracted to someone his family disapproves of
Ellen Olenska
Mysterious outsider
Though not physically present in this scene, her visit has created ripples of judgment and curiosity. Her formal social call shows she's trying to fit in, but her European style and mannerisms mark her as different.
Modern Equivalent:
The sophisticated new person in town who everyone talks about but no one quite trusts
Marchioness Manson
Dramatic messenger
Ellen's eccentric aunt who reveals that Ellen's husband wants her back and describes the luxurious life she gave up. She forces everyone to confront what Ellen sacrificed by leaving Europe and staying in America.
Modern Equivalent:
The relative who shows up with life-changing news and dramatic stories about what everyone's missing out on
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She certainly lays herself out to please, even when she is calling on an old lady."
Context: When Newland asks if his mother liked Ellen after her visit
This backhanded compliment reveals Mrs. Archer's suspicion that Ellen is being artificially charming rather than naturally gracious. It shows how Ellen's European social skills are interpreted as manipulation rather than politeness in this conservative society.
In Today's Words:
She's trying way too hard to make a good impression - it feels fake.
"Mother doesn't think her simple."
Context: Explaining their mother's reservations about Ellen to Newland
In this society, 'simple' means naturally modest and unpretentious - the highest compliment for a proper lady. Janey's blunt statement exposes the family's belief that Ellen is complicated, worldly, and potentially deceptive.
In Today's Words:
Mom thinks she's got too much baggage and drama.
"Dear May is my ideal."
Context: Explaining why she prefers May over Ellen
This comparison makes clear that Mrs. Archer sees May as the perfect example of proper American womanhood - predictable, conventional, and safe. It also puts pressure on Newland to appreciate what he has rather than being tempted by Ellen's mysterious appeal.
In Today's Words:
May is exactly the kind of woman you should want - why would you need anyone more complicated?
Thematic Threads
Control
In This Chapter
The Marchioness controls Ellen's narrative by revealing the Count's offer strategically, framing Ellen's choices through her own agenda
Development
Evolved from earlier subtle family pressures to direct manipulation of Ellen's major life decisions
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone presents you with 'opportunities' that feel urgent but serve their interests more than yours
Class
In This Chapter
The stark contrast between European luxury (nine portraits, jewels, palaces) and Ellen's simple American life reduces complex identity to material comparison
Development
Deepened from social expectations to direct economic pressure and lifestyle comparison
In Your Life:
You see this when others use your financial situation or lifestyle choices to pressure you into decisions that benefit them
Identity
In This Chapter
Ellen faces the question of who she really is - the European countess surrounded by luxury or the independent American woman living simply
Development
Intensified from internal struggle to external pressure forcing her to choose between competing versions of herself
In Your Life:
You experience this when others try to define your worth by what you have rather than who you are or what you value
Isolation
In This Chapter
Ellen's physical and social isolation in New York makes her more vulnerable to manipulation and pressure from family members
Development
Progressed from social awkwardness to dangerous vulnerability that others can exploit
In Your Life:
You might notice this when you're going through transitions and people take advantage of your uncertainty to push their own agendas
Duty
In This Chapter
Newland faces impossible competing obligations - his duty to May, his feelings for Ellen, and now his knowledge of the Count's offer
Development
Escalated from social duty to moral crisis where every choice betrays someone important to him
In Your Life:
You feel this when you're caught between loyalty to different people whose needs directly conflict with each other
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does the Marchioness choose to reveal Count Olenski's offer when Newland is present, rather than speaking to Ellen privately?
analysis • surface - 2
How does the aunt use the contrast between Ellen's luxurious past and simple present to influence her decision?
analysis • medium - 3
When have you seen someone use timing and audience to pressure you into a decision? How did it affect your choice?
application • medium - 4
If you were Ellen's friend, what would you tell her about making this decision under these circumstances?
application • deep - 5
What does this scene reveal about how our 'free' choices can be shaped by others without us realizing it?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Spot the Setup
Think of a recent decision you made that felt pressured or rushed. Write down: Who presented the choice? What was their timing? Who else was present? What information were you given or denied? Then rewrite how that conversation could have happened if you had controlled the timing and setting.
Consider:
- •Notice who benefits when you decide quickly versus when you take time
- •Pay attention to how the presence of others changes what feels possible to say
- •Consider what information might be missing from urgent 'opportunities'
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone used perfect timing to get you to agree to something you later regretted. What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 18: The Moment Everything Changes
What lies ahead teaches us anger reveals our true feelings and priorities, and shows us timing in relationships can be both cruel and clarifying. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.