An excerpt from the original text.(complete · 1005 words)
om joined the new order of Cadets of Temperance, being attracted by the
showy character of their “regalia.” He promised to abstain from smoking,
chewing, and profanity as long as he remained a member. Now he found out
a new thing—namely, that to promise not to do a thing is the surest way
in the world to make a body want to go and do that very thing. Tom soon
found himself tormented with a desire to drink and swear; the desire
grew to be so intense that nothing but the hope of a chance to display
himself in his red sash kept him from withdrawing from the order. Fourth
of July was coming; but he soon gave that up—gave it up before he had
worn his shackles over forty-eight hours—and fixed his hopes upon old
Judge Frazer, justice of the peace, who was apparently on his deathbed
and would have a big public funeral, since he was so high an official.
During three days Tom was deeply concerned about the Judge’s condition
and hungry for news of it. Sometimes his hopes ran high—so high that
he would venture to get out his regalia and practise before the
looking-glass. But the Judge had a most discouraging way of fluctuating.
At last he was pronounced upon the mend—and then convalescent. Tom was
disgusted; and felt a sense of injury, too. He handed in his resignation
at once—and that night the Judge suffered a relapse and died. Tom
resolved that he would never trust a man like that again.
The funeral was a fine thing. The Cadets paraded in a style calculated
to kill the late member with envy. Tom was a free boy again,
however—there was something in that. He could drink and swear, now—but
found to his surprise that he did not want to. The simple fact that he
could, took the desire away, and the charm of it.
Tom presently wondered to find that his coveted vacation was beginning
to hang a little heavily on his hands.
He attempted a diary—but nothing happened during three days, and so he
abandoned it.
The first of all the negro minstrel shows came to town, and made a
sensation. Tom and Joe Harper got up a band of performers and were happy
for two days.
Even the Glorious Fourth was in some sense a failure, for it rained
hard, there was no procession in consequence, and the greatest man
in the world (as Tom supposed), Mr. Benton, an actual United States
Senator, proved an overwhelming disappointment—for he was not
twenty-five feet high, nor even anywhere in the neighborhood of it.
A circus came. The boys played circus for three days afterward in tents
made of rag carpeting—admission, three pins for boys, two for girls—and
then circusing was abandoned.
A phrenologist and a mesmerizer came—and went again and left the village
duller and drearier than ever.
There were some boys-and-girls’ parties, but they were so few and so
delightful that they only made the aching voids between ache the harder.
Becky Thatcher was gone to her Constantinople home to stay with her
parents during vacation—so there was no bright side to life anywhere.
The dreadful secret of the murder was a chronic misery. It was a very
cancer for permanency and pain.
Then came the measles.
During two long weeks Tom lay a prisoner, dead to the world and its
happenings. He was very ill, he was interested in nothing. When he got
upon his feet at last and moved feebly downtown, a melancholy change had
come over everything and every creature. There had been a “revival,” and
everybody had “got religion,” not only the adults, but even the boys and
girls. Tom went about, hoping against hope for the sight of one blessed
sinful face, but disappointment crossed him everywhere. He found Joe
Harper studying a Testament, and turned sadly away from the depressing
spectacle. He sought Ben Rogers, and found him visiting the poor with a
basket of tracts. He hunted up Jim Hollis, who called his attention to
the precious blessing of his late measles as a warning. Every boy
he encountered added another ton to his depression; and when, in
desperation, he flew for refuge at last to the bosom of Huckleberry Finn
and was received with a Scriptural quotation, his heart broke and he
crept home and to bed realizing that he alone of all the town was lost,
forever and forever.
And that night there came on a terrific storm, with driving rain, awful
claps of thunder and blinding sheets of lightning. He covered his head
with the bedclothes and waited in a horror of suspense for his doom; for
he had not the shadow of a doubt that all this hubbub was about him.
He believed he had taxed the forbearance of the powers above to the
extremity of endurance and that this was the result. It might have
seemed to him a waste of pomp and ammunition to kill a bug with a
battery of artillery, but there seemed nothing incongruous about the
getting up such an expensive thunderstorm as this to knock the turf from
under an insect like himself.
By and by the tempest spent itself and died without accomplishing its
object. The boy’s first impulse was to be grateful, and reform. His
second was to wait—for there might not be any more storms.
The next day the doctors were back; Tom had relapsed. The three weeks he
spent on his back this time seemed an entire age. When he got abroad
at last he was hardly grateful that he had been spared, remembering how
lonely was his estate, how companionless and forlorn he was. He drifted
listlessly down the street and found Jim Hollis acting as judge in a
juvenile court that was trying a cat for murder, in the presence of her
victim, a bird. He found Joe Harper and Huck Finn up an alley eating a
stolen melon. Poor lads! they—like Tom—had suffered a relapse.
Master this chapter. Complete your experience
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Let's Analyse the Pattern
Restrictions and prohibitions create artificial desire for things we didn't particularly want before they were forbidden.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between genuine wants and desires created by restrictions.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you suddenly crave something right after being told you can't have it—pause and ask if you wanted it before the restriction.
Now let's explore the literary elements.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He found out a new thing—namely, that to promise not to do a thing is the surest way in the world to make a body want to go and do that very thing."
Context: After Tom joins the Cadets and promises to give up smoking, chewing, and swearing
This captures a fundamental truth about human psychology - forbidden fruit is always sweeter. Tom discovers that restriction creates desire, not discipline.
In Today's Words:
Tell someone they can't have something, and suddenly that's all they want.
"Tom was disgusted; and felt a sense of injury, too."
Context: When Judge Frazer recovers instead of dying, ruining Tom's chance to march in the funeral
Tom's reaction shows his self-centered worldview - he's actually angry that someone didn't die on schedule. It reveals both his immaturity and his inability to see beyond his own wants.
In Today's Words:
Tom was pissed off and felt like the universe was personally screwing him over.
"Now that he could smoke and swear, he found that he did not want to."
Context: After Tom quits the Cadets and is free to indulge in forbidden behaviors again
This perfectly illustrates how desire often depends on restriction. Once the prohibition is removed, the appeal disappears. Tom learns that wanting something and actually enjoying it are different things.
In Today's Words:
As soon as he was allowed to do the bad stuff again, he didn't even want to anymore.
Thematic Threads
Social Performance
In This Chapter
Tom joins the Cadets purely for the fancy uniform and chance to march publicly, not for any genuine commitment to temperance
Development
Builds on earlier chapters where Tom performs for attention (showing off for Becky, dramatic return from island)
In Your Life:
You might find yourself joining groups or making commitments more for how they look to others than for personal conviction
Irony
In This Chapter
Judge Frazer dies the very night Tom quits the Cadets, and Tom loses interest in vices once he's free to indulge them
Development
Twain's ironic voice strengthens, showing how life rarely unfolds as we expect
In Your Life:
You might notice that the things you desperately want often lose their appeal once you can have them freely
Isolation
In This Chapter
Tom feels completely alone when all his friends get religion during his illness, believing he's the only sinner left
Development
Deepens Tom's recurring fear of being different or left out from earlier social anxieties
In Your Life:
You might feel uniquely flawed when everyone around you seems to be making changes you're not ready for
Cycles
In This Chapter
The religious revival proves temporary—everyone relapses back to their old ways, including Tom's friends
Development
Introduces the theme of how dramatic changes often don't stick permanently
In Your Life:
You might observe that major life changes in your community or family often fade back to familiar patterns over time
Boredom
In This Chapter
Summer vacation becomes tedious despite being exactly what Tom thought he wanted—freedom from school and responsibility
Development
New theme showing how getting what we want doesn't always bring satisfaction
In Your Life:
You might find that periods of complete freedom or rest become surprisingly unsatisfying without some structure or challenge
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What happens to Tom's desire to smoke and swear the moment he promises to give them up?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Tom lose interest in smoking once he's free to do it again?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this 'forbidden fruit' pattern in workplaces, schools, or families today?
application • medium - 4
If you had to set boundaries for someone (child, employee, patient), how would you avoid triggering this rebellion effect?
application • deep - 5
What does Tom's experience reveal about the difference between genuine self-control and forced compliance?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track Your Forbidden Fruit Moments
Think of three times in your life when being told you couldn't do something made you want it more - maybe a restricted food during a diet, a forbidden relationship, or a banned activity at work. Write down what happened before, during, and after the restriction. Look for the pattern: did you actually want these things before they were forbidden?
Consider:
- •Notice whether your desire was genuine or just rebellion against control
- •Consider how the restriction affected your relationship with the person who set it
- •Think about whether you found ways around the rule or waited it out
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to set boundaries for someone else. How did they react? Knowing what you know now about psychological reactance, how might you handle it differently?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 23: The Weight of Truth
The sleepy town atmosphere is about to explode into chaos. The murder trial is finally beginning, and it will consume everyone's attention—including Tom's, whether he wants it to or not.




